Cover not available
Article published In:
Historiographia Linguistica
Vol. 37:3 (2010) ► pp.341–377

On “Eskimo Words for Snow”

The life cycle of a linguistic misconception

| Western Institute
| Adam Mickiewicz University

This article examines the complex interdependence of linguistics and the discourses of social sciences and philosophy based on the example of the Eskimo words for snow. In particular, we trace the life cycle of the example through three phases: (1) the origin of the misconception in the studies of Franz Boas (1858–1942) and Benjamin Lee Whorf (1897–1941); (2) its propagation in textbooks and in sympathetic and alternative theoretical contexts, and (3) the contemporary status quo following the exposition of the misconception by Laura Martin (1986), Geoffrey Pullum (1989) and Steven Pinker (1994, 2007). Further, we examine the theoretical and methodological shortcomings of the exposition, and their implications for the poverty of critical and impartial discussion on the nature of linguistic categorization and its cognitive implications, as originally discussed by Boas and Whorf.

Published online: 17 November 2010
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/hl.37.3.03cic
References
Andary, Lena, Yvonne Stolk & Steven Klimidis
2003 Assessing Mental Health across Cultures. Bowen Hills: Australian Academic Press.Google Scholar
Archer, Margaret S.
2000 Being Human: The problem of agency. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Asuncion-Lande, Nobleza C.
1998 “English as the Dominant Language for Intercultural Communication: Prospects for the next century”. Civic Discourse: Multiculturalism, cultural diversity, and global communication ed. by K. S. Sitaram & Michael H. Prosser, vol. I1, 67–81. Stamford, Conn.: Ablex.Google Scholar
Bastian, Adolf
1860 Der Mensch in der Geschichte: Zur Begründung einer psychologischen Weltanschauung. Leipzig: Otto Wigand.Google Scholar
Bertalanffy, Ludwig von
1955 “An Essay on the Relativity of Categories”. Philosophy of Science 22:4.243–263. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Boas, Franz
1894 “Der Eskimo-Dialekt des Cumberland-Sundes”. Mittheilungen der Anthropologischen Gesellschaft in Wien 24:6.97–114.Google Scholar
1911a “Introduction”. Handbook of American Indian Languages ed. by Franz Boas, Vol. I1, 1–83. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution.Google Scholar
1911b The Mind of Primitive Man: A course of lectures delivered before the Lowell Institute, Boston, Mass., and the National University of Mexico, 1910–1911. New York: Macmillan. (2nd rev. ed. 1938.)Google Scholar
1938 “Language”. General Anthropology ed. by Franz Boas, 124–145. Boston: D. C. Heath & Co.Google Scholar
1942 “Language and Culture”. Studies in the History of Culture: The disciplines of the humanities ed. byWaldo Gifford Leland, 178–184. Menasha, Wis.: George Banta.Google Scholar
Brinton, Daniel Garrison
1885 “On Polysynthesis and Incorporation as Characteristics of American Languages”. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 231.48–86. Philadelphia.Google Scholar
Brown, Roger
1958 Words and Things. Glencoe, Ill.: The Free Press.Google Scholar
Brown, Stephen
1995 “Postmodernism, the Wheel of Retailing and Will to Power”. International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer Research 5:3.387–414.Google Scholar
Carroll, John B[issel]
ed. 1956 Language, Thought, and Reality: Selected writings of Benjamin Lee Whorf. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Cavallaro, Dani
2001 Critical and Cultural Theory: Thematic variations. New Brunswick, N.J.: Athlone Press.Google Scholar
Copi, Irving
1954 “Essence and Accident”. The Journal of Philosophy 51:23.706–719. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Dixon, R[obert] M[alcolm] W[ard]
2010 Basic Linguistic Theory. Vol. I1: Methodology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Du Ponceau, Peter Stephen
1838 Mémoire sur le système grammatical des langues de quelques nations indiennes de l’Amérique du Nord. Paris: A. Pihan de la Forest. (Repr. in The Prix Volney ed. by Joan Leopold, vol. II1: Early Nineteenth-Century Contributions to General and Amerindian Linguistics: Du Ponceau and Rafinesque, 131–249. Dordrecht: Kluwer 1999.)Google Scholar
Egede, Hans
1818 A Description of Greenland. London: Printed for T. & J. Allman.Google Scholar
Farrar, Frederic William
1878 Language and Languages: Being “Chapters on Language” and “Families of Speech”. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co.Google Scholar
Federico, Ronald C. & Janet S. Schwartz
1983 Sociology. 3rd ed. Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley.Google Scholar
Feuer, Lewis
1953 “Sociological Aspects of the Relation between Language and Philosophy”. Philosophy of Science 20:2.85–100. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Feyerabend, Paul
1987 Farewell to Reason. London: Verso.Google Scholar
Fortescue, Michael
1984 West Greenlandic. Dover, N.H.: Croom Helm.Google Scholar
Fox, Mark, Peter Martin & Gill Green
2007 Doing Practitioner Research. London: Sage Publications. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Gagné, Raymond
1968 “Spatial Concepts in the Eskimo Language”. Eskimo of the Canadian Arctic ed. by Victor F. Valentine & Frank G. Vallee, 30–38. Toronto: McClelland & Stewart.Google Scholar
Gallatin, Albert
1836 “A Synopsis of the Indian Tribes within the United States East of the Rocky Mountains, and in the British and Russian Possessions in North America”. Archaeologia Americana: Transactions and Collections of the American Antiquarian Society 21.1–422.Google Scholar
1845 “Notes on the Semi-Civilized Nations of Mexico, Yucatan, and Central America”. Transactions of the American Ethnological Society 11.1–352.Google Scholar
1848 “Hale’s Indians of North-West America, and Vocabularies of North America, with an Introduction”. Transactions of the American Ethnological Society 21.xxiii–clxxxviii, 1–130.Google Scholar
Goddard, Angela & Lindsey Meân Patterson
2000 Language and Gender. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Grunlan, Stephen A. & Marvin K. Mayers
1988 Cultural Anthropology: A Christian perspective. 2nd ed. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan Publishing House.Google Scholar
Gummere, John F.
1948 Review of An Introduction to Linguistic Science by Edgar H[oward] Sturtevant (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press 1947) The Classical Journal 441.228–230.Google Scholar
Hall, Edward T.
1959 The Silent Language. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday.Google Scholar
Halpern, Mark
2006 Language and Human Nature. Oakland, Calif.: Regent Press.Google Scholar
Hazen, Nancy & Herbert L. Pick, Jr.
1985 “An Ecological Approach to Development of Spatial Orientation”. Issues in the Ecological Study of Learning ed. by Timothy D. Johnston & Alexandra T. Pietrewicz, 201–244. Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Herskovits, Melville J.
1953 Franz Boas: The science of man in the making. New York: Scribner.Google Scholar
Hodge, Robert & Gunther Kress
1993 Language as Ideology. 2nd ed. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Hunn, Eugene S.
2004 “Knowledge Systems”. A Companion to the Anthropology of American Indians ed. by Thomas Biolsi, 133–153. Oxford: Blackwell. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Jenness, Diamond
1928 Comparative Vocabulary of the Western Eskimo Dialects. Ottawa: Acland.Google Scholar
1977 [1932] Indians of Canada. Ottawa: National Museum of Canada.Google Scholar
Joseph, John E.
2002 “The Sources of the ‘Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis’”. From Whitney to Chomsky. Essays in the history of American linguistics by Joseph, 71–105. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kaplan, Lawrence
2003 “Inuit Snow Terms: How many and what does it mean?”. Building Capacity in Arctic Societies: Dynamics and shifting perspectives. Proceedings from the 2nd IPSSAS Seminar, Iqaluit, Nunavut, Canada: May 26–June 6, 2003 ed. by François Trudel. Montreal: Ciéra, Faculté des sciences sociales, Université Laval ([URL], consulted on 1 August 2010).
Kendall, Diana
2008 Sociology in our Times: The essentials. 7th ed. Belmont: Wadsworth.Google Scholar
Kilarski, Marcin
2009 “Cherokee Classificatory Verbs: Their place in the study of American Indian languages”. Historiographia Linguistica 36:1.39–73. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Koerner, E. F. K[onrad]
2002 “On the Sources of the ‘Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis’”. Toward a History of American Linguistics by Koerner, 38–62. London & New York: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Krupnik, Igor & Ludger Müller-Wille
2010 “Franz Boas and Inuktitut Terminology for Ice and Snow: From the emergence of the field to the “Great Eskimo Vocabulary Hoax””. Krupnik et al. 2010 377–400. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Krupnik, Igor, Claudio Aporta, Shari Gearheard, Gita J. Laidler & Lene Kielsen Holm
eds. 2010 SIKU: Knowing our Ice: Documenting Inuit sea ice knowledge and use. Dordrecht: Springer. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Lucy, John A.
1992 Language Diversity and Thought: A reformulation of the linguistic relativity hypothesis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Macionis, John J. & Ken Plummer
2008 Sociology: A global introduction. 4th ed. Harlow: Pearson Education.Google Scholar
Magala, Sławomir
2005 Cross-Cultural Competence. London: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Mantovani, Giuseppe
2000 Exploring Borders: Understanding culture and psychology. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Martin, Laura
1986 “ ‘Eskimo Words for Snow’: A case study in the genesis and decay of an anthropological example”. American Anthropologist 88:2.418–423. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Matheson, Catherine & David Matheson
2000 “Educational Spaces and Discourses”. Educational Issues in the Learning Age ed. by Catherine Matheson & David Matheson, 1–12. London: Continuum.Google Scholar
Minami, Masahiko
2002 Culture-Specific Language Styles: The development of oral narrative and literacy. Clevedon: Multilingual Matters. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Mithun, Marianne
1999 The Languages of Native North America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Murray, Stephen O.
1987 “Snowing Canonical Texts”. American Anthropologist 89:2.443–444. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Newcomb, Theodore M. & Eugene L. Hartley
eds. 1947 Readings in Social Psychology. New York: Henry Holt & Co.Google Scholar
Newman, David M.
2008 Sociology: Exploring the architecture of everyday life. London: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
Ogden, C[harles] K[ay] & I[Vor] A[Rmstrong] Richards
1923 The Meaning of Meaning: A study of the influence of language upon thought and the science of symbolism. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. [Frequently reprinted.]Google Scholar
Peschel, Oscar
1874 Völkerkunde. Leipzig: Duncker & Humblot.Google Scholar
Pinker, Steven
1994 The Language Instinct: How the mind creates language. New York: Morrow; London: Lane. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2007 Stuff of Thought. London: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
Popper, Karl R.
1996 The Myth of the Framework: In defence of science and rationality. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Pullum, Geoffrey K.
1989 “The Great Eskimo Vocabulary Hoax”. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 71.275–281. (Repr. in The Great Eskimo Vocabulary Hoax and Other Irreverent Essays on the Study of Language by Pullum, 159–171. Chicago: University of Chicago Press 1991.)Google Scholar
Schaff, Adam
1973 Language and Cognition. New York: McGraw-Hill.Google Scholar
Schneider, Lucien
1985 Ulirnaisigutiit: An Inuktitut-English dictionary of Northern Quebec, Labrador, and Eastern Arctic dialects (with an English-Inuktitut index). Sainte-Foy, Québec: Les Presses de l’Université Laval.Google Scholar
Schultz-Lorentzen, C[hristian] W[ilhelm]
1927 Dictionary of the West Greenland Eskimo Language. (= Meddelelser om Grønland, 69.) Copenhagen: C. A. Reitzel.Google Scholar
Shea, John G[ilmary]
1860 “Languages of the American Indians”. The New American Cyclopaedia: A popular dictionary of general knowledge ed. by George Ripley & Charles A. Dana, vol. IX1, 491–498. New York: D. Appleton. [A revised version appeared under the same title in The American Cyclopaedia: A popular dictionary of general knowledge ed. by George Ripley & Charles A. Dana, vol. I1, 407–414. New York: D. Appleton 1873.]Google Scholar
Silverstein, Michael
1991 “Snowing Again”. Lingua Franca 1:3.29.Google Scholar
Spencer, Herbert
1882 [1874] The Principles of Sociology. Vol. I1. 3rd ed. London: Williams & Norgate.Google Scholar
Steckley, John L.
2008 White Lies about the Inuit. Peterborough, Ont.: Broadview Press.Google Scholar
Steinberg, S[heila]
2008 Introduction to Communication. Course book 1: The basics. Cape Town: Juta & Co.Google Scholar
Storey, John
2006 “Introduction”. Cultural Theory and Popular Culture: A reader ed. by John Storey, 273–277. 3rd ed. Harlow: Pearson Education.Google Scholar
Sturm, Matthew
2009a Apun: The Arctic snow. Fairbanks, Aka.: University of Alaska Press. [With a teacher’s guide.]Google Scholar
2009b “Composite List of Iñupiaq Snow Words”. Unpublished paper.Google Scholar
Sztompka, Piotr
2009 “One Sociology or Many?”. The ISA Handbook of Diverse Sociological Traditions ed. by Sujata Patel, 21–28. London: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
Ting-Toomey, Stella
1999 Communicating across Cultures. New York: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
Tuleja, Elizabeth A.
2009 Intercultural Communication for Business. 2nd ed. Mason, Ohio: South-Western Cengage Learning.Google Scholar
Ullmann, Stephen
1966 “Semantic Universals”. Universals of Language ed. by Joseph H. Greenberg, 217–262. 2nd ed. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Whorf, Benjamin Lee
1940 “Science and Linguistics”. The Technology Review 42:6.229–231, 247–248. (Repr. in S[amuel] I[chiyé] Hayakawa [(1906–1992)] as an appendix “Readings” to his book, Language in Action (New York: Harcourt, Brace & Co. 1941), pp. 302–321; Readings in Social Psychology ed. by Theodore M. Newcomb & Eugene L. Hartley, 211–218. New York: Henry Holt & Co. 1947; Collected Papers on Metalinguistics by Benjamin Lee Whorf ed. by George L[eonard] Trager [(1906–1992)], 1–8. Washington, D.C.: Foreign Service Institute, Department of State 1952; Language, Thought, and Reality: Selected writings of Benjamin Lee Whorf ed. by John B. Carroll, 207–219. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press 1956.)Google Scholar
Wierzbicka, Anna
1997 Understanding Cultures through Their Key Words: English, Russian, Polish, German, and Japanese. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Woodbury, Anthony C.
1994 “Counting Eskimo Words for Snow: A citizen’s guide; Lexemes referring to snow and snow-related notions in Steven A. Jacobson’s (1984) Yup’ik Eskimo Dictionary ”. LINGUIST List 5.1239 ([URL], consulted on 1 June 2010).
Cited by

Cited by 8 other publications

Caronia, Letizia
2021. Language, culture and social interaction. In Language and Social Interaction at Home and School [Dialogue Studies, 32], ► pp. 1 ff. DOI logo
Colomina-Almiñana, Juan J.
2022. A defense of a weak linguistic relativist thesis. Language Sciences 94 ► pp. 101512 ff. DOI logo
de Reuse, Willem J.
2020. Primitivism in Hunter and Gatherer Languages. In The Language of Hunter-Gatherers, ► pp. 523 ff. DOI logo
Joseph, John E.
2022. Review of Kilarski (2021): A History of the Study of the Indigenous Languages of North America. Historiographia Linguistica 49:2-3 ► pp. 405 ff. DOI logo
Kilarski, Marcin
2014. The Place of Classifiers in the History of Linguistics. Historiographia Linguistica 41:1 ► pp. 33 ff. DOI logo
Krupnik, Igor
2011. ‘How many Eskimo words for ice?’ Collecting Inuit sea ice terminologies in the International Polar Year 2007–2008. Canadian Geographies / Géographies canadiennes 55:1 ► pp. 56 ff. DOI logo
Schwartz, Saul
2018. The Predicament of Language and Culture: Advocacy, Anthropology, and Dormant Language Communities. Journal of Linguistic Anthropology 28:3 ► pp. 332 ff. DOI logo
[no author supplied]
2021. A History of the Study of the Indigenous Languages of North America [Studies in the History of the Language Sciences, 129], DOI logo

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 30 march 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.