A Dutch dose of dissent
Exploring the role of gender, education, and culture on Dutch students’ argumentative predispositions
The Dutch are often thought of as direct, verbally aggressive, and argumentative. Yet, evidence for this stereotype is lacking. This study explores argumentative predispositions in the Netherlands. In a survey, Dutch students’ (N = 133) argumentativeness, verbal aggressiveness, argument frames, and conflict personalization were measured. The effects of gender and education were assessed. To explore the role of Dutch culture on argumentativeness, comparisons to U.S. students (benchmark) were made. Overall, Dutch students showed orientations, expectations, and understandings of argumentation as being useful and enjoyable, and seemed to experience argumentation predominantly positive. Males were more aggressive than females, and students in higher professional and university (preparatory) education were more constructive than students in vocational education. In contrast to expectations, Dutch students did not appear more predisposed to argue than U.S. students. Dutch students prioritized prosocial behaviors and professional reflection, thereby tempering aggression in arguing. Thus, argumentativeness is certainly not merely (stereo)typically Dutch.
Keywords: argumentativeness, argumentative predispositions, argument frames, education, gender, Netherlands, students, taking conflict personally, United States, verbal aggressiveness
Published online: 28 October 2020
Bradley, K., and Charles, M.
Demir, Y., and Hample, D.
1992 Dissing the Dutch. All’s Fair in Love and War. Retrieved from http://www.newnetherlandinstitute.org/files/2613/6700/9122/DISSING_THE_DUTCH.pdf
2009 “Beleefdheid is de meeste Nederlanders totaal vreemd”. NRC. Retrieved from https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2009/08/01/beleefdheid-is-de-meeste-nederlanders-totaal-vreemd-11762668-a781449
Eemeren, van F. H.
Hample, D. and Anagondahalli, D.
Hample, D. and Cionea, I. A.
Hample, D. and Dallinger, J. M.
Hample, D., Han, B., and Payne, D.
Hample, D., Lewinski, M., Sàágua, J. and Mohammed, D.
2015 “A descriptive and comparative analysis of arguing in Portugal”. Paper presented to the meeting of the European Conference on Argumentation, Lisbon, Portugal.
2019 “Where does the expression “to get one’s Dutch up” come from and what does it mean?” Retrieved from https://zippyfacts.com/where-does-the-expression-to-get-ones-dutch-up-come-from-and-what-does-it-mean/
2019 “Country comparison”. Retrieved from https://www.hofstede-insights.com/country-comparison/the-netherlands,the-usa/
Hornikx, J. and Hoeken, H.
Infante, D. A. and Rancer, A. S.
Infante, D. A. and Wigley, C. J.
Marrewijk, A. van
2018 “Where Dutch directness comes from”. BBC Travel. Retrieved from http://www.bbc.com/travel/story/20180131-where-dutch-directness-comes-from
2018 “Education and diplomas the Netherlands”. Retrieved from https://www.nuffic.nl/en/subjects/education-and-diplomas-the-netherlands/
Ojajärvi, A., and Kokko, H.
Rancer, A. S. and Avtgis, T. A.
Rapanta, C. and Hample, D.
Santibáñez, C. and Hample, D.
Schmitt, D. P., Realo, A., Voracek, M., and Allik, J.
Schullery, N. M. and Schullery, S. E.
Ten minutes with 2015, March 7. 10 minutes with Geert Hofstede on Long versus Short Term Orientation 01032015. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DqAJclwfyCw
Tops, G. A. J., Dekeyser, X., Devriendt, B., and Geukens, S.
Waheed, M., and Hample, D.
Wijst, P. van der