Article published In:
Historiographia LinguisticaVol. 38:3 (2011) ► pp.255–292
The ‘Glaring’ Place of Prepositions
Grammar, Rhetoric and the Scottish Codifiers
This paper offers new insights into the 18th-century normative tradition, with special reference to the stigmatisation of preposition stranding. It brings to light the role of Scottish codifiers in contrast to English codifiers: works written by Scots contain more critical comments on the use of end-placed prepositions both quantitatively (in terms of frequency) and qualitatively (more semantic nuances and more condemnatory epithets). The semantic analysis of the data rules out the hypothesis that Scottish authors might have been particularly sensible towards this construction because of its nature as ‘provincial English’ or as a ‘Scotticism’. Rather, the author suggests that it was the ‘New Rhetoric’ movement (1748–1793) in the context of the Scottish Enlightenment that played a vital role in its stigmatisation. The importance of rhetoric as a facet of 18th-century prescriptivism, complementary to grammar, is thus put under the spotlight.
References
11. The majority of the 18th-century primary sources documented in the databases have been consulted in ECCO.
Aitken, A[dam] J[ames]
1979 “Scottish Speech: A historical view with special reference to the Standard English of Scotland”. Languages of Scotland ed. by A. J. Aitken & Tom McArthur, 85–118. Edinburgh: Chambers.
Allen, Cynthia L.
1980 Topics in Diachronic English Syntax. New York & London: Garland.
Arnovick, Leslie K.
1997 “Proscribed Collocations with shall and will: The Eighteenth-Century (Non-)Standard Reassessed”. Taming the Vernacular: From dialect to written standard language ed. by Jenny Cheshire & Dieter Stein, 135–151. London: Longman.
Bailey, Richard W.
1991 “Scots and Scotticisms: Language and ideology”. Studies in Scottish Literature 261.65–77.
1996 Nineteenth-Century English. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. 
Basker, James G.
1993 “Scotticisms and the Problem of Cultural Identity in Eighteenth-Century Britain”. Sociability and Society in Eighteenth-Century Scotland ed. by John Dwyer & Richard B. Sher, 81–95. Edinburgh: Mercat Press.
Beal, Joan C.
1999 English Pronunciation in the Eighteenth Century: Thomas Spence’s Grand Repository of the English Language (1775). Oxford: Clarendon.
2003 “John Walker: Prescriptivist or linguistic innovator?”. Dossena & Jones, eds. 2003.83–105.
2004a English in Modern Times 1700–1945. London: Arnold.
2004b “ ‘Marks of Disgrace’: Attitudes to Non-Standard Pronunciation in Eighteenth-Century Pronouncing Dictionaries”. Methods and Data in English Historical Dialectology ed. by Marina Dossena & Roger Lass, 329–349. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang.
2010 “Prescriptivism and the Suppression of Variation”. Hickey, ed. 2010.21–37.
Beal, Joan C., Carmela Nocera & Massimo Sturiale
eds. 2008 Perspectives on Prescriptivism. Bern: Peter Lang.
Broadie, Alexander
ed. 2003 The Cambridge Companion to the Scottish Enlightenment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Brown, Ian, Thomas Owen Clancy, Susan Manning & Murray Pittock
eds. 2007 The Edinburgh History of Scottish Literature. Vol. II1: Enlightenment, Britain and Empire (1707–1918). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Carr, Stephen L.
2002 “The Circulation of Blair’s ‘Lectures’”. Rhetoric Society Quarterly 32:4.75–104.
Dossena, Marina
1997 “The Search for Linguistic Excellence in Late Eighteenth-Century Scotland”. Textus 101.355–376.
2003 “Scots”. Germanic Standardizations – Past to Present ed. by Ana Deumart & Wim Vandenbussche, 383–404. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
2005 Scotticisms in Grammar and Vocabulary: ‘Like Runes upon a Standin’ Stane’. Edinburgh: John Donald.
Dossena, Marina & Charles Jones
eds. 2003 Insights into Late Modern English. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang.
ECCO Eighteenth-Century Collections Online. Thomson Gale.
ECEG: Eighteenth-Century English Grammars database 2010 Compiled by María E. Rodríguez-Gil (University of Las Palmas de Gran Canaria) & Nuria Yáñez-Bouza (The University of Manchester). Online access: [URL]
Fens-de Zeeuw, Lyda
Forthcoming. Lindley Murray (1745–1826), Quaker and Grammarian. (=
Utrecht LOT Dissertation Series, 283.) Utrecht.
Ferreira-Buckley, Linda
1994 “Hugh Blair (1718–1800)”. Moran, ed. 1994.21–35.
Fitzmaurice, Susan
ed. 2000 Rhetoric, Language and Literature: New Perspectives on English in the Eighteenth Century (= Special issue of Language Sciences 22:3).
Frank, Thomas
1994 “Language Standardization in Eighteenth-Century Scotland”. Towards a Standard English, 1600–1800 ed. by Dieter Stein & Ingrid Tieken-Boon van Ostade, 51–62. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Görlach, Manfred
1999 English in Nineteenth-Century England: An introduction. Cambridge & New York: Cambridge University Press.
2001 Eighteenth-Century English. Heidelberg: C. Winter.
Gustafsson, Larisa Oldireva
2008 “Phonoaesthetic Assessment of Words in Eighteenth-Century Prescriptions and Later”. Beal et al., eds. 2008.83–112.
Hickey, Raymond
2009 “ ‘Telling People How to Speak’: Rhetorical grammars and pronouncing dictionaries”. Tieken-Boon van Ostade & van der Wurff, eds. 2009.89–116.
ed. 2010 Eighteenth-Century English: Ideology and change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hodson, Jane
2006 “The Problem of Joseph Priestley’s (1733–1804) Descriptivism”. Historiographia Linguistica 33:1/2.57–84.
Hogg, Richard M.
2008 “Standardisation: The North-British View”. German Life and Letters 611.521–532.
Jones, Charles
1995 A Language Suppressed: The pronunciation of Scots in the eighteenth century. Edinburgh: John Donald.
1997 “An Early Eighteenth-Century Scottish Spelling Book for Ladies”. English Studies 78:5.430–450.
2006 English Pronunciation in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
2010 “Nationality and Standardisation in Eighteenth-Century Scotland”. Hickey, ed. 2010.221–234.
Leonard, S[terling] A[ndrus]
1929 The Doctrine of Correctness in English Usage 1700–1800. Madison: University of Wisconsin. (Repr., New York: Russell & Russell 1962.)
Manning, Susan
2000 “Scottish Style and American Romantic Idiom”. Language Sciences 22:3.265–283.
McIntosh, Carey
1998 The Evolution of English Prose 1700–1800: Style, Politeness, and Print Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
2000 “Elementary Rhetorical Ideas and Eighteenth-Century English”. Language Sciences 22:3.231–249.
McKnight, George H.
1930 [1928] Modern English in the Making. New York & London: D. Appleton & Co.
Meurman-Solin, Anneli
2000 “Change from Above or Below? Mapping the loci of linguistic change in the history of Scottish English”. Wright, ed. 2000.155–170.
Michael, Ian
1970 English Grammatical Categories and the Tradition to 1800. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
1987 The Teaching of English from the Sixteenth Century to 1870. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Miller, Jim
2004 “Scottish English: Morphology and syntax”. The British Isles, Vol. II1: Morphology and Syntax ed. by Bernd Kortmann & Clive Upton, 47–72. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Milroy, James & Lesley Milroy
1985 Authority in Language: Investigating language prescription and standardisation. London & New York: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Moran, Michael G.
ed. 1994 Eighteenth-Century British and American Rhetorics and Rhetoricians: Critical studies and sources. New York: Greenwood Press.
Mossner, Ernest C.
1954 The Life of David Hume. Edinburgh: Nelson.
Mugglestone, Lynda
2003 [1995] ‘Talking Proper’: The rise of accent as social symbol. 2nd revised ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Navest, Karlijn
2011 John Ash and the Rise of the Children’s Grammar. Doctoral dissertation, Leiden University.
Pérez-Guerra, Javier, Dolores González-Álvarez, Jorge Luis Bueno-Alonso & Esperanza Rama-Martínez
eds. 2007 ‘Of Varying Language and Opposing Creed’: New insights into Late Modern English. Bern: Peter Lang.
Rodríguez-Gil, María E.
2002 Teaching English Grammar in the Eighteenth Century: Ann Fisher. Doctoral dissertation, Universidad de Las Palmas de Gran Canaria.
Rodríguez-Gil, María E. & Nuria Yáñez-Bouza
2009 “The ECEG Database: A bio-bibliographic approach to the study of eighteenth-century English Grammars”. Tieken-Boon van Ostade & van der Wurff, eds. 2009.153–182.
Schmitz, Robert M.
1948 Hugh Blair. New York: King’s Crown Press.
Sher, Richard B.
1991 “Scottish Divines and Legal Lairds: Boswell’s Scots Presbyterian Identity”. New Light on Boswell ed. by Greg Clingham, 28–55. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
2007 The Enlightenment and the Book: Scottish authors and their publishers in eighteenth-century Britain, Ireland, and America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Short, Bryan C.
2000 “Figurative Language in the Scottish New Rhetoric”. Language Sciences 22:3.251–264.
Smout, Thomas C.
2007 “Scotland as North Britain: The historical background, 1707–1918”. Brown et al., eds. 2007.1–11.
Straaijer, Robin
2011 Joseph Priestley, Grammarian: Late Modern English normativism and usage in a sociohistorical context. Utrecht: LOT, Netherlands Graduate School of Linguistics.
Sturiale, Massimo
2006 “William Perry’s The Royal Standard English Dictionary (1775): A provincial’s attempt to ascertain and fix a standard to the pronunciation of the English tongue”. Historiographia Linguistica 33:1/2.139–168.
2008 “Prescriptivism and Eighteenth-Century Bilingual Dictionaries: William Perry’s The Standard of French and English Pronouncing Dictionary (1795)”. Beal et al., eds. 2008.181–195.
Sundby, Bertil, Anne Kari Bjørge & Kari E. Haugland
Tieken-Boon van Ostade, Ingrid
1985 “ ‘I will be drowned and no man shall save me’: The conventional rules for shall and will in eighteenth-century English grammars”. English Studies 66:2.123–142.
ed. 1996 Two Hundred Years of Lindley Murray. Münster: Nodus.
2000 “Normative Studies in England”. History of the Language Sciences/Geschichte der Sprachwissenschaften/Histoire des Sciences du Langage ed. by Sylvain Aroux, E. F. K. Koerner, Hans-Josef Niederehe & Kees Versteegh, vol. I1, 876–887. Berlin & New York: Walter de Gruyter.
2008a “Grammars, Grammarians and Grammar-Writing: An introduction”. Tieken-Boon van Ostade, ed. 2008b.1–14.
ed. 2008b Grammars, Grammarians and Grammar-Writing in Eighteenth-Century England. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
2011 The Bishop’s Grammar: Robert Lowth and the rise of prescriptivism in English. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Tieken-Boon van Ostade, Ingrid & Wim van der Wurff
eds. 2009 Current Issues in Late Modern English. Bern: Peter Lang.
Ward, Charles E.
ed. 1965 [1942] The Letters of John Dryden, with Letters addressed to him, collected and edited. New York: AMS Press.
Watts, Richard J.
2000 “Mythical Strands in the Ideology of Prescriptivism”. Wright, ed. 2000.29–48.
2008 “Grammar Writers in Eighteenth-Century Britain: A community of practice or a discourse community?”. Tieken-Boon van Ostade, ed. 2008b.37–56.
Wright, Laura
ed. 2000 The Development of Standard English, 1300–1800: Theories, descriptions, conflicts. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Yáñez-Bouza, Nuria
2007 Preposition Stranding and Prescriptivism in English from 1500 to 1900: A corpus-based approach. Doctoral dissertation, The University of Manchester.
2008 “Preposition Stranding in the Eighteenth Century: Something to talk about
”. Tieken-Boon van Ostade, ed. 2008b.251–277.
2011 “Grammar Writing and Provincial Grammar Printing in the Eighteenth-Century British Isles”. Transactions of the Philological Society 109:3.
Forthcoming. “Mapping Eighteenth-Century Grammarians in the British Isles (and beyond)”. To appear in Studies in Variation, Contacts and Change in English (VARIENG), [URL]
Cited by
Cited by 2 other publications
Yáñez-Bouza, Nuria
2022. Methodological approaches to the study of codification, prescription, and prescriptivism. Studia Neophilologica 94:3 ► pp. 334 ff. 
Yáñez‐Bouza, Nuria & María E. Rodríguez‐Gil
2013. The ECEG database. Transactions of the Philological Society 111:2 ► pp. 143 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 30 march 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.