Article published In:
Linguistics in the Netherlands 2023Edited by Sterre Leufkens and Marco Bril
[Linguistics in the Netherlands 40] 2023
► pp. 309–317
Edited by Sterre Leufkens and Marco Bril
[Linguistics in the Netherlands 40] 2023
► pp. 309–317
Essays ‘LOT Big Questions Prize’
Reimagining language
Towards a better understanding of language by including our interactions with non-humans
What is language and who or what can be said to have it? In this essay we consider this question in the context of interactions with non-humans, specifically: animals and computers. While perhaps an odd pairing at first glance, here we argue that these domains can offer contrasting perspectives through which we can explore and reimagine language. The interactions between humans and animals, as well as between humans and computers, reveal both the essence and the boundaries of language: from examining the role of sequence and contingency in human-animal interaction, to unravelling the challenges of natural interactions with “smart” speakers and language models. By bringing together disparate fields around foundational questions, we push the boundaries of linguistic inquiry and uncover new insights into what language is and how it functions in diverse non-human-exclusive contexts.
Keywords: language, human-animal interaction, human-computer interaction, meaning-making, large language models
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Human-animal interaction
- 3.Human-computer interaction
- 4.Discussion
- LOT Essay Prize
-
References
Available under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) 4.0 license.
For any use beyond this license, please contact the publisher at [email protected].
References
Alač, M., Y. Gluzman, T. Aflatoun, A. Bari, B. Jing & G. Mozqueda
2020 “Talking
to a Toaster: How Everyday Interactions with Digital Voice Assistants Resist a Return to the
Individual”. Evental
Aesthetics 91: 3–53.
Ameka, F. K.
1992 “Interjections:
The Universal Yet Neglected Part of Speech”. Journal of
Pragmatics 181: 101–18. 
Amha, Azeb
2013 “Directives to humans and to domestic animals: The imperative and some interjections in Zargulla”. In Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Cushitic and Omotic languages, ed. by M.C. Simeone-Senelle and M. Vanhove, 211–229. Cologne: Rüdiger Köppe.
Ashktorab, Z., M. Jain, Q. V. Liao & J. D. Weisz
2019 “Resilient
Chatbots: Repair Strategy Preferences for Conversational
Breakdowns”. In Proceedings of the 2019 CHI Conference on Human
Factors in Computing Systems, 1–12. New York: Association for Computing Machinery.
Bangerter, A., E. Genty, R. Heesen, F. Rossano & K. Zuberbühler
2022 “Every
Product Needs a Process: Unpacking Joint Commitment as a Process across Species”. Philosophical
Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological
Sciences 3771: 20210095.
Bateson, G.
1972 Steps
to an Ecology of Mind; Collected Essays in Anthropology, Psychiatry, Evolution, and
Epistemology. Chicago/London: University of Chicago Press.
Bender, E. M. & A. Koller
2020 “Climbing
towards NLU: On Meaning, Form, and Understanding in the Age of
Data”. In Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the Association
for Computational Linguistics, 5185–5198. Association for Computational Linguistics.
Birhane, A. & J. van Dijk
2020 “Robot
rights? Let’s talk about human welfare instead”. In AIES’20: Proceedings of the AAAI/ACM Conference on AI, Ethics, and Society, 207–213. Association for Computing Machinery.
Brandt, K.
2004 “A
language of their own: An interactionist approach to human-horse communication”. Society &
Animals 121: 299–316.
Burkart, J. M., J. E. C. Adriaense, R. K. Brügger, F. M. Miss, K. Wierucka & C. P. van Schaik
2022 “A
convergent interaction engine: Vocal communication among marmoset monkeys”. Philosophical
Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological
Sciences 3771: 20210098.
Bynon, J.
1976 “Domestic
animal calling in a Berber tribe”. In Language and Man:
Anthropological Issues, ed. by W. McCormack and S. A. Wurm, 39–65. The Hague: Mouton.
Cohen, A. A.
2016 “From
mute objects to militant subjects: The politics of rebellious
animals”. In Subjectivation in Political Theory and Contemporary
Practices, ed. by A. Oberprantacher and A. Siclodi, 237–63. London: Palgrave Macmillan UK.
Contreras Kallens, P., R. D. Kristensen-McLachlan & M. H. Christiansen
2023 “Large
language models demonstrate the potential of statistical learning in language”. Cognitive
Science 471: e13256.
Cornips, Leonie
2019 “The
final frontier: Non-human animals on the linguistic research agenda”. Linguistics in the
Netherlands 361: 13–19.
2022 “The
animal turn in postcolonial (socio)linguistics: The interspecies greeting of the dairy
cow”. Journal of Postcolonial
Linguistics 61: 210–32.
Fröhlich, M., P. Kuchenbuch, G. Müller, B. Fruth, T. Furuichi, R. M. Wittig & S. Pika
2016 “Unpeeling
the layers of language: Bonobos and chimpanzees engage in cooperative turn-taking
sequences”. Scientific
Reports 61: 25887.
Fröhlich, M. & C. P. van Schaik
2022 “Social
tolerance and interactional opportunities as drivers of gestural redoings in
orang-utans”. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological
Sciences 3771: 20210106.
Gibson, J. J.
1977 “The
Theory of Affordances”. In Perceiving, Acting, and Knowing: Toward
an Ecological Psychology, ed. by R. Shaw and J. Bransford, 67–82. Hilldale, USA: Routledge.
Ginzburg, J.
2012 The
Interactive Stance: Meaning for Conversation. Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press.
Ginzburg, J. & M. Poesio
2016 “Grammar
is a system that characterizes talk in interaction”. Frontiers in
Psychology 71: 1938.
Goode, D.
2007 Playing
with My Dog Katie: An Ethnomethodological Study of Dog-Human Interaction. West Lafayette, Purdue University Press.
Goodwin, C.
1981 Conversational
Organization. New York: Academic Press.
2000 “Action
and embodiment within situated human interaction”. Journal of
Pragmatics 321: 1489–1522.
Harjunpää, K.
2022 “Repetition
and prosodic matching in responding to pets’ vocalizations”. Langage et
société 1761: 69–102.
Heesen, R., M. Fröhlich, C. Sievers, M. Woensdregt & M. Dingemanse
2022 “Coordinating
social action: A primer for the cross-species investigation of communicative
repair”. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological
Sciences 3771: 20210110.
Hockett, C. F.
1987 Refurbishing
our foundations: Elementary linguistics from an advanced point of
view. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing.
Keevallik, L.
2018 “What
does embodied interaction tell us about grammar?” Research on Language and Social
Interaction 511: 1–21.
Krebs, John R. & R. Dawkins
1984 “Animal
signals: Mind-reading and manipulation”. In Behavioural Ecology: An
Evolutionary Approach, ed. by J. R. Krebs & N. B. Davies, 380–402. Blackwell Scientific.
Laurier, E., R. Maze & J. Lundin
2006 “Putting
the dog back in the park: Animal and human mind-in-action”. Mind, Culture, and
Activity 131: 2–24.
Lipp, B.
2022 “Caring
for robots: How care comes to matter in human-machine interfacing”. Social Studies of
Science, Advance online publication.
Litman, D., J. Hirschberg & M. Swerts
2006 “Characterizing
and predicting corrections in spoken dialogue systems”. Computational Linguistics 321: 417–38.
MacMartin, C., J. B. Coe & C. L. Adams
2014 “Treating
distressed animals as participants: I know responses in veterinarians’ pet-directed
talk”. Research on Language and Social
Interaction 471: 151–74.
Malinowski, B.
1922 Argonauts
Of The Western Pacific. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Massey, G. J. & D. A. Boyle
1999 “Descartes’s
tests for (animal) mind”. Philosophical
Topics 271: 87–146.
Mavrina, L., J. Szczuka, C. Strathmann, L. M. Bohnenkamp, N. Krämer & S. Kopp
2022 “ ‘Alexa,
you’re really stupid’: A longitudinal field study on communication breakdowns between family members and a voice
assistant”. Frontiers in Computer Science 41: 791704.
McIlvenny, P. B.
1993 “Constructing
societies and social machines: Stepping out of the turing test discourse”. Journal of
Intelligent Systems 31: 119–156.
Meijer, E.
2019 When
Animals Speak: Toward an Interspecies Democracy. New York: New York University Press.
Miltenburg, E. van, M. Clinciu, O. Dušek, D. Gkatzia, S. Inglis, L. Leppänen, S. Mahamood, S. Schoch, C. Thomson & L. Wen
2023 “Barriers
and enabling factors for error analysis in NLG Research”. Northern European Journal of Language
Technology 91.
Mondada, L.
2011 “Understanding
as an embodied, situated and sequential achievement in interaction”. Journal of
Pragmatics 431: 542–52.
Mondada, L. & A. Meguerditchian
2022 “Sequence
organization and embodied mutual orientations: Openings of social interactions between
baboons”. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological
Sciences 3771: 20210101.
Mondémé, C.
2020 “Touching
and petting: Exploring ‘Haptic Sociality’ in interspecies
interaction”. In Touch in Social
Interaction, ed. by A. Cekaite and L. Mondada, 171–96. Berlin: Routledge.
2022 “Why
study turn-taking sequences in interspecies interactions?” Journal for the Theory of Social
Behaviour 521: 67–85.
Moore, R. K., Marxer, R. & S. Thill
2016 “Vocal Interactivity in-and-between Humans, Animals, and Robots”. Frontiers in Robotics and AI 3: 61.
Nicastro, N.
2004 “Perceptual
and acoustic evidence for species-level differences in meow vocalizations by domestic cats (Felis Catus) and African wild cats
(Felis Silvestris Lybica)”. Journal of Comparative
Psychology 1181: 287–96.
Pika, S., R. Wilkinson, K. H. Kendrick & S. C. Vernes
2018 “Taking
turns: Bridging the gap between human and animal Communication”. Proceedings of the Royal
Society B: Biological Sciences 2851: 20180598.
Porcheron, M., J. E. Fischer, S. Reeves & S. Sharples
2018 “Voice
interfaces in everyday life”. In Proceedings of the 2018 CHI
Conference on Human Factors in Computing
Systems, 1–12. Montreal QC Canada: ACM.
Rasenberg, M., A. Özyürek & M. Dingemanse
2020 “Alignment
in multimodal interaction: An integrative framework”. Cognitive
Science 441: e12911.
Rossano, F.
2013 “Sequence
organization and timing of bonobo mother-infant interactions”. Interaction
Studies 141: 160–89.
Schlenker, P., C. Coye, S. Steinert-Threlkeld, N. Klinedinst & E. Chemla
2022 “Beyond
anthropocentrism in comparative cognition: Recentering animal linguistics”. Cognitive
Science 461: e13220.
Sejnowski, T. J.
2023 “Large
Language Models and the reverse Turing Test”. Neural
Computation 351: 309–42.
Sidnell, J. & N. J. Enfield
2012 “Language
diversity and social action”. Current
Anthropology 531: 302–333.
Smith, B.
2012 “Language
and the Ffontiers of the human: Aymara animal-oriented interjections and the mediation of
mind”. American
Ethnologist 391: 313–324.
Stivers, T. & J. Sidnell
2005 “Introduction: Multimodal Interaction”. Semiotica 156: 1–20.
Suchman, L. A.
2007 Human-Machine
Reconfigurations: Plans and Situated Actions. 2nd ed. Cambridge ; New York: Cambridge University Press.
2019 “Demystifying
the intelligent machine”. In Cyborg Futures: Cross-Disciplinary
Perspectives on Artificial Intelligence and Robotics, ed. by T. Heffernan, 35–61. Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Swerts, M. & M. Ostendorf
1997 “Prosodic
and lexical indications of discourse structure in human-machine interactions”. Speech
Communication 221: 25–41.
Tuncer, S., C. Licoppe, P. Luff & C. Heath
2023 “Recipient
design in human–robot interaction: The emergent assessment of a robot’s competence”. AI &
SOCIETY.
Turing, A. M.
1950 “Computing
machinery and
intelligence”. In Parsing the Turing Test, ed. by R. Epstein, G. Roberts and G. Beber, 23–65. Dordrecht: Springer.
Voinea, C.
2018 “Designing
for conviviality”. Technology in Society, 521: 70–78.
Von Uexküll, J.
1921 Umwelt
und Innenwelt der Tiere. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer.
1992 “A
stroll through the worlds of animals and men: A picture book of invisible
worlds”. Semiotica 891: 319–391.
Weizenbaum, J.
1976 Computer
Power and Human Reason: From Judgment to Calculation. San Francisco: W. H. Freeman.
Yeon, S. C., Y. K. Kim, S. J. Park, S. S. Lee, S. Y. Lee, E. H. Suh, K. A. Houpt, H. H. Chang, H. C. Lee, B. G. Yang & H. J. Lee
2011 “Differences
between vocalization evoked by social stimuli in feral cats and house cats”. Behavioural
Processes 871: 183–89.