No way forward without consensus
Church leaders envision ‘The Zimbabwe we want’
This paper discusses a document produced in 2006 by church leaders which claimed to present a “vision” of “a way forward” in the ongoing crisis in Zimbabwe. We suggest that the document served rather to reinforce the status quo, specifically the hegemony of Mugabe’s government. We argue that, by insisting that the greatest problem in Zimbabwe is “lack of a national vision”, the document promoted consensus, which resonated with Mugabe’s own position. We suggest that four major strategies were used to achieve this: assertion of the primarily spiritual nature of Zimbabwe’s crisis; insistence on the shared responsibility of all Zimbabweans; obfuscation of agency for the crisis and delegitimization of political opposition as a route to change. Finally, we point out that these strategies failed, as the document in its original form was censored before its launch, illustrating the tendency for President Mugabe to give the impression of opening democratic space, only to close it off.
Keywords: Zimbabwe crisis, church-state relations, national vision, textual strategies, consensus, spiritual values, shared responsibility, agency
Published online: 15 December 2009
Catholic Commission for Justice and Peace (CCJP) and Legal Resources Foundation (LRF)
1999 Breaking The Silence, Building True Peace. A report on the disturbances in Matabele-land and the Midlands, 1980—1988. A Summary. Harare: CCJP & LDF. http://www.kubatana.net/html/archive/hr/990401ccjplrf.asp?sector=CACT
Chilton, Paul and Schäffner, Christina
Dorman, Sara R.
Huckin, Thomas N.
Miller, Donna R.
2004 “�to meet our common challenge”: ENGAGEMENT strategies of alignment and alienation in current US international discourse. Textus XVII/1. www.grammatics.com/appraisal/millerD/miller-bush-gore.doc accessed 7 June 2007.
Morrison, Andrew D. and Love,. Alison M.
2005 Prospects for National Dialogue in Zimbabwe. www.ijr.org.za/paste-vents/transformingconflictsfolder/conferencepapers/raftopoulos accessed 5 August 2007 Ranger, Terence O 1985 Peasant Consciousness and Guerrilla War in Zimbabwe. Oxford: James
Currey Ltd “Rift erupts over church report in Zim”
2006 http://www.zimbabwejournalists.com/story.php?art_id=1353&cat=2 accessed 17 May 2007.
Sithole, Masipula and Makumbe, John
2006 National Vision document buys time for government The Standard, 19 November 2006 http://www.kubatana.net/html/archive/opin/061119pw.asp?sector=RELIG&year=2006&range_start=1 accessed 25 July 2008
White, Peter R.R.
2002 Appraisal: the language of attitudinal evaluation and intersubjective stance. http://www.grammatics.com/appraisal accessed 14 September 2009
Zimbabwe Catholic Bishops Conference
Evangelical Fellowship of Zimbabwe & Zimbabwe Council of Churches. September 18, 2006. The Zimbabwe We Want: “Towards a National Vision for Zimbabwe”. http://kubatana.net/html/archive/relig/060918zcbc.asp?spec_ code=061103visiondex& sector=RELIG&year=2006&range_start=1 accessed 8 August, 2007
Zimbabwe Catholic Bishops’ Conference
2007 God Hears the Cries of the Oppressed. Pastoral Letter. www.zimbabwejournalists.com/uploaddocs/Catholic%20Bishops%20Pastoral%20 Letter.pdf accessed 8 June 2007