Cover not available
Article published In:
ITL - International Journal of Applied Linguistics
Vol. 131/132 (2001) ► pp.107–137

Variation and Text Structure

the Discussion Section in Economics Research Articles

| Mara University of Technology Shah Alam, Malaysia

This paper is an attempt to use genre analysis to explore the sources of variation in the structure of texts produced within academic communities. The “move” structure of the Discussion Sections of 43 recent articles in agricultural economics journals sponsored by national professional associations in the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Australia and India was analyzed. The frequency and distribution of moves and the degree of structural complexity of these texts was examined. It was noted that these texts showed distinct preferences for certain moves although there was some variation within the subdiscipline. One noticeable feature was that texts from the Indian journal were much less complex that the others. It is suggested that variation in academic text structure reflects economic, social and cultural pressures and constraints and that competitive publishing situations lead to the elaboration of texts.

Published online: 1 January 2001
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/itl.131-132.06hol
References

Bibliography

Agricultural Economics Society
(1997): 'The 1997 Agricultural Economics Society survey of members' perceptions', [URL] (14/6/99)
BAZERMAN, C.
(1995): 'Money talks: The rhetorical project of The Wealth of Nations' in W. Henderson, T. Dudley-Evans & R. Backhouse (eds.) Economics and Language. London: Rout-ledge.Google Scholar
ARKIRAN, N.
(1997): 'Scientific collaboration in finance does not lead to better quality research'. Scientometrics, 391, 173–184. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
BEATON, B.
(1995): 'The discourse of technical comments'. Unpublished MA dissertation, University of Surrey.Google Scholar
BECHER, A.
(1989): Academic Tribes and Territories. Milton Keynes: Open University Press.Google Scholar
BERKENKOTTER, C., T. HUCKIN and J. ACKERMAN
(1991) 'Social contexts and socially constructed texts: The initiation of a graduate student into a writing research community' in C. Bazerman and J. Paradis (eds.) Textual Dynamics of the Professions: Historical and contemporary Studies of Writing in Academic and other Professional Communities. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
BHATIA, V.
(1993): Analysing Genre: Language Use in Professional Settings, London: Longman.Google Scholar
BLOOR, T.
(1996) 'Three hypothetical strategies in philosophical writing' in Mauranen and Ventola (eds.). DOI logoGoogle Scholar
BUTLER, C.
(1990): 'Qualifications in science: modal meanings in scientific text' in Nash (ed.).Google Scholar
BRETT, P.
(1994): 'A genre analysis of the results section of sociology articles'. English for Specific Purposes 131, 47–59. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
CHOI, K.
(1999): 'How to publish in top journals'. [URL] (14/6/99)
CLYNE, M.
(1990): Inter-Cultural Communication at Work: Cutural Values in Discourse. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
CONNOR, U.
(1996): Contrastive Rhetoric: Cross-Cultural Aspects of Second-Language Writing. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
COX, J.
(1995): 'Analysing geotechnical engineering abstracts: Towards a pedagogical template'. ESP Malaysia, 31, 136–144.Google Scholar
CROOKES, G.
(1986): 'Towards a validated analysis of scientific text structure'. Applied Linguistics, 71, 57–70. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
CMEJRKOVA, S.
(1996): 'Academic writing in Czech and English' in Mauranen and Ventola (eds.) DOI logoGoogle Scholar
DUDLEY-EVANS, T.
(1993a.): 'The debate over Milton Friedman's theoretical framework: An applied linguist's view' in W. Henderson, T. Dudley-Evans and R. Backhouse Eds.) Economics and Language. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
(1993b): 'Variation in communication patterns between discourse communities: the case of highway engineering and plant biology' in G. Blue (ed.) Language, Learning and Success: Studying through English. Macmillan: London.Google Scholar
DUDLEY-EVANS, T. AND W. HENDERSON
(1990): 'The organisation of article introductions: Evidence of change in economics writing' in T. Dudley-Evans and W. Henderson (Eds.) The Language of Economics: The Analysis of Economic Discourse. Modern English Publications/The British Council: London.Google Scholar
FISH, S.
(1982): 'Working on the chain gang: Interpretations in the law and in literary criticism.' Critical Inquiry, 91, 201–216. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
FISHELOV, D.
(1993): Metaphors of Genre: The Role of Analogies in Genre Theory. Pennsylvania State University Press: Philadelphia.Google Scholar
GIANNONI, D.
(1997): 'Credit where it's due: A sociopragmatic interpretation of Acknowledgements sections in English academic articles'. Unpublished MA dissertation. University of Surrey.Google Scholar
GOLINSKI, J.
(1987): 'Robert Boyle: Scepticism and authority in seventeenth-century chemical discourse' in A. Benjamin, G. Cantor & J. Christie (eds.) The Figurai and the Literal: Problems of Language in the History of Science and Philosophy 1630-1800. Manchester: Manchester University Press.Google Scholar
GOSDEN, H.
(1993): 'Discourse functions of subject in scientific research articles'. Applied Linguistics 141, 56–75. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
GRIMES, P. AND C. REGISTER
(1997): 'Career Publications and academic Job Rank: Evidence from the Class of 1968'. Journal of Economic Education, 281, 82–95. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
HALLIDAY, M.
(1994): 'The Construction of Knowledge and Value in the Grammar of scientific Discourse, with Reference to Charles Darwin's The Origin of Species in M. Coulthard (ed.) Advances in Written Text Analysis. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
HANANIA, E. AND K. AKHTAR
(1985): 'Verb Form and rhetorical Function in science Writing: a study of ms Theses in Biology, Chemistry and Physics'. The ESP Journal 41, 49–58. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
HAWES, T. AND S. THOMAS
(1997): Tense Choices in Citations'. Research in the Teaching of English, 311, 393–414.Google Scholar
HOLMES, J. AND M. MEYERHOFF
(1999): 'The Community of Practice: Theories and Methodologies in Language and Gender Research'. Language in Society, 281, 173–183. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
HOLMES, R.
(1997): (Genre Analysis and the social sciences: An investigation of the structure of Research Article Discussion Sections in three disciplines'. English for Specific Purposes, 161, 321–37. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hopkins, A. AND T. Dudley-Evans
(1988): 'A Genre-based investigation of the Discussion Section in articles and dissertations'. English for Specific Purposes, 71, 113–121. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
HUNSTON, S.
(1993): Evaluation and Ideology in Scientific Writing. In M. Ghadessy (ed.) Register Analysis: Theory and Practice. London: Pinter.Google Scholar
HYLAND K.
(1996): 'Writing without conviction? Hedging in science research articles'. Applied Linguistics 171, 433–454. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
HYLAND, K.
(1997): 'Scientific claims and community values: articulating an academic culture'. Language and Communication 171, 19–31. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
JOLIFFE, D. and E. BRIER
(1988): 'Studying writers' knowledge in academic disciplines” inD., Joliffe (ed.) Advances in Writing Research, Volume Two. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.Google Scholar
KACHRU, B.
(1985): 'Standards, codification and sociolinguistic realism: The English language in the outer circle” in R. Quirk, & H. Widdowson, (eds.) English in the World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
KATHPALIA, S.
(1977): 'Cross-cultural variations in professional genres: A comparative study of book blurbs'. World Englishes 161, 417–426. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
MAURANEN, V. and E. VENTOLA
(1996): Academic Writing: Inter-cultural and Textual Issues. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.Google Scholar
MCNAMEE, S. and C. WILLIS
(1994): 'Stratification in science: A comparison of publication patterns in four disciplines'. Knowledge: Creation, Diffusion, Utilization 151, 196–416.Google Scholar
MORRIS, J.
(1992): 'Paradox in the discourse of science' in R. Wurthnow (ed.) Vocabularies of Public Life: Empirical Essays in Symbolic Structure. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
MORROW, P.
(1989): 'Conjunct use in business news stories and academic journal articles: A comparative study'. English for Specific Purposes 81, 239–254. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
NASH, W.
(d.) (1990): The Writing Scholar: Studies in Academic Discourse. Newbury Park: Sage.Google Scholar
NWOGU, K.
(1991): 'Structure of science popularisations: A genre-analysis approach to the schema of popularised medical texts'. English for Specific Purposes 101, 111–123. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
OSAREH, F. and W. WILSON
(1997): 'Third World Countries (TWC) research publications by disciplines: a country-by-country citation analysis'. Scientometrics 391, 253–266. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
PENG, J.
(1987): 'Organizational features in chemical engineering research articles'. English Language Research Journal 11, 79–116.Google Scholar
PECK MACDONALD, S.
(1990): 'The literary argument and its discursive conventions'. In W. Nash (ed.) The Writing Scholar: Studies in Academic Discourse. Newbury Park: Sage.Google Scholar
RYMER, J.
(1988): 'Scientific composing processes: How eminent scientists write journal articles” in Joliffe D. (ed.) Advances in Writing research, Volume Two. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.Google Scholar
STEHR, N.
(1996): 'The salt of social science'. Sociological Research Online, Vol. 1, No. 1, [URL] 14/6/99 DOI logo
SWALES, J.
(1981): Aspects of Article Introductions. Birmingham, UK: University of Aston Language studies Unit.Google Scholar
(1986): 'Citation analysis and discourse analysis'. Applied Linguistics, 71, 39–50. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
(1990): Genre Analysis: English in Academic and Research Settings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
(1997): 'English as Tyrannosaurus rex'. World Englishes, 161, 373–382. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
et al. (1998): 'Consider this: The role of imperatives in scholarly writing'. Applied Linguistics 191, 97–121. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
SWALES, J. and H. NAJJAR
(1987): 'The writing of research'article introductions'. Written Communication 41, 175–191. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
TAYLOR, G. and T. Chen
(1991): 'Linguistic, cultural and subcultural issues in contrastive discourse analysis'. Applied Linguistics 131, 319–336. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
THOMPSON, D.
(1993): 'Arguing for experimental ”facts” in science: a study of research article results sections in biochemistry'. Written Communication 101, 106–128. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
THOMPSON, S.
(1994): 'Frameworks and contexts: a genre-based approach to analysing lecture introductions'. English for Specific Purposes 131, 171–187. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
THOMPSON, P.
(1999): 'Examining Ph.D. theses in a corpus', [URL] 14/6/99
UMMUL, K.
(1998): 'Cultural, linguistic and non-linguistic influences in scientific communication: opportunities or limitations?' Paper presented at the 3rd International Conference, Faculty of Language Studies, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 20-22, October 1998.Google Scholar
ZIMAN, J.
(1984): An Introduction to science studies: The philosophical and social aspects of science and technology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

Texts cited

FOUSEKIS, P. and A. PAPAKONSTANTINOU
(1997): 'Economic capacity utilization and productivity growth in Greek agriculture'. Journal of Agricultural Economics 461, 38–51. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
GAVIAN, S. and M. FAFCHAMPS
(1996): 'Land tenure and allocative efficiency in Niger'. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 781, 460–471. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
HESHMATI, A. and S. KHUMBAKAR
(1997): 'Estimation of technical efficiency in Swedish crop farms: a pseudo panel data approach'. Journal of Agricultural Economics 481, 22–37. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
IRWIN, S., C. ZULAUF and T. Jackson
(1996): 'Monte Carlo analysis of mean reversion in commodity futures prices'. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 781, 387–399. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
JONASSON, L.
(1997): 'A policy oriented multi-input and multi-output measure of overall efficiency and its decomposition.' Journal of Agricultural Economics 481, 52–64. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
KIRESUR, S., R. BALAKRISHNAN and M. PRASAD
(1996): 'A model for estimation of the economic sustainability of improved oilseeds crop prediction technologies'. Indian Journal of Agricultural Economics 511, 328–341.Google Scholar
MAHESHWARI, A.
(1996): 'Agricultural growth in a semi-arid area: The case of Karnataka'. Indian Journal of Agricultural Economics, 511, 315–326.Google Scholar
ONAL, H.
(1996): 'Optimum management of a hierarchically exploited open access resource: A multilevel optimization approach'. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 781, 448–459. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
PANDA, R.
(1996): 'Efficiency and productivity: The case of sericulture farms in Tamil Nadu'. Indian Journal of Agricultural Economics 511, 355–362.Google Scholar
RICHARDS, T.
(1995): 'Supply management and productivity growth in Alberta dairy'. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics, 431, 421–434. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Roehner, B.
(1996): 'The role of transportation costs in the economics of commodity markets'. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 781, 339–353. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
SMITH, V. B. GOODWIN
1996 'Crop insurance, moral hazard, and agricultural chemical use'. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 781, 428–438. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
SYLVIA, G. and S. LARKIN
(1995): 'Firm-level intermediate demand for Pacific whiting products: A multi-attribute, multi-sector analysis'. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics 431, 501–518. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
WARR, P. and F. WOLLMER
(1996): 'The demand for LDC exports of primary commodities: The case of the Philippines' Australian Journal of Agricultural Economics 401, 37–49. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
WILSON, W. and D. JOHNSON
(1995): 'North American malting barley trade: Impacts of differences in quality and marketing costs'. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics 431, 335–353. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
WU, J.
et al. (1995): 'An empirical analysis of the relative efficiency of policy instruments to reduce nitrate water pollution in the U.S. Southern High Plains'. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics 431, 403–420. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Cited by

Cited by 8 other publications

Boonyuen, Tharinee & Supong Tangkiengsirisin
2018. The Investigation of the Textual Organization of Research Article Discussion Sections in the Field of Second Language Writing. SSRN Electronic Journal DOI logo
Jin, Guangsa, Chenle Li & Ya Sun
2020. Exploring the Macrostructure of Research Articles in Economics. IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication 63:3 ► pp. 227 ff. DOI logo
Liang, Maocheng
2015. Patterned Distribution of Phraseologies within Text: The Case of Research Articles. In Corpus Linguistics in Chinese Contexts, ► pp. 74 ff. DOI logo
Loi, Chek Kim, Moyra Sweetnam Evans, Jason Miin-Hwa Lim & Songyut Akkakoson
2016. A Comparison Between Malay and English Research Article Discussions. SAGE Open 6:2 ► pp. 215824401665292 ff. DOI logo
Peacock, Matthew
2002. Communicative moves in the discussion section of research articles. System 30:4 ► pp. 479 ff. DOI logo
Razali, Nur Zafirah & Loi Chek Kim
2023. COMMUNICATIVE STRATEGIES USED IN TOURISM AND PHARMACOLOGY RESEARCH ARTICLE DISCUSSIONS. Journal of Language and Communication 10:1 ► pp. 1 ff. DOI logo
Soler-Monreal, Carmen
2015. Announcing one's work in PhD theses in computer science: A comparison of Move 3 in literature reviews written in English L1, English L2 and Spanish L1. English for Specific Purposes 40 ► pp. 27 ff. DOI logo
Soler-Monreal, Carmen
2019. Rhetorical strategies in PhD conclusions of computer science. Revista Española de Lingüística Aplicada/Spanish Journal of Applied Linguistics 32:1 ► pp. 356 ff. DOI logo

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 1 april 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.