Article published in:
EUROSLA Yearbook: Volume 5 (2005)Edited by Susan H. Foster-Cohen, María del Pilar García Mayo and Jasone Cenoz
[EUROSLA Yearbook 5] 2005
► pp. 223–250
Focus on Form in Second Language Vocabulary Learning
Batia Laufer | University of Haifa
The realization by applied linguists that second language learners cannot achieve high levels of grammatical competence from entirely meaning centered instruction has led them to propose that learners need to focus on form, i.e. to attend to linguistic elements during a communicative activity (Long 1991, De Keyser 1998, Norris and Ortega 2000, Ellis 2001). However, most advocates of Focus on Form (FonF), have also proscribed Focus on Forms (FonFs), the systematic teaching of isolated grammatical items and rules. So far, FonF research has been concerned with grammatical, not lexical, instruction. In this paper, which was originally presented as a plenary session at the 2004 EUROSLA conference, I examine the need for Focus on Form and the proscription of Focus on Forms from the vocabulary learning perspective.
First, I argue that, similarly to grammar, comprehensible input is insufficient for acquiring vocabulary, and consequently Focus on Form is an essential component of instruction. I base my argument on the fallacy of the assumptions which underlie the vocabulary-through-input hypothesis: the noticing assumption, the guessing ability assumption, the guessing-retention link assumption and the cumulative gain assumption. Second, I defend Focus on Forms and argue against the claim that attention to form must be motivated by and carried out within a communicative task environment. The defense is based on the nature of lexical competence, which is perceived as a combination of different aspects of vocabulary knowledge, vocabulary use, speed of lexical access and strategic competence. The two arguments above will be supported by empirical evidence from three types of vocabulary learning studies: (a) the ‘classic’ task embedded FonF, (b) task related FonFs, and (c) ‘pure’ FonFs studies, unrelated to any task.
Published online: 02 August 2005
https://doi.org/10.1075/eurosla.5.11lau
https://doi.org/10.1075/eurosla.5.11lau
Cited by
Cited by 78 other publications
Ajideh, Parviz, Massoud Rahimpour, Davoud Amini & Farahman Farrokhi
Altin, Mehmet, Asuman Seda Saracaloğlu & Mark Boylan
ANSARİN, Ali Akbar & Salva Kazemipour KHABBAZİ
Asención-Delaney, Yuly, Joseph G. Collentine, Karina Collentine, Jersus Colmenares & Luke Plonsky
BORDAG, DENISA, AMIT KIRSCHENBAUM, ERWIN TSCHIRNER & ANDREAS OPITZ
Boroujeni, Fatemeh Abbasian
Choo, LEE Bee, Debbita TAN Ai Lin & Ambigapathy Pandian
Deconinck, Julie, Frank Boers & June Eyckmans
Dubiner, Deborah
Eckerth, Johannes & Parveneh Tavakoli
Elgort, Irina
Feng, Teng
Gebril, Atta & Lia Plakans
González Ortega, Bianca & Iban Mañas Navarrete
Gordani, Yahya
Handley, Zöe
Hettiarachchi, Shyamani, Mahishi Ranaweera & H. M. Lalani N. Disanayake
Huang, Pao-Yao, Aaron Robert Fischer & Shuchih Ernest Chang
Jankowska, Aleksandra & Michał Jankowski
Kaivanpanah, Shiva, Seyed Mohammad Alavi, Afsaneh Ravandpour & Meihua Qian
Kamali, Mojtaba, Fatemeh Behjat, Mohammad Sadegh Bagheri & Shuying Li
Kang, Hyeonah, Soo-Ok Kweon & Sungmook Choi
Keating, Gregory D.
Khezrlou, Sima
Khezrlou, Sima, Rod Ellis & Karim Sadeghi
Kim, Jeong-eun & Hosung Nam
Kirsch, Claudine
Laufer, Batia & Bella Rozovski-Roitblat
Lee, Jang Ho & Glenn S. Levine
Lee, Siu-on
Lin, Lu-Fang
Lindstromberg, Seth & June Eyckmans
Macaro, Ernesto & Lili Tian
Milton, James
Mohamed, Ayman A.
MONTERO PEREZ, MARIBEL, ELKE PETERS & PIET DESMET
Montero Perez, Maribel, Elke Peters & Piet Desmet
Méndez, María del Carmen
Nakata, Tatsuya
Pauwels, Paul
Pauwels, Paul
Peters, Elke
Peters, Elke
Porto, Melina, Ann Montemayor-Borsinger & Mario López-Barrios
Pujadas, Geòrgia & Carmen Muñoz
Pujadas, Geòrgia & Carmen Muñoz
Sadeghi, Karim, Sima Khezrlou & Sima Modirkhameneh
Sarbazi, Mouhammad- Reza
Saygili, Kubra
Schmitt, Norbert
Schmitt, Norbert
Schmitt, Norbert
Skorczynska, Hanna, Milagros del Saz Rubio & María Luisa Carrió-Pastor
Soodmand Afshar, Hassan
Stæhr, Lars Stenius
Suárez, Maria del Mar & Ferran Gesa
Teng, Feng
Ur, Penny
Wang, Dongshuo, Bin Zou & Minjie Xing
WEBB, STUART, AKIFUMI YANAGISAWA & TAKUMI UCHIHARA
Wu, Qun
Yang, Yingli & Xiaofang Cao
Yang, Yingli, Natsuko Shintani, Shaofeng Li & Yingyi Zhang
Zhang, Pengchong & Suzanne Graham
김보람
윤미선 & Unkyoung Maeng
이연준
이지현
임미진
조영아 & 마지현
하주연 & 윤현숙
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 14 april 2021. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.