A Late 19th-Century British Perspective on Modern Foreign Language Learning, Teaching, and Reform
The legacy of Prendergast’s “Mastery System”
The late 19th century saw a great rise in private foreign language learning and increasing provision of Modern foreign language teaching in schools. Evidence is presented to document the uptake of innovations in Thomas Prendergast’s (1807–1886) “Mastery System” by both individual language learners and educationalists. Although it has previously been suggested that Prendergast’s method failed to have much impact, this study clearly demonstrates the major influence he had on approaches to language learning and teaching in Britain and around the world both with his contemporaries and long after his death. This detailed case study illuminates the landscape of modern language pedagogy in Victorian Britain.
References (95)
References
Anonymous. 1864. “Advertisements and Notices”. Morning Post September 7, Issue 28308.11. London.
Anonymous. 1864. Review of The Mastery of Language
. The Examiner October 22, Issue 2969.51. London.
Anonymous. 1868a. “Notice”. John Bull February 1, 2.81. London.
Anonymous. 1868b. “Short Notices”. The London Review February 22, 16.188.
Anonymous. 1869. “Notice”. The Scholastic Register July 8, 191.
Anonymous. 1873. Fifteenth Annual Report of the Columbia Institution for the Deaf and Dumb. Washington, D.C.: Columbia Institution for the Deaf.
Anonymous. 1875. “Papers Set at the Christmas Examination for the College Diplomas”. Educational Times, and the Journal of the College of Preceptors 281.25–28.
Anonymous. 1877. “Latin Language”. The Cyclopaedia of Education: a dictionary of information for the use of teachers, school officers, parents and others ed. by H. Kiddle and A. J. Schem, 510–515. New York: E. Steiger.
Anonymous. 1879. “College of Preceptors, Training Class for Teachers. Seventh Session”. Educational Times, and the Journal of the College of Preceptors 32.134.
Anonymous. 1880. Advertisement. Cheltenham Looker-On September 4, 21.
Anonymous. 1883. Notice. Dundee Evening Telegraph May 4, 11. Dundee, Scotland.
Anonymous. 1887. “Thomas Prendergast”. Harrow Notes 5:47.6–7.
Anonymous. 1888. “Notice”. The Cheltenham Looker-On April 28, 2831.
Anonymous. 1889. “Modern Schools, or Sides”. Sonnenschein’s Cyclopaedia of Education. Ed. by Arthur E. Fletcher, 224–225. London: Swan Sonnenschein & Co.
Anonymous. 1890. “French Classes”. Sunderland Daily Echo October 18, 31. Sunderland.
Anonymous. 1900. Catalogue of the Library, Together with the Rules and Regulations for the Teachers’ Guild of Great Britain and Ireland Ireland. London: Cowell.
Anonymous. 1915. “Cheltenham Notices”. The Gloucester Journal April 3, 51. Gloucester.
Atherton, Mark. 2008. “To Observe Things as They are without Regard to their Origin”. Bulletin of the Henry Sweet Society No.51.41–58.
Atherton, Mark. 2010. “‘The Globe of Language’: Thomas Prendergast and Applied Linguistics in the 1870s”. Language & History 53:1.15–26. 

Beale, Dorothea. 1869. Reports Issued by the Schools’ Inquiry Commission on the Education of Girls. London: Nutt.
Berlitz, Maximilian Delphinus. 1887. Méthode Berlitz pour l’Enseignement des langues modernes. New York: Berlitz & Cie.
Bowen, Edward Ernest. 1879. “On the Study of Modern Languages at Public Schools”. Paper read at the Headmasters’ Conference at Eton. London: publisher unknown.
Bowen, Herbert Courthope. 1880. First Lessons in French: A book for beginners. London: Macmillan & Co.
Brown, Samuel Robbins. 1878. Prendergast’s Mastery System, Adapted to the Study of Japanese or English. Yokohama, Japan: Kelly & Co.
Capell, Authur. 1940. “Language Study for New Guinea Students”. Oceania January 1, 40–74. 

Carroll, Lewis. 1979. The Letters of Lewis Carroll. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Coignou, Alfred. 1868. The French Mastery Manual, Specially Adapted for the Use of Schools. London: Simkin, Marshall & Co.
Coignou, Alfred. 1871. The Public School Edition of the French Mastery Manual. Manchester: John Heywood.
Colbeck, Charles. 1887. On the Teaching of Modern Languages in Theory and Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cummings, Thomas Fulton. 1916. How to Learn a Foreign Language: an exposition of the phonetic inductive method for foreign resident language students. A direct, practical, scientific way of mastering any foreign tongue. New York: Bible Teachers Training School, New York.
de Morgan, Augustus. 1864. “The Mastery of Languages”. The Antheneum October 14, 4961.
Decoo, Wilfried. 2011. Systemitazation in Foreign Language Teaching: Monitoring content progression. Abingdon: Routledge. 

Ellis, Alexander J. 1875. “On the Acquisiton of Language”. Educational Times, and the Journal of the College of Preceptors 281.175–82.
ELTons, The. 2015. TEFLology Podcast. Episode 26: Thomas Prendergast, and the lexical approach. 37 minutes. Tokyo: TEFLology. [URL]
Fay, Edward A. 1869. “The Acquisition of Language by Deaf Mutes”. American Annals of the Deaf 14:4.193–204.
Fitch, Joshua. 1881. Lectures on Teaching delivered in the University of Cambridge during the Lent Term, 1880. Cmabridge: Cambridge University Press.
Fletcher, Alfred Ewen, ed. 1889. Sonnenschein’s Cyclopædia of Education; a handbook of reference on all subjects connected with education (its history, theory, and practice), comprising articles by eminent educational specialists. London: S. Sonnenschein & Co.
Gallaudet, Edward Miner. 1868. “Preface”. Handbook to the Mastery Series, 8–9. New York: Appleton.
Gallaudet, Edward Miner. 1869. “Discussion on Dr. Peet’s and Mr. Brock’s Papers. Proceedings of the National Conference of Principals of Institutions for the Deaf and Dumb, held at Washington, District of Columbia, May 12th though 16th, 1868”. Annual Report of the Columbia Institution of the Deaf, Dumb and Blind. Washington, D.C: Columbia Institution of the Deaf.
Gatbonton, Elizabeth & Norman Segalowitz. 2005. “Rethinking Communicative Language Teaching: A Focus on Access to Fluency”. The Canadian Modern Language Review / La Revue canadienne des langues vivantes 61:3.325–353. 

Gouin, François. 1880. L’art d’Enseigner et d’Etudier les Langues. Paris: G. Flachbacher.
Hale, Edward Everett. 1883. “Colonel Ingham’s Journey”. Harper’s New Monthly Magazine 681.143–149.
Hale, Edward Everett. 1886. Seven Spanish Cities, and the Way to Them. Boston: Roberts Brothers.
Handschin, Charles Hart. 1913. “The Teaching of Modern Languages in the United States”. Bulletin. United States Bureau of Education, 5101.1–154. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
Howatt, Anthony P. R. 1984. A History of English Language Teaching. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Howatt, Anthony P. R. & H. G. Widdowson. 2004. A History of English Language Teaching. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kroeh, Charles F. 1887. “Methods of Teaching Modern Languages”. Transactions and Proceedings of the Modern Language Association of America 31.169–185. 

Laviosa, Sara. 2014. Translation and Language Education: Pedagogic approaches explored, New York: Taylor & Francis. 

Lewis, Arthur. 1888. George Maxwell Gordon, M.A. F.R.G.S. The Pilgrim Missionary of the Punjab: A history of his life and work 1838–1880. London: Seely & Co.
Lindgren, Carl Edwin. 2004. “Robert Hebert Quick (1831–1891)”. Oxford Dictionary of National Biography Oxford: Oxford University Press. Online Edition [URL] Consulted July 4, 2014.
Lodeman, August. 1893. “Practical and Psychological Tests of Modern Language Study”. Methods of Teaching Modern Languages, 90–108. Boston: D. C. Heath & Co.
Lorch, Marjorie. 2017. “Investigating the Biographical Sources of Thomas Prendergast’s (1807– 1886) Innovation in Language Learning”. The History of Language Learning and Teaching II: 19th and 20th century Europe ed. by Nicola McLelland & Richard C. Smith, Oxford: Legenda. [In press.].
Lovett, Charlie. 2005. Lewis Carroll among his Books: Aa descriptive catalogue. Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland & Co.
Maltby, Thomas James. 1874. Practical Handbook of the Uriya or O’diya Language. Calcutta: Wyman & Co.
McLelland, Nicola & Richard C. Smith. 2014. “Introduction: Building the history of language learning and teaching (HoLLT)”. Language & History 571:1.1–9. 

Millard, James Elwin. 1868. “The Handbook to the Mastery Series, French and German”. The Antheneum March 28, Issue 2109. 4591.
Murphy, John M. & Amanda Ann Baker. 2015. “History of ESL Pronunciation”. The Handbook of English Pronunciation ed. by M. Reed & J. M. Levis. 36–64. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. 

Nakarai, Toyozo W. 1961. “Textbooks for Teaching Biblical Hebrew”. Hebrew Abstracts 71.22–29.
Ogden, Charles Kay. 1930. Basic English: A general introduction with rules and grammar. London: Kegan Paul.
Ogden, Charles Kay. 1930. “Editorial: Decimal-Basic English”. Pyche 10:40. 1–31.
Prendergast, Thomas. 1864. The Mastery of Languages; or, the art of speaking foreign tongues idiomatically. London: Richard Bentley.
Prendergast, Thomas. 1866. “Letter from Thomas Prendergast to Thomas Young Hall”. Thomas Young Hall papers. N. C. Board. The Grosvenor, London, Durham County Record Office. Mss. No: NCB 01/TH 66.
Prendergast, Thomas. 1868. Handbook to the Mastery Series. London: Longmans, Green.
Prendergast, Thomas. 1868. The Mastery Series. French. London: Longmans, Green.
Prendergast, Thomas. 1869. The Mastery Series. Spanish. London: Longmans, Green.
Prendergast, Thomas. 1871. The Mastery Series. Hebrew. London: Longmans, Green.
Prendergast, Thomas. 1872. The Mastery Series. Latin. London: Longmans, Green.
Prendergast, Thomas. 1873. Het taalonderwijs langs natuurlijken weg: Verhandeling over de methode. Amsterdam: B. H. Blankenberg, Jr.
Prendergast, Thomas. 1874. Methode Prendergast: Handboek voor de fransche taal. Amsterdam: B. H. Blankenberg, Jr.
Quick, Robert Hebert. 1864. Essays on Educational Reformers. London: Longmans, Green & Co.
Quick, Robert Hebert. 1872. “On the Study of Language”. Quarterly Journal of Education [London: Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge, n.d.] [3]-8. Quick Memorial Library Collection SHL [Q.M.L.] B.P.2. Senate House Library, University of London.
Quick, Robert Hebert. 1875. The First Steps in Teaching a Foreign Language with some account of celebrated methods: A lecture delivered at the College of Preceptors. London: S. Clarke.
Quick, Robert Hebert. 1890. Essays on Educational Reformers. London, Longmans, Green & Co.
Richards, Jack C. & Theodore S. Rodgers. 1986. Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Richards, Jack C. & Theodore S. Rodgers. 2001. Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 

Richards, Jack C. & Theodore S. Rodgers. 2014. Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching. 3rd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rippmann, Walter. 1916. “The ‘Substitution Method’”. Modern Language Teaching 12:4.109–110.
Rosenthal, Richard Sigismund. 1878. Das Meisterschafts-System zur praktischen und naturgemäßen Erlernung der französischen und englischen Geschäfts- und Umgangs-Sprache: Französisch; eine neue Methode, in drei Monaten eine Sprache Sprechen, Schreiben und Lesen zu Lernen. Zum Selbst-Unterricht. Berlin: L. Liepmannssohn.
Rosenthal, Richard Sigismund. 1885. The Meisterschaft System: A short and practical method of acquiring complete fluency of speech in the French language. Boston: The Meisterschaft Publication Co.
Rossner, Richard. 1987. Review of Working with Words: A guide to teaching and learning vocabulary by Ruth Gairns & Stuart Redman”. ELT Journal 41:4.301–303.
Senex. 1887. “The Late Mr. Thomas Prendergast”. Harrow Notes 5:47.6–7.
Smith, Richard C. 2004. An Investigation into the Roots of ELT, with a particular focus on the career and legacy of Harold E. Palmer (1877–1949). Ph.D. dissertation, University of Edinburgh.
Spurrell, William. 1881. Practical Lessons in Welsh: In imitation of the natural method of learning to speak a language. Carmarthen: W. Spurrell.
Storr, Francis. 1883. “French Class-Books”. Journal of Education July 1, 241–245.
Storr, Francis, ed. 1899. Life and Remains of the Rev. R. H. Quick. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Street, J. C. 1897. “A Study in Language Teaching”. Pedagogical Seminary 4(3): 269–293. 

Sweet, Henry. 1913 [1877]. “Presidential Address at the Anniversary Meeting of the Philological Society, May 18, 1877. Collected Papers of Henry Sweet ed, by H. C. K. Wyld. 93–94. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Sweet, Henry. 1899. The Practical Study of Languages. A guide for teachers and learners. London: Dent.
Thornbury, Scott. 2004. “Big Words, Small Grammar”. English Teaching Professional 311.10–11.
Thornbury, Scott. 2004. “Starting out with Words that ‘Glue’ Language”. The Guardian, Education Section, March 18. [URL]. wordsandlanguage. Consulted July 10, 2015.
Tickoo, Makhan L. 1986. “Prendergast and the ‘Mastery Method’: An assessment”. ELT Journal 40:1.52–58. 

Watts, George. 1963. “The Teaching of French in the United States: A history”. French Review 37:1.1–165.
Weihua, Yu. 2013. “Grammar-Translation Method”. The Routledge Encyclopedia of Language Teaching and Learning ed. by Michael Byram & Adelheid Hu. 287–289. Abingdon: Routledge.
Wheeler, Garon. 2013. Language Teaching Through the Ages, New York: Routledge. 

Zimmerman, Cheryl Boyd. 1997. “Historical Trends in Second Language Vocabulary Instruction”. Second Language Vocabulary Acquisition: A rationale for pedagogy ed. by James Coady & Thomas Huckin. 5–19. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cited by (2)
Cited by two other publications
Hodgetts, John
2020.
Pronunciation Instruction: Background, Techniques and Relevant Studies. In
Pronunciation Instruction in English for Academic Purposes [
Second Language Learning and Teaching, ],
► pp. 9 ff.

McLelland, Nicola
2018.
The history of language learning and teaching in Britain.
The Language Learning Journal 46:1
► pp. 6 ff.

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 3 august 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.