Dyadic power theory (DPT; Dunbar 2004) predicts that equal and unequal-power dyads will seek to persuade one another differently because they use different control attempts. This paper seeks to expand the theory’s definition of control attempts beyond dominance by examining convergence behavior, topic avoidance, aggression, deception, and affection or support. Participants answered a survey about the way they interact with an interpersonal partner who is lower in power, equal in power, or higher in power than themselves. Results reveal that, consistent with DPT, equal power partners were more likely than high or low power partners to use a control attempt that emphasized equilibrium, and were more likely to use verbal affection and social support. However, equal power partners were also more likely to use deception and they reported their partner was least likely to be deceptive compared to the other power groups. Low power partners were more likely, compared to equal or high power, to be motivated to submit to their partner, to use topic avoidance, and to experience psychological aggression from their partner. The type of relationship moderated several of these effects.
2005“The Chilling Effect in Families and the Pressure to Conceal Secrets.”Communication Monographs 72 (2): 192–216.
Afifi, Walid A., and Laura K. Guerrero
1998“Some Things Are Better Left Unsaid Ii: Topic Avoidance in Friendships.”Communication Quarterly 46 (3): 231–49.
Barrick, Murray R., and Michael K. Mount
1996“Effects of Impression Management and Self-Deception on the Predictive Validity of Personality Constructs.”Journal of Applied Psychology 81 (3): 261–72.
Bevan, Jennifer L
2010“Serial Argument Goals and Conflict Strategies: A Comparison between Romantic Partners and Family Members.”Communication Reports 231: 52–64.
Canary, Daniel J., Jeanette E. Brossmann, Brent G. Brossmann, and Harry Weger
1995“Toward a Theory of Minimally Rational Argument: Analyses of Episode-Specific Effects of Argument Structures.”Communications Monographs 62 (3): 183–212.
Canary, Daniel J., William R. Cupach, and Susan Messman
1995Relationship Conflict: Conflict in Parent-Child, Friendship, and Romantic Relationships. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Canary, Daniel J., Harry Weger, and Laura Stafford
1991“Couples’ Argument Sequences and Their Associations with Relational Characteristics.”Western Journal of Speech Communication 55 (2): 159–79.
Caughlin, John P., and Tamara D. Afifi
2004“When Is Topic Avoidance Unsatisfying? Examining Moderators of the Association between Avoidance and Dissatisfaction.”Human Communication Research 30 (4): 479–513.
Cloven, Denise H., and Michael E. Roloff
1993“The Chilling Effect of Aggressive Potential on the Expression of Complaints in Intimate Relationships.”Communication Monographs 601: 199–219.
Dailey, René M., and Nicholas A. Palomares
2004“Strategic Topic Avoidance: An Investigation of Topic Avoidance Frequency, Strategies Used, and Relational Correlates.”Communication Monographs 71 (4): 471–96.
De Goede, Irene H.A., Susan J.T. Branje, and Wim H.J. Meeus
2009“Developmental Changes and Gender Differences in Adolescents’ Perceptions of Friendships.”Journal of Adolescence 32 (5): 1105–23.
Dunbar, Norah E
2004“Dyadic Power Theory: Constructing a Communication-Based Theory of Relational Power.”Journal of Family Communication 4 (3 and 4): 235–48.
Dunbar, Norah E., and Gordon Abra
2012“A Dyadic Power Theory Explanation of the Demand-Withdraw Interaction Pattern.”
National Communication Association
.
Dunbar, Norah E., and Gordon Abra
2010“Observations of Dyadic Power in Interpersonal Interaction.”Communication Monographs 77 (4): 657–84.
Dunbar, Norah E., John A. Banas, Dariela Rodriguez, Shr-Jie Liu, and Gordon Abra
2012“Humor Use in Power-Differentiated Interactions.”Humor: International Journal of Humor Research 24 (4): 469–89.
Dunbar, Norah E., Amy M. Bippus, A. Allums, and Shawn King
2012“The Dark Side of Humor: The Use of Aggressive Humor in Conflicts in Close Relationships.”
International Communication Association Annual Meeting
. Phoenix, AZ.
Dunbar, Norah E., Amy M. Bippus, and Stacy L. Young
2008“Interpersonal Dominance in Relational Conflict: A View from Dyadic Power Theory.”Interpersona 2 (1): 1–33.
Dunbar, Norah E., and Judee K. Burgoon
2005“Perceptions of Power and Interactional Dominance in Interpersonal Relationships.”Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 221: 207–33.
Dunbar, Norah E., Matthew L. Jensen, Elena Bessarabova, Judee K. Burgoon, Daniel Rex Bernard, Kylie J. Harrison, Katherine M. Kelley, Bradley J. Adame, and Jacqueline M. Eckstein
2014“Empowered by Persuasive Deception: The Effects of Power and Deception on Interactional Dominance, Credibility, and Decision-Making.”Communication Research 41(6): 869–893.
Fainzang, Sylvie
2002“Lying, Secrecy and Power within the Doctor-Patient Relationship.”Anthropology and Medicine 9 (2): 117–33.
Floyd, Kory, and Jonathan M. Bowman
2006“Closeness and Affection in Father-Son Relationships.” In Men in Relationships: A New Look from a Life Course Perspective, ed. by Victoria Hilkevitch Bedford and Barbara Formaniak Turner, 147–63. New York, NY US: Springer Publishing Co.
Floyd, Kory, and Mark T. Morman
1998“The Measurement of Affectionate Communication.”Communication Quarterly 46 (2): 144–62.
Floyd, Kory, Jack E. Sargent, and Mark Di Corcia
2004“Human Affection Exchange: Vi. Further Tests of Reproductive Probability as a Predictor of Men’s Affection with Their Adult Sons.”The Journal of Social Psychology 144 (2): 191–206.
Guerrero, Laura K., and Walid A. Afifi
1995“Some Things Are Better Left Unsaid: Topic Avoidance in Family Relationships.”Communication Quarterly 43 (3): 276–96.
Kaye, Michael
1991“Deception in Communication between Adult Learners and Teachers: Implications for Research and Practice.”Australian Journal of Communication 181: 115–31.
Knobloch, Leanne K., and Katy E. Carpenter-Theune
2004“Topic Avoidance in Developing Romantic Relationships: Associations with Intimacy and Relational Uncertainty.”Communication Research 31 (2): 173–205.
Knox, David, Marty E. Zusman, Kristen McGinty, and Jennifer Gescheidler
2001“Deception of Parents During Adolescence.”Adolescence 36 (143): 611–14.
Lindsey, Lisa L.M., Norah E. Dunbar, and Jessica Russell
2011“Risky Business or Managed Event? Perceptions of Power and Deception in the Workplace.”Journal of Organizational Culture, Communications and Conflict 15 (1): 55–79.
Miller-Day, Michelle A
2004Communication among Grandmothers, Mothers, and Adult Daughters: A Qualitative Study of Maternal Relationships. Routledge.
Rawlins, W.K
1992Friendship Matters: Communication, Dialectics, and the Life Course. New York: Aldine De Gruyter.
Rollins, Boyd C., and Stephen J. Bahr
1976“A Theory of Power Relationships in Marriage.”Journal of Marriage and the Family 38 (4): 619–27.
Roloff, Michael E., and Denise H. Cloven
1990“The Chilling Effect in Interpersonal Relationships: The Reluctance to Speak One’s Mind.” In Intimates in Conflict: A Communication Perspective, ed. by Dudley D. Cahn, 49–76. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Solomon, Denise H., and Jennifer A. Samp
1998“Power and Problem Appraisal: Perceptual Foundations of the Chilling Effect in Dating Relationships.”Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 151: 191–209.
Van Eemeren, Frans H., and Peter Houtlosser
1999“Strategic Manoeuvring in Argumentative Discourse.”Discourse Studies 1 (4): 479–97.
Walker, Amber M
2008“Convergence Communication Scale: Instrument Development and Theory Testing.” Dissertation. The Pennsylvania State University.
Walster, Elaine, and G. William Walster
1975“Equity and Social Justice.”Journal of Social Issues 31 (3): 21–43.
Wang, Qi, Edward L. Fink, and Deborah A. Cai
2012“The Effect of Conflict Goals on Avoidance Strategies: What does Not Communicating Communicate?Human Communication Research 38(2): 222–252.
Weger, Harry, and Daniel J. Canary
2010“Conversational Argument in Close Relationships: A Case for Studying Argument Sequences.”Communication Methods and Measures 4 (1-2): 65–87.
Cited by
Cited by 11 other publications
Bostwick, Eryn, Norah E. Dunbar & Amy Janan Johnson
2022. The Influence of Risk, Location, and Relationship on Refusing an Event Invitation During the COVID-19 Pandemic. Frontiers in Communication 7
Carpenter, Christopher J.
2017. A Relative Commitment Approach to Understanding Power in Romantic Relationships. Communication Studies 68:1 ► pp. 115 ff.
Dunbar, Norah E. & Gordon Abra
2021. A dyadic power theory explanation of the demand‐withdraw interaction pattern. Personal Relationships 28:3 ► pp. 586 ff.
Dunbar, Norah E., Bradley Dorn, Mohemmad Hansia, Becky Ford, Matt Giles, Miriam Metzger, Judee K. Burgoon, Jay F. Nunamaker & V. S. Subrahmanian
2021. Dominance in Groups: How Dyadic Power Theory Can Apply to Group Discussions. In Detecting Trust and Deception in Group Interaction [Terrorism, Security, and Computation, ], ► pp. 75 ff.
Dunbar, Norah E., Katlyn Gangi, Samantha Coveleski, Aubrie Adams, Quinten Bernhold & Howard Giles
2016. When Is It Acceptable to Lie? Interpersonal and Intergroup Perspectives on Deception. Communication Studies 67:2 ► pp. 129 ff.
Gresham, Abriana M., Brett J. Peters, Gery C. Karantzas, Linda D. Cameron, Jeffry A. Simpson & Ana M. DiGiovanni
2023. Associations between power, stress, and dominance in romantic relationships during the COVID‐19 pandemic: Examining curvilinear and within‐person effects. Social and Personality Psychology Compass 17:11
2024. Not all child‐to‐parent violence is the same: A person‐based analysis using the function of aggression. Family Relations
Jia, Guangmei, Yanbo Yao & Daisy X. F. Fan
2023. Travel in your way or in my way? Resolution of conflict between young adult children and their parents during family vacation decision-making. Current Issues in Tourism 26:4 ► pp. 664 ff.
Worley, Timothy R. & Jennifer Samp
2016. Complaint Avoidance and Complaint-Related Appraisals in Close Relationships. Communication Research 43:3 ► pp. 391 ff.
Worley, Timothy R. & Jennifer A. Samp
2019. Dyadic power, marital status, face concerns, and politeness in the context of relational complaining. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 36:4 ► pp. 1367 ff.
Yao, Shuting & Mian Jia
2023. “You-Don’t-Wanna-Mess”: A Case Study of Nonverbal Behaviors in Chinese Freestyle Rap Battles. Western Journal of Communication► pp. 1 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 1 march 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.