Cover not available
Part of
Investigating Language Isolates: Typological and diachronic perspectives
Edited by Iker Salaberri, Dorota Krajewska, Ekaitz Santazilia and Eneko Zuloaga
[Typological Studies in Language 135] 2025
► pp. 306–333

One language or two?

The arbitrariness of isolate classifications in New Guinea

ORCID logo | Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam | Langues et Civilisations à Tradition Orale (LACITO) — Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS)
This chapter draws attention to the arbitrariness of isolate classifications for many Papuan languages. So little is known about the history of the vast majority of Papuan languages that most classifications in the literature are founded neither on significant documentation nor intensive historical-comparative study. The chapter illustrates how arbitrary the boundaries are in defining isolates versus small language families of Papuan languages. To highlight this issue, I juxtapose case studies of Yawa-Saweru and Maybrat-Karon. Saweru and Karon are both referred to as divergent varieties, yet the former is classified as an independent language and the latter as a dialect. Based on existing literature, it is shown that there is no principled reason to give different classifications to Yawa-Saweru and Maybrat-Karon.
Keywords: Papuan languages, language classification, epistemic uncertainty, language contact, language divergence
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.Historical linguistics of Papuan languages
  • 3.The problem of isolates in New Guinea
  • 4.Case studies
    • 4.1Case study 1: Yawa-Saweru
    • 4.2Case study 2: Maybrat-Karon
  • 5.Conclusion and discussion
  • Author queries
  • Acknowledgements
  • Notes
  • Abbreviations
  • References
This content is being prepared for publication; it may be subject to changes.
References (86)
References
Anceaux, J. C. 1958. Languages of the Bomberai peninsula: Outline of a linguistic map. Nieuw-Guinea Studiën 2: 109–121.Google Scholar
1961. The Linguistic Situation in the Islands of Yapen, Kurudu, Nau and Miosnum, New Guinea. ’s-Gravenhage: Martinus Nijhoff. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Arnold, Laura. 2018. A preliminary archaeology of tone in Raja Ampat. In Contact and Substrate in the Languages of Wallacea (Part 2), Antoinette Schapper (ed), 7–37. Special issue of NUSA: Linguistic Studies of Languages in and around Indonesia 64.Google Scholar
Baru, Yosefina. 2018. Sistem numeralia Bahasa Miyah. Melanesia: Jurnal Ilmiah Kajian Bahasa dan Sastra 1(1): 77–83. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Brown, William U. 1991. A quantitative phonology of Mai Brat. In Papers in Papuan Linguistics No. 1, Tom Dutton (ed), 1–27. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
Campbell, Lyle. 2016. Language isolates and their history, or, what’s weird, anyway? In Proceedings of the Thirty Six Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society, Nicholas Rolle, Jeremy Steffman & John Sylak-Glassman (eds), 16–31. Berkeley: Berkeley Linguistic Society. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. 2017. Language isolates and their history. In Language Isolates, Lyle Campbell (ed), 1–18. London: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Clifton, J. 1994. Stable multilingualism in a small language group: the case of Kaki Ae. Language and Linguistics in Melanesia 25: 107–124.Google Scholar
Comrie, Bernard. 1989. Genetic classification, contact, and variation. In Synchronic and Diachronic Approaches to Linguistic Variation and Change [Georgetown University Round Table on Languages and Linguistics 1988], Thomas J. Walsh (ed), 81–93. Washington D.C.: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
. 2000. Language contact, lexical borrowing, and semantic fields. Studies in Slavic and General Linguistics 28: 73–86. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Cowan, H. K. J. 1953. Voorlopige Resultaten van een Ambtelijk Taalonderzoek in Nieuw-Guinea. ’s-Gravenhage: Martinus Nijhoff.Google Scholar
Daniels, Don. 2015. A Reconstruction of Proto-Sogeram: Phonology, Lexicon, and Morphosyntax. PhD dissertation, University of California at Santa Barbara.
. 2020. Grammatical Reconstruction: The Sogeram Languages of New Guinea. Berlin: De Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Dol, Philomena. 1994. Karon Dori kleine woordenlijst. Unpublished fieldnotes.Google Scholar
. 2007. A Grammar of Maybrat: a Language of the Bird’s Head Peninsula, Papua Province, Indonesia. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
Donohue, Mark. no date. Saweru Phonology and Orthographic Guide. Unpublished ms, Department of Linguistics, The University of Sydney.
. 1997. Tone systems in New Guinea. Linguistic Typology 1: 347–386. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. 2001. Split intransitivity and Saweru. Oceanic Linguistics 40: 321–336. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. 2007. The Papuan language of Tambora. Oceanic Linguistics 46: 520–537. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Donohue, Mark & Ayeri, Alfons. no date. Yafan (Saweru) Word List. Unpublished ms, University of Sydney.
Elmberg, John-Erik. 1955. Field notes on the Mejbrat people. Ethnos XX: 2–102.Google Scholar
Foley, William A. 1986. The Papuan Languages of New Guinea. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
2000. The languages of New Guinea. Annual Review of Anthropology 29: 357–404. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
François, Alexandre. 2012. The dynamics of linguistic diversity. Egalitarian multilingualism and power imbalance among northern Vanuatu languages. International Journal of the Sociology of Language 214: 85–110. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Franklin, Karl J. 1975. Isolates: Gulf district. In New Guinea Area Languages and Language Study, Vol. 1: Papuan Languages and the New Guinea Linguistic Scene, Stephen A. Wurm (ed), 891–896. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
Gasser, Emily. 2017. Papuan-Austronesian language contact on Yapen island: A Preliminary Account. NUSA 62: 101–155.Google Scholar
Gravelle, Gilles. 2004. The Meyah Language of Papua. PhD dissertation, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam.
Hammarström, Harald. 2010. The status of the least documented language families in the world. Language Documentation and Conservation 4: 183–212.Google Scholar
. 2017. Language isolates in the New Guinea region. In Language Isolates, Lyle Campbell (ed), 287–323. London: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hammarström, Harald, Forkel, Robert, Haspelmath, Martin, & Bank, Sebastian. 2015. Glottolog 2.6 [Database]. Jena: Max Planck Institute for the Science of Human History. <[URL]>
Haudricourt, André-Georges. 1961. Richesse en phonèmes et richesse en locuteurs. L’Homme 1: 5–10. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Holzknecht, Susanne. 1988. Word taboo and its implications for language change in the Markham family of languages. Language and Linguistics in Melanesia 18: 43–69.Google Scholar
Jones, Larry B. 1986. The dialects of Yawa. Papers in New Guinea Linguistics 25: 31–68.Google Scholar
Jones, Linda K. 1986. The question of ergativity in Yawa, a Papuan language. Australian Journal of Linguistics 6: 37–55. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Jones, Linda K., Paai, Zeth, & Paai, Yohanes. 1989. Ayao Yawa mo mona nanentabo ranugan = Perbendaharaan kata bahasa Yawa = Yawa Vocabulary. Jayapura: Cenderawasih University and SIL.Google Scholar
Kamholz, David. 2017. Tone and language contact in southern Cenderawasih Bay. In Contact and Substrate in the Languages of Wallacea (Part 1), Antoinette Schapper (ed), 7–39. Special issue of NUSA: Linguistic Studies of Languages in and around Indonesia 62.Google Scholar
Kempf, Steve. 1981. Karon Dori Pef Wordlist. Dallas: SIL archive. <[URL]>
Kijne, Isaak S. no date. Schrift met woordenlijst Nederlands-Yava, dialect Turu. Leiden University Special Collections, Isaak Samuel Kijne Collection, Or. 421, Folder 20.
Komul, Maria Febriani. 2020. Negative Constructions in Miyah. MA dissertation, Universitas Papua.
Krey, Inseren. 2020. Possessive Constructions in Miyah. MA dissertation, Universitas Papua.
Laycock, Don. 1975. Isolates: Sepik Region. 1975. In New Guinea Area Languages and Language Study, Vol. 1: Papuan Languages and the New Guinea Linguistic Scene, Stephen A. Wurm (ed), 881–886. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
. 1982. Linguistic diversity in Melanesia: a tentative explanation. In Gava’: Studies in Austronesian Languages and Cultures Dedicated to Hans Kähler, Rainer Carle, Martine Heinschke, Peter W. Pink, Christel Rost, & Karen Stadtlander (eds), 31–37. Berlin: Reimer.Google Scholar
McElhanon, Kenneth A. 1975. Isolates: Morobe District: Wasembo (or Gusap). In New Guinea Area Languages and Language Study, Vol. 1: Papuan Languages and the New Guinea Linguistic Scene, Stephen A. Wurm (ed), 897–904. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
McElhanon, Kenneth A. & Voorhoeve, C. L. 1970. The Trans-New Guinea Phylum: Explorations in Deep-Level Genetic Relationships. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
Nichols, Johanna. 1997. Sprung from two common sources: Sahul as a linguistic area. In Archaeology and Linguistics: Aboriginal Australia in Global Perspective, Patrick McConvell & Nicholas Evans (eds), 135–168. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Pawley, Andrew. 2005. The chequered career of the Trans New Guinea hypothesis: recent research and its implications. In Papuan Pasts: Studies in the Cultural, Linguistic and Biological History of the Papuan-speaking Peoples, Andrew Pawley, Robert Attenborough, Jack Golson, & Robin Hide (eds), 67–108. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
Pawley, Andrew & Hammarström, Harald. 2017. The Trans New Guinea family. In Papuan Languages and Linguistics, Bill Palmer (ed), 21–195. Berlin: Mouton. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Pick, Andrew. 2020. A Reconstruction of Proto-Northern Adelbert Phonology and Lexicon. PhD dissertation, University of Hawai’i at Mānoa.
Ross, Malcolm. 2005. Pronouns as a preliminary diagnostic for grouping Papuan languages. In Papuan Pasts: Studies in the Cultural, Linguistic and Biological History of the Papuan-speaking Peoples, Andrew Pawley, Robert Attenborough, Jack Golson, & Robin Hide (eds), 15–65. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
Salisbury, Richard. 1962. Notes on bilingualism and language change in New Guinea. Anthropological Linguistics 4: 77–109.Google Scholar
Sankoff, Gillian. 1977. Multilingualism in Papua New Guinea. In New Guinea Area Languages and Language Study: Language, Culture, Society and the Modern World, Stephen A. Wurm (ed), 265–307. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
Sawaki, Yusuf. 2017. A Grammar of Wooi: An Austronesian Language of Yapen Island, Western New Guinea. PhD dissertation, Australian National University.
Schapper, Antoinette. 2020. Linguistic Melanesia. In Routledge Handbook of Language Contact, Yaron Matras & Evangelia Adamou (eds), 480–502. London: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. forthcoming. Papuan influence on the Malayo-Polynesian languages of Southeast Asia. In Oxford Guide to the Malayo-Polynesian Languages of Southeast Asia, Sander Adelaar & Antoinette Schapper (eds). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Schapper, Antoinette, Huber, Juliette & van Engelenhoven, Aone. 2012. The historical relations of the Papuan languages of Timor and Kisar. In History, Contact & Classification of Papuan languages, Harald Hammarström & Wilco van den Heuvel (eds), 194–242. Special issue of Language and Linguistics in Melanesia.Google Scholar
Schapper, Antoinette, Huber, Juliette, & van Engelenhoven, Aone. 2014. The relatedness of Timor-Kisar and Alor-Pantar languages: a preliminary demonstration. In Alor-Pantar languages: History and Typology, Marian Klamer (ed), 99–154, Berlin: Language Science Press.Google Scholar
Simons, Gary. 1982. Word taboo and comparative Austronesian linguistics. In Papers from the Third International Conference on Austronesian Linguistics, Vol. 3: Accent on Variety, Amran Halim, Lois Carrington, & Stephen A. Wurm (eds), 157–226. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
Smallhorn, Jacinta. 2011. The Binanderean Languages of Papua New Guinea. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
Smits, Leo & Voorhoeve, C. L. 1998. The J.C. Anceaux Collection of Wordlists of Irian Jaya Languages B: Non-Austronesian (Papuan) Languages (Part II). Leiden-Jakarta: DSALCUL/IRIS.Google Scholar
Suter, Edgar. 2012. Verbs with pronominal object prefixes in Finisterre-Huon languages. In History, Contact and Classification of Papuan Languages, Harald Hammarström & Wilco van den Heuvel (eds), 23–58. Port Moresby: Linguistic Society of Papua New Guinea.Google Scholar
. 2018. Comparative Morphology of the Huon Peninsula Languages (Papua New Guinea). PhD dissertation, Universität zu Köln.
Suter, Edgar & Usher, Timothy. 2017. The Kamula-Elevala language family. Language and Linguistics in Melanesia 35. 105–131.Google Scholar
Syufi, Marsela Romana. 2021. Multilingualism in Irires District. MA dissertation, Universitas Papua.
Syufi, Yafed. 2016. Sejarah Kampung Distrik Senopi Kabupaten Tambrauw Provinsi Papua Barat. Bantul, Yogyakarta: Absolute Media.Google Scholar
Thomason, Sarah G. 1999. Speakers’ choices in language change. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 29(2): 19–43.Google Scholar
Thoonen, Louise. 2005. The Door to Heaven Female Initiation, Christianity and Identity in West Papua. PhD dissertation, Radboud University.
Thurston, William R. 1987. Processes of Change in the Languages of North-Western New Britain. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
1992. Sociolinguistic typology and other factors effecting change in northwestern New Britain, Papua New Guinea. In Culture Change, Language Change: Case Studies from Melanesia, Tom Dutton (ed), 123–139. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
1994. Renovation and innovation in the languages of north-western New Britain. In Language Contact and Change in the Austronesian World, Tom Dutton & Darrell Tryon (eds), 573–609. Berlin: De Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Urban, Matthias. 2021. The geography and development of language isolates. Royal Society of Open Science 8(202232). DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Usher, Timothy. no date. Pauwasi Language Family. New Guinea World Website.
Usher, Timothy & Schapper, Antoinette. 2022. The Greater West Bomberai family. Oceanic Linguistics 61(1): 469–527. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Usher, Timothy & Suter, Edgar. 2015. The Anim languages of Southern New Guinea. Oceanic Linguistics 54: 110–142. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. 2020. The Asmat-Muli languages of Southwestern New Guinea. Language and Linguistics in Melanesia 38: 148–175.Google Scholar
Visser, Eline. 2020a. A Grammar of Kalamang: The Papuan Language of the Karas Islands. PhD dissertation, Lund University.
. 2020b. Kalamang dictionary. Dictionaria 13: 1–2737. <[URL]>
Voorhoeve, Clemens L. 1975a. Central and Western Trans-New Guinea phylum languages. In New Guinea Area Languages and Language Study, Vol. 1: Papuan Languages and the New Guinea Linguistic Scene, Stephen A. Wurm (ed), 345–460. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
1975b. Isolates: Irian Jaya. In New Guinea Area Languages and Language Study, Vol. 1: Papuan Languages and the New Guinea Linguistic Scene, Stephen A. Wurm (ed), 887–890. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
1975c. West Papuan phylum languages on the mainland of New Guinea: Bird’s Head (Vogelkop) peninsula. In New Guinea Area Languages and Language Study, Vol. 1: Papuan Languages and the New Guinea Linguistic Scene, Stephen A. Wurm (ed), 717–728. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
1982. Brat Wordlists. Unpublished typescript.Google Scholar
1989. The masked bird: linguistic relations in the Bird’s Head area. In Peoples on the Move, Paul Haenen & Jan Pouwer (eds), 78–101. Nijmegen: Centre for Australian and Oceanic Studies.Google Scholar
Wade, Martha. 1993. Language convergence or divergence: the case of the Apalī (Emerum) language. Language and Linguistics in Melanesia 24: 73–93.Google Scholar
Wester, Ruth. 2014. A Linguistic History of Awyu-Dumut: Morphological Study and Reconstruction of a Papuan Language Family. PhD dissertation, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam.
Witanti, S. A. 1992. Struktur Fonologi dan Morfologi Bahasa Maibrat Ayamaru: Sebuah Studi Pendahuluan. MA dissertation, Universitas Sanata Dharma.
Wurm, Stephen A. (ed). 1975. New Guinea Area Languages and Language Study. Vol 1: Papuan Languages and the New Guinea Linguistic Scene. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics.Google Scholar
1982. Papuan Languages of Oceania. Tübingen: Günther Narr.Google Scholar