Risk, responsibility, resistance
Young women’s negotiations of identity and healthy citizenship in human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination narratives
The introduction of human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination has resulted in a proliferation of discourse about HPV-related health risks, with a particular emphasis on the link between HPV and cervical cancer. Using a discursive narrative approach, we critically examine how young women navigate and construct their identities in relation to discourses on HPV vaccination, and the master narratives of risk, medicalization and individual responsibility for health that inform these discourses. Drawing on positioning theory, the narratives of three women who accepted, declined and were undecided about vaccination are presented to illustrate how they actively and uniquely negotiate their identities in relation to the positions idealized by HPV vaccination discourse, and in the context of their intimate relations and everyday lives. These findings fundamentally challenge dominant techno-scientific perspectives on health risk that underpin the majority of research on HPV vaccine decision-making, and health promotion research more generally. We suggest that discursive narrative approaches can advance critical understanding of how health risk discourse, and emerging technologies aimed at reducing health risks, are implicated in promoting neoliberal constructions of healthy citizenship that frame health risk management as an individual responsibility and moral obligation.
Published online: 24 November 2014
Allen, J.D., Mohllajee, A.P., Shelton, R.C., Othus, M.K.D., Fontenot, H.B., & Hanna, R
Ajzen, I., & Fishbein, M
Batt, S., & Lippman, A
Caskey, R., Lindau, S.T., & Alexander, G.C
Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC)
(2014) HPV vaccine: Why boys are less likely to get it. September 5. Retrieved from http://www.cbc.ca/news/health/hpv-vaccine-why-boys-are-less-likely-to-get-it-1.2756037
(2009) The debate over HPV inoculations. August 19. Retrieved from http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/the-debate-over-hpv-inoculations-1.800185
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)
(2008) HPV Vaccine Information for Young Women. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/std/hpv/STDFact-HPV-vaccine-young-women.htm
Dennhardt, S., & Laliberte Rudman, D
Grantham, S., Ahern, L., & Connolly-Ahern, C
Hartley, H., & Tiefer, L
Hopfer, S., & Clippard, J.R
Janz, N., & Becker, M
Krieger, J.L., Kam, J., Katz, M., & Roberto, A.J
Lenselink, C.H., Schmeink, C.E., Melchers, W.J.G., Massuger, L.F.A.G., Hendriks, J.C.M., van Hamont, D., et al.
Licht, A.S., Murphy, J.M., Hyland, A.J., Fix, B.V., Hawk, L.W., & Mahoney, M.C
Lieblich, A., Tuval-Mashiach, R., & Zilber, T
Lippman, A., Melnychuk, R., Shimmin, C., & Boscoe, M
Mamo, L., Nelson, A., & Clark, A
(2010) Producing and protecting risky girlhoods: How the HPV vaccine became the right tool to prevent cervical cancer. In K. Wailoo, J. Livingston, S. Epstein & R. Aronowitz (Eds.), Three shots at prevention: The HPV vaccine and the politics of medicine’s simple solutions (pp. 121–146). Baltimore, MA: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Mancuso, F., & Polzer, J
(2007) Everything you wanted to know, but were afraid to ask: Is the HPV vaccine a victory for women’s health or a triumph of aggressive marketing? Ottawa Citizen.
Petersen, A.R., & Lupton, D
Polzer, J., & Knabe, S
Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC)
(2012) National Advisory Committee on Immunization’s (NACI) update on human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccines, 38 (ACS-1). 1–62. Retrieved from http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/publicat/ccdr-rmtc/12vol38/acs-dcc-1/assets/pdf/12vol-38-acs-dcc-1-eng.pdf
(2007) National Advisory Committee on Immunization’s (NACI) statement on human papillomavirus vaccine. Canada Communicable Disease Report; 33(DCC-2), 1–32. Retrieved from http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/publicat/ccdr-rmtc/07pdf/acs33-02.pdf
Roberts, M.E., Gerrard, M., Reimer, R., & Gibbons, F.X
Rosenthal, S.L., Rupp, R., Zimet, G.D., Meza, H.M., Loza, M.L., Short, M.B., et al.
Society of Obstetricians and Gynecologists of Canada (SOGC)
(2007) Spread the word, not the disease. Retrieved from http://www.hpvinfo.ca/uploads/hpvinfo.ca/files/quick-facts-general-info_e.pdf
Stretcher, V., Champion, V., & Rosenstock, I
Talbot, J., Bibace, R., Bokhour, B., & Bamberg, M
Cited by 4 other publications
Carson, Andrea, Fiona Webster, Jessica Polzer & Sandra Bamford
Emerson, Amanda M.
Freijomil-Vázquez, Carla, Denise Gastaldo, Carmen Coronado, María-Jesús Movilla-Fernández & Simone Garzon
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 10 april 2022. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.