Article published In:
GestureVol. 7:1 (2007) ► pp.97–118
Formulating the Triangle of Doom
Considerable attention has been paid in the CA literature to the glossing practices through which participants in conversation formulate who they are, what they are talking about, where the things they are talking about are located, and so forth. There are, of course, gestural glossing practices as well. For any concept or category presented gesturally, however, there is a range of possibilities from which a particular formulation may be adopted on any actual occasion of use. Identifying alternative formulations serves as a useful analytic exercise for exploring the pragmatic consequences of a produced gesture. In our own research, we have been studying the practices through which surgeons provide instruction while performing surgeries in a teaching hospital. We describe here a particular anatomy lesson produced during a surgery. The attending surgeon uses his hands and arms to gesturally construct a representation of a specific anatomic region (“the Triangle of Doom”) for the benefit of two medical students viewing and participating in the surgery. Employing the structure of Schegloff’s analysis of place formulations, we conduct an analysis of the attending’s gestural formulation. We will show how analyzing a particular gesture in this way illuminates both the intricate ways in which the gesture is tied to its context of production and the exquisite specificity of the gesture itself.
Keywords: glossing practices, Conversation Analysis, ethnomethodology
Cited by
Cited by 69 other publications
Alač, Morana
2016. Social robots: Things or agents?. AI & SOCIETY 31:4 ► pp. 519 ff. 
Alač, Morana
2020. Beyond intersubjectivity in olfactory psychophysics I: Troubles with the Subject. Social Studies of Science 50:3 ► pp. 440 ff.
Alač, Morana, Javier Movellan & Fumihide Tanaka
2011. When a robot is social: Spatial arrangements and multimodal semiotic engagement in the practice of social robotics. Social Studies of Science 41:6 ► pp. 893 ff.
Arminen, Ilkka & Petra Auvinen
2013. Environmentally coupled repairs and remedies in the airline cockpit: Repair practices of talk and action in interaction. Discourse Studies 15:1 ► pp. 19 ff.
Arnold, Lynnette
2012. Dialogic Embodied Action: Using Gesture to Organize Sequence and Participation in Instructional Interaction. Research on Language & Social Interaction 45:3 ► pp. 269 ff.
Bolden, Galina B.
2010. ‘Articulating the unsaid’ via and-prefaced formulations of others’ talk. Discourse Studies 12:1 ► pp. 5 ff.
Cope, Alexandra C, Jeff Bezemer, Roger Kneebone & Lorelei Lingard
2015. ‘You see?’ Teaching and learning how to interpret visual cues during surgery. Medical Education 49:11 ► pp. 1103 ff.
de Carvalho, Aparecido Fabiano Pinatti, Sven Hoffmann, Darwin Abele, Marcus Schweitzer, Peter Tolmie, David Randall & Volker Wulf
2018. Of Embodied Action and Sensors: Knowledge and Expertise Sharing in Industrial Set-Up. Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW) 27:3-6 ► pp. 875 ff.
Egbert, Maria, Mamiko Yufu & Fumiya Hirataka
2016. An investigation of how 100 articles in the Journal of Pragmatics treat transcripts of English and non-English languages. Journal of Pragmatics 94 ► pp. 98 ff.
Elsey, Christopher, Lynn Monrouxe & Andrew Grant
2014. Chapter 3. The reciprocal nature of trust in bedside teaching encounters. In Trust and Discourse [Discourse Approaches to Politics, Society and Culture, 56], ► pp. 45 ff.
Filliettaz, Laurent
2021. The Epistemic Use of the Body in Medical Radiology: Insights from Interactional Video-Ethnography. In Organizational Video-Ethnography Revisited, ► pp. 37 ff.
Filliettaz, Laurent & Patricia Lambert
2019. La formation professionnelle, un point aveugle de la linguistique sociale ?. Langage et société N° 168:3 ► pp. 15 ff.
Fincher, Sally, Johan Jeuring, Craig S. Miller, Peter Donaldson, Benedict du Boulay, Matthias Hauswirth, Arto Hellas, Felienne Hermans, Colleen Lewis, Andreas Mühling, Janice L. Pearce & Andrew Petersen
2020. Proceedings of the Working Group Reports on Innovation and Technology in Computer Science Education, ► pp. 21 ff.
Gegenfurtner, Andreas, Erno Lehtinen, Laura Helle, Markus Nivala, Erkki Svedström & Roger Säljö
2019. Learning to see like an expert: On the practices of professional vision and visual expertise. International Journal of Educational Research 98 ► pp. 280 ff.
Green, Courtney A., Simon N. Chu, Emily Huang, Hueylan Chern & Patricia O'Sullivan
2020. Teaching in the robotic environment: Use of alternative approaches to guide operative instruction. The American Journal of Surgery 219:1 ► pp. 191 ff.
Haavik, Torgeir K.
2016. Keep your coats on: augmented reality and sensework in surgery and surgical telemedicine. Cognition, Technology & Work 18:1 ► pp. 175 ff.
Ivarsson, Jonas & Mikaela Åberg
2020. Role of requests and communication breakdowns in the coordination of teamwork: a video-based observational study of hybrid operating rooms. BMJ Open 10:5 ► pp. e035194 ff.
Izumi, Hiroaki
2017. A technical analysis of scaling in rehabilitation team talk. Journal of Pragmatics 121 ► pp. 1 ff.
Izumi, Hiroaki
2019. Use of the functional independence measure in Japanese rehabilitation team interaction. Discourse Studies 21:6 ► pp. 660 ff.
Kneebone, Roger & Heather Fry
2011. The Environment of Surgical Training and Education. In Surgical Education [Advances in Medical Education, 2], ► pp. 3 ff.
Kneebone, Roger L.
2016. Performing Surgery: Commonalities with Performers Outside Medicine. Frontiers in Psychology 7
Koschmann, Timothy
2017. Why would the discovery of gestures produced by signers jeopardize the experimental finding of gesture-speech mismatch?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 40
Koschmann, Timothy, Curtis LeBaron, Charles Goodwin & Paul Feltovich
2011. “Can you see the cystic artery yet?” A simple matter of trust. Journal of Pragmatics 43:2 ► pp. 521 ff.
Kääntä, Leila & Arja Piirainen-Marsh
2013. Manual Guiding in Peer Group Interaction: A Resource for Organizing a Practical Classroom Task. Research on Language & Social Interaction 46:4 ► pp. 322 ff.
Leudar, Ivan, Wes Sharrock, Jacqueline Hayes & Shirley Truckle
2008. Psychotherapy as a “structured immediacy”. Journal of Pragmatics 40:5 ► pp. 863 ff.
Lindwall, Oskar
2014. The body in medical work and medical training: An introduction. Discourse Studies 16:2 ► pp. 125 ff.
Lindwall, Oskar & Gustav Lymer
2008. The Dark Matter of Lab Work: Illuminating the Negotiation of Disciplined Perception in Mechanics. Journal of the Learning Sciences 17:2 ► pp. 180 ff.
Liu, Yu & Paul Craig
2018. Toward a View Coordination Methodology for Collaborative Shared Large-Display Environments. In Cooperative Design, Visualization, and Engineering [Lecture Notes in Computer Science, 11151], ► pp. 291 ff.
Lopriore, Stefanie, Amanda LeCouteur, Katie Ekberg & Stuart Ekberg
2019. “You'll have to be my eyes and ears”: A conversation analytic study of physical examination on a health helpline. Journal of Clinical Nursing 28:1-2 ► pp. 330 ff.
Luff, Paul & Christian Heath
2012. Some ‘technical challenges’ of video analysis: social actions, objects, material realities and the problems of perspective. Qualitative Research 12:3 ► pp. 255 ff.
Luff, Paul & Christian Heath
2015. Transcribing Embodied Action. In The Handbook of Discourse Analysis, ► pp. 367 ff.
Majlesi, Ali Reza
2021. The Intersubjective Objectivity of Learnables. In Classroom-based Conversation Analytic Research [Educational Linguistics, 46], ► pp. 41 ff.
Markaki, Vassiliki & Laurent Filliettaz
2017. Shaping Participation in Vocational Training Interactions: The Case of Schisming. In Interactional Competences in Institutional Settings, ► pp. 89 ff.
Melander, Helen
2017. Becoming a “Good Nurse”: Social Norms of Conduct and the Management of Interpersonal Relations. In Interactional Competences in Institutional Settings, ► pp. 171 ff.
Mentis, Helena M., Amine Chellali & Steven Schwaitzberg
2014. Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, ► pp. 2113 ff.
Mentis, Helena M., Yuanyuan Feng, Azin Semsar & Todd A. Ponsky
2020. Proceedings of the 2020 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, ► pp. 1 ff.
Mentis, Helena M., Ahmed Rahim & Pierre Theodore
2016. Proceedings of the 19th ACM Conference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work & Social Computing, ► pp. 744 ff.
Minami, Yasusuke, Hiro Yuki Nisisawa, Mitsuhiro Okada & Rui Sakaida
2023. Two Types of Demonstration Through Guided Touch with Cane: Instruction Sequences in Orientation and Mobility Training for a Person with Visual Impairments. Human Studies 46:4 ► pp. 723 ff.
Mondada, Lorenza
2009. Video Recording Practices and the Reflexive Constitution of the Interactional Order: Some Systematic Uses of the Split-Screen Technique. Human Studies 32:1 ► pp. 67 ff.
Mondada, Lorenza
Mondada, Lorenza
2014. Instructions in the operating room: How the surgeon directs their assistant’s hands. Discourse Studies 16:2 ► pp. 131 ff.
Mondada, Lorenza
2014. Requesting immediate action in the surgical operating room. In Requesting in Social Interaction [Studies in Language and Social Interaction, 26], ► pp. 269 ff.
Möller, Hans, Johan Creutzfeldt, Karin Valeskog, Hans Rystedt, Samuel Edelbring, Madelen Fahlstedt, Li Felländer-Tsai & Madeleine Abrandt Dahlgren
2022. Technology-Enhanced Learning of Human Trauma Biomechanics in an Interprofessional Student Context. Teaching and Learning in Medicine 34:2 ► pp. 135 ff.
Nevile, Maurice
2009. “You Are Well Clear of Friendlies”: Diagnostic Error and Cooperative Work in an Iraq War Friendly Fire Incident. Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW) 18:2-3 ► pp. 147 ff.
Nevile, Maurice
2015. The Embodied Turn in Research on Language and Social Interaction. Research on Language and Social Interaction 48:2 ► pp. 121 ff.
Nevile, Maurice, Pentti Haddington, Trine Heinemann & Mirka Rauniomaa
Nguyen, Hanh thi
2019. Turn Design as Longitudinal Achievement: Learning on the Shop Floor. In Conversation Analytic Research on Learning-in-Action [Educational Linguistics, 38], ► pp. 77 ff.
Nguyen, Hanh thi & Minh Thi Thuy Nguyen
2022. Talking language ideologies into being in parent-child conversations in Singapore. Language & Communication 87 ► pp. 244 ff.
Nielsen, Mie Femø, Søren Beck Nielsen, Gitte Gravengaard & Brian Due
2012. Interactional functions of invoking procedure in institutional settings. Journal of Pragmatics 44:11 ► pp. 1457 ff.
Parry, Ruth H & Victoria Land
2013. Systematically reviewing and synthesizing evidence from conversation analytic and related discursive research to inform healthcare communication practice and policy: an illustrated guide. BMC Medical Research Methodology 13:1
Pelikan, Hannah R. M., Amy Cheatle, Malte F. Jung & Steven J. Jackson
2018. Operating at a Distance - How a Teleoperated Surgical Robot Reconfigures Teamwork in the Operating Room. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 2:CSCW ► pp. 1 ff.
Perry, Mark, Mathias Broth, Arvid Engström & Oskar Juhlin
2019. Visual Narrative and Temporal Relevance: Segueing Instant Replay into Live Broadcast TV. Symbolic Interaction 42:1 ► pp. 98 ff.
Pichonnaz, David, Camille Bécherraz, Isabelle Knutti, Liliana Staffoni & Veronika Schoeb
2017. Filmer les soins. Données vidéo et recherche qualitative. Recherches qualitatives 36:2 ► pp. 63 ff.
Pilnick, Alison, Jon Hindmarsh & Virginia Teas Gill
2009. Beyond ‘doctor and patient’: developments in the study of healthcare interactions. Sociology of Health & Illness 31:6 ► pp. 787 ff.
Pilnick, Alison, Jon Hindmarsh & Virginia Teas Gill
2010. Beyond ‘Doctor and Patient’: Developments in the Study of Healthcare Interactions. In Communication in Healthcare Settings, ► pp. 1 ff.
Pinatti de Carvalho, Aparecido Fabiano, Sarah Reichel, Marcel Manuel Sanchez Martin, Eva Sonja Allen & Marcus Schweitzer
2023. Group Effect Aspects in Digitalisation Production Contexts. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 7:GROUP ► pp. 1 ff.
Rae, John P. & Monica Ramey
2020. Correction and repair: a comparative analysis of a boy with ASD interacting with a parent and with an ABA trainer. Clinical Linguistics & Phonetics 34:10-11 ► pp. 1018 ff.
Randell, Rebecca, Stephanie Honey, Jon Hindmarsh, Natasha Alvarado, Joanne Greenhalgh, Alan Pearman, Andrew Long, Alexandra Cope, Arron Gill, Peter Gardner, Alwyn Kotze, David Wilkinson, David Jayne, Julie Croft & Dawn Dowding
2017. A realist process evaluation of robot-assisted surgery: integration into routine practice and impacts on communication, collaboration and decision-making. Health Services and Delivery Research 5:20 ► pp. 1 ff.
Roberts, Nicole K., Michael J. Brenner, Reed G. Williams, Michael J. Kim & Gary L. Dunnington
2012. Capturing the teachable moment: A grounded theory study of verbal teaching interactions in the operating room. Surgery 151:5 ► pp. 643 ff.
Rystedt, Hans, Jonas Ivarsson, Sara Asplund, Åse Allansdotter Johnsson & Magnus Båth
2011. Rediscovering radiology: New technologies and remedial action at the worksite. Social Studies of Science 41:6 ► pp. 867 ff.
Stokoe, Elizabeth
2009. “For the benefit of the tape”: Formulating embodied conduct in designedly uni-modal recorded police–suspect interrogations. Journal of Pragmatics 41:10 ► pp. 1887 ff.
Streeck, Jürgen
2015. Embodiment in Human Communication. Annual Review of Anthropology 44:1 ► pp. 419 ff.
Sutkin, Gary, Eliza B. Littleton & Steven L. Kanter
2015. How Surgical Mentors Teach: A Classification of In Vivo Teaching Behaviors Part 1: Verbal Teaching Guidance. Journal of Surgical Education 72:2 ► pp. 243 ff.
Svensson, Marcus Sanchez, Christian Heath & Paul Luff
2010. Embedding Instruction in Practice: Contingency and Collaboration during Surgical Training. In Communication in Healthcare Settings, ► pp. 99 ff.
Svensson, Marcus Sanchez, Paul Luff & Christian Heath
2009. Embedding instruction in practice: contingency and collaboration during surgical training. Sociology of Health & Illness 31:6 ► pp. 889 ff.
van Baalen, Sophie, Annamaria Carusi, Ian Sabroe & David G. Kiely
2017. A social‐technological epistemology of clinical decision‐making as mediated by imaging. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 23:5 ► pp. 949 ff.
Wilce, James M.
2009. Medical Discourse. Annual Review of Anthropology 38:1 ► pp. 199 ff.
Yohannan, Doris George, Aswathy Maria Oommen, Amogh Bhaskaran Jayaprasad, Nithin Kadakampallil Raju, Rakesh Omana Suresh & Santhanu Jagannath Nair
2022. “Air Anatomy” – Teaching Complex Spatial Anatomy Using Simple Hand Gestures. Anatomical Sciences Education 15:3 ► pp. 552 ff.
[no author supplied]
2012. References. In The Handbook of Conversation Analysis, ► pp. 741 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 30 march 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.