Cover not available
Article published In:
Argumentation in Journalism: Professional practices and the public sphere
Edited by Corina Andone and Andrea Rocci
[Journal of Argumentation in Context 5:1] 2016
► pp. 88–111

Economic-financial journalists as argumentative intermediaries

| Institute of Argumentation, Linguistics and Semiotics (IALS)
| University of Lugano
The paper offers a single-case analysis of newsmaking discourse, considering the source, the writing process and the news product from the vantage point of argumentation. The case study examines how a journalist of the business-finance desk of a generalist newspaper copes with the argumentative and persuasive nature of the corporate press releases on financial results on which he depends for his reporting. The paper contributes to the understanding of journalistic practices in the economy-finance desk showing that even within the constrained genre of hard news reporting and despite the epistemic and practical limitations of newsmaking practices the journalist does not renounce to a critical stance towards the argumentation in the source. This is done without fully and explicitly assuming the argumentative roles of antagonist and protagonist of alternative standpoints but rather by rhetorically framing the reader in these roles. Methodologically, the paper showcases a two-way cross-fertilization between argumentation theory and the ethnography of newsmaking. The newsmaking process joining the press release and the newspaper article is analyzed in vivo thanks to the ethnographic methodology of Progression Analysis (PA). Progression Analysis provides a new kind of evidence for argumentative reconstruction, while argumentative reconstruction provides an explicit framework for comparing source and product texts and for laying down the reasoning behind the journalist’s decision making as elicited by (PA).
Keywords: argumentative reconstruction, newsmaking discourse, progression analysis, argumentation in financial disclosures, ethnography of newsmaking, financial journalism, argumentation in the newsroom
Published online: 24 March 2016
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/jaic.5.1.05roc
References
Bell, Allan
1998 “The Discourse Structure of News Stories.” In Approaches to Media Discourse, ed. by Allan Bell and Peter Garrett, 64–104. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Bitzer, Lloyd F.
1968 “The Rhetorical Situation.” Philosophy & Rhetoric 11 (April): 1–14.Google Scholar
Brown, R.M.
1979 “The Gatekeeper Reassessed: A Return to Lewin”. Journalism Quarterly 561: 595–601, 679. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Del Lungo Camiciotti, Gabriella
1998 “Financial News.” In Forms of Argumentative Discourse. Per Un’analisi Linguistica Dell’argomentare, ed. by Marina Bondi, 195–205. Bologna: CLUES.Google Scholar
Clayman, S., and A. Reisner
1998 “Gatekeeping in Action: Editorial Conferences and Assessments of Newsworthiness”. American Sociological Review 63 (2): 178–199. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Cooper, G., and M. Ebeling
2007 “Epistemology, Structure and Urgency: The Sociology of Financial and Scientific Journalists”. Sociological Reseacrh Online 12 (3).Google Scholar
Eemeren, F.H. van, and R. Grootendorst
2004 A Systematic Theory of Argumentation: The Pragma-Dialectical Approach. Cmbridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Eemeren, F.H. van, P. Houtlosser, and A.F.S. Henkemans
2007 Argumentative Indicators in Discourse a Pragma-Dialectical Study. Springer. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Eemeren, F.H. van
2010 Strategic Maneuvering in Argumentative Discourse. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Filimon, I. Agatha
2011 “Argumentative Valences of the Key-phrase Value Creation in Corporate Reporting”. In Proceedings of the seventh conference of the International Society for the Study of Argumentation, ed. by F.H. Van Eemeren, B. Garssen, D. Godden, and G. Mitchell, 461–479. Amsterdam: Sic Sat.Google Scholar
2014 “Two-sided Rhetorical Strategies in Top Management’s Letters to Shareholders and Stakeholders from Corporate Reports”. In Rhétorique et Cognition/ Rhetoric and Cognition, ed. by T. Herman and S. Oswald, 215–248. Bern: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Gieber, Walter
1964 “News is what Newspapermen Make it”. In People, Society and Mass Communication, ed. by Lewis Anthony Dexter and David Manning White. New York: Free Press.Google Scholar
Harcup, Tony
2009 Journalism: Principles and Practice. Thousand Oaks: Sage.Google Scholar
Healy, P., K. Palepu
, and V. Bernard 2003 Business Analysis and Valuation Using Financial Statements: Text and Cases, 3rd ed. Mason, OH: Thomson South-Western.Google Scholar
Henry, E.
2008 “Are Investors Influenced By How Earnings Press Releases Are Written?” Journal of Business Communication 45 (4): 363–407. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hursti, Kristian
2011 “Management Earnings Forecasts. Could an Investor Detect an Unduly Positive Bias on the Basis of the Strength of the Argumentation?” Journal of Business Communication 48 (4): 393–408. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Jacobs, Geert
1999 Preformulating the News. An Analysis of the Metapragmatics of Press Releases. Amsterdam & New York: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Krieg-planque, Alice
2009 “Pour Une Analyse Discursive de La Communication : La Communication Comme Anticipation Des Pratiques de Reprise et de Transformation Des Énoncés.” In Actes Du Colloque « Le Français Parlé Dans Les Médias : Les Médias et Le Politique », ed. by Marcel Burger, Jérôme Jacquin, and Raphaël Micheli, 1–15.Google Scholar
Luciani, Margherita, Andrea Rocci, and Marta Zampa
In press. “Capturing Editorial Gatekeeping through the Analysis of Argumentation in Editorial Conference Discussions”. In Procedeeings of the VALS ASLA conference “Norme linguistiche in contesto“ , Università della Svizzera italiana (Switzerland), 12-14th February 2014 ed. by Matteo Casoni, Sabine Christopher, Alain Kamber, Johanna Miecznikowski, Elena Pandolfi and Andrea Rocci
Martin, James Robert, and Peter R. R White
2005 The Language of Evaluation. New York: Palgrave Macmillian. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Merkl-Davies, Doris M., and Niamh M. Brennan
2007 “Discretionary Disclosure Strategies in Corporate Narratives : Incremental Information or Impression Management ?” Journal of Accounting Literature 261: 116–119.Google Scholar
Miecznikowski, Johanna, Andrea Rocci, and Gergana Zlatkova
2012 L’argumentation dans la presse économique et financière italienne” In Les discours de la bourse et de la finance. (= Forum für Fachsprachen-Forschung), ed. by Laurent Gautier, 65–83. Berlin: Frank und Timme.Google Scholar
Pander Maat, Henk
2007 “How Promotional Language in Press Releases is Dealt with by Journalists: Genre Mixing or Genre Conflict?” Journal of Business Communication 44 (1): 59–95. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Perrin, Daniel
2003 “Progression Analysis (PA): Investigating Writing Strategies at the Workplace”. Journal of Pragmatics 351: 907–921. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2012 “Stancing. Strategies of Entextualizing Stance in Newswriting”. Discourse, Context & Media 1 (2–3): 135–147. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Perrin, D.
2013 The Linguistics of Newswriting. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Shoemaker, Pamela J.
1991 Gatekeeping. Newbury Park [etc.]: Sage.Google Scholar
Skulstad, Aud Solbjørg
1996 “Rhetorical Organization of Chairmen’s Statements.” International Journal of Applied Linguistics 6 (1): 43–62. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Smirnova, A.V.
2009 “Reported Speech as an Element of Argumentative Newspaper Discourse”. Discourse & Communication 3 (1): 79–103. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Van Hout, Tom, and G. Jacobs
2008 “News Production Theory and Practice. Fieldwork Notes on Power, Interaction and Agency”. Pragmatics 18 (1): 59–86. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Van Hout, Tom
2010  Writing from Sources. Ethnographic Insights into Business News Production . PhD dissertation, Universiteit Gent.
Van Hout, Tom, and Felicitas Macgilchrist
2010 “Framing the News: An Ethnographic View of Business Newswriting”. Text & Talk 30 (2): 169–191. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Walsh, Polly
2001 “Prediction and Conviction: Modality in Articles from The Economist.” In Modality in Specialized Texts, ed. by Maurizio Gotti and Marina Dossena, 361–378. MLA-IB. Bern, Switzerland: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
2006 “Playing Safe? A Closer Look at Hedging, Conditions and Attribution in Economic Forecasting.” In Explorations in Specialized Genres, ed. by Vijay K Bhatia and Maurizio Gotti, 351:135–154. Bern etc.: P. Lang.Google Scholar
White, D.M.
1964 [1950] “The “Gatekeeper”: A Case Study in the Selection of News”. In People, Society and Mass Communication, ed. by Lewis Anthony Dexter and David Manning White, 160–172. London: Collier-Macmillan Ltd.Google Scholar
White, Peter R.R.
2004 “Subjectivity, Evaluation and Point of View in Media Discourse”. In Applying English Grammar, ed. by C. Coffin, A. Hewings and K. O’Halloran, 229–257. London: Hodder Arnold.Google Scholar
2006 “Evaluative Semantics and Ideological Positioning in Journalistic Discourse – A New Framework for Analysis”. In Mediating Ideology in Text and Image: Ten Critical Studies, ed. by I. Lassen, 37–69. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2012 “Exploring the Axiological Workings of Reporter Voice News Stories. Attribution and Attitudinal Positioning”. Discourse, Context and Media 1 (2-3): 57–67. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Zampa, M., and D. Perrin
This volume “Arguing with Oneself: The Writing Process as an Argumentative Soliloquy”. In Argumentation in Journalism, ed. by Corina Andone and Andrea Rocci. Special issue of Journal of Argumentation in Context 5 (1): 9–29.Google Scholar
Zampa, M.
2015  News Values as Endoxa of Newsmaking. An Investigation of Argumentative Practices in the Newsroom . PhD Dissertation.Google Scholar
Zlatkova, G.
2012 “Reported Argumentation in Economic-financial News”. In Exploring Argumentative Contexts, ed. by F.H. van Eemeren and B. Garssen, 377–391. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Cited by

Cited by 7 other publications

Burger, Marcel & Richard Fitzgerald
2019. Good Professional Reasons for Bad Journalism Practice: Inventing Audience Contributions in a Live Tv Debate. Journalism Practice 13:10 ► pp. 1185 ff. DOI logo
Palmieri, Rudi
2017. The Role of Argumentation in Financial Communication and Investor Relations. In The Handbook of Financial Communication and Investor Relations, ► pp. 45 ff. DOI logo
Rocci, Andrea
2017. Introduction. In Modality in Argumentation [Argumentation Library, 29], ► pp. 1 ff. DOI logo
Rocci, Andrea
2017. Meaning and Argumentation. In Modality in Argumentation [Argumentation Library, 29], ► pp. 33 ff. DOI logo
Rocci, Andrea
2017. Case Studies of Italian Modal Constructions in Context. In Modality in Argumentation [Argumentation Library, 29], ► pp. 371 ff. DOI logo
Rocci, Andrea & Carlo Raimondo
2017. Conference Calls. In The Handbook of Financial Communication and Investor Relations, ► pp. 293 ff. DOI logo
[no author supplied]
2017. Argumentation in the Newsroom [Argumentation in Context, 13], DOI logo

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 27 november 2023. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.