The function of extra negation
Insights from the Dutch privative construction
This paper provides insight into the phenomenon of extra negation, also known as non-compositional, expletive, or
pleonastic negation. It provides a corpus-based analysis of the Dutch negative privative construction, which consists of
zonder ‘without’ and niet ‘not’, in which one negation does not cancel the other. Two basic
factors that trigger an extra negation are discussed, and an explanation of why these factors facilitate the use of an extra
negation is offered. It is argued that the extra negation has a semantic-pragmatic function that is reminiscent of similar
instances of extra negation in Dutch and other languages, specifically sentences consisting of a main clause and a subordinate
clause containing a word which expresses implicit negation. It is shown that in complex hypotactic constructions, the extra
negation is used to make explicit in the subordinate clause that the presupposition of non-occurrence is rejected.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Previous work, terminology and possible explanations
- 3.Data collection
- 4.Main triggers for the negation
- 5.Explanation of the triggers for the extra negation
- 6.Comparison with compositional sentences
- 7.Relations with other constructions
- 8.Conclusion
- Acknowledgments
- Notes
-
Corpora used
-
References
References (39)
Corpora used
Brieven als Buit-corpus. Leiden University. Compiled by Marijke van der Wal (Programme leader), Gijsbert Rutten, Judith Nobels and Tanja Simons, with the assistance of volunteers of the Leiden-based Wikiscripta Neerlandica transcription project, and lemmatised, tagged and provided with search facilities by the Institute for Dutch Lexicology (INL). 3rd
release January 2021. [URL]
Corpus Middelnederlands (Version
1.0) (January 2021) [Online
service]. Available at the Dutch Language Institute: [URL]
Delpher newspaper corpus. Available
at [URL]
Nexis Uni newspaper database (for
Dutch). Accessed via the Leiden University Library.
OpenSoNaR [Online service]. Compiled by Oostdijk, Nelleke, Martin Reynaert, Veronique Hoste & Ineke Schuurman. 2018. Available at the Dutch Language Institute: [URL]
Historical Corpus of Dutch. Made available by Gijsbert Rutten. See Van De Voorde, Iris, Gijsbert Rutten, Rik Vosters, Marijke van der Wal & Wim Vandenbussche. In press. Historical Corpus of Dutch: A new multi-genre corpus of Early and Late Modern Dutch. Taal en Tongval 75(1).
References
Clark, Herbert H. 1976. Semantics and
comprehension. The Hague: Mouton.
Delfitto, Denis. 2020. Expletive
negation. In Viviane Déprez & M. Teresa Espinal (eds.), 255–268.
Déprez, Viviane & M. Teresa Espinal. The Oxford
handbook of
negation. Oxford: OUP.
Fortuin, Egbert. 2014. Deconstructing
a verbal illusion: The ‘no X is too Y to Z’ construction and the rhetoric of
negation. Cognitive
Linguistics 251. 249–92.
Fortuin, Egbert & Thom van Hugte. In
prep. Convention or error? Expletive negation in Dutch sentences with
‘without’. In Chiara Gianollo & Johan van der Auwera (eds.), A
hundred years of negative
concord. Berlin: Mouton.
Haspelmath, Martin. Manuscript. Negindefinites
and negative concord: Concepts, terms and analyses.
Horn, Laurence. 1991. Duplex
negatio affirmat: The economy of double negation. In CLS 27–2: The
Parasession on
Negation, 78–106. Chicago: Chicago Linguistic Society.
Horn, Laurence. 2009. Hypernegation,
hyponegation, and parole violations. In Ikso Kwon, Hannah Pritchett & Justin Spence (eds.), Proceedings
of the Thirty-fifth annual meeting of the Berkeley Linguistic Society, 403–423. Berkeley CA: Berkeley Linguistics Society.
Jespersen, Otto. 1917. Negation
in English and other languages. Copenhagen: A. F. Høst.
Jin, Yanwei & Jean-Pierre Koenig. 2020. A
cross-linguistic study of expletive negation. Linguistic
Typology 25(1). 39–78.
Keijsper, Cornelia E. 1985. Information
structure. Amsterdam: Rodopi.
Maldonado, Mora & Jennifer Culbertson. 2021. Nobody
doesn’t like negative concord. Journal of Psycholinguistic
Research 501. 1401–1416.
Oostdijk, Nelleke, Martin Reynaert, Veronique Hoste & Ineke Schuurman. 2018. OpenSoNaR [Online service]. Available at the Dutch Language Institute: [URL]
Oskolskaya, Sofia A., Natalia M. Zaika, Sergei B. Klimenko & Maksim L. Fedotov. 2020. Opredelenie kartiva kak sravitel’nogo ponjatija. [Defining
caritive as a comparative concept]. Voprosy
Jazykoznanija 31. 7–25.
Paape, Dario, Shravan Vasishth & Titus von der Malsburg. 2020. Quadruplex
negatio invertit? The on-line processing of depth charge sentences. Journal of
Semantics 37(4). 509–555.
Paardekooper, Piet C. 1975. Zonder en zonder dat: twee
ontkennende vw’s. De Nieuwe Taalgids 681. [URL]
van der Auwera, Johan. 2022. Nominal
and pronominal negative concord, through the lens of Belizean and Jamaican
Creole. Linguistics 601. 505–540.
van der Auwera, Johan & Olga Krasnoukhova. 2020. The
typology of negation. In Viviane Déprez and M. Teresa Espinal (eds.), 91–116.
van der Auwera, Johan. & Sepideh Koohkan. 2022. Extending
the typology: Negative concord and connective negation in Persian. Linguistic Typology at the
Crossroads
2
(1). 1–36.
van der Auwera, Johan & Lauren van Alsenoy. 2018. More
ado about nothing: On the typology of negative indefinites. In Ken Turner & Laurence R. Horn (eds.), Pragmatics,
truth and underspecification: Towards an atlas of
meaning, 107–146. Leiden: Brill.
van der Horst, Joop. 2008. Geschiedenis
van de Nederlandse syntaxis, Deel
1. Leuven: Universitaire Pers Leuven.
van der Wouden, Ton. 2021. 29.4
Meervoudige ontkenningen (versie 3.0). Algemene Nederlandse Spraakkunst. [URL]
Van De Voorde, Iris, Gijsbert Rutten, Rik Vosters, Marijke van der Wal & Wim Vandenbussche. In press. Historical Corpus of Dutch: A new multi-genre corpus of Early and Late Modern Dutch. Taal en Tongval 75(1).
Vandeweghe, Willy. 2009. Negatievermenigvuldiging
in het West-Vlaams. Studies van de BKL 41. [URL]
Wason, Peter. C. & Shuli S. Reich. 1979. A
verbal illusion. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental
Psychology 311. 591–597.
Zhang, Yuhan, Rachel Ryskin & Edward Gibson. 2023. A
noisy-channel approach to depth-charge
illusions. Cognition 2321. 1–19.
Zeijlstra, Hedde. 2010. Emphatic
multiple negative expressions in Dutch. The Linguistic
Review 27(1). 37–73.
Zorikhina Nilsson, Nadezhda. 2012. Peculiarities
of expressing the apprehensive in Russian. Oslo Studies in
Language 4(1). 53–70.