Article published in:
Journal of Language and Politics
Vol. 20:2 (2021) ► pp. 254–276

The legitimization of the use of sweat shops by H&M in the Swedish press

| Örebro University , Sweden
| Zhejiang University , China
In the Swedish news-media we find sporadic critical, or reflective, reporting on the production conditions of Swedish ‘sweat-shop’ factories in the Global South, used to supply Transnational Corporations (TNCs). In this paper we carry out a critical discourse analysis, in particular using Van Leeuwen’s social actor and social action analysis, to look at examples from a larger corpus of 88 news reports and editorials from the Swedish press, between 2012–2017, which report and comment on activities of the Swedish company H&M in relation to its production chains. Analysis reveals how these recontextualize events, processes and motives, to represent Sweden and Swedish TNCs as characterized by a benevolent, democratic, humane, form of capitalism, drawing on discourses of a former social democratic Sweden of the 1960s before it became highly neo-liberalized. This nationalism converges with other discourses promoting the exploitation of the Global South.
Keywords: Sweden, nationalism, transnational corporations, sweatshops, fashion industry, working conditions, news
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.Global supply chains and exploitation of workers
  • 3.H&M and its global suppliers
  • 4.The news media and reporting the Global South
  • 5.Theory and methods
  • 6.Analysis
    • 6.1Article 1: ‘Exporting Trade-union rights – H&M and IF Metall want to fight bad working conditions in Cambodian factories’ (SvenskaDagbladet, 23/10/2012)
      • 6.1.1How the participants are represented
        • 6.1.1.1The Swedish participants
        • 6.1.1.2Chinese and other participants
      • 6.1.2What the participants are represented as doing
        • 6.1.2.1What the Swedish participants are doing
        • 6.1.2.2What the factory owners/bosses are doing
        • 6.1.2.3What the workers are doing
    • 6.2Article 2: Now it’s the time for Africa (Sydsvenskan 27/7/2013)
      • 6.2.1The participants in the report
      • 6.2.2What are these participants doing?
  • 7.Conclusion
  • References
Published online: 10 November 2020
https://doi.org/10.1075/jlp.20015.cot
References
Abalo, Ernesto
2015 Through a Post-Political Gaze – On the Ideological Loading of Democracy in the Coverage of Chávez Venezuela. Örebro: Örebro University.Google Scholar
Abousnnouga, Gill, and Machin, David
2013 The language of war monuments. London: Bloomsbury.Google Scholar
Asia Floor Wage Alliance
2016 “Precarious Work in the H&M Global Value Chain”. Retrieved from http://​www​.central​-cambodia​.org​/wp​-content​/uploads​/2016​/05​/Asia​-Floor​-Wage​-Alliance​-H​-M​.pdf
Andersson, Helen
2019 “Nature, nationalism and neoliberalism on food packaging: The case of Sweden”, Discourse, Media, Context, Online FirstGoogle Scholar
Andersson, Jenny, and Hilson, Mary
2009 “Images of Sweden and the Nordic countries”, Scandinavian Journal of History, 34(3): 219–228. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Andersson Åkerblom, Tobias, and Kärnstrand, Moa
2016 Modeslavar: Jakten på Billigare Kläder. Stockholm: Leopard.Google Scholar
Anner, Marc
2015 “Stopping the Race to the Bottom.” Retrieved from https://​ler​.la​.psu​.edu​/gwr​/documents​/AnnerRacetotheBottom​.pdf
Amed, Imran, Balchandani, Anita, Beltrami, Marco, Berg, Achim, Hedrich, Saskia and Rölkens, Felix
2019 The state of fashion 2019: the year of awakening. https://​www​.mckinsey​.com​/industries​/retail​/our​-insights​/the​-state​-of​-fashion​-2019​-a​-year​-of​-awakening
Bain, Mark
2017 “To break our fast-fashion addiction, Greenpeace says we have to embrace ‘true materialism’”. Quartz. https://​qz​.com​/1083816​/greenpeace​-warns​-against​-the​-waste​-of​-fast​-fashion​-advocates​-true​-materialism/
Bellamy Foster, John, McChesney, Robert, and Jamil, Jonna
2011 “The Global Reserve Army of Labor and the New Imperialism”, Monthly Review, 63(6): 1. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Billig, Michael
1985 Banal nationalism. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Blyth, Mark
2011 “The Transformation of the Swedish Model: Economic Ideas, Distributional Conflict, and Institutional Change”, World Politics 54(1): 1–26. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Breazu, Petre. and Machin, David
2018 “A critical multimodal analysis of the Romanian press coverage of camp evictions and deportations of the Roma migrants from France”, Discourse & Communication 12(4): 339–356. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
CARMA
2006 The CARMA Report on Western Media Coverage of Humanitarian Disasters. Retrieved from http://​www​.imaging​-famine​.org​/images​/pdfs​/carma​_%20report​.pdf
Davies, William
2016 The Limits of Neoliberalism: Authority, Sovereignty & the Logic of Competition. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Ehn, Billy
1993 Försvenskningen av Sverige: det nationellas förvandlingar, Stockholm, Natur och kultur.Google Scholar
Foucault, Michel
1979 The Archaeology of Knowledge. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Franks, Suzanne
2005 “Lacking a Clear Narrative: Foreign Reporting After the Cold War” The Political Quarterly 76(s1): 91–101. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Geo-Jaja, M. and Mangum, G.
2001 “Structural adjustment as an inadvertent enemy of human development in Africa’, Journal of Black Studies 32(1): 30–49. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Graham, Phil, Keenan, Thomas and Dowd, Ane-Maree
2004 “A call to arms at the end of history: A Discourse – Historical Analysis of George W. Bush’s declaration of War on Terror”, Discourse & Society 15 (2–3) 199–221. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Greenberg, Josh, and Knight, Graham
2004 “Framing Sweatshops: Nike, Global Production, and the American News Media”, Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies 1(2):151–175. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Guo, L., Hsu, S.-H., Holton, Avery, and Jeong, Sun H.
2012 “A Case Study of the Foxconn Suicides: An International Perspective to Framing the Sweatshop Issue”, International Communication Gazette 74(5): 484–503. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Hafez, Kai
2007 The Myth of Media Globalization. Cambridge: Polity.Google Scholar
International Labour Organization
2014 “Trade Union Manual on Export Processing Zones”. Retrieved from http://​www​.ilo​.org​/wcmsp5​/groups​/public​/-​--ed​_dialogue​/-​--actrav​/documents​/publication​/wcms​_324632​.pdf
Hart-Landsberg, Martin
2013 Capitalist Globalization: Consequences, Resistance, and Alternatives. New York: NYU Press.Google Scholar
Hilary, John
2013 The Poverty of Capitalism: Economic Meltdown and the Struggle for What Comes Next. London: Pluto Press.Google Scholar
Human Rights Watch
2012 “Building a Better World Cup: Protecting Migrant Workers in Qatar Ahead of FIFA 2022”. https://​www​.hrw​.org​/report​/2012​/06​/12​/building​-better​-world​-cup​/protecting​-migrant​-workers​-qatar​-ahead​-fifa​-2022
International Trade Union Confederation
2016 “Scandal Inside the Global Supply Chains of 50 Top Companies”. Retrieved from https://​www​.ituccsi​.org​/IMG​/pdf​/pdffrontlines​_scandal​_en​-2​.pdf
2019 “2019 ITUC Global Index: The World’s Worst Countries for Workers”. Retrieved from https://​www​.ituc​-csi​.org​/IMG​/pdf​/2019​-06​-ituc​-global​-rights​-index​-2019​-report​-en​-2​.pdf
Kimberly, Louis
2005 “The Lament of a Nation: Ghanas SAP Experience”. April 30. http://​www​.ghanaweb​.com​/GhanaHomePage​/features​/artikel​.php​?ID​=80453
Liebelson, Dana
2014 “H&M Plans to Pay Garment Workers Fair Wages. Here’s Why That’s Probably BS”. https://​www​.motherjones​.com​/politics​/2014​/01​/hm​-fair​-labor​-wages/
Lindström, Sverker
2004 Gränslösa Kläder. Stockholm: Bokförlaget Atlas.Google Scholar
Lugo-Ocando, Jairo
2014 Blaming the Victim: How Global Journalism Fails Those in Poverty. London: Pluto Press.Google Scholar
Lugo-Ocando, Jairo, and Malaolu, Patrick O.
2015 “Africa, That Scar on Our Face”. In Blaming the Victim: How Global Journalism Fails Those in Poverty by Jairo Lugo-Ocando, 85–103. London: Pluto Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kress, Gunther
1985 Linguistic Processes in Sociocultural Practice. London: Christie.Google Scholar
Krzyżanowski, Michal and Wodak, Ruth
2008 The politics of exclusion: Debating migration in Austria, Transaction. New Brunswick: NJ.Google Scholar
Machin, David and Mayr, Andrea
2012 How to do Critical Discourse Analysis. London: Sage.Google Scholar
MacLeod, Alan
2018 Bad News From Venezuela – Twenty Years of Fake News and Misreporting. New York: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
McMullen, Anna and Majumder, Sanjita
2016 “Do We Buy it? A Supply Chain Investigation into Living Wage Commitments From M&S and H&M”. Retrieved from http://​labourbehindthelabel​.org​/wp​-content​/uploads​/2016​/02​/DoWeBuyIt​-spreadssml​.pdf
McMurtry, John
1998 Unequal Freedoms: The Global Market as an Ethical System. West Hartford: Kumarian Press.Google Scholar
Newell, Sarah
2018 “H&M’s Hypocrisy: When it comes to brand activism, look at actions, not words”, International Labor Rights Forum https://​laborrights​.org​/blog​/201807​/hm%E2%80%99s​-hypocrisy​-when​-it​-comes​-brand​-activism​-look​-actions​-not​-words
O’Connell, Liam
2020 “Global Apparel Market – Statistics & Facts”, Statista Jan 21. https://​www​.statista​.com​/topics​/5091​/apparel​-market​-worldwide/
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
2017 OECD Economic Surveys: Sweden 2017.Google Scholar
O’Keefe, Kate and Narin, Sun
2013 “H&M Clothes Made in Collapsed Cambodian Factory” https://​www​.wsj​.com​/articles​/SB10001424127887324787004578497091806922254
Parenti, Michael
2011 The Face of Imperialism. Boulder: Paradigm Publishers.Google Scholar
Paczynska, Agnieszka
2006 “Globalization, structural adjustment, and pressure to conform: Contesting labour law reforms in Egypt”, New Political Science 28(1): 45–64. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Peet, Richard
2009 Unholy Trinity – The IMF, World Bank and WTO. London: ZedBooks. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Peterson, Sophia
1980 “A Case Study of Third World News Coverage by the Western News Agencies and The times (London)”. Studies in Comparative International Development 15(2), 62–98. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Preston, Joel, and Leffler, Carin
2016 “ When ‘Best’ is Far From Good Enough. Violations of Workers’ Rights at Four of H&M «Best-in-Class» Suppliers in Cambodia ”. http://​www​.central​-cambodia​.org​/wp​-content​/uploads​/2016​/09​/When​-best​-is​-far​-from​-good​-enough​-ENG​-2016​.pdf
Ross, Robert J.
2004 Slaves to Fashion. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kantar SIFO
(2017) Förtroendebarometer 2017 – Allmänhetens Förtroende för Institutioner, Politiska Partier, Massmedier & Företag” Retrieved from http://​medieakademien​.se​/wp​-content​/uploads​/2017​/04​/Fortroendebarometern2017​.pdf
Siegle, Lucy
2016 “Am I a fool to expect more than corporate green washing?” The Guardian 3rd April https://​www​.theguardian​.com​/commentisfree​/2016​/apr​/03​/rana​-plaza​-campaign​-handm​-recycling
Singh, Ganit
2017 “Fast Fashion Has Changed the Industry and the Economy”, FEE https://​fee​.org​/articles​/fast​-fashion​-has​-changed​-the​-industry​-and​-the​-economy/
Slater, Jennifer
2009 “Sweatshop Labour in News Media: The Economics of a Social Issue”, Footnotes, 21.Google Scholar
Smith, John
2016 Imperialism in the Twenty-First Century: Globalization, Super-Exploitation, and Capitalism’s Final Crisis. New York: Monthly Review.Google Scholar
The Local Europe AB
2012, 2012-03-24 kl. 09:47. Liberalisation fastest in Sweden: Report. Retrieved from https://​www​.thelocal​.se​/20120324​/39864
Therborn, Goran
2018 “Twilight of Swedish Democracy”, New Left Review, 1131, Sept-Oct https://​newleftreview​.org​/issues​/II113​/articles​/goran​-therborn​-twilight​-of​-swedish​-social​-democracy
Van Dijk, Teun
1998 Ideology. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Van Leeuwen, Theo
2008 Discourse and Practice. London: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Van Leeuwen, T. and Wodak, R.
1999 “Legitimizing Immigration Control: A discourse-historical analysis”. Discourse Studies, 1(1), 83–119. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Williams, Kevin
2011 International Journalism. London: Sage. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Wodak, Ruth, de Cillia, Rudolf and Reisigl, Martin
2009 The discursive construction of national identity. Edinburgh University Press: Edinburgh.Google Scholar
Wodak, Ruth
2017 “Discourses about nationalism”, in Flowerdew, John and Richardson, John, Routledge Handbook of Critical Discourse Studies. London: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Wodak, Ruth and Forchtner, Bernard
2014 “Embattled Vienna 1683/2010: Right wing Populism, collective memory and the fictionalization of politics”, Visual Communication (13/2): 231–255. CrossrefGoogle Scholar