Article published in:
Gesture
Vol. 16:1 (2017) ► pp. 1–34

The shrug

Forms and meanings of a compound enactment

| Université Paris Ouest Nanterre La Défense
The shrug is a widely shared gesture ensemble with several different components. These include: lifting the shoulders; rotating the forearms outwards with extended fingers to a “palm up” position; with mouth firmly closed, pulling the lips downwards (the “mouth shrug”), which may or may not be combined with raising the eyebrows and tilting the head to one side. It comprises a rich yet consistent network of forms (a single component or a combination of components can index the whole enactment). These components, together or in various combinations, are shown to express incapacity, powerlessness, indetermination, indifference, obviousness which, we suggest, are unified by a common semantic theme of personal disengagement. Since the shrug expresses pragmatic meanings and its formational and semantic core remains stable across different contexts and speakers, the shrug also qualifies as a recurrent gesture. Based on empirical evidence gathered from a videotaped corpus of dyadic interactions between native speakers of British English, this study proposes a qualitative-yet-systematic method to provide a unified account of shrugging.
Keywords: shrug, emblem, recurrent gesture, compositionality, gesture complexity, compound enactment
Article outline
  • Is the shrug an emblem?
  • Corpus and method for an empirical study of shrugging
  • Formal variations of a compound enactment
  • Multiple meanings unified by a semantic theme
    • Attitudinal shrugs: incapacity and inaction
    • Affective distance: shrugging as indifference and rejection
    • Epistemic “I don’t know” and “you know” shrugs
    • A common semantic theme
  • Emerging forms-functions patterns
  • Conclusion: the shrug as a recurrent gesture
  • Acknowledgements
  • Notes
  • References


This article is currently available as a sample article.

Published online: 29 June 2017
https://doi.org/10.1075/gest.16.1.01deb
References
Bateson, Gregory
(1968) Redundancy and coding. In Thomas A. Sebeok (Ed.), Animal communication (pp. 614–626). Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Baude, Olivier
(Ed.) (2006) Corpus oraux: Guide des bonnes pratiques. Paris & Orléans: Editions du CNRS & Presses Universitaires d’Orléans.Google Scholar
Benus, Stefan, Agustín Gravano, & Julia Hirschberg
(2007) Prosody, emotions and … ‘whatever’. International Proceedings of INTERSPEECH 2007, Antwerp, Belgium.Google Scholar
Boutet, Dominique
(2008) Une morphologie de la gestualité: structuration articulaire. Cahiers de Linguistique Analogique, 51, 81–115.Google Scholar
(2010) Structuration physiologique de la gestuelle: modèle et tests. LIDIL, 421, 77–96. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Bressem, Jana & Cornelia Müller
(2014a) A repertoire of German recurrent gestures with pragmatic functions. In Cornelia Müller, Alan Cienki, Ellen Fricke, Silva Ladewig, David McNeill, & Sedinha Teβendorf (Eds.), Body – language – communication, Vol. 21 (pp. 1575–1591). Berlin & Boston: Walter de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Brookes, Heather J.
(2001)  O clever ‘He’s streetwise’. When gestures become quotable: The case of the clever gesture. Gesture, 11, 167–184. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Calbris, Geneviève
(2003) From cutting an object to a clear-cut analysis: Gesture as the representation of a preconceptual schema linking concrete actions to abstract notions. Gesture, 3 (1), 19–46. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Clark, Herbert
(1996) Using language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Darwin, Charles
(1872) The expression of emotions in man and animals. Accessed online in August 2015 at: http://​www​.gutenberg​.org​/files​/1227​/1227​-h​/1227​-h​.htm doi:  Crossref
De Fornel, Michel
(1992) The return gesture: Some remarks on context, inference and iconic gesture. In Peter Auer & Aldo di Luzio (Eds.), The contextualization of language (pp. 159–176). Amsterdam: John Benjamins. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Debras, Camille
(2013) L’expression multimodale du positionnement interactionnel (Multimodal Stance-taking). Unpublished thesis manuscript, Sorbonne Nouvelle, Paris.Google Scholar
Debras, Camille & Alan Cienki
(2012) Some uses of head tilts and shoulder shrugs during human interaction, and their relation to stancetaking. International proceedings of the ASE 2012 International Conference of Social Computing. Amsterdam, Netherlands 3–5 September 2012. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Debras, Camille & Pauline Beaupoil-Houdel
in press). Developing communicative postures: the emergence of shrugging in child communication. LIA.
De Jorio, Andrea
(2000) Gesture in Naples and gesture in classical antiquity. A translation of La mimica degli antichi investigata nel gestire napoletano (1832), and with an introduction and notes, by Adam Kendon. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
Du Bois, John W.
(2007) The stance triangle. In Robert Englebretson (Ed.), Stancetaking in discourse: Subjectivity, evaluation, interaction (pp. 139–182). Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Efron, David
(1972 [1941]) Gesture, race and culture. Preface by Paul Ekman. The Hague: Mouton.Google Scholar
Ekman, Paul & Wallace V. Friesen
(1969) The repertoire of nonverbal behaviour: Categories, origin, usage, and coding. Semiotica, 11, 49–98. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(1972) Hand movements. Journal of Communication, 221, 353–374. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(1974) Nonverbal behaviour and psychopathology. In Raymond J. Friedman & Martin M. Katz (Eds.), The psychology of depression: Contemporary theory and research (pp. 203–232). Washinton, DC: J. Winston.Google Scholar
Ekman, Paul, Wallace V. Friesen, and Klaus Scherer
(1976) Body movement and voice pitch in deceptive interaction. Semiotica, 16 (1), 23–27. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Elfenbein, Hillary A. & Nalini Ambady
(2002) On the universality and cultural specificity of emotion recognition: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 1281, 203–235. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Fuchs, Yann
(2013) Les quotatifs en interaction en anglais contemporain. Paris: Presses de la Sorbonne Nouvelle.Google Scholar
Givens, David
(1977) Shoulder shrugging: a densely communicative behavior. Semiotica, 19 (1/2), 13–29.Google Scholar
Glynn, Dylan
(2014) Correspondence analysis: Exploring data and identifying patterns. In Dylan Glynn & Justyina Robinson (Eds.), Corpus methods for semantics: Quantitative studies in polysemy and synonymy (pp. 443–485). Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Goodwin, Charles
(2000) Action and embodiment within situated human interaction. Journal of Pragmatics, 321, 1489–1522. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(2007) Participation, stance and affect in the organization of activities. Discourse and Society, 18 (1), 53–73. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Graziano, Maria, Adam Kendon, & Carla Cristilli
(2011) ‘Parallel gesturing’ in adult-child conversations. In Gale Stam & Mika Ishino (Eds.), Integrating gestures: The interdisciplinary nature of gesture (pp. 89–101). Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Gumperz, John J.
(1982) Discourse strategies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Holler, Judith
(2010) Speakers’ use of interactive gestures as markers of common ground. In Stefan Kopp & Ipke Wachsmuth (Eds.), Revised selected papers from the 8th International Gesture Workshop, GW 2009, 59341, 11–22.Google Scholar
Kärkkäinen, Elise
(2012) I thought it was very interesting. Conversational formats for taking a stance, Journal of Pragmatics, 441, 2194–2210.Google Scholar
Kendon, Adam
(1981) Geography of gesture. Semiotica, 371, 129–163.Google Scholar
(2002) Some uses of the head shake. Gesture, 2 (2), 147–182. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(2004) Gesture: Visible action as utterance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(2008) Some reflections on the relationship between ‘gesture’ and ‘sign’. Gesture, 8 (3), 348–366. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kimbara, Irene
(2006) On gestural mimicry. Gesture, 61, 39–61. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Ladewig, Silva H.
(2011) Putting the cycling gesture on a cognitive basis. CogniTextes, 61. http://​cognitextes​.revues​.org​/406
Ladewig Silva H.
(2014a) Recurrent gestures. In Cornelia Müller, Alan Cienki, Ellen Fricke, Silva Ladewig, David McNeill, & Sedinha Teβendorf (Eds.), Body – language – communication, Vol. 21 (pp. 1558–1574). Berlin & Boston: Walter de Gruyter.Google Scholar
(2014b) Creating multimodal utterances: The linear integration of gesture into speech. In Cornelia Müller, Alan Cienki, Ellen Fricke, Silva Ladewig, David McNeill, & Sedinha Teβendorf (Eds.), Body – language – communication, Vol. 21 (pp. 1662–1677).Google Scholar
Lapaire, Jean-Rémi
(2011) Grammar, gesture and cognition: Insights from multimodal utterances and applications for gesture analysis. Вісник Львівського університету. Серія філологічна, 521, 87–107.Google Scholar
Lê, Sébastien, Julie Josse, & François Husson
(2008) FactoMineR: An R Package for Multivariate Analysis. Journal of Statistical Software, 25 (1), 1–18. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
LeBaron, Curtis & Jürgen Streeck
(2000) Gesture, knowledge and the world. In David McNeill (Ed.), Language and gesture (pp. 118–138). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Marzano, Michela
(2008) L’éthique appliquée: De la théorie à la pratique, Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.Google Scholar
McNeill, David
(1992) Hand and mind. What gestures reveal about thought. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
(2005) Gesture and thought. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Mondada, Lorenza
(2006a) Participants’ online analysis and multi-modal practices: projecting the end of the turn and the closing of the sequence. Discourse Studies, 8 (1), 117–129. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(2006b) Video recording as the preservation of fundamental features for analysis. In Hubert Knoblauch, Jürgen Raab, Hans-Georg Soeffner, & Bert. Schnettler (Eds.), Video analysis: Methodology and methods (pp. 51–68). Bern: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
(2011) Understanding as an embodied, situated and sequential achievement in interaction. Journal of Pragmatics, 431, 542–552. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Morgenstern, Aliyah
(2014) Children’s multimodal language development. In Christiane Fäcke (Ed.), Manual of language acquisition (pp. 123–142). Berlin & Boston: De Gruyter. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Morgenstern, Aliyah, Pauline Beaupoil-Hourdel, Dominique Boutet, & Marion Blondel
(2016) A multimodal approach to the development of negation in signed and spoken languages: Four case studies. In Lourdes Ortega, Andrea Tyler, Hae In Park, & Mariko Uno (pp. 15–36), The usage-based study of language learning and multilingualism. Georgetown: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
Morris, Desmond
(1994) Bodytalk: A worldguide to gesture. London: Jonathan Cape.Google Scholar
Morris, Desmond, Peter Collett, Peter Marsh, & Marie O’Shaughnessy
(1979) Gestures: Their origins and distribution. London: Jonathan Cape.Google Scholar
Müller, Cornelia
(2004) Forms and uses of the Palm Up Open Hand: A case of a gesture family? In Cornelia Müller & Roland Posner (Eds.), The semantics and pragmatics of everyday gestures, Proceedings of the Berlin conference, April 1998 (pp. 233–256). Berlin: Weidler Buchverlag.Google Scholar
(2008) Metaphors dead and alive, sleeping and waking: A dynamic view. Chicago & London: University of Chicago Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(2010) Wie Gesten bedeuten. Eine Kogniti-linguistische und sequenzanalytische Perspektive. Sprache und Literatur, 41 (1), 37–68. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Müller, Cornelia, Silva H. Ladewig, & Jana Bressem
(2013a) Gesture and speech from a linguistic perspective: A new field and its history. In Cornelia Müller, Alan Cienki, Ellen Fricke, Silva Ladewig, David McNeill, & Sedinha Teβendorf (Eds.), Body – language – communication, Vol. 11 (pp. 55–81). Berlin & Boston: Walter de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Müller, Cornelia, Jana Bressem, & Silva H. Ladewig
(2013b) Towards a grammar of gestures: A form-based view. In Cornelia Müller, Alan Cienki, Ellen Fricke, Silva Ladewig, David McNeill, & Sedinha Teβendorf (Eds.), Body – language – communication, Vol. 11 (pp. 707–733). Berlin & Boston: Walter de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Palmer, Frank Robert
(2001) Mood and modality (Second edition). Cambridge & New York: Cambridge University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Pascual, Esther
(2014) Fictive interaction. The conversation frame in thought, language and discourse. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins.Google Scholar
Payrató, Lluís
(1993) A pragmatic view on autonomous gestures: a first repertoire of Catalan emblems. Journal of Pragmatics, 201, 193–216. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Poggi, Isabella
(2002) Symbolic gestures. The case of the Italian gestionary. Gesture, 2 (1), 71–98. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Pomerantz, Anita
(1984) Agreeing and disagreeing with assessments: some features of preferred/dispreferred turn shapes. In J. Maxwell Atkinson & John Heritage (Eds.), Structures of social action: Studies in conversation analysis (pp. 57–101). Cambridge & Paris: Cambridge University Press & Éditions de la Maison des Sciences de l’Homme.Google Scholar
Poyatos, Fernando
(1981) Gesture inventories: Fieldwork methodology and problems. In Adam Kendon (Ed.), Nonverbal communication, interaction, and gesture. Selections from Semiotica (pp. 371–400). The Hague: Mouton. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Priesters Matthias A. & Irene Mittelberg
(2013) On the spherical nature of gesture spaces: Insights from visualized kinetic action. Oral presentation, Mapping Multimodal Dialogue (MaMuD) Workshop, RWTH Aachen, Germany.Google Scholar
Ruusuvuori, Johanna & Anssi Peräkylä
(2009) Facial and verbal expressions in assessing stories and topics. Research on Language and Social Interaction, 42 (4), 377–394. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Sacks, Harvey, Emanuel Schegloff, & Gail Jefferson
(1974) A simplest systematics for the organization of turn-taking for conversation. Language, 50 (4, 1), 696–735. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Schegloff, Emanuel
(1984) On some gestures’ relation to talk. In J Maxwell Atkinson & John Heritage (Eds.), Structures of social action: Studies in conversation analysis (pp. 266–296). Cambridge & Paris: Cambridge University Press & Éditions de la Maison des Sciences de l’Homme.Google Scholar
Schiffrin, Deborah
(1987) Discourse markers. Cambridge & New York: Cambridge University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Simon-Vandenbergen, Anne-Marie, & Karin Aijmer
(2007) The semantic field of modal certainty: A corpus-based study of English adverbs. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Stivers, Tanya
(2008) Stance, alignment, and affiliation during storytelling: When nodding is a token of affiliation. Research on Language and Social Interaction, 41 (1), 31–57. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Streeck, Jürgen
(1994) ‘Speech-handling’: The metaphorical representation of speech in gestures. A cross-cultural study. Unpublished manuscript, Austin, TX.Google Scholar
(2009) Gesturecraft: The manu-facture of meaning, Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Tannen, Deborah
(1986) Introducing constructed dialogue in Greek and American conversational and literary narratives. In Florian Coulmas (Ed.), Direct and indirect speech (pp. 311–322). Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Teβendorf, Sedinha
(2013) Emblems, quotable gestures, or conventionalized body movements. In Cornelia Müller, Alan Cienki, Ellen Fricke, Silva Ladewig, David McNeill, & Sedinha Teβendorf (Eds.), Body – language – communication, Vol. 11 (pp. 82–100). Berlin & Boston: Walter de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Tsui, Amy
(1991) The pragmatic functions of I don’t know . Text and Talk, 11 (4), 607–622.Google Scholar
Weatherall, Ann
(2011)  I don’t know as a prepositioned epistemic hedge. Research on Language and Social Interaction, 44 (4), 317–337. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Wittenburg, Peter, Hennie Brugman, Albert Russel, A. Klassmann, & Han Sloetjes
(2006) ELAN: A professional framework for multimodality research. In Proceedings of LREC 2006, Fifth International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation. http://​www​.lat​-mpi​.eu​/tools​/elan​/download

Full-text

The shrug
Cited by

Cited by 19 other publications

No author info given
2021.  In Multimodal Performance and Interaction in Focus Groups [Discourse Approaches to Politics, Society and Culture, 90], Crossref logo
Allison, Meredith, Jennifer Gerwing & Cecily B. Gadaire
2022. When the eyewitness to a crime is an English language learner: Identifying and resolving troubles in understanding in interviews. Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling Crossref logo
Boutet, Dominique, Marion Blondel, Pauline Beaupoil-Hourdel & Aliyah Morgenstern
2021. A multimodal and kinesiological approach to the development of negation in signing and non-signing children. Languages and Modalities 1 ► pp. 31 ff. Crossref logo
Boutet, Dominique & Aliyah Morgenstern
2020. Prélude et Ode à l’approche kinésiologique de la gestualité. TIPA. Travaux interdisciplinaires sur la parole et le langage :36 Crossref logo
Bye, Patrik
2020. Expressive Sibilant Retraction in North Norwegian: morpheme or ‘spoken gesture’?. Glossa: a journal of general linguistics 5:1 Crossref logo
Cooperrider, Kensy, Natasha Abner & Susan Goldin-Meadow
2018. The Palm-Up Puzzle: Meanings and Origins of a Widespread Form in Gesture and Sign. Frontiers in Communication 3 Crossref logo
Debras, Camille
2021. How to prepare the video component of the Diachronic Corpus of Political Speeches for multimodal analysis. Research in Corpus Linguistics 9:1 ► pp. 132 ff. Crossref logo
Debras, Camille
2021. Multimodal profiles of je (ne) sais pas in spoken French. Journal of Pragmatics 182 ► pp. 42 ff. Crossref logo
Engberg-Pedersen, Elisabeth
2021. Markers of epistemic modality and their origins. Studies in Language 45:2 ► pp. 277 ff. Crossref logo
Gawne, Lauren
2018. Contexts of use of a rotated palms gesture among Syuba (Kagate) speakers in Nepal. Gesture 17:1 ► pp. 37 ff. Crossref logo
Hinnell, Jennifer
2018. The multimodal marking of aspect: The case of five periphrastic auxiliary constructions in North American English. Cognitive Linguistics 29:4 ► pp. 773 ff. Crossref logo
Marrese, Olivia H., Chase Wesley Raymond, Barbara A. Fox, Cecilia E. Ford & Megan Pielke
2021. The Grammar of Obviousness: The Palm-Up Gesture in Argument Sequences. Frontiers in Communication 6 Crossref logo
Morgenstern, Aliyah, Stéphanie Caët, Camille Debras, Pauline Beaupoil-Hourdel & Marine Le Mené
2021.  In Language and Social Interaction at Home and School [Dialogue Studies, 32], ► pp. 45 ff. Crossref logo
Morgenstern, Aliyah, Lea Chevrefils, Marion Blondel, Coralie Vincent, Chloé Thomas, Jean-François Jego & Dominique Boutet
2021. “Of thee I sing”: An opening to Dominique Boutet’s kinesiological approach to gesture. Languages and Modalities 1 ► pp. 3 ff. Crossref logo
Pehkonen, Samu
2021. Coaches’ Self-Initiated Complaints About Referees in Ice Hockey Postgame Press Conferences. Communication & Sport 9:4 ► pp. 670 ff. Crossref logo
Rekittke, Linn-Marlen
2017. Viewpoint and stance in gesture: How a potential taboo topic may influence gestural viewpoint in recounting films. Journal of Pragmatics 122 ► pp. 50 ff. Crossref logo
Siyavoshi, Sara
2019. Hands and faces: The expression of modality in ZEI, Iranian Sign Language . Cognitive Linguistics 30:4 ► pp. 655 ff. Crossref logo
Siyavoshi, Sara & Sherman Wilcox
2021. Exerting control: the grammatical meaning of facial displays in signed languages. Cognitive Linguistics 32:4 ► pp. 609 ff. Crossref logo
Walton, Chris, Charles Antaki & W. M. L. Finlay
2020.  In Atypical Interaction, ► pp. 93 ff. Crossref logo

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 09 april 2022. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.