Article published in:
ITL - International Journal of Applied Linguistics
Vol. 103/104 (1994) ► pp. 39–56

Lateral Preference and L2 Proficiency

| Bogaziçi University, Istanbul
| Bogaziçi University, Istanbul
This study investigates the relationship between the L2 proficiency of advanced EFL learners and biological lateral preference. The former is thought of as the person's advanced ability in English, developed within a school setting and involving both reading comprehension and grammatical and lexical knowledge - as represented by the Michigan Test of English Language Proficiency. The latter is conceptualized as a continuous and multifactorial construct that predicts the degree of the hemispheric specialization of cognitive functions in the human brain as well as the degree of hemisphericity as a personal trait. It is measured by the Lateral Preference Schedule, developed as an instrument to meet the research and clinical needs for a standardized measure of lateral preference. Sixty university students majoring in TEFL participated in the study. Overall, the findings suggest that, from the various lateral preference patterns, only those which involve footed-ness and handedness are related to L2 proficiency. The findings further suggest that the relationship between lateral preference and L2 proficiency is independent of differences in gender.
Published online: 01 January 1994
https://doi.org/10.1075/itl.103-104.03alp
References
ALPTEKIN, C. and ATAKAN, S.
1990: Field Dependence-Independence and Hemisphericity as Variables in L2 Achievement. Second Language Research 61: 135–149. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
ANNETT, M. and MANNING, M.
1990: Arithmetic and Laterality. Neuropsychologia 281: 61–69. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
BRYDEN, M.P.
1982: Laterality: Functional Asymmetry in the Intact Brain. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
CASEY, M.B., WINNER, E., BENBOW, C., HAYES, R. and DASILVA, D.
1993: Skill at Image Generation: Handedness Interacts with Strategy Preference for Individuals Majoring in Spatial Fields. Cognitive Neuropsychology 101:57–77. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
CERVENKA, E.J.
1978: Michigan Test of English Language Proficiency. In Buros, O.K., editor, The Eight Mental Measurements Yearbook, Vol. 11, 104–106. Highland Park, New Jersey: Gryphon.Google Scholar
CORMIER, P., TOMLINSON-KEASEY, C. and GEARY, D.C.
1988: Gender and Hemispheric Specialization Differences in the Learning of Morse Code Letters. Bulletin of the Psychonomie Society 261: 399–402. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
DEAN, R.S.
1979: Cerebral Laterality and Verbal-Performance Discrepancies in Intelligence. Journal of School Psychology 171: 145–150. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
1982: Assessing Patterns of Lateral Preference. Clinical Neuropsychology 41: 124–128.Google Scholar
1988: Lateral Preference Schedule. Odessa, Florida: Psychological Assessment Resources, Inc.Google Scholar
DlZNEY, H.
1965: Concurrent Validity of the Test of English as a Foreign Language at an American University. Educational and Psychological Measurement 251: 1129–1131. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
EDWARDS, B.
1989: Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain. Los Angeles: Jeremy P. Tarcher, Inc.Google Scholar
GALLOWAY, L. and SCARCELLA, R.
1982: Cerebral Organization in Adult Second Language Acquisition: Is the Right Hemisphere more Involved? Brain and Language 161: 56–60. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
GASS, S. and VERONIS, E.
1986: Sex Differences in NNS/NNS Interactions. In Day, R. editor. Talking to Learn: Conversation in Second Language Acquisition, 327–351. Rowley, Mass: Newbury House.Google Scholar
GAY, L.R.
1976: Educational Research: Competencies for Analysis and Application. Columbus, Ohio: Charles E. Merrill.Google Scholar
GORDON, H.W.
1980: Cerebral Organization in Bilinguals: Lateralization. Brain and Language 91: 255–268. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
GUR, R.C. and GUR, R.E.
1974: Handedness, Sex and Eyedness as Moderating Variables in the Relation Between Hypnotic Suscep-tibility and Functional Brain Asymmetry. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 831: 635–643. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
HAHN, W.K.
1987: Cerebral Lateralization of Function: From Infancy through Childhood. Psychological Bulletin 1011: 376–392. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
HECEAN, H. and SAUGUET, J.
1971: Cerebral Dominance in Lefthanded Subjects. Cortex 71: 19–48. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
HUGDAHL, K. and FRANZON, M.
1985: Visual Half-field Presentations of Incongruent Colour-words Reveal Mirror-Reversal of Language Lateralization in Dextral and Sinistral Subjects. Cortex 211: 359–374. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
HUGHES, A.
1988: Introducing a Needs Based Test of English Language Proficiency into an English Medium University in Turkey In Hughes, A., editor, Testing English for University Study., 134–153. Hong Kong: Modern English Publications and the British Council.Google Scholar
JACOBS, B.
1988: Neurobiologicai Differentiation of Primary and Secondary Language Acquisition. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 101: 303–337. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
JOHNS, L.B.
1989: Hemispheric Preference and Progressive-Part or Whole Practice in Beginning Typewriting. Perceptual and Motor Skills 681: 359–364. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
JOHNSON, J.S. and NEWPORT, E.L.
1989: Critical Period Effects in Second Language Learning: The Influence of Maturational State on the Acquisition of English as a Second Language. Cognitive Psychology 211:60–99. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
KIM, H. and LEVINE, S.C.
1991: Inferring Patterns of Hemispheric Specializations for Individual Subjects from Laterality Data: A Two-task Criterion. Neuropsychologia 291:93–105. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
KlMURA, D.
1987: Are Men’s and Women’s Brains Really Different? Canadian Psychology 281/133–147. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
KlNSBOURNE, M.
1974: Direction of Gaze and Distribution of Cerebral Thought Processes. Neuropsychologia 121:279–281. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
1986a: Brain Organization as Elicited by Laterality Tests. Journal of Neurolinguistics 21:365–370. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
1986b: Cerebral Representation of Language in Left and Right Hemispheres. Journal of Neurolinguistics 21:371–381. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
LECOURS, A.R. and NESPOULOUS, J.
1988: The Biology of Writing. In de Kerckhove, D. and Lumsden, C.J., editors, The Alphabet and the Brain: The Lateralization of Writing, 231–245. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.Google Scholar
LONG, M.H.
1990: Maturational Constraints on Language Development. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 121:251–285. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
MARKHAM, P.
1988: Gender and Perceived Expertness of the Speaker as Factors in ESL Listening Recall. TESOL Quarterly 221:397–406. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
McGLONE, J.
1980: Sex Differences in Human Brain Asymmetry: A Critical Survey. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 31: 215–263. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
MENDELSOHN, S.
1988: Language Lateralization in Bilinguals: Facts and Fantasy. Journal of Neurolinguistics 31: 261–291. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
PARADIS, M.
1990: Language Lateralization in Bilinguals: Enough Already! Brain and Language 391: 576–586. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
PATKOWSKI, M.S.
1990: Age and Accent in a Second Language: A Reply to James Emil Flege. Applied Linguistics 111: 73–89. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
PETERS, M.
1988: Footedness: Asymmetries in Foot Preference and Skill and Neuropsychological Assessment of Foot Movement. Psychological Bulletin 1031: 179–182. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
PIAZZA, D. and ZATORRE, R.
1981: Right Ear Advantage for Dichotic Listening in Bilingual Children. Brain and Language 131: 389–396. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
PICA, T., HOLLIDAY, L., LEWIS, N., BERDUCCI, D. and NEWMAN, J.
1991: Language Learning through Interaction: What Role does Gender Play? Studies in Second Language Acquisition 131: 343–376. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
ROTHLISBERG, B.A.
1982: Lateral Preference and its Relation to Reading Achievement in Selected Reader Types. University of Wisconsin. Master’s thesis.Google Scholar
SACKHEIM, H.A., WEIMAN, A.L. and GREGA, D.M.
1984: Effects of Predictors of Hemispheric Specialization on Individual Differences in Hemispheric Activation. Neuropsychologia 221: 55–64. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
SCOVEL, T.
1988: A time to Speak: A Psycholinguistic Inquiry into the Critical Period for Human Speech. New York: Newbury House.Google Scholar
SEARLEMAN, A.
1983: Language Capabilities and the Right Hemisphere. In Young, A.W., editor, Functions of the Right Cerebral Hemisphere, 87–111. London: Academic Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
SKEHAN, P.
1989: Individual Differences in Second Language Learning. London: Edward Arnold.Google Scholar
SOARES, C.
1984: Left-hemisphere Language Lateralization in Bilinguals: Use of the Concurrent Activities Paradigm. Brain and Language 231: 86–96. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
SUSSMAN, H., FRANKLIN P. and SIMON, T.
1982: Bilingual Speech: Bilateral Control? Brain and Language 151: 124–142. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
WEISZ, J., BALAZS, L. and ADAM, G.
1990: Hemispheric Preference and Obesity. Neuropsychologia 281: 883–887. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
ZATORRE, R.
1989: On the Representation of Multiple Languages in the Brain: Old Problems and New Directions. Brain and Language 361: 127–147. CrossrefGoogle Scholar