Exploring the abuse of robots
Christoph Bartneck | Eindhoven University of Technology
Robots have been introduced into our society, but their social role is still unclear. A critical issue is whether the robot’s exhibition of intelligent behaviour leads to the users’ perception of the robot as being a social actor, similar to the way in which people treat computers and media as social actors. The first experiment mimicked Stanley Milgram’s obedience experiment, but on a robot. The participants were asked to administer electric shocks to a robot, and the results show that people have fewer concerns about abusing robots than about abusing other people. We refined the methodology for the second experiment by intensifying the social dilemma of the users. The participants were asked to kill the robot. In this experiment, the intelligence of the robot and the gender of the participants were the independent variables, and the users’ destructive behaviour towards the robot the dependent variable. Several practical and methodological problems compromised the acquired data, but we can conclude that the robot’s intelligence had a significant influence on the users’ destructive behaviour. We discuss the encountered problems and suggest improvements. We also speculate on whether the users’ perception of the robot as being “sort of alive” may have influenced the participants’ abusive behaviour.
Keywords: robots, perceived intelligence, abuse, killing
Published online: 15 December 2008
https://doi.org/10.1075/is.9.3.04bar
https://doi.org/10.1075/is.9.3.04bar
Cited by
Cited by 48 other publications
Aroyo, A.M., T. Kyohei, T. Koyama, H. Takahashi, F. Rea, A. Sciutti, Y. Yoshikawa, H. Ishiguro & G. Sandini
Babel, Franziska, Johannes M. Kraus & Martin Baumann
Bartneck, Christoph & Merel Keijsers
Brščić, Dražen, Hiroyuki Kidokoro, Yoshitaka Suehiro & Takayuki Kanda
Carlson, Zachary, Louise Lemmon, MacCallister Higgins, David Frank, Roya Salek Shahrezaie & David Feil-Seifer
Carolus, Astrid, Carolin Wienrich, Anna Törke, Tobias Friedel, Christian Schwietering & Mareike Sperzel
Coghlan, Simon, Frank Vetere, Jenny Waycott & Barbara Barbosa Neves
de Graaf, Maartje Margaretha Allegonda & Somaya Ben Allouch
Desideri, Lorenzo, Cristina Ottaviani, Massimiliano Malavasi, Roberto di Marzio & Paola Bonifacci
Duan, Jiali, Qian Wang, Lerrel Pinto, C.-C. Jay Kuo & Stefanos Nikolaidis
Festerling, Janik & Iram Siraj
Goldie, Peter
Gordon, John‐Stewart & David J. Gunkel
Gunkel, David J.
Harris, Jamie & Jacy Reese Anthis
Hildt, Elisabeth
Hortensius, Ruud & Emily S. Cross
Hortensius, Ruud, Felix Hekele & Emily S. Cross
Kang, Youngjin
Keijsers, Merel, Hussain Kazmi, Friederike Eyssel & Christoph Bartneck
Kolling, Thorsten, Stefanie Baisch, Arthur Schall, Stefanie Selic, Saskia Rühl, Ziyon Kim, Holger Rossberg, Barbara Klein, Johannes Pantel, Frank Oswald & Monika Knopf
Küster, Dennis, Aleksandra Swiderska & David Gunkel
Menne, Isabelle M.
Menne, Isabelle M., Christin Schnellbacher & Frank Schwab
Menne, Isabelle M. & Frank Schwab
Mieczkowski, Hannah, Sunny Xun Liu, Jeffrey Hancock & Byron Reeves
Moore, Dylan, Rebecca Currano, Michael Shanks & David Sirkin
Nomura, Tatsuya, Takayuki Kanda, Hiroyoshi Kidokoro, Yoshitaka Suehiro & Sachie Yamada
Patel, Himalaya & Karl F. MacDorman
Phan, Raphaël C.-W. & Elizabeth Sheppard
Quick, Oliver Santiago
Riddoch, Katie A. & Emily. S. Cross
Rosenthal-von der Pütten, Astrid M., Frank P. Schulte, Sabrina C. Eimler, Sabrina Sobieraj, Laura Hoffmann, Stefan Maderwald, Matthias Brand & Nicole C. Krämer
Rosenthal-von der Pütten, Astrid M., Nicole C. Krämer, Laura Hoffmann, Sabrina Sobieraj & Sabrina C. Eimler
Rossmy, Beat, Sarah Theres Völkel, Elias Naphausen, Patricia Kimm, Alexander Wiethoff & Andreas Muxel
Sanoubari, Elaheh, James Young, Andrew Houston & Kerstin Dautenhahn
Sauer, Vanessa, Axel Sauer & Alexander Mertens
Seymour, William & Max Van Kleek
Sharkey, Amanda J. C.
Strait, Megan, Gordon Briggs & Matthias Scheutz
Strait, Megan K., Cynthia Aguillon, Virginia Contreras & Noemi Garcia
Strengers, Yolande, Lizhen Qu, Qiongkai Xu & Jarrod Knibbe
Suzuki, Yutaka, Lisa Galli, Ayaka Ikeda, Shoji Itakura & Michiteru Kitazaki
Tan, Xiang Zhi, Marynel Vázquez, Elizabeth J. Carter, Cecilia G. Morales & Aaron Steinfeld
Vanman, Eric J. & Arvid Kappas
Völkel, Sarah Theres, Ramona Schödel, Daniel Buschek, Clemens Stachl, Verena Winterhalter, Markus Bühner & Heinrich Hussmann
Yamada, Sachie, Takayuki Kanda & Kanako Tomita
Złotowski, Jakub, Diane Proudfoot, Kumar Yogeeswaran & Christoph Bartneck
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 15 april 2022. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.