Cover not available
Part of
Disability in Dialogue
Edited by Jessica M.F. Hughes and Mariaelena Bartesaghi
[Dialogue Studies 33] 2023
► pp. 88–114

Death and traumatic affect on Twitter

ORCID logo | Millersville University

References to death appear frequently in activist discourse. Activists make death matter on- and offline when they speak the names of people killed, hold die-ins and vigils, mention the number of lives lost, and tell the stories or share pictures of those who have died. This chapter examines how death materializes in digital activism on Twitter. Using a relational ontological approach (Cooren, 2018) to analyze agents and relationships evident in tweets about death in her own Twitter profile, the author works to understand how references to death are used in digital disability activism and what kinds of affective impact references to death might have on Twitter users. Taking as a focal point disability activists’ responses to comments about COVID-19 deaths made by the Director of the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the analysis demonstrates how references to death are used to mobilize activists, hold authorities to account, and reframe states of affairs to center the needs of vulnerable community members. Putting this case study in dialogue with other references to death on Twitter reveals the power of traumatic affect (Richardson, 2018), a force that materializes in the body and positions audience members in moral relation with those who have died.

Keywords: death, materiality, relational ontology, disability activism, Twitter, dialogue
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.A relational ontological approach
  • 3.Making death matter on Twitter
    • 3.1An upstream agent: Walensky’s interview
    • 3.2Initial reactions: Critique, contestation, and conspiracy theories
    • 3.3Eugenic discourse
    • 3.4Hypothetical reported discourse
    • 3.5Downstream dialogues
  • 4.Death and traumatic affect
  • 5.Conclusions
  • Notes
  • References
Published online: 19 September 2023
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/ds.33.05hug
References
ADA National Network
2022 An Overview of the Americans with Disabilities Act. [URL]
Arnett, Ronald C.
2017 “Language as the Originative House of Dialogic Ethics.” In The Routledge Handbook of Language and Dialogue, ed. by Edda Weigand, 307–317. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Autistic Self Advocacy Network
2022 Following Meeting with Dr. Rochelle Walensky, Disability Rights Advocates Release Statement and Readout. [URL]
Bakhtin, Mikhail M.
1986 Speech Genres and Other Late Essays, ed. by Caryl. Emerson and Michael. Holquist, trans. by Vern W. McGee. Austin: University of Texas Press.Google Scholar
Barad, Karen
2003 “Posthumanist Performativity: Toward an Understanding of How Matter Comes to Matter.” Signs 28(3): 801–831. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Baxter, Judith
2015 “Heteroglossia.” In The International Encyclopedia of Language and Social Interaction, ed. by Karen Tracy, Cornelia Ilie, and Todd Sandel, 734–745. Hoboken: Wiley Blackwell. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Benjamin, Andrew
2015 Towards a Relational Ontology: Philosophy’s Other Possibility. Albany: SUNY Press.Google Scholar
2017 “Recovering Aboriginal Relationality.” Research in Phenomenology, 47, 250–261. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Buber, Martin
2007 “Dialogue.” In Theorizing Communication: Readings across Traditions, ed. by Robert T. Craig and Heidi L. Muller, 225–238. Newbury Park. Sage.Google Scholar
Catevari [@catevari11]
2022 Sorry about your friend, but this is a BS interpretation. It IS good news, as the alternative scenario could be [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
n.d.). Homepage. Retrieved on Feb. 8, 2022. [URL]
2022a “Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR).” [URL]
2022b “Order: Wearing of Face Masks while on Conveyances and at Transportation Hubs.” [URL]
Centers for Disease Control Media Relations
2022 “Readout of Dr. Walensky’s Call with Disability Advocacy Groups and Allies [Readout].” [URL]
Chang, Alisa, Sundaresan, Mango and Sarah Handel
2022 “Disability Rights Activists Meet with CDC Director Walensky.” NPR. [URL]
Chowdhury, Rumman, and Luca Belli
2021 “Examining Algorithmic Amplification of Political Content on Twitter.” Twitter Blog. [URL]
Cleveland Clinic
2021 “Empathy Fatigue: How Stress and Trauma Can Take a Toll on You.” Health Essentials. [URL]
Coelho, Steph
2020 “How to Cope with Crisis Fatigue.” MedicalNewsToday. [URL]
Conroy, Erin
. [@chargrille] 2022 I see many people write off others’ lives as if the CDC should only take protective actions if this disease [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
@chargrille]. (n.d.). Bio [Twitter profile]. Twitter. [URL]
Cooren, François
2010 Action and agency in dialogue: Passion, incarnation, and ventriloquism. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2016 “Ethics for Dummies: Ventriloquism and Responsibility.” Atlantic Journal of Communication 24(1): 17–30. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2018 “Materializing Communication: Making the Case for a Relational Ontology.” Journal of Communication 68(2): 278–288. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Cortland, Matthew
. [@mattbc] 2022a It is “encouraging” to @CDCDirector that chronically ill and disabled Americans are dying. It’s no wonder that @CDCgov has consistently Twitter. [URL]
. [@mattbc] 2022b The problem is that the people running @CDCgov, including @CDCDirector, **fundamentally believe** it’s “encouraging” if disabled and chronically ill people Twitter. [URL]
@mattbc]. (n.d.). Bio Twitter. [URL]
Dale, Daniel
2022 “Fact Check: Right-Wing Figures Falsely Describe CDC Director’s Comments about COVID-19 Deaths.” CNN. [URL]
Dolmage, Jay Timothy
2017 Academic Ableism: Disability and Higher Education. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
DuBois, John W.
2007 “The Stance Triangle.” In Stancetaking in Discourse: Subjectivity, Evaluation, Interaction, ed. by Robert Englebretson, 139–182. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Garcia, Eric M.
@EricMGarcia]. (n.d.). Bio [Twitter profile]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022a The CDC met with @AAPD and disability rights activists are giving a rundown of their meeting with @CDCDirector. Follow here. [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022b “This has been an excruciating 2 years” for the disability community @bethanylilly of the Arc, and saying @CDCDirector’s comments about [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022c WOW! That is a big deal. Hung says that the community demanded a public apology from @CDCDirector [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022d “I really want to hyper-emphasize that we are looking for substantive changes that we can markedly see within the CDC”-@SeeMiaRoll [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022e Americans know that they need better protection but they need technical guidance because employees base corporate policies for employees based [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022f “We also hope that the CDC schedule a meeting with us in the next few weeks to begin these substantive [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022g “The director did offer an apology at the start for how hurtful her comments were and we acknowledged it.”-@ElenaHung202 [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022h “We wanted to provide them with a really detailed discussion about the policy needs we have.”-@bethanylilly [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022i “We wanted to draw attention to those who are new to the disability community.” with regard to Long Covid, @elenahung202 [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022j “I would say my sense was that she was fairly actively listening but again I think we want to return” [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022k Plenty of people with disabilities, including disability rights activists, are pissed at the Biden administration and the CDC for issuing [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
[@EricMGarcia] 2022l And for what it’s worth, I was hearing rumblings of dissatisfaction BEFORE today. There was a feeling that the CDC did not follow through after Walensky’s apology. [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
Georgakopoulou, Alexandra
2017 “Friends and Followers ‘in the Know’: A Narrative Interactional Approach to Social Media Participation.” In Dialogue across Media, ed. by Jarmila Mildorf and Bronwen Thomas, 155–178. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Good Morning America
2022 CDC Director Responds to Criticisms on COVID-19 Guidance | GMA [Video]. YouTube. [URL]
Hayes, Kelly
@MsKellyHayes]. (n.d.). Bio [Twitter profile]. Retrieved Mar. 29, 2022. [URL]
. [@MsKellyHayes] 2022a We are experiencing the expansion of disposability and that will always be framed as inevitability [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
. [@MsKellyHayes] 2022b They aren’t saying: Spread is inevitable, so we need to protect the vulnerable, make healthcare and testing free, and make [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
Hicks, Mar
. [@histoftech] 2022 “It is very encouraging news,” said the government, “that only people like you will die.” “Excuse me?” I said. “Very [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
Hughes, Jess M. F.
@JessMFH]. (n.d.). Bio [Twitter profile]. Twitter. [URL]
[@JessMFH] 2020 CW: Death [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
Hung, Elena
@ElenaHung202]. (n.d.). Bio [Twitter profile]. Twitter. [URL]
. [@ElenaHung202] 2022a When the ACA was under attack, disabled people showed up and saved health care for everyone. Then we worked hard [QT and video attached] [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
. [@ElenaHung202] 2022b And yet, @CDCDirector, you are doing the exact opposite of protecting us. You look us in the eye with your “apology” [Tweet; QT attached]. Twitter. [URL]
. [@ElenaHung202] 2022c If you prioritize disabled, chronically ill people in your Covid response, you help *everyone* but if you prioritize “healthy people” [Tweet; QT attached]. Twitter. [URL]
Jagger, Gill
2015 “The New Materialism and Sexual Difference.” Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 40(2): 321–342. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Johnson, Carla K.
2022 “U.S. COVID Deaths Hit 1 Million Less than 3 Years into the Pandemic.” PBS NewsHour. [URL]
Kecskes, Istvan
2017 “From Pragmatics to Dialogue.” In The Routledge Handbook of Language and Dialogue ed. by Edda Weigand, 78–9. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Ken, Ryan
. [@Ryan_Ken_Acts] 2022a Putting aside the vacuum of humanity it takes to believe that and to declare it aloud, the societal acceptance of [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
. [@Ryan_Ken_Acts] 2022b The sentiment that “it’s only those people who will die” should not bring you comfort [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
Latour, Bruno
2004 “Why has Critique Run out of Steam? From Matters of Fact to Matters of Concern.” Critical Inquiry 30(2): 225–248. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Létourneau, Alain
2012 “Towards an Inclusive Notion of Dialogue for Ethical and Moral Purposes.” In (Re)presentations and Dialogue ed. by François Cooren and Alain Létourneau, 17–36. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Levinas, Emmanuel
1984 “Ethics as First Philosophy.” In The Levinas Reader ed. by Seán. Hand, 75–87. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.Google Scholar
Lua, Alfred
2018 “How the Twitter Timeline Works (and 6 Simple Tactics to Increase Your Reach.” Buffer. [URL]
Martínez, L. A.
2019 “Eugenics.” Salem Press Encyclopedia of Health. [URL]
Massumi, Brian
2015 Politics of Affect. Cambridge: Polity.Google Scholar
Mauldin, Laura
. [@mauldin_laura] 2022 The casual ableism of this should stun you. Does the @CDCDirector not know their own stats? 6 in 10 adults [Tweet; QT attached]. Twitter. [URL]
Maybin, Janet
2008 “Revoicing across Learning Spaces.” In Encyclopedia of Language and Education: Discourse and Education, ed. by Marilyn Martin-Jones, Anne Marie de Mejia and Nancy H. Hornberger. 2nd ed. 1–12. Berlin: Springer. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
McElrath, Leah
. [@leahmcelrath] 2021 Good morning! If you’re feeling a little off, that might be because we’re still in the midst of a pandemic [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
Myers, Greg
1999 “Unspoken Speech: Hypothetical Reported Discourse and the Rhetoric of Everyday Talk.” Text and Talk 19(4): 571–590. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Nair, Aparna
. [@DisabilityStor1] 2022a The CDC only speaks to and for able-bodied people; the rest of us can go fuck right off [Tweet; QT attached]. Twitter. [URL]
. [@DisabilityStor1] 2022b It REALLY WASNT THAT HARD [Tweet; QT and video attached]. Twitter. [URL]
[URL]
2020 About #NoBodyIsDisposable. [URL]
OneButtOneChair [@hotmomoffour]
2022 Why are we doing this…twisting words and taking things out of context? This whole mess is so out of [Tweet]. Twitter. [URL]
Richardson, Michael
2018 “Radical Absence: Encountering Traumatic Affect in Digitally Mediated Disappearance.” Cultural Studies 32(1): 63–80. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Richardson, Michael and Meera Atkinson
2013 “At the Nexus: An Introduction.” In Traumatic Affect, ed. by Meera Atkinson and Michael Richardson, 1–19. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Press.Google Scholar
Sharma, Bhakti, Lee, Susanna S. and Benjamin K. Johnson
2022 “The Dark at the End of the Tunnel: Doomscrolling on Social Media Newsfeeds.” Technology, Mind, and Behavior 3(1). DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Shotter, John
2011 Getting It: Withness-Thinking and the Dialogical…in Practice. New York: Hampton Press, Inc.Google Scholar
Sins Invalid
2020 “What is Disability Justice?” [URL]
Swink, Simone
(Executive producer) 2022 CDC Director One-on-one: New Study Finds Severe Illness Rare among Vaccinated People [TV series episode]. In, Good Morning America. ABC News.Google Scholar
Thrasher, Steven W.
2022 “There Is Nothing Normal about One Million People Dead from COVID.” Scientific American. [URL]
Yek, Christina, Warner, Sarah, Wiltz, Jennifer L., Sun, Junfeng, Adjei, Stacy, Mancera, Alex, Silk, Benjamin J., Gundlapalli, Adi V., Harris, Aaron M., Boehmer, Tegan K. and Sameer S. Kadri
2022 “Risk Factors for Severe COVID-19 Outcomes among Persons Aged ≥18 Years Who Completed a Primary COVID-19 Vaccination Series – 465 Health Care Facilities, United States, December 2020 – October 2021.” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (71)1: 19–25. [URL]. DOI logo