Article published in:
Diachronic Dimensions of Alignment TypologyEdited by Eystein Dahl
[Diachronica 38:3] 2021
► pp. 358–412
Evolutionary dynamics of Indo-European alignment patterns
Gerd Carling | Lund University
Chundra Cathcart | University of Zurich
This paper employs phylogenetic modeling to reconstruct the alignment system of Indo-European. We use a data set of
categorical morphosyntactic features, which take states such as ‘nominative-accusative’, ‘active-stative’, or ‘ergative’. We analyze these
characters with a standard Bayesian comparative phylogenetic method, inferring transition rates between character states on the basis of a
phylogenetic representation of the languages in the data. Using these rates, we then reconstruct the probability of presence of traits at
the root and nodes of Indo-European. We find that the most probable alignment system for Proto-Indo-European is a nominative-accusative
system, with low probabilities of neutral marking and ergativity in the categories lower in grammatical hierarchies (nouns, past). Using a
test of phylogenetic signal, we find that characters pertaining to categories higher in hierarchies show greater phylogenetic stability than
categories lower in hierarchies. We examine our results in relation to theories of Proto-Indo-European alignment as well as to general
typology.
Keywords: historical linguistics, evolutionary linguistics, Proto-Indo-European, linguistic typology, grammar evolution, alignment, syntactic reconstruction
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 1.1The study: An overview
- 1.2Comparative, typological and phylogenetic models of reconstruction
- 1.3Indo-European alignment – reconstructions by comparative syntax
- 1.4Marking and animacy hierarchies in alignment
- 1.5General trends in the family
- 2.Data, model and method
- 2.1Data: Languages and coding models
- 2.2The Bayesian phylogenetic comparative reconstruction model
- 2.3The model for assessing phylogenetic stability across characters
- 3.Results
- 3.1Result overview
- 3.2Proto-language probabilities in the light of reconstruction by the comparative method and diachronic typology
- 3.3Probability levels and grammatical hierarchies of alignment
- 3.4Phylogenetic strength
- 3.5Summary of results
- 4.Concluding discussion: Reconstructing the evolution of alignment
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
- Appendices: Data and results
- Appendix 1.
- Appendix 2.
- Appendix 3.
-
References
Available under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial (CC BY-NC) 4.0 license.
For any use beyond this license, please contact the publisher at rights@benjamins.nl.
Published online: 23 July 2021
https://doi.org/10.1075/dia.19043.car
https://doi.org/10.1075/dia.19043.car
References
Barðdal, Jóhanna
Barðdal, Jóhanna & Thórhallur Eythórsson
Bauer, Brigitte
Bickel, Balthasar
Bickel, Balthasar & Johanna Nichols
Bollback, J. P.
Borges, Rui, João Paulo Machado, Cidália Gomes, Ana Paula Rocha & Agostinho Antunes
Bouckaert, Remco, Philippe Lemey, Michael Dunn, Simon J. Greenhill, Alexander V. Alekseyenko, Alexei J. Drummond, Russell D. Gray, Marc A. Suchard & Quentin D. Atkinson
Brugman, Claudia & Anne David
Bubenik, Vit
Calude, Andreea S. & Annemarie Verkerk
Campbell, Lyle & Alice C. Harris
Carling, Gerd
Carling, Gerd & Chundra Cathcart
Carling, Gerd, Filip Larsson, Chundra A. Cathcart, Niklas Johansson, Arthur Holmer, Erich Round & Rob Verhoeven
Carpenter, Bob, Andrew Gelman, Matthew D. Hoffman, Daniel Lee, Ben Goodrich, Michael Betancourt, Marcus Brubaker, Jiqiang Guo, Peter Li, & Allen Riddell
Cathcart, Chundra, Gerd Carling, Filip Larsson, Niklas Johansson & Erich Round
Cennamo, Michaela
Chang, Will, Chundra Cathcart, David Hall & Andrew Garrett
Clackson, James
Comrie, Bernard
Croft, William
Dahl, Eystein
Dahl, Eystein & Krzysztof Stroński
Delbrück, Berthold
1893 Grundriss der vergleichenden Grammatik der indogermanischen Sprachen : kurzgefasste Darstellung der Geschichte des Altindischen, Altiranischen (Avestischen u. Altpersischen), Altarmenischen, Altgriechischen, Albanesischen, Lateinischen, Oskisch-Umbrischen, Altirischen, Gotischen, Althochdeutschen, Litauischen und Altkirchenslavischen. Bd 3, Vergleichende Syntax der indogermanischen Sprachen, T. 1. Strassburg: Trübner.
1897 Grundriss der vergleichenden Grammatik der indogermanischen Sprachen : kurzgefasste Darstellung der Geschichte des Altindischen, Altiranischen (Avestischen u. Altpersischen), Altarmenischen, Altgriechischen, Albanesischen, Lateinischen, Oskisch-Umbrischen, Altirischen, Gotischen, Althochdeutschen, Litauischen und Altkirchenslavischen. Bd 4, Vergleichende Syntax der indogermanischen Sprachen, T. 2. Strassburg: Trübner.
1900 Grundriss der vergleichenden Grammatik der indogermanischen Sprachen : kurzgefasste Darstellung der Geschichte des Altindischen, Altiranischen (Avestischen u. Altpersischen), Altarmenischen, Altgriechischen, Albanesischen, Lateinischen, Oskisch-Umbrischen, Altirischen, Gotischen, Althochdeutschen, Litauischen und Altkirchenslavischen. Bd 5, Vergleichende Syntax der indogermanischen Sprachen, T. 3. Strassburg: Trübner. 

Dench, Alan
Drinka, Bridget
1999 Alignment in Early Proto-Indo-European. In Carol F. Justus & Edgar C. Polomé (eds.), Language change and typological variation: In honor of Winfred P. Lehmann on the occasion of his 83rd birthday (Journal of Indo-European Studies, Monograph Series, II), 464–500. Washington D.C.: Institute for the Study of Man.
Dryer, Matthew S. & Martin Haspelmath
2013 The world atlas of language structures online. Leipzig: Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology. http://wals.info
Dunn, Michael
Felsenstein, Joseph
Friedrich, Paul
Gamkrelidze, Tamaz Valerianovič, Vjačeslav Vsevolodovič Ivanov & Werner Winter
Gelman, Andrew & Donald B. Rubin
Goedegebuure, Petra
Gray, Russell D. & Quentin D. Atkinson
Greenberg, Joseph H.
Greenhill, Simon J., Quentin D. Atkinson, Andrew Meade & Russell D. Gray
Harris, Alice C.
Harris, Alice C. & Lyle Campbell
Haspelmath, Martin
Hawkins, John A.
Hendery, Rachel
Hock, Hans Henrich
Hock, Hans Henrich & Brian D. Joseph
Hopper, Paul & Elizabeth C. Traugott
Hrozný, Bedřich
Huelsenbeck, John P., Rasmus Nielsen & Jonathan P. Bollback
Jaeger, Florian T.
Jasanoff, Jay H.
Kortlandt, Frederik
Krahe, Hans, Hans Schmeja & Wolfgang Meid
Lehmann, Winfred P.
Lopuhaä-Zwakenberg, Milan
Luraghi, Silvia
Malchukov, Andrej L.
Martinet, André
Matasović, Ranko
2011 Clause alignment in Indo-European. Manuscript. Zagreb: Zagreb University. http://mudrac.ffzg.unizg.hr/~rmatasov/ClauseAlignmentInPIE.pdf.
Matasović, Ranko
Maurits, Luke & Thomas L. Griffiths
Meid, Wolfgang
Meier-Brügger, Michael, Matthias Fritz & Manfred Mayrhofer
Meiser, Gerhard
Pooth, Roland, Peter Alexander Kerkhof, Leonid Kulikov & Jóhanna Barđdal
Roberts, Ian G.
Ronan, Patricia
Rumsey, A.
Schlerath, Bernfried
Schmalsteig, William R.
Schmidt, Karl Horst
Silva, Sara Graça da & Jamshid J. Tehrani
Silverstein, Michael
Szemerényi, Oswald
Uhlenbeck, C. Cornelis
Walkden, George
Watkins, Calvert
Verbeke, Saartje & De Cuypere, Ludovic
Verbeke, Saartje & De Clercq, Eva
Villar, Francisco
Viti, Carlotta
Winter, Werner
Witzlack-Makarevich, Alena & Seržant, Ilja A.