Cover not available
Article published In:
Bochumer Philosophisches Jahrbuch für Antike und Mittelalter: Band 24
Herausgegeben von Manuel Baumbach und Olaf Pluta
[Bochumer Philosophisches Jahrbuch für Antike und Mittelalter 24] 2021
► pp. 1–17

Antiochus’ and Cicero’s different theories of memory in the Lucullus

| University of Notre Dame
The essay deals with an important epistemological debate in the Lucullus: Can there be remembrance of false beliefs, as Cicero argues against his interlocutor, who defends Antiochus’ position? It is shown that Antiochus, like Aristoteles, considers ‘remember’ to be a double achievement verb: Remembrance occurs only if a correct past perception is faithfully transmitted to the present. Cicero, on the other hand, insists that faithful transmission can also occur with false beliefs. The distinction seems to be analogous to that between valid and sound inference in contemporary Stoic logic. Finally, I discuss differences between ancient and modern forms of skepticism, address the issue of why misremembering plays no role in the Lucullus, and find an answer in Cicero’s doctrine of the orator.
Article outline
  • I.
  • II.
  • III.
  • Notes
  • Bibliography
Published online: 7 June 2022
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/bpjam.00070.hos
References (36)
Bibliography
Aristotelis. Parva naturalia, rec. Guilelmus Biehl, Leipzig 1898.Google Scholar
Jonathan Barnes. Antiochus of Ascalon, in: Philosophia togata, ed. by Mitaim Griffin and Jonathan Barnes, Oxford, 51–96 1989.Google Scholar
Sven Bernecker. Memory. A Philosophical Study, Oxford 2009. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Sven Bernecker/Kourken Michaelian. The Routledge Handbook of Philosophy of Memory, Abingdon/New York 2017. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Charles Brittain. Philo of Larissa: The Last of the Academic Skeptics, Oxford 2001.Google Scholar
. Antiochus’ epistemology, in: David Sedley, 104–130 2012. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
M. Tulli Ciceronis. Scripta quae manserunt omnia, Fasc. 42: Academicorum reliquiae cum Lucullo, rec. O. Plasberg, Leipzig 1922.Google Scholar
. Scripta quae manserunt omnia, Fasc. 45: De natura deorum, post O. Plasberg ed W. Ax, Stuttgart 1961.Google Scholar
. De finibus bonorum et malorum, rec. L. D. Reynolds, Oxford 1998.Google Scholar
. Epistulae ad Atticum, ed. D. R. Shackleton-Bailey, 21 vols., Stuttgart 1987.Google Scholar
. Epistulae ad familiares, ed. D. R. Shackleton-Bailey, Stuttgart 1988.Google Scholar
Marcus Tullius Cicero. Hortensius. Lucullus. Academici Libri, lateinisch-deutsch, edited, translated and commented by Laila Straume-Zimmermann, Ferdinand Broemser, and Olof Gigon, München/Zürich 1990.Google Scholar
M. Tulli Ciceronis. Rhetorica, Vol. 21, rec. A. S. Wilkins, Oxford 1903.Google Scholar
Cleomedis. De motu circulari corporum caelestium liri duo, instr. H. Ziegler, Leipzig 1891.Google Scholar
John Dillon. The Middle Platonists, London 1977.Google Scholar
Diogenis Laertii. Vitae philosophorum, rec. H. S. Long, 21 vols., Oxford 1964.Google Scholar
E. R. Dodds. Review of: Willy Theiler, Die Vorbereitung des Neuplatonismus, Berlin 1930, in: Gnomon 71, 307–310 1931.Google Scholar
Ludwig Fladerer. Antiochos von Askalon. Hellenist und Humanist, Graz 1996.Google Scholar
John Glucker. Antiochus and the Late Academy, Göttingen 1978.Google Scholar
. Review of: Ludwig Fladerer, Antiochos von Askalon. Hellenist und Humanist , in: Gnomon 741, 289–295 2002.Google Scholar
Vittorio Hösle. The Philosophical Dialogue, Notre Dame 2012.Google Scholar
Karlheinz Hülser. Die Fragmente zur Dialektik der Stoiker, Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt 1987f.Google Scholar
Katerina Ierodiakonou. The Stoics and the Skeptics on Memory, in: Tracce nella mente. Teoria della memoria da Platone ai moderni, ed. by Maria Michela Sassi, Pisa, 47–65 2007.Google Scholar
Adolf Lörcher. Das Fremde und das Eigene in Ciceros Büchern De finibus bonorum et malorum und den Academica, Halle/Saale, Reprint Hildesheim 1975 1911.Google Scholar
Georg Luck. Der Akademiker Antiochos, Bern/Stuttgart 1953.Google Scholar
Dmitri Nikulin. Memory in Ancient Philosophy, in: Memory. A History, ed. by Dmitri Nikulin, Oxford, 35–84 2015. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Platonis. Opera, rec. … I. Burnet, 51 vols., Oxford 1900–1907.Google Scholar
Thomas Reid. Essays on the Intellectual Powers of Man, University Park 2002. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Tobias Reinhardt. Linguistic Naturalism in Cicero’s Academica , in: Language and Nature in the Classical Roman World, ed. by Giuseppe Pezzini and Barnaby Taylor, Cambridge, 153–170 2019. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
David Sedley. The Philosophy of Antiochus, ed. by David Sedley, Cambridge 2012a. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. Antiochus as historian of philosophy, in: 80–103 2012b. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Sexti Empirici opera . rec. H. Mutschmann, Vol. 11, Leipzig 1912; Vol. II1, Leipzig 1914; Vol. III1, rec. H. Mutschmann, iterum ed. I. Mau, Leipzig 1961.Google Scholar
Richard Sorabji. Aristotle On Memory, Providence. 1972. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Stoicorum veterum fragmenta . coll. I. ab Arnim, 31 vols., Berlin 1903–1905.Google Scholar
Harold Tarrant. Scepticism or Platonism? The Philosophy of the Fourth Academy, Cambridge 1985.Google Scholar
Willy Theiler. Die Vorbereitung des Neuplatonismus, Berlin 1930.Google Scholar