Article published In:
Journal of Language and PoliticsVol. 22:1 (2023) ► pp.1–21
News on fake news
Logics of media discourses on disinformation
This article presents a qualitative study of media discourses around fake news, examining 288 news articles from two national elections in Denmark in 2019. It explores how news media construct fake news as a national security threat and how journalists articulate their own role in relation to this threat. The study draws on discourse theory and the concept of logics to critically map how particular meaning ascriptions and subject positions come to dominate over others, finding five logics undergirding media discourses: (1) a logic of anticipation; (2) a logic of exteriorisation; (3) a logic of technologisation; (4) a logic of securitisation; and (5) a logic of pre-legitimation. The article concludes that fake news is constructed as an ‘ultimate other’ in Danish media discourses, potentially contributing to blind spots in both public perception and political solutions. This resonates with previous studies from other geo-political contexts, calling for further cross-national research.
Keywords: fake news, disinformation, journalism, discourse theory, election reporting, Denmark, European Parliament
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Addressing a gap in scholarship on fake news
- 3.Data collection and analysis
- 4.Theoretical framework: Discourse Theory and logics
- 5.The Danish media landscape and the threat of fake news
- 6.Five logics of news on fake news
- 6.1A logic of anticipation
- 6.2A logic of exteriorisation
- 6.3A logic of technologisation
- 6.4A logic of securitisation
- 6.5A logic of pre-legitimation
- 7.Discussion
- Acknowledgements
-
Bibliography
References
Bibliography
Aagaard, Thomas
2019 “Facebook til kamp mod udenlandsk indblanding i EP-valget [Facebook to Combat Foreign Interference in the EP Elections].” Berlingske, May 7, 2019. [URL]
Ahrens, Kevin
2018 “Forsvarets Efterretningstjeneste: Rusland vil forsøge at påvirke dansk valg [The Danish Defence Intelligence Agency: Russia Will Attempt to Influence the Danish Election]” Dr.Dk, December 4 2018 [URL]
Ankerhus, Christina, and Sarah Friis Elkjær
2019 “Fire Unge Og Én Ekspert Råder: Sådan Undgår Du at Fake News Påvirker Dig Til Valget [Four Young People and an Expert Offer Advice: This is How You Avoid Getting Influenced by Fake News During the Elections].” Dr.Dk, March 10 2019 [URL]
Bjerager, Erik
2019 “Alle sager har flere sider [All Cases Have Multiple Angles].” Kristeligt Dagblad, April 4 2019 [URL]
Blach-Ørsten, Mark, Jannie Møller Hartley, and Maria Bendix Wittchen
2018 “A Matter of Trust: Plagiarism, Fake Sources and Paradigm Repair in the Danish News Media.” Journalism Studies 19 (3): 1889–98. 
Boffey, Daniel
2018 “European Elections ‘Face Growing Threat of Manipulation.’” The Guardian, October 23 2018 [URL]
Boier, Peter
2018 “Millioner på vej til PET: Skal bekæmpe ‘fake News’ i Danmark [Millions Will Go to the Danish Security and Intelligence Service: Has to Fight ‘Fake News’ in Denmark”].” Dr.Dk, September 4 2018.
Bostrup, Jens
2019 “Partier vil opføre sig pænt i valgkampen [Parties Will Behave Nicely in the Election Campaign].” Politiken, February 8 2019.
Bratich, Jack
2020 “Civil Society Must Be Defended: Misinformation, Moral Panics, and Wars of Restoration.” Communication, Culture & Critique 13 (3): 1–22.
Brattberg, Erik
2019 “The EU’s Looming Test on Election Interference.” Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, April 18 2019 [URL]
Breinstrup, Thomas
2018 “Gør klar til angreb fra kunstig Intelligens, freelancerobotter og danske fake news-millionærer [Get Ready for Attacks from Artificial Intelligence, Freelance Robots and Danish Fake News Millionaires]” Berlingske, December 26 2018 [URL]
Bro, Karen
Brüggemann, Michael, Sven Engesser, Florin Büchel, Edda Humprecht, and Laia Castro
2014 “Hallin and Mancini Revisited: Four Empirical Types of Western Media Systems.” Journal of Communication 64 (6): 1037–65.
Carlson, Matt
2020 “Fake News as an Informational Moral Panic: The Symbolic Deviancy of Social Media during the 2016 US Presidential Election Election.” Information, Communication & Society 23 (3): 374–88.
D’Angelo, Paul, Florin Büchel, and Frank Esser
2014 “Mediatization of Campaign Coverage: Metacoverage of US Elections.” In Mediatization of Politics: Understanding the Transformation of Western Democracies, edited by Frank Esser and Jesper Strömbäck, 156–80. Palgrave Macmillan.
Danish Defence Intelligence Service
2018 “Efterretningsmæssig risikovurdering 2018: En aktuel vurdering af forhold i udlandet af betydning for Danmarks sikkerhed [Intelligence Risk Assessment 2018: A Contemporary Assessment of Foreign Affairs with Significance for Danish Security].” [URL]
*Dengsøe, Ida, and Simon Festersen
2019 “Facebook før Folketingsvalget: »Vi prøver at forberede os på det værste« [Facebook Before the General Election: »We Try to Prepare for the Worst«].” Jyllands-Posten, March 6 2019.
Dyrby, Michael
2019 “Det vigtigste valg i 46 år [The Most Important Election in 46 Years].” BT, May 8 2019.
Eberle, Jakub, and Jan Daniel
2019 “ ‘Putin, You Suck’: Affective Sticking Points in the Czech Narrative on ‘Russian Hybrid Warfare.’” Political Psychology 40 (6): 1267–81.
Egelhofer, Jana Laura, Loes Aaldering, Jakob-moritz Eberl, Sebastian Galyga, and Sophie Lecheler
2020 “From Novelty to Normalization? How Journalists Use the Term ‘Fake News’ in Their Reporting.” Journalism Studies 21 (10): 1323–43.
Egelhofer, Jana Laura, and Sophie Lecheler
2019 “Fake News as a Two-Dimensional Phenomenon: A Framework and Research Agenda.” Annals of the International Communication Association 43 (2): 97–116.
European Commission
2019 “Joint Communication To The European Parliament, The European Council, The Council, The European Economic And Social Committee And The Committee Of The Regions.” [URL]
Farkas, Johan, and Christina Neumayer
2020 “Mimicking News: How the Credibility of an Established Tabloid Is Used When Disseminating Racism.” Nordicom Review 41 (1): 1–17.
Farkas, Johan, and Jannick Schou
2018 “Fake News as a Floating Signifier: Hegemony, Antagonism and the Politics of Falsehood.” Javnost – The Public 25 (3).
2019 Post-Truth, Fake News and Democracy: Mapping the Politics of Falsehood. New York: Routledge.
2020 “Post-Truth Discourses and Their Limits: A Democratic Crisis ?” In Disinformation and Digital Media as a Challenge for Democracy, edited by E. Kużelewska, G. Terzis, D. Trottier, and D. Kloza, 103–26. Cambridge: Intersentia.
Fejerskov, Johan Moe
2019 “Den ultimative guide til fake news: Skurkene, skandalerne og alt andet, du skal vide for ikke at blive snydt i valgåret 2019 [The Ultimate Guide to Fake News: The Villains, Scandals, and Everything Else you Need to Know to Avoid being Deceived in the Election Year 2019].” Politiken, January 5, 2019. [URL]
Foy, Henry, Madhumita Murgia, and Michael Peel
2019 “EU Scrambles to Stop Russian Interference Ahead of May Elections.” Financial Times, February 28, 2019.
Franck, Nicolai
2018 “Skandaleår for Facebook: Men danskerne liker stadig på livet løs [Scandalous Year for Facebook: But Danes still ’Like’ Like Never Before].” Dr.Dk, December 26, 2018. [URL]
Freelon, Deen, and Chris Wells
2020 “Disinformation as Political Communication.” Political Communication 37 (2): 145–56.
Geist, Anton
2019 “Løkke advarede mod fake news, Men hvis nogen har spredt misinformation, er det ham selv og Venstre [Løkke Warned About Fake News: But if Anyone Has Spread Misinformation, it is Him and The Liberal Party].” Information, May 7, 2019. [URL]
Glynos, Jason, and David Howarth
2007 Logics of Critical Explanation in Social and Political Theory. London: Routledge.
Glynos, Jason, David Howarth, Ryan Flitcroft, Craig Love, Konstantinos Roussos, and Jimena Vazquez
Google Trends
Hansen, Michael
2019 “Valg på TV 2: Tættere på vælgernes møde med politikerne [Elections on TV 2: Closer to the Voters’ Encounter with Politicians].” TV2, May 7, 2019. [URL]
Hertz, Mikkel
2019 “Sådan dækker vi valget: TV 2 har et særligt ansvar [This is How We Cover the Elections: TV 2 Has a Special Responsibility].” TV2, May 7, 2019. [URL]
Howarth, David
2015 Ernesto Laclau: Post-Marxism, Populism and Critique. London: Routledge.
Jarlner, Michael
2019 “Sådan bliver 2019: Donald skaber ny ballade. Gud er færdig. Briterne kapper linen til EU og al fornuft. Og så går det galt med økonomien [This is How 2019 Will Be: Donald Creates new Trouble. God is Done. The Brits Cut the Cord to the EU and to Reason. And Then the Economy is in Trouble].” Politiken, January 1, 2019. [URL]
Jensen, Christian
2019a “54.000 nye læsere har fulgt valgkampen på Politiken – Nu begynder det politiske drama for alvor [54 000 new Readers Have Followed the Election Campaign Through Politiken – Now Starts the Real Political Drama].” Politiken, June 7, 2019.
2019b “Fri og fuld digital adgang til Politiken under valgkampen [Free and Full Digital Access to Politiken During the Election Campaign].” Politiken, August 5, 2019.
Karkov, Rasmus
2019 “PET-Chef advarer mod russisk misinformation i dansk valgkamp [Head of the Danish Security and Intelligence Service Warns about Russian Misinformation in Danish Election Campaign].” Berlingske, January. [URL]
Kalsnes, B., K. Falasca, and A. Kammer
2021 “Scandinavian Political Journalism in a Time of Fake News and Disinformation.” In Power, Communication, and Politics in the Nordic Countries, edited by E. Skogerbø, Ø. Ihlen, N. N. Kristensen, and & L. Nord, 283–304. Gothenburg: Nordicom.
Kamph, Peter H.
2019 “Valg på TV 2: Troværdighed og transparens i højsædet [Elections on TV 2: Credibility and Transparency at the Forefront].” Tv2.Dk, May 9, 2019.
KMD
2019 “Halvdelen af vælgerne frygter fake news i forbindelse med folketingsvalget [Half of Voters Fear Fake News in Relation to the General Election].” Kmd.Dk, May 3, 2019.
Kongstad, Jesper
2019 “Cybertruslen vokser: Ny teknologi øger risikoen for ødelæggende hackerangreb [The Cyber Threat is Growing: New Technology Increases the Risk of Destructive Hacker Attacks].” Jyllands-Posten, March 26, 2019.
Kretz, Steffen
2019 “Tidligere FBI-agent: Sådan kan Danmark bekæmpe falske nyheder [Former FBI Agent: This is How Denmark Can Fight Fake News].” Dr.Dk, January 14, 2019. [URL]
Krzyżanowski, Michał
2014 “Values, Imaginaries and Templates of Journalistic Practice: A Critical Discourse Analysis.” Social Semiotics 24 (3): 345–65.
2019 “Brexit and the Imaginary of ‘Crisis’: A Discourse-Conceptual Analysis of European News Media.” Critical Discourse Studies 16 (4): 465–90.
Laclau, Ernesto
2005 On Populist Reason. London: Verso Books.
Laclau, Ernesto, and Chantal Mouffe
2014 Hegemony and Socialist Strategy: Towards a Radical Democratic Politics. London: Verso.
Larsen, Thomas
2019 “Analyse: Claus Hjorts frygt for Paludan varsler valgkamp uden sidestykke i nyere historie [Analysis: Claus Hjort’s Fear of Paludan Signals an Election Campaign Like Nothing We Have Seen in Recent History].” Berlingske, May 4, 2019. [URL]
Lim, Gabrielle
2020 “Securitize / Counter – Securitize: The Life and Death of Malaysia’s Anti-Fake News Act.” New York. [URL]
Lischka, Juliane A.
2021 “Fighting an Indestructible Monster: Journalism’s Legitimacy Narratives during the Trump Era.” Journal of Language and Politics 20 (5): 803–23.
Madsen, Kristian
2019 “Det ømme punkt: Tre tal, der kan få dansk politik til at eksplodere [The Soft Spot: Three Figures that Could Make Danish Politics Explode].” Politiken, June 19, 2019. [URL]
Mollerup, Jacob
2019 “Selvgode medier [Self-Righteous Media].” Politiken, April 4, 2019.
Monsees, Linda
2020 “ ‘A War against Truth’ – Understanding the Fake News Controversy.” Critical Studies on Security.
2021 “Information Disorder, Fake News and the Future of Democracy.” Globalizations.
Newman, Nic, Richard Fletcher, Anne Schulz, Simge Andı, and Rasmus Kleis Nielsen
Nielsen, Jens Beck, and Simon Andersen
2019 “Hjort slog alarm – Men Forsvaret har ikke fundet ét eneste eksempel på russisk påvirkning af valget [Hjort Sounded the Alarm – But the Military has Not Found a Single Example of Russian Interference in the Elections].” Berlingske, June 5, 2019. [URL]
Nordvang Jensen, Christina, and Mads Korsager Nielsen
2019 “Efterretningstjeneste i Ny Trusselsvurdering: Køleskabe På Internettet Er Ny Lækkerbisken for Hackere [Intelligence Agency in New Threat Assessment: Fridges Connected to the Internet Are a New Treat for Hackers].” Dr.Dk, March 25, 2019.
Olsen, Theis Lange
2019 “Forfatter efterlyser daglig ‘temperaturmåling’ på fake news [Author Requests Daily ’Temperature Measurements’ on Fake News].” Dr.Dk, April 2, 2019.
Østergaard, Mette, and Tom Jensen
2019 “Berlingske skyder valgdækningen i gang. Fordin skyld [Berlingske Launches its Election Coverage. For Your Sake].” Berlingske, March 17, 2019.
Ritzau
Rasmussen, Rasmus Kjærgaard
2019 “Trussel: ‘Deep Fakes’ vil påvirke sikkerhedspolitik [Threat: Deepfakes will Affect Security Policy].” Politiken, March 30, 2019.
Rossini, Patrícia, Jennifer Stromer-Galley, and Ania Korsunska
2021 “More than ‘Fake News’? The Media as a Malicious Gatekeeper and a Bullyin the Discourse of Candidates in the 2020 U.S.Presidential Election.” Journal of Language and Politics 20 (5): 676–95.
Santos Rasmussen, Christiern
2019 “Bild jer ikke ind at Danmark ikke kan blive ramt af russiske påvirkningskampagner [Do Not be Under the Illusion that Denmark Could Not be Hit by Russian Influence Campaigns].” May 9, 2019. [URL]
Sjöberg, Alexander, and Johan Moe Fejerskov
2019 “Vi kommer aldrig til at udrydde alle fake news [We Will Never Eradicate all Fake News].” Politiken, May 2, 2019.
Splidsboel Hansen, Flemming
2019 “Den digitale trussel Fra Rusland vokser [The Digital Threat from Russia is Growing].” Berlingske, January 6, 2019. [URL]
Svendsen, Jacob
2018 “FE: Rusland Ventes at Påvirke Folketingsvalget [The Danish Defence Intelligence Agency: Russia is Expected to Influence the General Elections].” Politiken, December 5, 2018. [URL]
Tandoc, Edson C., Joy Jenkins, and Stephanie Craft
2019 “Fake News as a Critical Incident in Journalism.” Journalism Practice 13 (6): 673–89.
Tenove, Chris
2020 “Protecting Democracy from Disinformation: Normative Threats and Policy Responses.” The International Journal of Press/Politics 25 (3): 517–37.
Tolstrup Holm, Line
2019 “Lennart ville lave en alternativ avis, men hans medie er i krise – og det er godt nyt for demokratiet [Lennart Wanted to Make an Alternative Newspaper, but his Outlet is in Crisis – and That is Good News for Democracy].” Berlingske, March 31, 2019. [URL]
Waisbord, Silvio
2018 “Truth Is What Happens to News: On Journalism, Fake News, and Post-Truth.” Journalism Studies 19 (13): 1866–78.
Wasserman, Herman
2020 “Fake News from Africa: Panics, Politics and Paradigms.” Journalism 21 (1): 3–16.
Wright, Scott