Circulation of the World War II / Holocaust analogy in the 1999 Kosovo intervention
Articulating a vocabulary for international conflict
Benjamin R. Bates | School of Communication Studies, Ohio University
This essay offers an analysis of the circulation of World War II and Holocaust analogies in discourses about American military involvement in Kosovo. The essay argues that the World War II/Holocaust analogy provided the public with a new vocabulary for understanding the situation in Kosovo. The essay uses Bill Clinton’s speeches about Kosovo during the first week of American intervention as a representative anecdote for discussing the analogy and its rhetorical force. The essay then probes the circulation of the analogy in other governmental, media, and public opinion outlets. By comparing Kosovo 1999 to Europe 1945, the analogy offers descriptive and prescriptive reasons for American involvement that encourage public approval of military intervention. The essay offers conclusions and implications of this analysis for the understanding of the relationships among rhetoric, public opinion, and international conflict.
Anderson, William D., and Kernek, Sterling J. 1985. How “realistic” is Reagan’s diplomacy?Political Science Quarterly 100(3), 389—409.
Babington, Charles and Dewar, Helen. 1999, March 24. President pleads for support. Washington Post, A1.
Baird, A. Craig. 1950. Argumentation, Discussion, and Debate. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Beck, Robert J. 1989. Munich’s lessons reconsidered. International Security 14(2), 161—191.
Bombing begins: If Kosovo is so important, why not plan on ground troops?1999, March 25. Newsday, A54.
Branham, Robert J. 1991. Debate and Critical Analysis: The Harmony of Conflict. Hillsdale, NJ: L. Erlbaum Associates.
Burke, Kenneth. 1969. Grammar of Motives. Berkeley: University of California.
Can NATO airstrikes convince Serbs to discuss peace in Kosovo?1999, March 29. CNN Talk-Back Live, Transcript # 99032900V14.
CBS poll: Support grows for strikes. 1999, April 7. Available: [URL].
Conflict in Kosovo. 1999, March 29. FOX Hannity and Colmes, Transcript # 032901cb.253.
Cullen, Kevin. 1999, March 27. Despite memories of WWII, a return to combat. Boston Globe, A8.
Dauber, Cori. 2001. The shots seen ‘round the world: The impact of the Mogadishu photographs on American foreign policy. Rhetoric and Public Affairs 4(4), 653—687.
Decker, Cathleen. 1999, March 26. Public narrowly backs US role in airstrikes. Available: LATimes.com.
DeRouen, Karl R., Jr. 1995. The indirect link: Politics, the economy and the use of force. Journal of Conflict Resolution 39(4), 671—696.
Dutter, Lee E. 1991. The seventy-five years’ war, 1914—1989: Some observations on the psychology of American foreign policy-making during the 20th century. Political Psychology 12(3), 523—553.
Edelman, Murray. 1998. Constructing the Political Spectacle. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Ehninger, Douglas, and Brockriede, Wayne. (1963). Decision by Debate. New York: Dodd, Mead.
Elliott, Michael. 1999, April 5. Mission: Uncertain. Newsweek 1341, 29.
Escaping the horrors of Kosovo. 1999, March 29. ABC World News Tonight, Transcript # 99032903-j04.
Freeley, Austin J. 1993. Argumentation and Debate: Critical Thinking for Reasoned Decision Making. Belmont: Wadsworth.
Hedges, Chris. 1999, March 28. The world: Fog of war. New York Times, D1
.
Hoffman, Stanley. 1977. The hell of good intentions. Foreign Policy 291, 3—26.
Holsti, Ole R. 1992. Public opinion and foreign policy: Challenges to the Almond-Lippman consensus. International Studies Quarterly 36(4), 439—466.
Holsti, Ole R. 1996. Public Opinion and American Foreign Policy. Ann Ann: University of Michigan Press.
James, Patrick, and O’Neal, John R. 1991. The influence of domestic and international politics on the president’s use of force. Journal of Conflict Resolution 35(2), 307—333.
Jervis, Robert. 1976. Perception and Misperception in International Politics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Khong, Yuen Foong. 1992. Analogies at war: Korean, Munich, Dien Bien Phu, and the Vietnam Decisions of 1965. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Khong, Yuen Foong. 1999. Seduction by analogy in Vietnam: The Malaya and Korea analogies. In: G. John Ikenberry (ed.). American Foreign Policy: Theoretical Essays. New York: Long-man, 523—532.
Kosovo 101. 1999, March 26. Times Union, A10.
Kosovo Conflict. 1999, Mar 23. Fox: The Crier Report, Transcript # 032301cb.252.
Kosovo: Press on. 1999, March 26. Los Angeles Times, B6.
Kosovo’s tragedy: NATO must prevent a wider Balkan war. 1999, March 30. San Diego Union-Tribune. B6—8.
Langer, Gary. 1999a, March 17. Americans oppose bombing. Available: ABCNews.com.
Langer, Gary. 1999b, March 27. American support grows. Available: ABCNews.com.
Levy, Jack S. 1994. Learning and foreign policy: Sweeping a conceptual minefield. International Organization 48(2), 279—312.
Lian, Bradley, and O’Neal, John. 1993. The president’s use of military force and public opinion. Journal of Conflict Resolution 37(2), 277—301.
Los Angeles Times. 1999. Study #425: Los Angeles Times poll alert. Los Los: Times-Mirror Corporation.
Lynch, Colum. 1999, March 26. Parallel cited by US is doubted. Boston Globe, A14.
Matray, James I. 1979. Truman’s plan for victory: National self-determination and the thirty-eighth parallel decision in Korea. Journal of American History 66(2), 314—333.
May, Ernest. 1973. Lessons of the Past: The Use and Misuse of History in American Foreign Policy. New York: Oxford University Press.
McCroskey, James C., and Combs, Walter H. 1969. The effects of the use of analogy on attitude change and source credibility. Journal of Communication 19(4), 333—339.
Miga, Andrew. 1999, March 25. Kosovo crisis: Clinton prepares nation for long attack. Boston Herald, 4.
Monroe, Alan D. 1998. Public opinion and public policy, 1980—1993. Public Opinion Quarterly 62(1), 6—28.
Morgan, T. Clifton, and Bickers, Kenneth N. 1992. Domestic discontent and the external use of force. Journal of Conflict Resolution 36(1), 25—53.
Mueller, John E. 1973. War, Presidents, and Public Opinion. New York: John Wiley.
NATO changes tactics. 1999, March 29. CBS This Morning, 7:00 A.M. ET.
No quick fixes can be promised in Kosovo. 1999, March 26. Dayton Daily News, 14A.
Noon, David Hoogland. 2004. Operation enduring analogy: World War II, the war on terror, and the uses of historical memory. Rhetoric and Public Affairs 7(2), 339—366.
Ostrom, Charles, W., Jr., and Job, Brian L. 1986. The president and the political use of force. American Political Science Review 80(2), 541—566.
Papandreou, Margarita. 1999. The war that should not have been. New Perspectives Quarterly 16(5), 41—43.
Perelman, Chaim, and Olbrechts-Tyteca, Lucie. 1969. The New Rhetoric: A Treatise on Argumentation. Notre Notre: University of Notre Dame Press.
Phillips, Leslie, Hicks, William S., and Springer, Douglas R. 1996. Basic Debate (4th ed). New York: NTC.
Pinkerton, James B. 1999, March 26. Conflicting lessons of war. Minneapolis Star-Tribune, 29A1.
Powell, Stewart M, and Freedman, Dan. 1999, March 25. Clinton cites WWII in justifying strikes. New Orleans Times-Picayune, A7.
Pristina in chaos. 1999, March 28. ABC World News Sunday, Transcript # 99032803-j06.
Refugees fleeing Serbia as bombing continues. 1999, March 29. NBC Nightly News, 6:30 P.M. ET.
Report from Kosovo. 1999, March 26. ABC World News Tonight, Transcript # 99032602-j04.
Rock, William R. 1997. Appeasement. In The encyclopedia of U.S. foreign relations (Vol. 11, pp. 84—85). New York: Oxford University Press.
Rosenberg, J. Philipp. 1986. Presidential beliefs and foreign policy decision-making: Continuity during the Cold War era. Political Psychology 7(4), 733—751.
Russett, Bruce. 1990. Economic decline, electoral pressure, and the initiation of external conflict. In: Charles S. Gochman and Alan Ned Sabosky (eds.). The Prisoners of War. Lexington: Lexington Books, 123—140.
Sacksteder, William. 1974. The logic of analogy. Philosophy and Rhetoric 7(4), 234—252.
Sacksteder, William. 1979. Analogy: Justification for logic. Philosophy and Rhetoric 12(1), 21—40.
Scott, Robert L., and Klumpp, James F. 1984. A dear searcher for comparisons: The rhetoric of Ellen Goodman. Quarterly Journal of Speech 70(1), 69—79.
Secretary Albright Denounces Yugoslav President’s Ethnic Cleansing in Kosovo. 1999, March 23. Larry King Live, Transcript # 99032300V22.
Shepard, Scott. 1999, March 29. NATO goes after tanks, troops. Atlanta Journal and Constitution. 1A.
Snow, Tony. 1999, March 25. A war to save face. Denver Post, B11.
Snyder, Glenn H. and Paul Diesing. 1977. Conflict among Nations: Bargaining, Decision Making, and System Structure in International Crises. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Stables, Gordon Wilson. 1998. The Lessons of Vietnam as an American Social Myth: President Clinton’s Campaign for a Bosnian Troop Deployment. MA MA: University of Georgia.
Stakeout remarks by Senator Patrick Leahy. 1999, March 23. Federal News Service, wire.
Stuckey, Mary E. 1992. Remembering the future: Rhetorical echoes of World War II and Vietnam in George Bush’s public speech on the Gulf War. Communication Studies 43(4), 246—256.
The bombing begins. 1999, March 24. Newshour with Jim Lehrer, Transcript #6391.
The crisis in Kosovo. 1999, March 24. ABC Nightline, Transcript # 99032401-j07.
Thompson, Kenneth W. 1981. Power, force, and diplomacy. Review of Politics 43(3), 410—435.
USA Today/CNN/Gallup. 1999, April 8. USA Today/CNN/Gallup poll results. [URL].
Vertzberger, Yaacov Y. I. 1990. The World in Their Minds: Information Processing, Cognition, and Perception in Foreign Policy Decision-Making. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Vosniadou, Stella and Andrew Ortony. 1989. Similarity and Analogical Reasoning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Walt, Steven M. 2000. Two cheers for Clinton’s foreign policy. Foreign Affairs 79(1), 63—79.
Why America had no choice but to go to war in Kosovo. 1999, March 28. 60 Minutes, 7:00 P.M. ET.
Yugoslav President Solobodan Milosevic. 1999, March 25. ABC Good Morning America, Transcript # 99032515-j01. Speeches
Clinton, William J. 1999b, March 24. Statement by the President to the Nation (1). Available: [URL].
Clinton, William J. 1999c, March 24. Statement by the President to the Nation (2). Available: [URL].
Clinton, William J. 1999d, March 25. Videotaped Remarks by the President to the Serbian People. Available: [URL].
Clinton, William J. 1999e, March 27. Radio Address of the President to the Nation. Available: [URL].
Clinton, William J. 1999f, March 30. Remarks by the President at electronic Industries Alliance Dinner. Available: [URL].
Clinton, William. J. 1999a, March 23. Remarks by the President to AFSCME Biennial Convention. Available: [URL].
DoD news briefing. 1999a, March 23. Department of Defense. Available: [URL]
DoD news briefing. 1999b, March 24. Department of Defense. Available: [URL]
Press briefing by Joe Lockhart. 1999a, March 29. Office of the White House Press Secretary. >Available: [URL]
Press briefing by Joe Lockhart. 1999b, March 24. Office of the White House Press Secretary. Available: [URL]
Press conference on “Kosovo”. 1999, March 25. Office of the Spokesman, U.S. Department of State. [URL]
Cited by (9)
Cited by nine other publications
Lynch, John
2024. To Know Me Is to Exonerate Me: Appeals to Character in Defense of the Willowbrook Hepatitis Study. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine
Kushi, Sidita
2023. JUST ANOTHER CIVIL WAR?. World Affairs 186:2 ► pp. 284 ff.
Rimaitė-Beržiūnienė, Viktorija
2022. Visual Securitization: Commemorating the Partisan War in Lithuanian Foreign and Security Policy. Politologija 106:2 ► pp. 11 ff.
Pérez Rastrilla, Laura
2021. A Proposal for a Qualitative Analysis of the Media Discourse on the Bombing of Yugoslavia. In Researching Yugoslavia and its Aftermath [Societies and Political Orders in Transition, ], ► pp. 205 ff.
Lynch, John A., Aaron J. Goldenberg, Nanibaa’ A. Garrison & Kyle B. Brothers
2020. Analogies in Genomics Policymaking: Debates and Drawbacks. The American Journal of Human Genetics 107:5 ► pp. 797 ff.
Makhortykh, Mykola
2020. Historical memory and securitisation of the Russian intervention in Syria. International Politics 57:6 ► pp. 1063 ff.
Drury, Jeffrey P. Mehltretter
2018. Beyond “Rhetorical Agency”: Skutnik’s Story in the 1982 State of the Union Address. Western Journal of Communication 82:1 ► pp. 40 ff.
Valentino, Benjamin A. & Ethan M. Weinberg
2017. More than words? “Genocide,” Holocaust analogies, and public opinion in the United States. Journal of Human Rights 16:3 ► pp. 276 ff.
Oleinik, Anton
2015. The language of power: a content analysis of presidential addresses in North America and the Former Soviet Union, 1993–2012. International Journal of the Sociology of Language 2015:236
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 5 july 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.