Article published In:
Internet PragmaticsVol. 5:2 (2022) ► pp.197–226
Instagram and intermodal configurations of value
Ideology, aesthetics, and attitudinal stance in #avotoast posts
This paper explores how ideological positions associated with food are construed multimodally in Instagram posts produced by everyday social media users. Discourse about food choices is an important site for revealing syndromes of values that characterise the ideological positions that are embedded in everyday life. An example of a highly valued food is the avocado which is an important bonding icon in semantic domains from veganism, clean eating, keto/low-carb eating, ethical/sustainable eating to fitness. We explore how values associated with avocado toast are enacted intermodally through the interplay of meanings made in the images, captions, and tags in a corpus of 64,585 Instagram posts tagged #avotoast. The study draws on previous social semiotic work on visual intersubjectivity and everyday aesthetics in social photography (Zhao and Zappavigna 2018a) to interpret the visual meanings made in these posts. It also draws on research into intermodal coupling (image-text relations) and ambient affiliation (online social bonding) (Zappavigna 2018) to understand how different values are construed in these texts. A modified grounded theory approach is used to isolate and exemplify the visual and textual features at stake, and then to explore ideological positionings through close multimodal analysis. A particularly interesting pattern in the corpus is the interaction of aesthetic and moralising discourses. For instance, a regulative metadiscourse realised through hashtags is used to project an instructional discourse about how to eat and what is considered ethical, sustainable, and nutritious food consumption. Rather than being directly encoded as judgement of behaviour these assessments tended to be expressed as appreciation of food items and their aesthetics or worth (e.g., clean, healthy, etc.).
Keywords: social media discourse, Instagram, ideology, multimodal discourse analysis, ambient affiliation, social media photography
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Enacting ideologies in digital food discourse
- 3.Method
- 3.1Dataset and sampling
- 3.2Linguistic analysis: The Appraisal framework and ideation-attitude couplings
- 3.2.1Ideation-attitude couplings for exploring values in texts
- 3.3Visual analysis of everyday aesthetics – amplified ordinariness
- 4.Analysis and discussion
- 4.1Still life self images and amplified ordinariness
- 4.2Hashtagged values
- 4.3Aesthetic discourse invoking a moralising discourse
- 5.Conclusion
- Notes
-
References
References
Adami, Esterino
2017 “Pragmatics and the aesthetics of food discourse: Jamie’s Italy.” Anglistica AION: An Interdisciplinary Journal 21(1): 53–62.
Allen, Michelle, Kacie M. Dickinson, and Ivanka Prichard
2018 “The dirt on clean eating: A cross sectional analysis of dietary intake, restrained eating and opinions about clean eating among women.” Nutrients 10(9): 1266. 
Andersson, Helen
2020 “Nature, nationalism and neoliberalism on food packaging: The case of Sweden.” Discourse, Context & Media 341: 100329.
Baker, Stephanie A., and Michael J. Walsh
2020 “You are what you Instagram: Clean eating and the symbolic representation of food.” In Digital Food Cultures, ed. by Deborah Lupton, and Zeena Feldman, 53–68. Abingdon: Routledge.
Bakhtin, Mikhail M.
1981 The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Bernstein, Basil
2003 Class, Codes and Control, vol. 21, Applied Studies Towards a Sociology of Language. Abingdon: Routledge.
Black, Rosalyn, and Lucas Walsh
2019 Imagining Youth Futures: Imagining Youth Futures. Singapore: Springer.
Blum, Susan D.
2017 “Eat food from [here]: The Talismanic semiotics of local food.” Semiotic Review (5). Available at: [URL] (accessed 15 July 2020).
Cairns, Kate, and Josée Johnston
2015 “Choosing health: Embodied neoliberalism, postfeminism, and the ‘do-diet.’” Theory and Society 44(2): 153–175.
Caple, Helen
2012 “Balancing act: Image composition.” In News Discourse, ed. by Monika Bednarek, and Helen Caple, 160–180. London: Bloomsbury.
Christie, Frances
2002 Classroom Discourse Analysis. London: Continuum.
Coary, Sean, and Morgan Poor
2016 “How consumer-generated images shape important consumption outcomes in the food domain.” Journal of Consumer Marketing 33(1): 1–8.
Cotter, William M., and Mary-Caitlyn Valentinsson
2018 “Bivalent class indexing in the sociolinguistics of specialty coffee talk.” Journal of Sociolinguistics 22(5): 489–515.
Cronin, James M., Mary B. McCarthy, and Alan M. Collins
2014 “Covert distinction: How hipsters practice food-based resistance strategies in the production of identity.” Consumption Markets & Culture 17(1): 2–28.
De Solier, Isabelle
2013 Food and the Self: Consumption, Production and Material Culture. London: Bloomsbury.
Djonov, Emilia, and Sumin Zhao
2013 Critical Multimodal Studies of Popular Discourse. New York: Routledge.
Ehgartner, Ulrike
2018 “Discourses of the food retail industry: Changing understandings of ‘the consumer’ and strategies for sustainability.” Sustainable Production and Consumption 161: 154–161.
Eriksson, Göran, and David Machin
2020 “Discourses of ‘Good Food’: The commercialization of healthy and ethical eating.” Discourse, Context & Media 331: 100365.
Halliday, M. A. K., and Christian M. I. M. Matthiessen
2004 An Introduction to Functional Grammar (3rd edn.). London: Arnold.
Hasan, Ruqaiya
1986 “The ontogenesis of ideology: An interpretation of mother child talk.” Sydney Studies in Society and Culture 31: 125–146.
Hoffman, Christian R.
2017 “Log in: Introducing the pragmatics of social media.” In Pragmatics of Social Media, ed. by Christian R. Hoffman, and Wolfram Bublitz, 1–28. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton.
Järlehed, Johan, and Máiréad Moriarty
2018 “Culture and class in a glass: Scaling the semiofoodscape.” Language & Communication 621: 26–38.
Knight, Naomi K.
2013 “Evaluating experience in funny ways: How friends bond through conversational humour.” Text & Talk 33(4–5): 553–574.
Leaver, Tama, Tim Highfield, and Crystal Abidin
2020 Instagram: Visual Social Media Cultures. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
Leddy, Thomas
2012 The Extraordinary in the Ordinary: The Aesthetics of Everyday Life. Peterborough, Ontario: Broadview Press.
Lee, Carmen, and Dennis Chau
2018 “Language as pride, love, and hate: Archiving emotions through multilingual Instagram hashtags.” Discourse, Context & Media 221: 21–29.
Levin, Sam
2017 “Millionaire tells millennials: If you want a house, stop buying avocado toast.” The Guardian 15 May. [URL] (accessed 18 July 2018).
Lewis, Tania
2018 “Digital food: From paddock to platform.” Communication Research and Practice 4(3): 212–228.
Lupton, Deborah
2018 “ ‘I just want it to be done, done, done!’: Food tracking apps, affects, and agential capacities.” Multimodal Technologies and Interaction 2(2): 29.
Lupton, Deborah, and Bethaney Turner
2016 “ ‘Both fascinating and disturbing’: Consumer responses to 3D food printing and implications for food activism.” In Digital Food Activism, ed. by Tanja Schneider, Karin Eli, Catherine Dolan, and Stanley Ulijaszek, 151–167. Abingdon: Routledge.
Mapes, Gwynne
2018 “(De) constructing distinction: Class inequality and elite authenticity in mediatized food discourse.” Journal of sociolinguistics 22(3): 265–287.
2020 “Marketing elite authenticity: Tradition and terroir in artisanal food discourse.” Discourse, Context & Media 341: 100328.
2021 Elite Authenticity: Remaking Distinction in Food Discourse. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Mapes, Gwynne, and Andrew S. Ross
2020 “Making privilege palatable: Normative sustainability in chefs’ Instagram discourse.” Language in Society.
Martin, J. R.
2008 “Intermodal reconciliation: Mates in arms.” In New Literacies and the English Curriculum: Multimodal Perspectives, ed. by Len Unsworth, 112–148. London: Continuum.
Martin, J. R., and David Rose
2008 Genre Relations: Mapping Culture. London: Equinox.
Martin, J. R., and P. R. R. White
2005 The Language of Evaluation: Appraisal in English. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Martin, J. R., Michele Zappavigna, Paul Dwyer, and Chris Cléirigh
2013 “Users in uses of language: Embodied identity in Youth Justice Conferencing.” Text & Talk 33(4–5): 467–496.
Matley, David
2018 “ ‘This is NOT a #humblebrag, this is just a #brag’: The pragmatics of self-praise, hashtags and politeness in Instagram posts.” Discourse, Context & Media 221: 30–38.
2020 “ ‘I can’t believe #Ziggy #Stardust died’: Stance, fan identities and multimodality in reactions to the death of David Bowie on Instagram.” Pragmatics 30(2): 247–276.
Matwick, Kelsi, and Keri Matwick
2019 Food Discourse of Celebrity Chefs of Food Network. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
McDonagh, Pierre, and Andrea Prothero
2005 “Food, markets & culture: The representation of food in everyday life.” Consumption Markets & Culture 8(1): 1–5.
Middha, Bhavna
2018 “Everyday digital engagements: Using food selfies on Facebook to explore eating practices.” Communication Research and Practice 4(3): 291–306.
Orenstein, Jayne
2016 “How the Internet became ridiculously obsessed with avocado toast.” The Washington Post 6 May. [URL] (accessed 9 December 2020).
Paddock, Jessica
2016 “Positioning food cultures: ‘Alternative’ food as distinctive consumer practice.” Sociology 50(6): 1039–1055.
Page, Ruth
2012 “The linguistics of self-branding and micro-celebrity in Twitter: The role of hashtags.” Discourse & Communication 6(2): 181–201.
Pichler, Pia, and Nathanael Williams
2016 “Hipsters in the hood: Authenticating indexicalities in young men’s hip-hop talk.” Language in Society 45(4): 557–581.
Riley, Kathleen C., and Jillian R. Cavanaugh
2017 “Tasty talk, expressive food: An introduction to the semiotics of food-and-language.” Semiotic Review 51. [URL]
Ross, Andrew S., and Gwynne Mapes
2020 “Food, class and ideological political affiliation: Indexical fields in the #secondcivilwarletters tweets.” Language & Communication 741: 103–112.
Rousseau, Signe
2012 Food and Social Media: You are What You Tweet. Lanham: AltaMira Press.
Schaefer, Sara E., Charlotte Biltekoff, Carolyn Thomas, and Roxanne N. Rashedi
2016 “Healthy, vague: Exploring health as a priority in food choice.” Food, Culture & Society 19(2): 227–250.
Schneider, Tanja, Karin Eli, Catherine Dolan, and Stanley Ulijaszek
2017 Digital Food Activism. Abingdon: Routledge.
Scott, Kate
2018 “ ‘Hashtags work everywhere’: The pragmatic functions of spoken hashtags.” Discourse, Context & Media 221:57–64.
Shugart, Helene A.
2014 “Food fixations: Reconfiguring class in contemporary food discourse.” Food, Culture & Society 17 (2):261–281.
Smith, Angela
2020 “Clean eating’s surprising normalisation: The case of Nigella Lawson.” Discourse, Context & Media 351: 100376.
Tovares, Alla, and Cynthia Gordon
(eds.) 2021 Identity and Ideology in Digital Food Discourse. London: Bloomsbury.
Zappavigna, Michele
2011 “Ambient affiliation: A linguistic perspective on Twitter.” New Media & Society 13(5): 788–806.
2012 Discourse of Twitter and Social Media. London: Continuum.
2014a “Ambient affiliation in microblogging: Bonding around the quotidian.” Media International Australia 151(1): 97–103.
2014b “Coffeetweets: Bonding around the bean on Twitter.” In The Language of Social Media: Communication and Community on the Internet, ed. by Phillip Seargeant, and Caroline Tagg, 139–160. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
2016 “Social media photography: Construing subjectivity in Instagram images.” Visual Communication 15(3): 271–292.
2017a “Evaluation.” In Pragmatics of Social Media, ed. by Christian R. Hoffmann, and Wolfram Bublitz, 435–459. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton.
2017b “ ‘had enough of experts’: Intersubjectivity and quotation in social media.” In Studies in Corpus-Based Sociolinguistics, ed. by Ericson Friginal, 321–343. New York: Routledge.
2018 Searchable Talk: Hashtags and Social Media Metadiscourse. London: Bloomsbury.
Zappavigna, Michele, and J. R. Martin
2018 Discourse and Diversionary Justice: An Analysis of Ceremonial Redress in Youth Justice Conferencing. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Zappavigna, Michele, and Sumin Zhao
2020 “Selfies and recontextualisation: A social semiotic perspective on the visual structure of Instagram images.” In Photography and Its Publics, ed. by Melissa Miles and Edward Welch, 207–227. Abingdon: Routledge.
Zhao, Sumin
2010 “Intersemiotic relations as logogenetic patterns: The time factor in hypertext description.” In New Discourse on Language: Functional Perspectives on Multimodality, Identity, and Affiliation, ed. by Monika Bednarek, and J. R. Martin, 195–218. London: Continuum.
Zhao, Sumin, and Michele Zappavigna
2018a “Beyond the self: Intersubjectivity and the social semiotic interpretation of the selfie.” New Media & Society 20(5): 1735–1754.
2018b “Digital scrapbooks, everyday aesthetics & the curatorial self: Social photography in female visual blogging.” In Multimodality and Aesthetics, ed. by Elise S. Tønnessen, and Frida Forsgren, 218–235. New York: Routledge.
2018c “The interplay of technologies and genre: The case of the selfie.” Social Semiotics 281: 665–682.