Cover not available
Part of
Discourses on the Edges of Life
Edited by Vicent Salvador †, Adéla Kotátková and Ignasi Clemente
[IVITRA Research in Linguistics and Literature 26] 2020
► pp. 97–110

Rhetoric of death in clinical case reports and clinical tales

| Universitat Jaume I

Death is a taboo in Western civilization. Even healthcare fields, which are strongly familiar with the end of life, cannot avoid the tendency to soften the impact caused by talking or writing about death. Like anyone else, healthcare professionals who publish clinical case reports (ccr) tend to use euphemisms. They also have the option to use a technical lexicon that could be perceived as a range of euphemistic expressions. In this chapter we review the place of death in this professional genre. We also compare several aspects of the rhetoric of death in ccr and clinical tales. The latter, though frequently written by medical authors, are intended for a non-specialized public and have a literary communicative purpose.

Keywords: death, rhetoric, clinical case report, euphemism, taboo, clinical tale and Oliver Sacks
Article outline
  • 1.Clinical case reports and clinical tales
  • 2.The taboo of death
  • 3.The reference to death in health settings
  • 4.Reporting death in clinical case reports
  • 5.Telling of death in clinical tales
  • References
  • Corpora cited
Published online: 9 April 2020
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/ivitra.26.07kot
References
Aiken R., Lewis
2000 Death, Dying and Bereavement. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Allan, Keith, and Kate Burridge
2006 Forbidden Words: Taboo and the Censoring of Language. Cambridge/New York: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ariès, Philippe
1981 The Hour of Our Death. New York: Vintage Books.Google Scholar
Bauman, Zygmunt
1992 “Survival as a Social Construct.” Theory, Culture and Society 9: 1–36. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Corless, Inge, Barbara B. Germino, and Mary A. Pittman
(eds) 2003 Dying, Death, and Bereavement. New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company.Google Scholar
Flynn, Eleanor, and Jennifer Philip
2017 “How Doctors Are Taught to Deal with Death.” The Conversation, Oct. 22. [URL]
Gorer, Geoffrey
1967 Death, Grief and Mourning. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.Google Scholar
Heerema, Esther
2018 “Euphemisms for Dead, Death, and Dying: Are They Helpful or Harmful?.” Verywell Health, Feb. 12. [URL]
Herbert, Anthony
2016 “The Role of Euphemisms in Healthcare Communication.” Journal of Healthcare Communications. 1 (2:14): 1–2. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Jenicek, Milos
2001 Clinical Case Reporting in Evidenced-Based Medicine. London: Arnold.Google Scholar
Macián, Cecili
2013 La construcción discursiva de la profesión podológica: Aplicación al análisis de un corpus de revistas especializadas (Ph.D. Thesis). Castelló de la Plana: Universitat Jaume I.Google Scholar
Mornex, René
2001 “Case Reporting in Evidence-based Medicine.” In Clinical Case Reporting in Evidenced-Based Medicine, by Milos Jenicek. London: Arnold.Google Scholar
Nissen, Trygve, and Rolf Wynn
2012 “The Recent History of the Clinical Case Report: A Narrative Review.” Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 3 (87): 1–5.Google Scholar
Nordquist, Richard
2017 “Never Say ’Die’: Euphemisms for Death”. ThoughtCo, Jul. 19. [URL]
Ofri, Danielle
2017 What Patients Say, What Doctors Hear. Boston: Beacon Press (ebook).Google Scholar
Přidalová, Marie
1998 “Proč je moderní smrt tabu?.” Sociologický Časopis / Czech Sociological Review 34 (3): 347–361.Google Scholar
Sacks, Oliver
1987 The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat and Other Clinical Tales. New York: Perennial Library.Google Scholar
1996 An Anthropologist on Mars. New York: Vintage Books.Google Scholar
2011 The Mind’s Eye. New York: Vintage Books.Google Scholar
Salvador, Vicent, Cecili Macián, and Maria Josep Marín
2013 “La construcción de las profesiones sanitarias a través de las revistas especializadas.” Discurso & Sociedad 7 (1): 73–96.Google Scholar
Salvador, Vicent
2016 “The Clinical Case Report as a Discourse Genre in the Context of Professional Training.” In Medical Discourse in Professional, Academic and Popular Settings, ed. by Pilar Ordóñez-López, and Nuria Edo-Marzá, 31–54. Bristol: Multilingual Matters. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Smith, Richard, and Nataly Kelly
2012 “Global Attempts to Avoid Talking Directly about Death and Dying.” BMJ Opinion, Aug. 16. [URL]
Venes, Donald
(ed) 2013 Taber’s Cyclopedic Medical Dictionary. Philadelphia: F. A. Davis Company.Google Scholar
Walter, Tony
1991 “Modern Death: Taboo or Not Taboo?.” Sociology 25 (2): 293–310. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

Corpora cited

1. Forensic Med.: Death Caused by Honey Bee Stings

Anolay, Nezih, M. Nihat Arslan, Bahadır Kumral, and Yalçın Büyük
2014 “Death Caused by Honey Bee Stings: Case Report.” Medicine Science 3 (2): 1305–1314. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

2. Forensic Med.: Sudden Death After a Cold Drink

Burke P., Allen, Muhammad Nasir Afza, Muhammad Nasir Afzal, Diane Scala Barnett, and Renu Virmani
1999 “Sudden Death After a Cold Drink: Case Report.” American Journal of Forensic Medicine & Pathology 20 (1): 37–39. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

3. Neurology: Sudden Death After Medullary Infarction

Wang, Yuh-Jen, and Han-Hwa Hu
2013 “Sudden Death After Medullary Infarction – A Case Report.” Kaohsiung Journal of Medical Sciences 29: 578–581. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

4. Neurology: Intracranial Leptomeningeal Carcinomatosis

Nuvoli, Susanna, Silvia Contu, Bi Llie Joy Pung, Patrizia Solinas, Giuseppe Madeddu, and Angela Spanu
2018 “Intracranial Leptomeningeal Carcinomatosis: A Diagnostic Study with F Fluorodeoxyglucose Positron Emission Tomography/Computed Tomography.” Case Reports in Neurology 10: 45–53. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

5. Gastroenterology: Systemic Reactive Amyloidosis Associated with Castleman’s Disease

Gaduputi, Vinaya, Hassan Tariq, Kanthi Badipatla, and Ariyo Ihimoyan
2013 “Systemic Reactive Amyloidosis Associated with Castleman’s Disease.” Case Reports in Gastroenterology 7: 476–481. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

6. Dermatology: Three Cases of Intravascular Large B-Cell Lymphoma

Araia, Takashi, Yukihiko Katoa, Maki Funakib, Sanae Shimamurac, Naoto Yokogawac, Syoji Sugiic, and Ryoji Tsuboid
2016 “Three Cases of Intravascular Large B-Cell Lymphoma Detected in a Biopsy of Skin Lesions.” Dermatology 232: 185–188. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

7. Ophthalmology: In vivo Confocal Microscopy in Differentiating Ipilimumab

Kiratli, Hayyam, Mehmet C. Mocan, and Murat İrkeç
2016 “In vivo Confocal Microscopy in Differentiating Ipilimumab-Induced Anterior Uveitis from Metastatic Uveal Melanoma.” Case Reports in Ophthalmology 7: 126–131. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

8. Gastroenterology: Malignant Gastric Outlet Obstruction

McGrath, Clare, Adrian Tsang, Harrish Nithianandan, Eric Nguyen, Patrick Bauer, and Kristopher Dennis
2017 “Malignant Gastric Outlet Obstruction from Pancreatic Cancer.” Case Reports in Gastroenterology 11: 511–515. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

9. Ophthalmology: A Case of Mature Natural Killer-Cell Neoplasm

Tagawa, Yoshiaki, Kenichi Namba, Reiki Ogasawara, Hiromi Kanno, and Susumu Ishida
2015 “A Case of Mature Natural Killer-Cell Neoplasm Manifesting Multiple Choroidal Lesions: Primary Intraocular Natural Killer-Cell Lymphoma.” Case Reports in Ophthalmology 6: 380–384. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

10. Gastroenterology: Foreign Material in the Gastrointestinal Tract: Cocaine Packets

Turkel Kucukmetin, Nurten, Bulent Gucyetmez, Tuncer Poyraz, Sadik Yildirim, Gungor Boztas, and Nurdan Tozun
2014 “Foreign Material in the Gastrointestinal Tract: Cocaine Packets.” Case Reports in Gastroenterology 8: 56–60. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

11. Dermatology: Cutaneous Angiosarcoma

Tomasini, Carlo, Marcella Grassi, and Mario Pippione
2004 “Cutaneous Angiosarcoma Arising in an Irradiated Breast.” Dermatology 209: 208–214. DOI logoGoogle Scholar

12. Sacks: A Passage to India

Sacks, Oliver
1987 “A Passage to India.” In The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat and Other Clinical Tales, 153–155. New York: Perennial Library.Google Scholar