The appeal to religious authority
A case-study
This paper analyzes a particular type of support that religious authorities use in their argumentative monologues
on moral and theological matters. In particular, the argumentative monologue given by Joseph Ratzinger as Pope Benedict XVI during
his 2011 visit to the federal parliament in the Reichstag in Berlin will be used as a case study. In his speech, Ratzinger offers
his reflections on the foundations of law starting from his interpretation of a brief story from the First Book of the
Kings in the Old Testament (1 Kings 3:5–10). The entire interpretation assumes the form of an
argumentative text, in which he appeals to an authoritative voice of German-language jurisprudence (Hans Kelsen) and three
Christian religious authorities (St Augustine, Origen of Alexandria, and St Paul). The aim of the study is to assess the pragmatic
strength of Ratzinger’s argumentation and thus verify the authoritative contribution of religious experts in his argumentation, in
which religion and ethics are linked together.
Article outline
- Introduction
- 1.The appeal to authority
- 2.The argumentation scheme
- 3.Ratzinger’s argumentative steps
- 4.First appeal to expert opinion: Saint Augustine
- 4.1First argument based on example: German history
- 5.Second appeal to expert opinion: Origen of Alexandria
- 5.1Second argument based on example: German history
- 6.Third appeal to expert opinion: Saint Paul
- Conclusion
- Notes
-
References
-
Web sites