What is negative in Haitian Creole? Negative Concord Items, sentential, constituent and expletive negation
Negative sentences in Creole languages, provocatively claimed to be the world ‘simplest languages’ (Mc Whorter 2001), commonly present a puzzling multiplicity of redundant negative expressions with a single negative interpretation that appear to systematically violate logical compositionality. An intriguing solution to this puzzle proposes that, contrary to appearances, negation is entirely abstract in Creoles, i.e. solely represented by a phonologically null operator dubbed NEG (Homer 2013; Zeijlstra 2004 and following) and has, de facto, no actual direct morpho-phonological exponent. On this, view, not only expressions like pèsonn `nobody’ or anyen `nothing’ are not negative, but neither is the morpheme pa. Revisiting Haitian Creole negative dependencies on the basis of novel data drawn from a corpus of Haitian writings and internet data, this paper critically reviews this approach, showing that it makes a number of incorrect predictions, both with respect to the distribution of Negative Concord items (NCIs) as well as with the morpheme pa, especially on its so called ‘expletive negation’ use, which is investigated here for the first time. The paper argues for a less radical solution that brings Haitian negative dependencies in line with other classic NPI dependencies, claiming that Haitian NCIs are in fact strong NPIs that can be licensed by sentential negation under reconstruction. The puzzle, hence, receives a different solution, keeping with the idea that NCI are non-negative expressions, but also with the more concrete view that pa is the core negation morpheme in Haitian.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 1.1Abstract negation and negative concord
- 1.2Properties of Haitian Creole NCI
- 2.Properties of the Haitian Creole sentential marker ‘pa’
- 2.1Constituent negation in HC
- 2.2Expletive negation in HC
- 3.Concluding remarks
-
Notes
-
References
References (41)
Alrenga, P. & Kennedy, C.
2013 No more shall we part.
Natural Language Semantics 22(1): 1–53
Biberauer, T. & Zeijlstra, H.
2012 Negative concord in Afrikaans: Filling a typological gap.
Journal of Semantics 29(3): 345–371.
Bickerton, D.
1981 Roots of Language. Ann Arbor MI: Karoma.
Bickerton, D.
2010 Adam’s Tongue: How Humans Made Language, How Language Made Humans. New York, NY: Hill and Wang.
Chierchia, G.
2006 Broaden your views: Implicatures of domain widening and the “logicality” of language.
Linguistic Inquiry 37(4): 535–590.
Chomsky, N.
1995 The Minimalist Program. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
Chomsky, N.
1998 Minimalist Inquiries: The Framework. Cambridge MA: MITWPL.
DeGraff, M.
1993 A riddle on negation in Haitian.
Probus 5: 63–93.
Déprez, V.
1997 Two types of negative concord.
Probus 9(2): 103–143.
Déprez, V.
1998 Semantic effects of agreement: The case of French past participle agreement.
Probus 10(1): 1–66.
Déprez, V.
1999 The roots of negative concord in French and French based creoles. In
Language Creation and Language Change: Creole, Diachrony and Development,
M. DeGraff (ed) 375–428. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
Déprez, V.
2000 Parallel (A)symmetries and the internal structure of negative expressions.
Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 18(2): 253–342.
Déprez, V.
2007 On the structuring role of grammaticalized morpho-syntactic features. In
NELS 37. Proceedings of the thirty-seventh meeting of the North East Linguistic Society,
E. Elfner &
M. Walkow (eds) 31–45. Charleston NC: Booksurge.
Déprez, V.
2012 Atoms of negation: An outside-in micro-parametric approach to negative concord. In
The Evolution of Negation: Beyond the Jespersen Cycle,
P. Larrivée &
R. Ingham (eds), 221–272. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Déprez, V.
2014 NC vs. DN: A macroparametric variation? What can an experimental investigation tell us? Paper presented at the
Linguistic Symposium of Romance Languages 44, London, University of Western Ontario.
Déprez , V. & Yeaton, J.
Forthcoming.
French negative concord and discord.
An experimental investigation.
Déprez, V. & Martineau, F.
Espinal, M. T.
2000 Expletive negation, negative concord and feature checking.
Catalan Working Paper in Linguistics (December 1996): 47–69.)
Hoeksema, J.
2012 On the natural history of negative polarity items.
Linguistic Analysis 38: 1–2.
Homer, V.
2013 On the nonexistence of negative quantifiers: The case of Haitian Creole.
Paper presented at the Paris 8 Seminar on Creole Languages, Saint-Denis, France, 7 October.
[URL]
Homer, V. & Thommen, T.
2013 Remarks on a language with no overt negation.
Paper Presented at the 14th Szklarska Poreba Workshop, Szklarska Poreba, Poland, 1–4 March.
[URL]
Ladusaw, W.
1992 Expressing negation. In
Semantics and Linguistic Theory (
SALT) II. Ithaca NY: Cornell University Press.
Lahiri, U.
1998 Focus and negative polarity in Hindi.
Natural Language Semantics 6: 57–123.
Laka, I.
1990 Negation in Syntax: On the Nature of Functional Categories and Projections. PhD dissertation, MIT.
Mc Whorter, John
2001 The world’s simplest grammars are creole grammars.
Linguistic Typology 5: 125–166.
Merchant, J.
2001 The Syntax of Silence: Sluicing, Islands, and the Theory of Ellipsis. Oxford: OUP.
Pompilus, P.
1976 Contribution à l’étude compare du creole et du français à partir du creole haitien: Morphologie et syntaxe. Port au Prince Haiti: Editions Caraibes Preminger, O. 2013 Reversing agreement is untenable: A reply to Zeijlstra, February 2013. lingbuzz/001442.
Puskás, G.
2012 Licensing double negation in NC and non-NC languages.
Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 30: 611–649.
Watanabe, A.
2004 The genesis of negative concord: Syntax and morphology of negative doubling.
Linguistic Inquiry 35(4): 559–612.
Weir, A.
2014 Fragment answers and the question under discussion. In
NELS 44. Proceedings of the Forty-fourth Annual Meeting of the North East Linguistic Society,
Jyoti Iyer &
Leland Kusmer (eds) 255–266. Seattle WA: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform.
Yoon, S.
2011 “Not” in the Mood: The Syntax, Semantics, and Pragmatics of Evaluative Negation. PhD dissertation, University of Chicago.
Yoon, S.
2013 Parametric variation in subordinate evaluative negation: Korean/Japanese versus others.
Journal of East Asian Linguistics 22: 133–166.
Zanuttini, R.
1991 Syntactic Properties of Sentential Negation: A Comparative Study of Romance Languages. PhD dissertation, University of Pennsylvania.
Zanuttini, R.
1997 Negation and Clausal Structure: A Comparative Study of Romance Languages. Oxford: OUP.
Zeijlstra, H.
2004 Sentential Negation and Negative Concord. PhD dissertation, University of Amsterdam.
Zeijlstra, H.
2008 Negative concord is syntactic agreement. Ms, University of Amsterdam.
Zeijlstra, H.
2012 There is only one way to agree.
The Linguistic Review 29: 491–539.
Cited by (1)
Cited by 1 other publications
van der Auwera, Johan
2022.
Nominal and pronominal negative concord, through the lens of Belizean and Jamaican Creole.
Linguistics 60:2
► pp. 505 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 26 june 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.