Article published in:
Language, Politics and Media: The Hong Kong Protests
Edited by Guofeng Wang and Ming Liu
[Journal of Language and Politics 21:1] 2022
► pp. 81–116

Media portrayals of the Hong Kong Occupy Central Movement’s social actors

Multilevel and critical discourse analysis

| Lingnan University
| The Education University of Hong Kong
We investigated how two English-language newspapers – Hong Kong’s South China Morning Post (SCMP) and the mainland China Daily (CD) – portrayed key social actors (police, students, protesters, and governments) during the Occupy Central/Yellow Umbrella movement. We examined emotional valence, arousal, and dominance characterizations in 1,180 news articles via a multilevel, multivariate outcome regression and critical discourse analysis. The findings reveal that emotional sentiments associated with students and protesters in SCMP were generally more positive than in CD but that this was reversed for the police and the government. Whereas SCMP deployed personal stories to construct a humanized image of protesters and students, CD relied on expert authority, rhetorical questions, and imagined scenarios to convey empathy towards Hong Kong residents, creating a villainized image of protesters. Our mixed-methods approach reveals how SCMP and CD portrayed students differently via the discursive frames of “optimistic dreamers” and “powerless scapegoats,” respectively.
Keywords: Occupy Central, Hong Kong, news media, social actors, multilevel analysis, critical discourse analysis
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.Discursive construction of identity and power
  • 3.Integrating critical discourse analysis with sentiment analysis
  • 4.Data and methods
    • 4.1Data
    • 4.2Variables
      • 4.2.1Sentiment ratings
      • 4.2.2Article attributes
      • 4.2.3Sentence attributes
    • 4.3Analysis
      • 4.3.1Analytic difficulties and statistics strategies
      • 4.3.2Explanatory model
      • 4.3.3Qualitative analysis
  • 5.Findings
    • Valence
    • Arousal
    • Dominance
  • 6.Discussion and conclusions
  • Acknowledgements
  • References
Published online: 22 September 2021
https://doi.org/10.1075/jlp.20030.ho
References
Baldwin, Clare, and James Pomfret
2014 “Hong Kong Students to Boycott Class to Protest China Curbs on Democracy.” Reuters, September 21, 2014. https://​www​.reuters​.com​/article​/uk​-hongkong​-china​/hong​-kong​-students​-to​-boycott​-class​-to​-protest​-china​-curbs​-on​-democracy​-idUKKBN0HF0MN20140920
Barboza, David
2015 “Alibaba Buying South China Morning Post, Aiming to Influence Media.” The New York Times, December 11, 2015. https://​www​.nytimes​.com​/2015​/12​/12​/business​/dealbook​/alibaba​-scmp​-south​-china​-morning​-post​.html
Bennett, Samuel
2019 “Values as Tools of Legitimation in EU and UK Brexit Discourses.” In Discourses of Brexit, ed. by Veronika Koller, Susanne Kopf, and Marlene Miglbauer, 17–31. London: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Benjamini, Yoav, Abba M. Krieger, and Daniel Yekutieli
2006 “Adaptive Linear Step-Up Procedures That Control the False Discovery Rate.” Biometrika 93 (3): 491–507. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Bertsekas, Dimitri P.
2014 Constrained Optimization and Lagrange Multiplier Methods. Cambridge, MA: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Bhatia, Aditi
2016 “Discursive Construction of the ‘Key’ Moment in the Umbrella Movement.” Journal of Language and Politics 15 (5): 551–568. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Brady, Anne-Marie
2008 Marketing Dictatorship: Propaganda and Thought Work in Contemporary China. Plymouth: Rowman & Littlefield.Google Scholar
Bradley, Tamsin
2009 “Religion and Globalisation.” Globalizations 6 (2): 265–279. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Cabalin, Cristian
2014 “The Conservative Response to the 2011 Chilean Student Movement.” Discourse 35 (4): 485–498.Google Scholar
Cabrejas-Peñuelas, Ana B., and Mercedes Díez-Prados
2014 “Positive Self-Evaluation versus Negative Other-Evaluation in the Political Genre of Pre-Election Debates.” Discourse & Society 25 (2): 159–185. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Ceron, Andrea, Luigi Curini, and Stefano M. Iacus
2016 “First-and second-level agenda setting in the Twittersphere: An application to the Italian political debate.” Journal of Information Technology & Politics 13(2): 159–174. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
China Daily
2017 “About Us: China Daily’s Print Media.” China Daily. Accessed January 31, 2020, http://​www​.chinadaily​.com​.cn​/static​_e​/printmedia​.html
Chen, Xinran Andy
2016 “Cultural Framing in Social Movements.” Virginia Review of Asian Studies 181: 1–20.Google Scholar
Fendler, Lynn
2006 “Others and the Problem of Community.” Curriculum Inquiry 36 (3): 303–326. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Flowerdew, John
2016 “A Historiographical Approach to Hong Kong Occupy.” Journal of Language and Politics 15 (5): 527–548. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Flowerdew, John, David C. S. Li, and Sarah Tran
2002 “Discriminatory News Discourse.” Discourse & Society 13 (3): 319–345. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Galtung, Johan, and Mari Ruge
1973 “Structuring and Selecting News.” In The Manufacture of News, ed. by Stanley Cohen, and Jock Young, 62–72. London: Constable.Google Scholar
Goldstein, Harvey
2011 Multilevel Statistical Models. London: Edward Arnold.Google Scholar
Haigh, Maria, Thomas Haigh, and Nadine I. Kozak
2018 “Stopping Fake News.” Journalism Studies 19 (14): 2062–2087. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Henley, Jon
2014 “How the Umbrella Became a Symbol of the Hong Kong Democracy Protests.” The Guardian, September 29, 2014. https://​www​.theguardian​.com​/world​/2014​/sep​/29​/umbrella​-symbol​-hong​-kong​-democracy​-protests
Hollander, Barry A.
1996 “Talk Radio.” Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 73 (1): 102–113. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kennedy, Peter
2008 A Guide to Econometrics. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Khosravinik, Majid
2009 “The Representation of Refugees, Asylum Seekers and Immigrants in British Newspapers during the Balkan Conflict (1999) and the British General Election (2005).” Discourse & Society 20 (4): 477–498. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Konstantopoulos, Spyros
2008 “The Power of the Test in Three-Level Cluster Randomized Designs.” Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness 1 (1): 66–88. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kottasova, Ivana
2015 “Alibaba buys South China Morning Post.” CNN Business, December 11, 2015. https://​money​.cnn​.com​/2015​/12​/11​/media​/alibaba​-south​-china​-morning​-post​/index​.html
Lakoff, George
1991 “Metaphor and War.” Peace Research 231, 25–32.Google Scholar
Lee, Chin Chuan
2010 “Bound to rise: Chinese media discourses on the new global order.” In Reorienting global communication: Indian and Chinese media beyond borders, ed. by Michael Curtin, and Shah Hemant, 260–283. Illinois: University of Illinois Press.Google Scholar
Liu, Lihua
2010 Interpersonal Rhetoric in the Editorials of China Daily. Bern: Peter Lang Publishing.Google Scholar
MacKinnon, David P., Chondra M. Lockwood, and Jason Williams
2004 “Confidence Limits for the Indirect Effect.” Multivariate Behavioral Research 39 (1): 99–128. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Mann, William C., and Sandra A. Thompson
1988 “Rhetorical Structure Theory.” Text: Interdisciplinary Journal for the Study of Discourse 8 (3): 243–281.Google Scholar
Martin, Denis-Constant
1995 “The Choices of Identity.” Social Identities 1 (1): 5–20. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Martin, J. R. and White, P. R. R.
2005 The Language of Evaluation. New York: Palgrave/Macmillan. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Mey, Jacob L., and Hans J. Ladegaard
2015 “Discourse, Democracy and Diplomacy.” Word 61 (4): 319–334. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Miglbauer, Marlene, and Veronika Koller
2019 “The British people have spoken” In Discourses of Brexit, ed. by Veronika Koller, Susanne Kopf, and Marlene Miglbauer, 86–103. London: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Musolff, Andreas
2017 “Metaphor, Irony and Sarcasm in Public Discourse.” Journal of Pragmatics 1091: 95–104. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Naeem, Waqasia, and Muhammad Shaban Rafi
2019 “Linguistic Realization of Legitimation of Power by Zia ul Haq and Pervez Musharraf during the Afghanistan Wars.” Journal of Political Studies 26 (1): 31–57.Google Scholar
Nightingale, Alastair, Michael Quayle, and Orla Muldoon
2017 “It’s just heart breaking: Doing Inclusive Political Solidarity or Ambivalent Paternalism through Sympathetic Discourse within the ‘Refugee Crisis’ Debate.” Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology 27 (2): 13–146. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Nuolijärvi, Pirkko, and Liisa Tiittula
2011 “Irony in Political Television Debates.” Journal of Pragmatics 43 (2): 572–587. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Öztürk, Nazan, and Serkan Ayvaz
2018 “Sentiment Analysis on Twitter.” Telematics and Informatics 35 (1): 136–147. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Phillips, Tom
2016 “Mysterious Confession Fuels Fears of Beijing’s Influence on Hong Kong’s Top Newspaper.” The Guardian, July 25, 2016. https://​www​.theguardian​.com​/world​/2016​/jul​/25​/south​-china​-morning​-post​-china​-influence​-hong​-kong​-newspaper​-confession
Reisigl, Martin, and Ruth Wodak
2009 “The Discourse-Historical Approach (DHA).” In Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis (2nd ed.), ed. by Ruth Wodak, and Michael Meyer, 87–121. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Reyes, Antonio
2011 “Strategies of Legitimation in Political Discourse.” Discourse & Society 22 (6): 781–807. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Richardson, John
2007 Analyzing Newspapers. London: Palgrave. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Scott, Mike
2015 WordSmith Tools (Version 6) Online manual. Lexically. Accessed 20 August, 2019. http://​lexically​.net​/downloads​/version6​/HTML​/index​.html
SCMP Reporter
2015 “SCMP wins eight Human Rights Press Awards.” South China Morning Post, 10 May, 2015. https://​www​.scmp​.com​/news​/hong​-kong​/education​-community​/article​/1791698​/scmp​-wins​-eight​-human​-rights​-press​-awards
Torfing, Jacob
1999 New Theories of Discourse: Laclau, Mouffe and Žižek. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers Ltd.Google Scholar
Vaara, Eero
2014 “Struggles over Legitimacy in the Eurozone Crisis.” Discourse & Society 25 (4): 500–518. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Van Dijk, Teun A.
1996 “Power and the News Media.” In Political Communication in Action, ed. by David L. Paletz, 9–36. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.Google Scholar
1998 Ideology. London: Sage.Google Scholar
2002 “Political Discourse and Political Cognition.” In Politics as Text and Talk, ed. by Paul A. Chilton, and Christina Schäffner, 203–237. Amsterdam: Benjamins. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Van Leeuwen, Theo A.
2007 “Legitimation in discourse and communication.” Discourse & Communication 1 (1): 91–112. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
2008 Discourse and Practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Warriner, Amy Beth, Victor Kuperman, and Marc Brysbaert
2013 “Norms of Valence, Arousal, and Dominance for 13,915 English Lemmas.” Behavior Research Methods 45 (4): 1191–1207. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Wenzl, Nora
2019 “This is about the kind of Britain we are.” In Discourses of Brexit, ed. by Veronika Koller, Susanne Kopf, and Marlene Miglbauer, 32–47. London: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Wodak, Ruth
2001 “The Discourse Historical Approach.” In Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis, ed. by Ruth Wodak, and Michael Meyer, 63–94. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Wodak, Ruth, Rudolf De Cillia, Martin Reisigl, and K. Liebhart
2009 The Discursive Construction of National Identities. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.Google Scholar
Yin, Liangen, and Wang Haiyan
2010 “People-centred myth: Representation of the Wenchuan earthquake in China Daily.” Discourse & Communication 4 (4): 383–398. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Zappavigna, Michele
2019 “Ambient Affiliation and #Brexit.” In Discourses of Brexit, ed. by Veronika Koller, Susanne Kopf, and Marlene Miglbauer, 48–68. London: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar