Chapter 3
The discursive construction of husband and
wife bonding
Analyzing benefactives in childrearing
narratives
In this chapter, we analyze
Japanese women’s narratives about their
child-rearing experiences to reveal the meta-level
of positioning of their husbands’ involvement
through examining the use and non-use of
benefactive verb forms. We pose the grammatical
form of benefactive, especially the -te
kureru form, as a center of meaning
making wherein the ideologies of husband and wife
bonding are negotiated and enacted in the situated
context of interviews. Analyzing the narratives of
women in three different groups (i.e., housewives,
dual-income working women, and farmer women) in
Japan, we demonstrate how the use and the non-use
of -te kureru benefactive
differently indexes husband and wife bonding in
childrearing, while reflecting and reproducing
contrasting ideologies regarding gender relations
within the family.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Theoretical backgrounds
- 2.1Grammatical usage of benefit
expressions
- 2.2The ideological usage of -te
kureru
- 2.3The changing Japanese family and gender
norms
- 3.Data and results
- 4.Analysis: Husband and wife bonding in childrearing
narratives
- 4.1The use of -te kureru
among the housewife group
- 4.2The non-usage of -te
kureru and use of -te
morau among the dual-income group
- 4.3The non-usage of -te
kureru among the farmer group
- 5.Discussion
- 6.Concluding remarks
-
Acknowledgements
-
Notes
-
References
References
Bauman, Richard, and Charles Briggs
1990 “
Poetics
and Performance as Critical Perspectives on
Language and Social
Life.”
Annual
Review of
Anthropology Vol. 19: 59–88.
Befu, Harumi
1968 “
Gift-Giving
in a Modernizing
Japan,”
Monumenta
Nipponica Vol. 23, No.3/4: 445–456.
Gal, Susan
2001 “
Language,
Gender, and Power: An Anthropological
Review.” In
Linguistic
Anthropology: A Reader, ed.
by
A. Duranti, Malden, 420–430. MA: Blackwell Publishers.
Harada, Tomi
2007 “
Nihongo kaiwa ni okeru ‘juju hyougen’ no shiyo jittai to poraitonesu sutorategii [Actual use of donatory verbs in Japanese conversations and politeness strategies].”
Gengo to Bunka [
Language and Culture] 11: 117–138.
Hata, Kaori, Takako Okamoto, and Risako Ide
2017 Shussan Kosodate no Narrative
Bunseki [
Narrative Analysis of Childbirth and
Child-rearing]. Osaka: Osaka University Press.
Hill, Jane
1995 “
The
Voices of Don Gabriel: Responsibility and Self in
a Modern Mexicano
Narrative.” In
The
Dialogic Emergence of
Culture, ed.
by
Dennis Tedlock and
Bruce Mannheim, 97–147. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Hill, Jane
2005 “
Finding
Culture in
Narrative.” In
Finding
Culture in Talk: A Collection of
Methods, ed.
by
N. Quinn, 157–202. New York, NY: Palgrave MacMillan.
Holstein, A. James and Jaber, F. Guburium
1995 The
Active
Interview. London: Sage Publications.
Ide, Risako and Yong-chol, Yim
(
2001) “
Hito to hito to o tsunagu Mono: naze
nihongo ni juju doushi ga
ooinoka [What connects people to people: The
reason why Japanese has many give and receive
verbs].”
Gengo [
Language] 30(5): 42–45.
Ide, Sachiko
2006 Wakimae no
Goyoron [
The Pragmatics of
Wakimae]. Tokyo: Taishuukan.
Jaffe, Alexandra
2009 Stance:
Sociolinguistic
Perspectives. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Jolivet, Muriel
1997 Japan:
The Childless
Society. London: Routledge.
Kuno, Susumu
1973 The
Structure of the Japanese
Language. Cambridge and London: The MIT Press.
Kuno, Susumu
1987 Functional
Syntax: Anaphora, Discourse and
Empathy. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.
Lebra, S. Takie and William, P. Lebra
eds. 1986 Japanese
Culture and
Behavior. Revised
edition. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.
Makino, Seiichi
1996 Uchi to Soto no Gengo
Bunkagaku [
Language and Cultural Studies on
Uchi and
Soto]. Tokyo: ALC.
Masuoka, Takashi
2001 “
Nihongo ni okeru juju doushi to
onkeisei [On the Japanese give and take verbs
and its
indebtedness].”
Gengo [
Language] 30(5): 26–32.
Maynard, K. Senko
2009 Teiuka, Yappari, Nihongo
Dayone [
Well, It’s Japanese
Afterall]. Tokyo: Taishuukan Shoten.
Nakatani, Ayumi
2006 “
The
Emergence of ‘Nurturing Fathers’: Discourses and
Practices of Fatherhood in Contemporary
Japan.” In
The
Changing Japanese
Family, eds.
by
R. Marcus and
A. Takenaka, 94–108. Oxon and New York: Routledge.
Ochiai, Emiko
1996 The
Japanese Family System in Transition: A
Sociological Analysis of Family Change in Postwar
Japan. Tokyo: LTCB International Library Foundation.
OECD
2017 “
The
Pursuit of Gender Equality: An Uphill
Battle.”
[URL] (Feb. 28,
2019)
Okamoto, Takako
2008 “
An
Investigation of the Supportive Giving/Receiving
Verbs (SGR Verbs) tekureru/temorau in the
Narratives of Japanese Women who Experienced
Childbirth and
Childcare.”
Studies
in English and American
Literature 43: 79–101, Japan Women’s University.
Okamoto, Takako
2017 “
Amarazu tarazu kosannin: Tochigi
kenoubu nouson deno choosa
kara [Three children are just right: An
investigation of a farming community in middle
Tochigi].” In
Shussan Kosodate no Narrative
Bunseki. [
Narrative Analysis of Childbirth and
Child-rearing], by
Kaori Hata,
Takako Okamoto, and
Risako Ide, 39–116. Osaka: Osaka University Press.
Okutsu, Keiichirou
1983 “
Juju hyougen no taishoo
kenkyuu [Comparative analysis of give and
take expressions].”
Nihongogaku [
Japanese
Studies]
April: 2–4.
Ooe, Saburo
1975 Nichieigo no Hikaku
Kenkyu [
Comparative Studies of Japanese and
English]. Tokyo: Nanundo.
Pomerantz, Anita
1986 “
Extreme
Case Formulations: A Way of Legitimating
Claims.”
Human
Studies 9: 219–229.
Sasagawa, Ayumi
2006 “
Mother-rearing:
The social world of mothers in a Japanese
suburb.” In
The
Changing Japanese
Family, eds.
by
R. Marcus and
A. Takenaka, 129–146. Oxon and New York: Routledge.
Sherzer, Joel
1987 “
A
Discourse-Centered Approach to Language and
Culture.”
American
Anthropologist 89(2): 2965–309.
Silverstein, Michael and Greg Urban
eds. 1996 Natural
History of
Discourse. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Tessa, Carroll
2006 “
Changing
Language, Gender and Family Relations in
Japan.” In
The
Changing Japanese
Family, eds.
by
R. Marcus and
A. Takenaka, 119–126. Oxon and New York: Routledge.
Tsutui, Junya
2016a Kekkon to Kazoku no
Korekara [
The Future of Marriage and
Family]. Tokyo: Kobunsha.
Tsutsui, Junya
2016b “
Female
Labor Participation and the Sexual Division of
Labor: A Consideration on the Persistent
Male-Breadwinner
Model.”
Japan Labor
Review 13(3): 80–100.
Urban, Greg
1991 A
Discourse-Centered Approach to Culture: Native
South American Myths and
Rituals. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Wetzel, Patricia
1994 “
A
Movable Self: The Linguistic Indexing of
uchi and
soto
.” In
Situated
Meaning: Inside and Outside in Japanese Self,
Society and Language eds.
by
J. Bachnick and
C. Quinn, 73–88. Princeton University Press.
Yamaguchi, Masataka
2007 “
Finding
Metaculture in Narrative: The Case of Diasporic
Japanese in the United
States.”
SITES: A
Journal of Social Anthropology and Cultural
Studies 4(1): 122–143.
Yamaguchi, Masataka
2014 “
Discovering
Shared Understanding in Discourse: Prototypes and
Stereotypes.” In
Approaches
to Language, Culture and Cognition: The
Intersection of Cognitive Linguistics and
Linguistic
Anthropology, eds.
by
M. Yamaguchi,
D. Tay, and
B. Blout, 217–233, New York, NY: Palgrave MacMillan.
Yim, Yong-chol and Risako Ide
2004 Hashi to
Chokkarak [
Japanese Chopsticks, Korean
Chopsticks] Tokyo: Taishuukan Shoten.
Yu, Wei-Hsin, and Janet Chen-Lan Kuo
2018 “
Does
Parenthood Foster Traditionalism?: Childrearing
and Alterations in Gender and Family Attitudes in
Japan.”
Social
Forces 97(1) 221–250.
Cited by
Cited by 1 other publications
Chen, Junyuan
2023.
Narratives to identities: Japanese graduate teaching assistants as language teachers.
Journal of Language and Cultural Education 11:2
► pp. 1 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 15 april 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.