Vol. 47:2 (2021) ► pp.253–299
Taxonomy of questions in Taiwan Southern Min
Contra the conventional four-way distinction of syntactically-formed questions in Taiwan Southern Min (TSM): (i) yes-no, (ii) A-not-A, (iii) disjunctive, and (iv) wh-questions (e.g., Lau 2010a), we justify a more revealing dichotomy of confirmation-seeking (CS) polar questions and information-seeking (IS) constituent questions, based on a suite of semantic and syntactic tests proposed in extensive literature for Mandarin and adapted further for TSM, where A-not-A belongs to the disjunctive type, which is in turn a subcategory of IS constituent questions. Controversies over the proper status of some sentence-final question particles and kám questions are also deliberated. Dismissing some alleged polar question particles as polar or A-not-A tags, we recognize nih and honnh as interrogative polar particles. We also show that kám has two underlying forms. One is a portmanteau word of the modal kánn and the negator m̄ and thus forms a whether-or-not disjunctive question (Huang 1988a, 1991). However, when kám is short for kámkong ‘don’t tell me’, similar to the Mandarin nandao, it appears in a polar question.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Criteria for a two-way distinction in Mandarin
- 2.1The two-way semantic distinction in terms of answers
- 2.2The ‘ma vs. ne’ distinction
- 2.3The ‘nandao vs. daodi’ distinction
- 2.4Intervention effect
- 2.5The availability of the indirect question counterpart
- 2.6An interim summary
- 3.Taxonomy of questions in TSM
- 3.1Previous four-way classification
- 3.2IS questions vs. CS questions in TSM
- 3.3Disjunctive questions and wh-questions as IS questions
- 3.4An interim summary
- 4.Questions with interrogative sentence-final particles
- 4.1A-not-A questions
- 4.2Sentence-final polar question particles or question tags?
- 4.3An interim summary
- 5.The status of kám questions
- 5.1Two forms of kám
- 5.2The interrogative kám questions as A-not-A questions
- 5.3The focus effects of the interrogative kám
- 5.4An interim summary
- 6.Concluding remarks
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
- List of abbreviations
-
References
https://doi.org/10.1075/consl.00029.her