Article published In:
Journal of Language and Politics: Online-First ArticlesFrom war to crime rhetoric
The evolution in the presidential framing of the 2019 Chilean social uprising
In October 2019, Chile witnessed an unprecedented social uprising, with millions of citizens rising against social inequalities and injustice. The government employed various strategies to end demonstrations, including the speeches delivered by President Piñera. This study aims to explore the representation of protests and their actors in the presidential discourse and how it evolved over the course of events. Our analysis of themes, discursive actions, and attitudinal appraisals, coupled with a temporal framework, reveals that the initial framing of the uprising as a war shifted to crime rhetoric, possibly in response to negative reactions from the audience. Despite the President adopting a seemingly softer rhetoric later on, our study suggests that violence and division remained prominent themes in his speeches. Examining discourse shifts and fluctuations throughout the timeline of the social upheaval provides a comprehensive understanding of how political discourse is shaped in the midst of an unparalleled social uprising
Keywords: social uprising, social protests, critical discourse analysis, political rhetoric, war and crime rhetoric
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 1.1Political discourse and the delegitimization of protests
- 1.2Analysis of political discourse in Chile and Latin America
- 1.3Incorporating a time frame in discourse analysis
- 2.The present study
- 3.Method
- 3.1Data Selection
- 3.2Data analysis
- 4.Analysis
- 4.1Themes: Violence, public order, and policies
- 4.2Discursive actions: Evaluations, promises, and requests
- 4.3Appraisals: From delinquents to delinquency
- 5.Discussion
- 6.Conclusion
- Notes
-
References
References (60)
Activa
2019 [Online]. [URL]
Alarcón Silva, Mauricio, and Camila Cárdenas Neira
2023 “Análisis
crítico multimodal de textos diseñados para convocar a jornadas de protesta a través de Instagram durante el estallido social
chileno (2019–2020).” Latin American Journal of Discourse
Studies, 2(23): 04–23. 
Alvarez, Sonia
2019 “Feminismos en Movimiento, Feminismos en Protesta. [Feminisms
in Movement, Feminisms in Protest].” Revista Punto
Género, 111: 73–102.
Apablaza-Campos, Alexis
2019 “Estallido social en Chile: discursos de Piñera bajo la lupa de la inteligencia
artificial [Social Outburst in Chile: Piñera’s Discourses Under the Glass of
Artificial Intelligence].” The Conversation. [URL]
Austin, John
1962 How
to Do Things with Words. Oxford University Press.
Baker, Paul
2006 Using
Corpora in Discourse
Analysis. London: Continuum.
Baker, Richard and Nadia Verrelli
2017 “Smudging,
Drumming and the Like do not a Nation Make: Temporal Liminality and Delegitimization of Indigenous Protest in
Canada.” Journal of Canadian
Studies, 51(1): 37–63.
Banks, Chloe
2018 “Disciplining
Black Activism: Post-racial Rhetoric, Public Memory and Decorum in News Media Framing of the Black Lives Matter
Movement.” Continuum, 32(6): 709–720.
Bennett, Joe
2013 “Moralising
class: A discourse analysis of the mainstream political response to Occupy and the August 2011 British
riots.” Discourse &
Society, 24(1): 27–45.
Berrocal, Martina, Michaek Kranert, Paola Attolino, Santos, Julio Antonio Bonatti, Sara Santamaria, Nancy Henaku, Aimée Koffi, Camilla Marziani, Viktorija Mažeikienė, Dasniel Olivera Pérez, Kumaran Rajandran and Aleksandra Salamurović
2021 “Constructing
Collective Identities and Solidarity in Premiers’ Early Speeches on COVID-19: a Global
Perspective.” Humanities & Social Sciences
Communications, 8(1): 1–12.
Barbour, Brandon and Jones, Reece
2013 “Criminals,
Terrorists, and Outside Agitators: Representational Tropes of the ‘Other’ in the July 5 Xinjiang, China
Riots.” Geopolitics, 18(1): 95–114.
Billig, Michael
1995 Banal
Nationalism. London: Sage.
2017 “Banal
Nationalism and the Imagining of Politics.” In Everyday Nationhood:
Theorising Culture, Identity and Belonging after Banal Nationalism, ed. by Michael Skey, and Marco Antonsich, 307–321. London: Palgrave MacMillan.
Bonnin, Juan Eduardo
2020 “Rethinking Populist
Discourse from Latin America: Algorithmic Activism and the Constitution of a People in
Chile.” Trabalhos em Lingüística
Aplicada, 59(1): 469–490.
CADEM
2019 Retrieved
at: [URL]
Cárdenas-Neira, Camila and Pérez-Arredondo, Carolina
2023 “La
construcción de una narrativa mítica multimodal del negro matapacos tras las protestas del 18-O en
Chile.” Literatura y
lingüística, (47): 433–456.
Castro Seixas, Eunice
2021 “War
Metaphors in Political Communication on Covid-19.” Frontiers in
Sociology, 51.
Chatzikoumi, Eirini and González Arias, Cristian
2022 “Polifonía
y pluralismo en el tratamiento del delito en editoriales de prensa durante el estallido chileno del
2019.” Logos, 32(2): 288–306.
De Castella, Krista, Craig McGarty and Luke Musgrove
2009 “Fear
Appeals in Political Rhetoric about Terrorism: An Analysis of Speeches by Australian Prime Minister
Howard.” Political
Psychology, 30(1): 1 – 26.
Deppermann, Arnulf and Simona Pekarek Doehler
2021 “Longitudinal
Conversation Analysis – Introduction to the Special Issue.” Research on Language and Social
Interaction, 54(2): 127–141.
Sehnbruch, Kirsten and Sofia Donoso
(2020) “Social
protests in Chile: Inequalities and other inconvenient truths about Latin America’s poster
child”. Global Labour
Journal, 11(1): 52–58.
Drury, John and Stephen Reicher
2000 “Collective
Action and Psychological Change: The Emergence of New Social Identities.” British Journal of
Social Psychology, 391: 579–604.
Drury, John
2002 “ ‘When
the Mobs are Looking for Witches to Burn, Nobody’s Safe’: Talking About the Reactionary
Crowd.” Discourse &
Society, 131: 41–73.
Esch, Joanne
2010 “Legitimizing
the “War on Terror”: Political Myth in Official-Level Rhetoric.” Political
Psychology, 311: 357–391.
Fairclough, Norman
2001 “Critical
discourse analysis as a method in social scientific
research.” In Methods in critical discourse
analysis ed. by Ruth Wodak and Michael Meyer. London: Sage.
Faúndez, Ximena and Ximena Goecke
2015 “Psychosocial
Trauma Transmission and Appropriation in Grandchildren of Former Political Prisoners of the Civic–Military Dictatorship in
Chile (1973–1990).” Journal of Social Science
Education. 14(2): 26–39.
Féliz de Souza, Natalia
2019 “When
the Body Speaks (to) the Political: Feminist Activism in Latin America and the Quest for Alternative Democratic
Futures.” Contexto
Internacional, 41(1): 89–112.
Gaete, Ayleen, Pablo Iturrieta, Carlos Peña, Hugo Soto, Carla Valenzuela, Violeta Veliz, Felipe Vera
Godoy Echiburú, Gerardo, & Badillo Vargas, Carolina
2021 “Estados
de Excepción ante enemigos microscópicos y poderosos: análisis crítico del discurso de dos cadenas nacionales del presidente
Piñera.” Logos, 31(1): 119–137.
Halliday, Michael
1994 An
Introduction to Functional Grammar. London: Edward Arnold.
Hanisch-Wolfram, Alexander
2010 “Totalitarian
Propaganda as Discourse: A Comparative Look at Austria and France in the Fascist
Era.” In K. Postoutenko (Ed.), Totalitarian
Communication: Hierarchies, Codes and
Messages, 197–216. Bielefeld: transcript Verlag.
Hart, Christopher
2018 “Event-Frames
Affect Blame Assignment and Perception of Aggression in Discourse on Political Protests: An Experimental Case Study in
Critical Discourse Analysis.” Applied
Linguistics, 39(3): 400–421.
Hodges, Adam
2011 The
“War on terror” narrative discourse and intertextuality in the construction and contestation of sociopolitical
reality. Oxford University Press.
Holland, Janet
2011 “Timescapes:
Living a Qualitative Longitudinal Study.” Forum: Qualitative Social
Research, 12(3).
Ivanova, Anna and Almendras, Jorge Jocelin
2021 “Media
Representation Of October, 2019 Social Outbreak In
Chile.” Universum, 36(2): 521–538.
Lakoff, G.
(2007) No
pienses en un elefante: Lenguaje y debate
político. Madrid: Complutense
Loadenthal, Michael
2020 “Now
That Was A Riot!: Social Control in Felonious Times.” Global
Society, 34 (1): 128–144,
Maani, Bashar, Laith Hassan, Marwan Alqaryouti and Kamal Ahmad Alruzzi
2022 “The
Positive-self and Negative-other Representation in Bashar Al-Assad’s First Political Speech After the Syrian
Uprising.” Theory and Practice in Language
Studies, 12(10): 2201–2210.
Martin, Jim and Peter White
2005 The
Language of Evaluation. Appraisal in English. London and New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Mayorga Rojel, Alberto and Luis Nitrihual Valdebenito
2018 “The
socioimaginary construction of social protest in the discourse of the Latin American press: analysis of the editorials of El
Mercurio (Chile) and la nación (Argentina) newspapers in the context of the Argentine crisis of
2001.” Anagramas Rumbos y Sentidos de la
Comunicación, 17(33): 175–194.
McLeod, D. M.
2007 News
coverage and social protest: how the media’s protest paradigm exacerbates social
conflict. Journal of Dispute
Resolution, (1): 185–194.
Mourão, Rachel
2021 “When
the Right Protests: How Journalists Cover Conservative Movements.” Journalism
Practice, 17:6: 1232–1249.
Navarro, Federico and Carlos Tromben
2019 “’Estamos en guerra contra un enemigo poderoso, implacable’: los discursos de Sebastián Piñera y la revuelta
popular en Chile [‘We are at War Against a Relentless Enemy’: Sebastián
Piñera’s discourses and the popular revolt in Chile].” Literatura y
lingüística, 401: 295–324.
O’Connor, Cliodhna and Helene Joffe
2020 “Intercoder
Reliability in Qualitative Research: Debates and Practical Guidelines.” International Journal
of Qualitative Methods, 191.
Oddo, John
2011 “War
Legitimation Discourse: Representing ‘Us’ and ‘Them’ in four U.S. Presidential
Addresses.” Discourse &
Society, 22(3): 287–314.
Rak, Joanna
2021 “Framing
Enemies by the State Television: Delegitimization of Anti-government Protest Participants During the First Wave of the
Pandemic in Poland.” Journal of Contemporary Central and Eastern
Europe, 29(2–3): 157–175.
Reicher, Stephen, Alexander Haslam and Michael Platow
2018 “Shared
Social Identity in Leadership”. Current Opinion in
Psychology, 231: 129–133.
Saldaña, Johnny
2013 The
Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers. Los Angeles, California: Sage.
Searle, John
1969 Speech
Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy of Language. Cambridge University Press.
Somma, Nicolás, Bargsted, Matías, Disi Pavlic Rodolfo and Medel, Rodrigo M.
2021 “No water in the oasis:
the Chilean Spring of 2019–2020”. Social Movement
Studies, 20(4): 495–502,
Time
2019 “18 Killed as Hundreds
of Thousands of Protestors Take to the Streets in Chile. Here’s What to Know.” Retrieved
at: [URL]
Twitter Archive
2019 Retrieved
at: [URL]
Van Dijk, Teun
2001 “The
Multidisciplinarity of Critical Discourse Analysis: an Argument in Favor of
Diversity.” In Methods of Critical Discourse
Analysis ed. by Ruth Wodak & Michael Meyer. London: SAGE, 143–177.
2006 “Ideology
and Discourse Analysis.” Journal of Political
Ideologies, 11 (2): 115–140.
2008 Discourse
& Power. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Valenzuela-Valenzuela, Amanda and Ricardo Cartes-Velásquez
(2020) “Metáforas
presidenciales durante el estallido social chileno de 2019.” Comunicación y
medios 29(42): 44–55.
Wodak, Ruth
1996 Disorders
of
Discourse. London: Longman.
Wodak, Ruth, Rudolf De Cillia, Martin Reisigl and Karin Liebhart
2010 “The
Discursive Construction of National Identity.” Lang
Policy, 91: 273–275.
Wodak, Ruth
2015 The
Politics of Fear. What Right-wing Populist Discourses
Mean. London: Sage.
Zanotti, Lisa and Kenneth Roberts
(2021) “(Aún)
la excepción y no la regla: La derecha populista radical en América Latina.” Revista
Uruguaya de Ciencia
Política, 30(1), 23–48.