Article published In:
GestureVol. 14:1 (2014) ► pp.26–45
The effect of gestured instruction on the learning of physical causality problems
Recent research has demonstrated instruction that includes gesture can greatly impact the learning of certain mathematics tasks for children and much of this work relies on face-to-face instruction. We extend the work on this problem by asking how gesture in instruction impacts adult learning from a video production for a science concept. Borrowing from research by Perry and Elder (1997), the research presented here examines what role adding gesture to instruction plays for adults learning about gear movement. In this pretest-instruction-posttest design, 56 college-aged participants were asked to complete problems relating to gear movement. Participants viewed either an instructional video in which an instructor used speech only (control) or speech-plus-gesture (experimental) to explain a fundamental principle in the physics of gear movement. Results showed that adults who knew less actually learned more and that instruction was effective, but significantly more effective when gesture was added. These findings shed light on the role of gesture input in adult learning and carry implications for how gesture may be utilized in asynchronous instruction with adults.
Keywords: instruction, physics learning, adult learning
References (62)
Alibali, Martha W. & Mitchell J. Nathan (2007). Teachers’ gestures as a means of scaffolding students’ understanding: Evidence from an early algebra lesson. In Ricki Goldman, Roy Pea, Brigid Barron, & Sharon J. Derry (Eds.), Video research in the learning sciences (pp. 349–365). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
(2011): Embodiment in mathematics teaching and learning: Evidence from learners’ and teachers’ gestures. Journal of the Learning Sciences, 21 (2), 247–286. 
Alibali, Martha W., Mitchell J. Nathan, & Yuka Fujimori (2011). Gestures in the mathematics classroom: What’s the point? In Nancy L. Stein & Stephen W. Raudenbush (Eds.), Developmental cognitive science goes to school (pp. 219–234). New York: Routeledge.
Alibali, Martha W., Robert C. Spencer, Lucy Knox, & Sotaro Kita (2011). Spontaneous gestures influence strategy choices in problem solving. Psychological Science, 22 (9), 1138–1144.
Allen, I. Elaine & Jeff Seaman (2006). Making the grade: Online education in the United States, 2006. Needham, MA: The Sloan Consortium.
(2010). Learning on demand: Online education in the United States, 2009. Newburyport, MA: The Sloan Consortium.
Barr, Dale, Spencer D. Kelly, Ruth Breckinridge Church, & Kathryn Lynch (1999). Gesture is not just second-hand information: The interdependence of speech and gesture in comprehension and memory. Journal of Memory and Language, 401, 577–592.
Beilock, Sian L. & Susan Goldin-Meadow (2010). Gesture changes thought by grounding it in action. Psychological Science, 211, 1605–1610.
Bem, Jolanta, Steven A. Jacobs, Susan Goldin-Meadow, Susan Levine, Martha W. Alibali, & Mitchell Nathan (2012, June). Gesture’s benefit for instruction: Attention coordination or embodied cognition? Poster presented at the
Jean Piaget Society Conference
, Toronto, CA.
Ben-Zeev, Talia & Jon R. Star (2001). Spurious correlations in mathematical thinking. Cognition and Instruction, 191, 253–275.
Cassell, Justine, David McNeill, & Karl-Erik McCullough (1999). Speech-gesture mismatches: Evidence for one underlying representation of linguistic and nonlinguistic information. Pragmatics & Cognition, 7 (1), 1–34.
Chi, Michelene T.H., Marguerite Roy, & Robert G.M. Hausmann (2008). Observing tutorial dialogues collaboratively: Insights about human tutoring effectiveness from vicarious learning. Cognitive Science, 321, 301–341.
Chu, Mingyuan & Sotaro Kita (2008). Spontaneous gestures during mental rotation tasks: Insights into the microdevelopment of the motor strategy. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 1371, 706–723.
Chu, Mingyuan, & Sotaro Kita (2011). The nature of gestures’ beneficial role in spatial problem solving. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 1401, 102–116.
Church, Ruth Breckinridge, Saba Ayman-Nolley, & Shahrzad Mahootian (2004). The role of gesture in bilingual education: Does gesture enhance learning? International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 71, 303–319.
Church, Ruth Breckinridge, Phillip Garber, & Kathryn Rogalski (2007). The role of gesture in memory and social communication. Gesture, 71, 137–158.
Church, Ruth Breckinridge, Spencer D. Kelly, & Kathryn Lynch (2000). Immediate memory for mismatched speech and representational gesture across development. Journal of Nonverbal Behavior, 241, 151–174.
Church, Ruth Breckinridge, Kimberly Schonert-Reichl, Nancy Goodman, Spencer D. Kelly, & Saba Ayman-Nolley (1995). The role of gesture and speech communication as a reflection of cognitive understanding. Journal of Contemporary Legal Issues, 61, 123–154.
Cook, Susan Wagner & Susan Goldin-Meadow (2006). The role of gesture in learning: Do children use their hands to change their minds? Journal of Cognition and Development, 71, 211–232.
Cook, Susan Wagner, Zachary Mitchell, & Susan Goldin-Meadow (2008). Gesture makes learning last. Cognition, 1061, 1047–1058.
Cook, Susan Wagner, Ryan G. Duffy, & Kimberly M. Fenn (2013). Consolidation and transfer of learning after observing hand gesture. Child Development, 84 (6), 1863–1871.
Corballis, Michael (1999). The gestural origins of language: Human language may have evolved from manual gestures, which survive today as a “behavioral fossil” coupled to speech. American Scientist, 87 (2), 138–146.
Craig, Scotty D., Michelene T.H. Chi, & Kurt Van Lehn (2009). Improving classroom learning by collaboratively observing human tutoring videos while problem solving. Journal of Educational Psychology, 1011, 779–789.
Dixon, James A. & Ashley Bangert (2002). The prehistory of discovery: Precursors of representational change in solving gear-system problems. Developmental Psychology, 381, 918–933.
Ekman, Paul & Wallace V. Friesen (1974). Nonverbal behavior and psychopathology. In Raymond J. Friedman & Martin M. Katz (Eds.), The psychology of depression: Contemporary theory and research (pp. 203–232). Washington, DC: Winston and Sons.
Flevares, Lucia M. & Michelle Perry (2001). How many do you see? The use of nonspoken representations in first-grade mathematics lessons. Journal of Educational Psychology, 931, 330–345.
Gholson, Barry & Scotty D. Craig (2006). Promoting constructive activities that support vicarious learning during computer-based instruction. Educational Psychology Review, 181, 119–139.
Goldin-Meadow, Susan (2003). Hearing gesture: How our hands help us think. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
(2011). Learning through gesture. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Cognitive Science, 21, 595–607.
Goldin-Meadow, Susan, Martha W. Alibali, & Ruth Breckinridge Church (1993). Transitions in concept acquisition: Using the hand to read the mind. Psychological Review, 1001, 279–297.
Goldin-Meadow, Susan, Suyeon Kim, & Melissa Singer (1999). What the teacher’s hands tell the student’s mind about math. Journal of Educational Psychology, 911, 720–730.
Goldin-Meadow, Susan & Melissa Singer (2003). From children’s hands to adults’ ears: Gesture’s role in the learning process. Developmental Psychology, 391, 509–520.
Goldin-Meadow, Susan, Debra Wein, & Cecilia Chang (1992). Assessing knowledge through gesture: Using children’s hands to read their minds. Cognition and Instruction, 91, 201–219.
Gullberg, Marianne & Kenneth Holmqvist (2006). What speakers do and what addressees look at: Visual attention to gestures in human interaction live and on video. Pragmatics & Cognition, 141, 53–82.
Hostetter, Autumn B. (2011). When do gestures communicate? A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 1371, 297–315.
Jacobs, Steven A., Ruth Breckinridge Church, Mitchell J. Nathan, Eric J. Knuth, Matthew S. Wolfgram, & Martha W. Alibali (2009, April). How teachers use linking gestures to establish cohesion across multiple representations. Poster presented at the
Society for Research in Child Development
, Denver, CO.
Kelly, Spencer D. & Ruth Breckinridge Church (1997). Can children detect conceptual information conveyed through other children’s nonverbal behaviors? Cognition and Instruction, 151, 107–134.
(1998). A comparison between children’s and adults’ ability to detect conceptual information conveyed through representational gesture. Child Development, 691, 85–93.
Kelly, Spencer D., Sarah M. Manning, & Sabrina Rodak (2008). Gesture gives a hand to language and learning: Perspectives from cognitive neuroscience, developmental psychology and education. Language and Linguistics Compass, 21, 569–588.
Kendon, Adam (2004). Gesture: Visible action as utterance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Klahr, David & Milena Nigam (2004). The equivalence of learning paths in early science instruction. Effects of direct instruction and discovery learning. Psychological Science, 151, 661–667.
Lakoff, George & Rafael E. Nunez (2000). Where mathematics comes from: How the embodied mind brings mathematics into being. New York: Basic Books.
Mayer, Richard E. (2009). Multimedia learning (2nd ed.). New York: Cambridge University Press.
McNeill, David (1992). Hand and mind: What gestures reveal about thought. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
(2005). Gesture and thought. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
Morford, Marolyn & Susan Goldin-Meadow (1992). Comprehension and production of gesture in combination with speech in one-word speakers. Journal of Child Language, 191, 559–580.
Perry, Michelle & Anastasia D. Elder (1997). Knowledge in transition: Adults’ developing understanding of a principle of physical causality. Cognitive Development, 121, 131–157.
Perry, Michelle, Jacqueline Wooley, & John Ifcher (1995). Adults’ abilities to detect children’s readiness to learn. International Journal of Behavioral Development, 181, 365–381.
Piaget, Jean (1954). The construction of reality in the child. New York: Ballantine Books.
Ping, Raedy P., Susan Goldin-Meadow, & Sian L. Beilock (2013). Understanding gesture: Is the listener’s motor system involved? Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, Advance online publication.
Quandt, Lorna C., Peter J. Marshall, Thomas F. Shipley, Sian L. Beilock, & Susan Goldin-Meadow (2012). Sensitivity of alpha and beta oscillations to sensorimotor characteristics of action: An EEG study of action production and gesture observation. Neuropsychologia, 501, 2745–2751.
Reilly, Susan S. & Louis H. Muzekari (1986). Effects of emotional illness and age upon the resolution of discrepant messages. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 621, 823–829.
Reynolds, Fiona J. & Robert A. Reeve (2001). Gesture in collaborative mathematics problem solving. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 20 (4), 447–460.
Roseth, Cary J., Andy J. Saltarelli, & Chris R. Glass (2011). Effects of face-to-face and computer-mediated constructive controversy on social interdependence, motivation, and achievement. Journal of Educational Psychology, 1031, 804–820.
Schwartz, Daniel L. & Tamara Black (1999). Inferences through imagined actions: Knowing by simulated doing. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 251, 116–136.
Singer, Melissa A. & Susan Goldin-Meadow (2005). Children learn when their teacher’s gestures and speech differ. Psychological Science, 16 (2), 85–89.
Singer, Melissa A., Joshua Radinsky, & Susan R. Goldman (2008). The role of gesture in meaning construction. Discourse Processes, 451, 365–386.
Stine-Morrow, Elizabeth A.L. (2007). The Dumbledore hypothesis of cognitive aging. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 161, 295–299.
Stürmer, Birgit, Gisa Aschersleben, & Wolfgang Prinz (2000). Correspondence effects with manual gestures and postures: A study on imitation. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception & Performance, 261, 1746–1759.
Thompson, Laura A. & Dominic W. Massaro (1994). Children’s integration of speech and pointing gestures in comprehension. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 57 (3), 327–354.
Valenzeno, Laura, Martha W. Alibali, & Roberta Klatzky (2003). Teachers’ gestures facilitate students’ learning: A lesson in symmetry. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 28 (2), 187–204.
Woodall, W. Gill & Joseph P. Folger (1985). Nonverbal cue context and episodic memory: On the availability and endurance of nonverbal behaviors as retrieval cues. Communication Monographs, 521, 319–333.
Cited by (18)
Cited by 18 other publications
Choi, Yoon-Sung
2024. Descriptive Characteristics of Systematic Functional Gestures Used by Pre-Service Earth Science Teachers in Classroom Learning Environments. Journal of the Korean earth science society 45:4 ► pp. 377 ff. 
Church, R. Breckinridge, Michelle Perry, Melissa A. Singer, Susan Wagner Cook & Martha Wagner Alibali
2024. Teachers’ Gestures and How They Matter. Topics in Cognitive Science
Goldin‐Meadow, Susan
2024. The Mind Hidden in Our Hands. Topics in Cognitive Science
Li, Wenjing, Ziyi Kuang, Xiaoxue Leng, Richard E. Mayer & Fuxing Wang
2024. Role of Gesturing Onscreen Instructors in Video Lectures: A Set of Three-level Meta-analyses on the Embodiment Effect. Educational Psychology Review 36:3
Beege, Maik, Noah L. Schroeder, Steffi Heidig, Günter Daniel Rey & Sascha Schneider
2023. The instructor presence effect and its moderators in instructional video: A series of meta-analyses. Educational Research Review 41 ► pp. 100564 ff.
Parrill, Fey, Jeffrey J. Shymanski & Susan Wagner Cook
2023. Using the hands to learn about the brain: Testing action‐based instruction in brain anatomy. Applied Cognitive Psychology 37:5 ► pp. 967 ff.
Alemdag, Ecenaz
2022. Effects of instructor-present videos on learning, cognitive load, motivation, and social presence: A meta-analysis. Education and Information Technologies 27:9 ► pp. 12713 ff.
Ping, Raedy, Fey Parrill, Ruth Breckinridge Church & Susan Goldin-Meadow
2022. Teaching stereoisomers through gesture, action, and mental imagery. Chemistry Education Research and Practice 23:3 ► pp. 698 ff.
Guilbert, Daniel, Naomi Sweller & Penny Van Bergen
2021. Emotion and gesture effects on narrative recall in young children and adults. Applied Cognitive Psychology 35:4 ► pp. 873 ff.
McKern, Nicola, Nicole Dargue, Naomi Sweller, Kazuki Sekine & Elizabeth Austin
2021. Lending a hand to storytelling: Gesture’s effects on narrative comprehension moderated by task difficulty and cognitive ability. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 74:10 ► pp. 1791 ff.
Reuter, Timo & Miriam Leuchter
2021. Children's concepts of gears and their promotion through play. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 58:1 ► pp. 69 ff.
Wang, Jixin, Tingting Liu & Xuan Wang
2020. Human hand gesture recognition with convolutional neural networks for K-12 double-teachers instruction mode classroom. Infrared Physics & Technology 111 ► pp. 103464 ff.
Lubrick, Mark, George Zhou & Jingsheng Zhang
2019. Is the Future Bright? The Potential of Lightboard Videos for Student Achievement and Engagement in Learning. EURASIA Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education 15:8
Parrill, Fey, Alison McKim & Kimberly Grogan
2019. Gesturing standard deviation: Gestures undergraduate students use in describing their concepts of standard deviation. The Journal of Mathematical Behavior 53 ► pp. 1 ff.
Cook, Susan Wagner
2018. Enhancing learning with hand gestures: Potential mechanisms [Psychology of Learning and Motivation, 69], ► pp. 107 ff.
Rueckert, Linda, Ruth Breckinridge Church, Andrea Avila & Theresa Trejo
2017. Gesture enhances learning of a complex statistical concept. Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications 2:1
Abels, Simone
2016. The role of gestures in a teacher–student-discourse about atoms. Chemistry Education Research and Practice 17:3 ► pp. 618 ff.
Senior, Carl
2016. Innovation in education. Commentary: Teaching statistics using dance and movement and a case for neuroscience in mathematics education. Frontiers in Psychology 7
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 16 november 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.