Article published in:Media, Migration and Human Rights: Discourse and Resistance in the Context of the Erosion of Liberal Norms
Edited by Ekaterina Balabanova and Ruxandra Trandafoiu
[Journal of Language and Politics 19:3] 2020
► pp. 391–412
Migration controls in Italy and Hungary
From conditionalized to domesticized humanitarianism at the EU borders
This article analyses the humanitarianism and securitisation nexus in effect to migration controls in Italy and Hungary. Noteworthy for our purposes is how the humanitarian discourse is undervalued as the EU border states emphasise either full securitisation or else securitisation as a condition for humanitarianism when it comes to border management and refugee protection measures. Our goal is to trace, on the one hand, how politicians conceptualise humanitarianism for the self and for the extension of the self; and, on the other, how they subscribe to humanitarianism for the other as long as the other follows what the self demands. Reflecting on the institutional and discursive nexus of humanitarianism and securitization in effect to migration controls, we trace political narratives of Europeanisation geared to affect the public. We refer to how securitisation challenges humanitarianism while undervaluing human rights for the other and foregrounding human rights for the self.
Keywords: Italy, Hungary, Critical Discourse Studies, securitisation, migration control, humanitarianism
Published online: 07 April 2020
Andrade, Paula García
2014 “Initiatives of EU Member States in Managing Mixed Flows in the Mediterranean and the EU Distribution of Competences.” In The Common European Asylum System and Human Rights: Enhancing Protection in Times of Emergencies, eds. Claudio Matera and Amanda Taylor. The Hague: Centre for the Law of EU External Relations, CLEER Working Papers 2014/7.
Brown, Jamie and Dadu, Saagarika
2018 “Migrant rights in an age of international insecurity: Exploring the narratives of protection and security in European migration and refugee law” [Discussion or working paper] Available online at: https://sas-space.sas.ac.uk/9186/
Casas-Cortes, Maribel, Sebastian Cobarrubias, Nicholas De Genova, Glenda Garelli, Giorgio Grappi, Charles Heller, Sabine Hess, et al.
Chamber of Deputies and Senate of the Republic
2014 “From the Cap Anamur to Mare Nostrum: Humaniarianism and Migration Controls at the EU’s Maritime Borders.” In The Common European Asylum System and Human Rights: Enhancing Protection in Times of Emergencies, eds. by Claudio Matera and Amanda Taylor. The Hague: Centre for the Law of EU External Relations, 21–37. CLEER Working Papers 2014/7.
European Parliamentary Research Service
Frelick, Bill, Ian M. Kysel, and Jennifer Podkul
Guild, Elspeth and Didier Bigo
Kallius, Annastiina, Monterescu Daniel, and Rajaram Prem Kumar
Korkut, Umut and Eslen-Ziya, Hande
Korkut, Umut, Mahendran, Kesi, Bucken-Knapp, Gregg and Cox, Robert Henry
Korkut, Umut and Eslen-Ziya, Hande
Lamour, Cristian and Varga, Renata
Little, Adrian and Nick Vaughan-Williams
Mumby, Denis K. and Robin P. Clair
Murray, Philomena and Michael Longo
2012 “Migration Agreements between Italy and North Africa: Domestic Imperatives versus International Norms.” Available at: https://www.mei.edu/publications/migration-agreements-between-italy-and-north-africa-domestic-imperatives-versus
Pap, Norbert and Glied, Viktor
Sciurba, Alessandra and Filippo Furri
Scott, James Wesley
2018 “Humanitarian Securitization of the 2015 ‘Migration Crisis’. Investigating Humanitarianism and Security in the EU Policy Frames on Operational Involvement in the Mediterranean.” In Migration Policy in Crisis, eds. by, Ibrahim Sirkeci, Emilia Lana de Freitas Castro, and Ulku Sezgi Sozen, 9–30. London: Transational Press.
2017 Securitization as Enacted Melodrama: The Political Spectacle of the Hungarian Anti-Immigration Campaign, ECPR Conference 2017, Available Online https://ecpr.eu/Filestore/PaperProposal/67b21ad4-d637-42c9-99fa-64796cb5284f.pdf
Szalai, Andras and Gabriela Gőbl
2015 Securitizing Migration in Contemporary Hungary, CEU Center for EU Enlargement Studies Working paper. November 2015, Available Online https://cens.ceu.edu/sites/cens.ceu.edu/files/attachment/event/573/szalai-goblmigrationpaper.final.pdf
Szalai, Mate, Csornai, Zsuzsanna. and Garai, Nikolett
2017 V4 Migration Policy: Conflicting Narratives and Interpretative Frameworks, Barcelona Center for Foreign Affairs. Available Online https://www.cidob.org/en/articulos/monografias/illiberals/v4_migration_policy_conflicting_narratives_and_interpretative_frameworks
van Dijk, Teun A.
van Rythoven, E.