Early Scholastic Views on Ambiguity
Composition and Division
This article presents a linguistic study of a number of 12th-century logical tracts with respect to their views on fallacies of composition and division. It will be seen that early Scholastic work done in this area was greatly influenced by certain syntactic properties of Latin.
The correlation between meaning and syntactic order came to preoccupy logicians upon the rediscovery and subsequent translation of Aristotle’s De Sophisticis Elenchis at the beginning of the 12th century. Some logicians of the period felt that a composite syntactic order correlated obligatorily with a composite sense; others thought that order and sense could be independent from each other, and that, consequently, a composite syntactic order could have two readings, a composite one and a divided one. A third opinion expressed was that certain syntactic orders received two interpretations, one considered to be normal (a composite order correlating preferentially with a composite sense), and another one regarded as secondary (the possibility for a composite order to be understood in a divided sense as well).
The ideas which found expression in the 12th century manuscripts discussed in this study influenced logical speculation throughout the Scholastic period.
References
Bocheński, Innocentius M(aria)
1961,
A History of Formal Logic. Transl. and ed. by
Ivo Thomas. Notre Dame, Ind.: Univ. of Notre Dame Press.
Bursill-Hall, G(eoffrey) L(eslie)
1971 Speculative Grammars of the Middle Ages: The doctrine of partes orationis of the Modistae, The Hague: Mouton.
Carnap, Rudolf
(1891–1970). 1947 Meaning and Necessity: A study in semantics and modal logic. Chicago, Ill.: Univ. of Chicago Press.
Cohen, Morris R(aphael), and Ernest Nagel
1934 An Introduction to Logic and Scientific Method. New York: Harcourt, Brace & Co.
Copi, Irving M.
1953 Introduction to Logic. New York: Macmillan.
Frege, (Friedrich Ludwig) Gottlob
(1848–1925). 1970 [1892] “
On Sense and Reference” [Ueber Sinn und Bedeutung].
Translations from the Philosophical Writings of Gottlob Frege ed. by
Peter Geach and
Max Black, 56–78. Oxford: B. Blackwell.
Hamblin, Charles L.
1970 Fallacies. London: Methuen.
Hintikka, Jaakko
1969 “
Semantics for Proportional Attitudes”.
Philosophical Logic ed. by
J. W. Davis,
et al., 21–45. Dordrecht: D. Reidel.
Kneale, William, and Martha Kneale
1962 The Development of Logic. Oxford: Clarendon Press. (Repr. 1968)
Lakoff, George, and Stanley Peters
1966 “
Phrasal Conjunction and Symmetric Predicates”.
Report No. NSF-17 to the National Science Foundation VI1. 1–49. Cambridge, Mass.: Computational Laboratory, Harvard Univ.
McCawley, James D.
1971 “
Where Do Noun Phrases Come from?”.
Semantics: An interdisciplinary reader in philosophy, linguistics and psychology ed. by
Danny D(avid) Steinberg and
Leon A. Jakobovits, 217–31. London:. Cambridge Univ. Press.
Minio-Paluello, Lorenzo
1952 “
Iacobus Veneticus Graecus – canonist and translator of Aristotle”.
Traditio 81.265–304.
Moody, Ernest A(ddison)
1965 “
Buridan and a Dilemma of Nominalism”.
Harry Austryn Wolfson Jubilee Volume II1, 577–96. Jerusalem: Kraus Reprint.
Newmeyer, Frederick J.
1969 English Aspectual Verbs. (=
Studies in Linguistics and Language Learning 6.) Seattle: Univ. of Washington.
Newmeyer, Frederick J.
1970 “
The ‘Root Modal’: Can it be transitive? ”.
Studies Presented to Robert B. Lees by his Students ed. by
Jerrold M. Sadock and
Anthony L(adislav) Vanek, 189–96. Edmonton, Alberta: Linguistic Research.
O’Donnell, J. Reginald
ed. 1941 “
The Syncategoremata of William of Sherwood”.
Medieval Studies 31.46–93. (For E. version, see William of Sherwood 1968.)
Paul of Pergula [Paulus Pergulensis
(d.1451)]. 1961 Logica and Tractatus de sensu composito et diviso. Ed. by
Sister Mary Anthony Brown. St. Bonaventura N.Y.: Franciscan Institute.
Peter of Spain [
Petrus Hispanus (c.1210–1277)]. 1964 Tractatus syncategor-ematum and Selected Anonymous Treatises. Transl. by
Joseph P(atrick) Mullally. Milwaukee, Wis.: Marquette Univ. Press.
Pinborg, Jan
1967 Die Entwicklung der Sprachtheorie im Mittelalter. (=
Beiträge zur Geschichte der Philosophie und Theologie des Mittelalters, 42:2.) Münster: Aschendorff; Copenhagen: Frost-Hansen.
Pinborg, Jan
1972 Logik und Semantik im Mittelalter. Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt: Fromman-Holzboog.
Quine, W(illard) V(an) O(rman)
1951 Mathematical Logic. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard Univ. Press.
Quine, W(illard) V(an) O(rman)
1953 “
Reference and Modality”.
From a Logical Point of View: 9 logico-philosophical essays by
W. V. O. Quine, 139–59. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard Univ. Press.
Quine, W(illard) V(an) O(rman)
1960 Word and Object. Cambridge, Mass.: M.I.T. Press.
Quine, W(illard) V(an) O(rman)
1966 “
Quantifiers and Prepositional Attitudes”.
The Ways of Paradox and Other Essays by
W. V. O. Quine, 183–94. New York: Random House.
Rijk, L(ambertus) M(arie) de
1962–1967 Logica modernorum: A contribution to the history of early terminist logic. 2 vols, in 3. Assen: Van Gorcum.
Rivero, María-Luisa
1973 “
Antecedents of Contemporary Logical and Linguistic Analyses in Scholastic Logic”.
FL 101.55–64.
Rivero, María-Luisa
1974a “
Modalities and Scope in Scholastic Logic from a Linguistic Point of View”.
AL 15:2.133–52.
Rivero, María-Luisa
1974b “
La ambigüedad de los verbos modales: Una visión histórica”.
To appear.
Robins, R(obert) H(enry)
1951 Ancient and Medieval Grammatical Theory in Europe, with particular reference to modern linguistic doctrine. London: G. Bell & Sons. (Repr., Port Washington, N.Y. & London: Kennikat Press 1971.)
Robins, R(obert) H(enry)
1967 A Short History of Linguistics. London: Longmans. (2nd printing 1970.)
Russell, Bertrand (Arthur William
, 3rd Earl
1872–1970). 1940 An Inquiry into Meaning and Truth. London: Allen & Unwin.
Sosa, Ernest
1970 “
Propositional Attitudes De dicto and De re
”.
Journal of Philosophy 671.883–96.
Thomas Aquinas, Saint
(1225–74). 1940 [
De propositionibus modalibus] “
Sancti Thomae Aquinatis de modalibus opusculum et doctrina”. Ed. by
I. M. Bocheński.
Angelicum 171.180–218.
William of Sherwood [Guilelmus Shirwodus
(fl. 1260)]. 1937 Die Introdutiones in logicam des Wilhelm von Shyreswood. Ed. by
Martin Grabmann (1875–1949) Munich: Bayerische Akad. der Wissenschaften.
William of Sherwood [Guilelmus Shirwodus
(fl. 1260)]. 1966 William of Sherwood’s Introduction to Logic. Transl. by
Norman Kretzmann. Minneapolis, Minn.: Univ. of Minnesota Press.
William of Sherwood [
Guilelmus Shirwodus (fl. 1260)]. 1968 William of Sherwood’s Treatise on Syncategorematic Words. Transl. by
Norman Kretzmann. Minneapolis, Min.: Univ. of Minnesota Press. (See
O’Donnell 1941 for Lat. ed.)
Cited by
Cited by 2 other publications
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 30 march 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.