Article published In:
Vocalize to LocalizeEdited by Christian Abry, Anne Vilain and Jean-Luc Schwartz
[Interaction Studies 5:3] 2005
► pp. 387–408
Edited by Christian Abry, Anne Vilain and Jean-Luc Schwartz
[Interaction Studies 5:3] 2005
► pp. 387–408
Manual deixis in apes and humans
Pointing by apes is near-ubiquitous in captivity, yet rare in their natural habitats. This has implications for understanding both the ontogeny and heritability of pointing, conceived as a behavioral phenotype. The data suggest that the cognitive capacity for manual deixis was possessed by the last common ancestor of humans and the great apes. In this review, nonverbal reference is distinguished from symbolic reference. An operational definition of intentional communication is delineated, citing published or forthcoming examples for each of the defining criteria from studies of manual gestures in apes. Claims that chimpanzees do not point amongst themselves or do not gesture declaratively are refuted with published examples. Links between pointing and cognitive milestones in other domains relating means to ends are discussed. Finally, an evolutionary scenario of pointing as an adaptation to changes in hominid development is briefly sketched.
Keywords: apes, communication, manual gestures, deixis, nonverbal reference, pointing, hominoidea
Cited by
Cited by 56 other publications
Bard, Kim A., Heidi Keller, Kirsty M. Ross, Barry Hewlett, Lauren Butler, Sarah T. Boysen & Tetsuro Matsuzawa
2021. Joint Attention in Human and Chimpanzee Infants in Varied Socio‐Ecological Contexts. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 86:4 ► pp. 7 ff. 
Bard, Kim A. & David A. Leavens
2014. The Importance of Development for Comparative Primatology. Annual Review of Anthropology 43:1 ► pp. 183 ff.
Bourjade, Marie
2016. Le pointage controversé des singes : éléments empiriques chez le babouin olive ( Papio anubis ). Enfance N° 4:4 ► pp. 375 ff.
Bourjade, Marie, Charlotte Canteloup, Adrien Meguerditchian, Jacques Vauclair & Florence Gaunet
2015. Training experience in gestures affects the display of social gaze in baboons’ communication with a human. Animal Cognition 18:1 ► pp. 239 ff.
Bourjade, Marie, Hélène Cochet, Sandra Molesti & Michèle Guidetti
2020. Is Conceptual Diversity an Advantage for Scientific Inquiry? A Case Study on the Concept of ‘Gesture’ in Comparative Psychology. Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science 54:4 ► pp. 805 ff.
Bourjade, Marie, Mawa Dafreville, Céline Scola & Marianne Jover
2023. Six-month-old infants’ communication in a comparative perspective: Do maternal attention and interaction matter?. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 231 ► pp. 105651 ff.
Bourjade, Marie, Florence Gaunet, Anaïs Maugard & Adrien Meguerditchian
2019. Manipulating social cues in baboon gesture learning: what does it tell us about the evolution of communication?. Animal Cognition 22:1 ► pp. 113 ff.
Bourjade, Marie, Adrien Meguerditchian, Audrey Maille, Florence Gaunet & Jacques Vauclair
2014. Olive baboons, Papio anubis, adjust their visual and auditory intentional gestures to the visual attention of others. Animal Behaviour 87 ► pp. 121 ff.
CALL, JOSEP
2011. How Artificial Communication Affects the Communication and Cognition of the Great Apes. Mind & Language 26:1 ► pp. 1 ff.
Cartmill, Erica A.
2022. Gesture. Annual Review of Anthropology 51:1 ► pp. 455 ff.
Cartmill, Erica A., Sian Beilock & Susan Goldin-Meadow
2012. A word in the hand: action, gesture and mental representation in humans and non-human primates. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 367:1585 ► pp. 129 ff.
Defolie, Charlotte, Raphaëlle Malassis, Marion Serre & Hélène Meunier
2015. Tufted capuchins (Cebus apella) adapt their communicative behaviour to human’s attentional states. Animal Cognition 18:3 ► pp. 747 ff.
Duranton, Charlotte & Florence Gaunet
2020. Le rôle de l’affiliation dans la synchronisation comportementale interspécifique du chien avec l’humain : des processus cognitifs sociaux analogues à ceux de l’humain. L’Année psychologique Vol. 120:4 ► pp. 315 ff.
Fedurek, Pawel & Katie E. Slocombe
2011. Primate Vocal Communication: A Useful Tool for Understanding Human Speech and Language Evolution?. Human Biology 83:2 ► pp. 153 ff.
Fröhlich, Marlen, Christine Sievers, Simon W. Townsend, Thibaud Gruber & Carel P. van Schaik
2019. Multimodal communication and language origins: integrating gestures and vocalizations. Biological Reviews 94:5 ► pp. 1809 ff.
Fröhlich, Marlen & Carel P. van Schaik
2020. Must all signals be evolved? A proposal for a new classification of communicative acts. WIREs Cognitive Science 11:4
Gaunet, Florence & Bertrand L. Deputte
2011. Functionally referential and intentional communication in the domestic dog: effects of spatial and social contexts. Animal Cognition 14:6 ► pp. 849 ff.
Gaunet, Florence & Farid El Massioui
2014. Marked referential communicative behaviours, but no differentiation of the “knowledge state” of humans in untrained pet dogs versus 1-year-old infants. Animal Cognition 17:5 ► pp. 1137 ff.
Genty, Emilie, Christof Neumann & Klaus Zuberbühler
2015. Complex patterns of signalling to convey different social goals of sex in bonobos, Pan paniscus. Scientific Reports 5:1
Gillespie-Lynch, Kristen, Patricia M. Greenfield, Heidi Lyn & Sue Savage-Rumbaugh
2014. Gestural and symbolic development among apes and humans: support for a multimodal theory of language evolution. Frontiers in Psychology 5
Halina, Marta, Katja Liebal, Michael Tomasello & Kim A. Bard
2018. The goal of ape pointing. PLOS ONE 13:4 ► pp. e0195182 ff.
Henschel, Melanie, James Winters, Thomas F. Müller & Juliane Bräuer
2020. Effect of shared information and owner behavior on showing in dogs (Canis familiaris). Animal Cognition 23:5 ► pp. 1019 ff.
Hobaiter, Catherine, David A. Leavens & Richard W. Byrne
2016. Les chimpanzés sauvages ( Pan troglodytes ) produisent-ils des gestes déictiques?. Enfance N° 4:4 ► pp. 405 ff.
Hobaiter, Catherine, David A. Leavens & Richard W. Byrne
2016. Les chimpanzés sauvages (Pan troglodytes) produisent-ils des gestes déictiques?. Enfance 2016:04 ► pp. 405 ff.
Holler, Judith
2022. Visual bodily signals as core devices for coordinating minds in interaction. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 377:1859
Hopkins, William D., Jared P. Taglialatela & David A. Leavens
2007. Chimpanzees differentially produce novel vocalizations to capture the attention of a human. Animal Behaviour 73:2 ► pp. 281 ff.
Hurford, James R.
2012. Linguistics From an Evolutionary Point of View. In Philosophy of Linguistics, ► pp. 477 ff.
Kaminski, Juliane & Patrizia Piotti
2016. Current Trends in Dog-Human Communication. Current Directions in Psychological Science 25:5 ► pp. 322 ff.
Kaplan, Gisela
2023. Evolution of human language: duetting as part of prosociality and cognition. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution 11
Lamaury, Augustine, Hélène Cochet & Marie Bourjade
2019. Acquisition of joint attention by olive baboons gesturing toward humans. Animal Cognition 22:4 ► pp. 567 ff.
Leavens, David A.
2021. The Referential Problem Space revisited: An ecological hypothesis of the evolutionary and developmental origins of pointing. WIREs Cognitive Science 12:4
Leavens, David A. & Kim A. Bard
2011. Environmental Influences on Joint Attention in Great Apes: Implications for Human Cognition. Journal of Cognitive Education and Psychology 10:1 ► pp. 9 ff.
Leavens, David A., Mahmoud M. Elsherif & Hannah Clark
2023. What animals can tell us about attentional prerequisites of language acquisition. Language & Communication 92 ► pp. 55 ff.
Leavens, David A., Jon Ely, William D. Hopkins & Kim A. Bard
2012. Effects of cage mesh on pointing: hand shapes in chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes). Animal Cognition 15:3 ► pp. 437 ff.
Leavens, David A., William D. Hopkins & Kim A. Bard
2005. Understanding the Point of Chimpanzee Pointing. Current Directions in Psychological Science 14:4 ► pp. 185 ff.
Leavens, David A., Lisa A. Reamer, Mary Catherine Mareno, Jamie L. Russell, Daniel Wilson, Steven J. Schapiro & William D. Hopkins
2015. Distal Communication by Chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes): Evidence for Common Ground?. Child Development 86:5 ► pp. 1623 ff.
Liebal, Katja, Christel Schneider & Manuela Errson-Lembeck
2019. How primates acquire their gestures: evaluating current theories and evidence. Animal Cognition 22:4 ► pp. 473 ff.
Maille, Audrey, Amandine Chapelain, Laure Déruti, Philippe Bec & Catherine Blois-Heulin
2013. Manual laterality for pointing gestures compared to grasping actions in guenons and mangabeys. Animal Behaviour 86:4 ► pp. 705 ff.
Maille, Audrey, Lucie Engelhart, Marie Bourjade, Catherine Blois-Heulin & Esteban Andres Fridman
2012. To Beg, or Not to Beg? That Is the Question: Mangabeys Modify Their Production of Requesting Gestures in Response to Human’s Attentional States. PLoS ONE 7:7 ► pp. e41197 ff.
Marno, Hanna, Christoph J. Völter, Brandon Tinklenberg, Dan Sperber & Josep Call
2022. Learning from communication versus observation in great apes. Scientific Reports 12:1
Mattos, Otávio & Wolfram Hinzen
2015. The linguistic roots of natural pedagogy. Frontiers in Psychology 6
Meguerditchian, Adrien, Molly J. Gardner, Steven J. Schapiro & William D. Hopkins
2012. The sound of one-hand clapping: handedness and perisylvian neural correlates of a communicative gesture in chimpanzees. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 279:1735 ► pp. 1959 ff.
Müller-Tomfelde, Christian
2007. Dwell-Based Pointing in Applications of Human Computer Interaction. In Human-Computer Interaction – INTERACT 2007 [Lecture Notes in Computer Science, 4662], ► pp. 560 ff.
Pika, Simone
2008. Gestures of apes and pre-linguistic human children: Similar or different?. First Language 28:2 ► pp. 116 ff.
Pika, Simone & Thomas Bugnyar
2011. The use of referential gestures in ravens (Corvus corax) in the wild. Nature Communications 2:1
Piotti, Patrizia, Juliane Kaminski & Katie Elizabeth Slocombe
2016. Do Dogs Provide Information Helpfully?. PLOS ONE 11:8 ► pp. e0159797 ff.
Prieur, Jacques, Stéphanie Barbu, Catherine Blois‐Heulin & Alban Lemasson
2020. The origins of gestures and language: history, current advances and proposed theories. Biological Reviews 95:3 ► pp. 531 ff.
Proust, Joëlle
2016. The Evolution of Primate Communication and Metacommunication. Mind & Language 31:2 ► pp. 177 ff.
Quintero, Fredy, Sonia Touitou, Martina Magris & Klaus Zuberbühler
2022. An Audience Effect in Sooty Mangabey Alarm Calling. Frontiers in Psychology 13
Roberts, Anna Ilona, Lindsay Murray & Sam George Bradley Roberts
2019. Complex Sociality of Wild Chimpanzees Can Emerge from Laterality of Manual Gestures. Human Nature 30:3 ► pp. 299 ff.
Rodrigues, Evelina D. & Marlen Fröhlich
2021. Operationalizing Intentionality in Primate Communication: Social and Ecological Considerations. International Journal of Primatology
Scott-Phillips, Thomas C.
2015. Nonhuman Primate Communication, Pragmatics, and the Origins of Language. Current Anthropology 56:1 ► pp. 56 ff.
Volterra, Virginia, Olga Capirci, Pasquale Rinaldi & Laura Sparaci
2018. From action to spoken and signed language through gesture. Interaction Studies. Social Behaviour and Communication in Biological and Artificial Systems 19:1-2 ► pp. 216 ff.
Volterra, Virginia, Olga Capirci, Pasquale Rinaldi & Laura Sparaci
2020. From action to spoken and signed language through gesture. In How the Brain Got Language – Towards a New Road Map [Benjamins Current Topics, 112], ► pp. 216 ff.
Williams, Tom, Matthew Bussing, Sebastian Cabrol, Elizabeth Boyle & Nhan Tran
2019. 2019 14th ACM/IEEE International Conference on Human-Robot Interaction (HRI), ► pp. 191 ff.
Worsley, Hannah K. & Sean J. O’Hara
2018. Cross-species referential signalling events in domestic dogs (Canis familiaris). Animal Cognition 21:4 ► pp. 457 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 31 march 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.