Online discourses of ‘homosexuality’ and religion
The discussion relating to Islam in Finland
Jarmo Harri Jantunen | University of Jyväskylä, Finland
Samu Kytölä | University of Jyväskylä, Finland
This article examines Finnish online forum discussions where religion and discourses of ‘homosexuality’ are
connected in various ways. Previous research (e.g. Jantunen 2018a) shows that in
Finnish online discussions where sexual minorities are the topic, religion stands out as a significant feature – particularly in
discourses on ‘homosexuality’. Via corpus-assisted discourse analysis (CADS), the present study adds to previous knowledge on this
subject by qualitatively analyzing the occurrences of certain keywords in the Finnish societal context – one in which immigration
and the visibility of both Islam and sexual minorities are perceived to have increased. The analysis found four interrelated key
discourses in these online discussions: (1) Islamization as an alleged threat to gay people (in the data: ‘homosexuals’); (2) the
alleged indifference/ignorance of people to Islam’s stance against sexual minorities; (3) relativist discourse(s) claiming all
fundamentalists to be similar; and (4) othering – including for instance, the verbal stylization of Muslims as being particularly
hypersexual.
Keywords: homosexuality, religion, Islam, web forums, online discourses, corpus-assisted discourse analysis, keyword analysis
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.‘Homosexuality’ vis-à-vis religion
- 3.Methodology and data
- 3.1Data
- 3.2Keywords and corpus-assisted discourse analysis
- 3.3Ethical issues
- 4.Discourse prosodies and keywords related to religion
- 4.1Overview of discourse prosodies
- 4.2Keywords related to religion
- 5.Islam and ‘homosexuality’ as discussed on Suomi24
- 5.1Discourse 1: Islamization threatens ‘homosexuals’
- Data Example (6): ‘Islamization’
- Data Example (7): ‘Gays are always having to watch out for Muslim gangs’
- 5.2Discourse 2: Tolerant liberals ignore the fact that Muslims disapprove of sexual minorities
- Data Example (8): ‘But Islam wants to kill gays who would usually support the Greens’
- Data Example (9): ‘But in Muslim countries the President stays quiet…’
- 5.3Discourse 3: Christian or Muslim – tolerance is better than fundamentalism
- Data Example (10): ‘It’s little different from your [evangelical] fundy doctrine’
- Data Example (11): ‘Most of the world’s Muslims accept gays’
- 5.4Discourse 4: Hypersexualization and stylization
- Data Example (12): ‘Preferably big-dicked black Muslim warriors’
- Data Example (13): ‘allah great he love anal sex’
- Data Example (14): ‘Yuck. Islam judge homo to lowest hell’
- 5.1Discourse 1: Islamization threatens ‘homosexuals’
- 6.Discussion and suggestions for further research
- Notes
-
References
Published online: 11 February 2022
https://doi.org/10.1075/jls.20011.jan
https://doi.org/10.1075/jls.20011.jan
References
Afzal, Ahmed
Anthony, Laurence
2015 AntConc.
Version 3.4.4. Computer Software. Tokyo: Waseda University. http://www.laurenceanthony.net/software/antconc/ (December 7 2017)
Bachmann, Ingo
Baker, Paul
Carlson, Elof Axel
Charpentier, Sari
2000 Gender,
body and the sacred: Heterosexual hegemony as a sacred order. Queen: Journal of Rhetorics and
Power 1(1). saricharpentier-genderbodyandthesacredheterosexualhegemonyasasacredorder-160221202352.pdf (May 6 2020)
Cruz, Angela Gracia B., Seo, Yuri & Rex, Mathew
Daniels, Jessie
Eidhamar, Levi Geir
Ellis, Sonja J. & Kitzinger, Celia
FIAM
García, Dalia I., Gray-Stanley, Jennifer & Ramirez-Valles, Jesus
Giffney, Noreen
Hooghe, Marc, Claes, Ellen, Harell, Allison, Quintelier, Ellen & Dejaeghere, Yves
Hughey, Matthew W. & Daniels, Jessie
Ioannides, George
Islamia queeristi
Jäckle, Sebastian & Wenzelburger, Georg
Jantunen, Jarmo H.
Jantunen, Jarmo H. & Juvonen, Tuula
Jaspal, Rusi
King, Brian W.
Kligerman, Nicole
2007 Homosexuality
in Islam: A difficult paradox. Macalester Islam
Journal 2(3): Article 8. http://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/islam/vol2/iss3/8 (June 22 2020)
Körkkö, Hilla
2020 Muslimi-seksuaalivähemmistöt organisoituvat Suomessakin – Lontoossa järjestetään jo
muslimipride. [London already hosts a Muslim Pride – now Muslim sexual
minorities in Finland are getting themselves organized]. Helsingin
Sanomat, March 6 2020 <https://www.hs.fi/nyt/art-2000006429715.html (June 16 2020)
Kytölä, Samu
2017 Researching
sexual minorities in men’s football (discourse): Methodological challenges of multi-sited and multisemiotic
ethnographies. (Paper presented at Language in the Media
Conference 2017, University of the Western Cape, October 19,
2017)
2018 Sexual
diversities in male football cultures from the perspectives of visibility: Insights from football events and digital
media. (Paper presented at the International Conference on
Sociolinguistics (ICS2), in the panel “Regimenting the public sphere: the politics of visibility”,
ELTE, Budapest, September 8,
2018)
Kytölä, Samu & Androutsopoulos, Jannis
Lähdesmäki, Tuuli & Saresma, Tuija
2014 The
intersections of sexuality and religion in the anti-interculturalist rhetoric in Finnish internet discussion on Muslim
homosexuals in Amsterdam. In Building Barriers and Bridges:
Interculturalism in the 21st Century, Jonathan Gourlay & Gabriele Strohschen (eds), 35–48. Oxford: Inter-Disciplinary Press. 

Leap, William
Lehman, Peter
Lehtonen, Heini
Leppänen, Sirpa, Kytölä, Samu, Westinen, Elina & Peuronen, Saija
Levon, Erez
Mapril, José, Martikainen, Tuomas & Khan, Adil Hussain
Mautner, Gerlinde
Meta-Share
Milani, Tommaso M. & Levon, Erez
Motschenbacher, Heiko
Ogland, Curtis P. & Verona, Ana Paula
OSF (Official Statistics of
Finland)
2015 Population structure [e-publication]. ISSN=1797–5395. Annual
review 2015, Appendix table 6. Population by religious community in 2000 to
2015. Helsinki: Statistics Finland. http://www.stat.fi/til/vaerak/2015/01/vaerak_2015_01_2016-09-23_tau_006_en.html (April 21 2020).
Partington, Alan, Duguid, Alison & Taylor, Charlotte
Paterson, Laura L. & Coffey-Glover, Laura
Perry, Barbara & Sutton, Michael
Peumans, Wim
Pew Research Center
2017 Europe’s
growing Muslim population. Published Nov 29, 2017. https://www.pewforum.org/2017/11/29/europes-growing-muslim-population/ (April 21 2020).
Provencher, Denis M.
Puar, Jasbir
Rich, Timothy S.
Rohleder, Poul
Ruckenstein, Minna
2017 Suomi24-käyttäjäkyselyn tuloksia [Results of the Suomi24 user
survey]. https://blogs.helsinki.fi/citizenmindscapes/2017/08/21/suomi24-kayttajakyselyn-tuloksia/ (June 29 2020)
Sakki, Inari & Pettersson, Katarina
Saresma, Tuija
2020 Vihan
sfäärit: Valkoisten heteromiesten affektiivinen mobilisaatio sosiaalisessa
mediassa. [The spheres of hate: The affective mobilization of white heterosexual men in social media]. In Affektit ja tunteet kulttuurien tutkimuksessa.
Ethnos-toimite 22, Jenni Rinne, Anna Kajander & Riina Haanpää (eds), 196–243. Helsinki: Ethnos ry.
Schulte, Lisa J. & Battle, Juan
Silva, Derek M. D.
Siraj, Asifa
Thompson, Katrina D.
van den Berg, Marianne, Bos, David J., Derks, Marco, Ganzevoort, R. Ruard, Jovanovič, Miloš, Korte, Anne-Marie & Sremac, Srdjan
Vitikainen, Sami
2019 Gay
Muslim refugees in Finland: Intersections of experience. Unpublished MA
dissertation, University of Helsinki. http://urn.fi/URN:NBN:fi:hulib-201906112590 (June 22 2020).
Whitehead, Andrew L.