An L1 grammar-driven model of loanword adaptation
Evidence from Korean
The present study proposes an L1 grammar-driven loanword-adaptation model with three intermediate steps — L1 perception, L1 lexical representations and L1 phonology — between L2 acoustic output and L1 output by examining how the distinctive features, syllable structure constraints and structural restrictions of one’s native language steer speakers in their search to replace foreign sounds with native sounds. Our main source of data in support of this model comes from differences between the Korean adaptations of English and French voicing contrasts on the basis of a recent survey of English and French loans in the year 2011. In word-initial position, for example, English voiceless plosives are borrowed as aspirated plosives, while French voiceless plosives are borrowed as either aspirated or fortis plosives in free variation. Considering the data examined here, we suggest that the different Korean adaptations of English and French voicing contrasts in plosives are based on Korean speakers’ perception of redundant phonetic variants in the donor languages (L2) and that this perception is conditioned by the acoustic cues to the laryngeal features [±spread glottis] and [±tense] of Korean, the host language (L1). In contrast to some current models, it shows that the distinctive feature composition of L1 segments plays an important role in loanword adaptations. We also suggest that not only L1 laryngeal features but also L1 syllable structure constraints and lexical restrictions influence L1 perception of the L2 voicing contrasts in word-final postvocalic plosives and that variation in vowel insertion after the plosives in our 2011 data collection is motivated by L1 phonology in both English and French loans. Variation in vowel insertion after English and French word-internal preconsonantal coda plosives is also affected by the native phonology in the 2011 data, no matter whether the plosives are released, as in French, or unreleased, as in English.
References
Ahn, Miyeon
2011 Phonetics and Phonology Interplay in Loanword Adaptation: English Alveolar Fricative into Korean. Ph. D. dissertation, University of Michigan.
Ahn, Sang-Cheol & Gregory Iverson
2004 Dimensions in Korean Laryngeal Phonology.
Journal of East Asian Linguistics 131: 345–379.


Avery, Peter & William J. Idsardi
2001 Laryngeal Dimensions, Completion and Enhancement.
Phonology and Phonetics ed. by
Tracy Hall, 41–70. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter.

Best, Catherine T
1995 A Direct Realist View of Cross-language Speech.
Speech Perception and Linguistic Experience ed. by
Winifred Strange, 171–204. Baltimore: York Press.

Boersma, Paul & Silke Hamann
Broselow, Ellen & Hye-Bae Park
1995 Mora Conservation in Second Language Prosody.
Phonological Acquisition and Phonological Theory ed. by
John Archibald, 151–168. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

Caisse, Michelle
1988 Modeling English Vowel Durations. Ph. D. dissertation. University of California, Berkeley.
Calabrese, Andrea & W. Leo Wetzels
Catford, John Cunnison
1977 Fundamental Problems in Phonetics. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.

Chen, Matthew
1970 Vowel Length Variation as a Function of the Voicing of the Consonant Environment.
Phonetica 221: 129–159.


Cho, Taehong, Sun-Ah Jun & Peter Ladefoged
2002 Acoustic and Aerodynamic Correlates of Korean Stops and Fricatives.
Journal of Phonetics 301: 193–228.


Cho, Young-Mee Yu & Sharon Inkelas
1994 Post-obstruent Tensification in Korean and Geminate Inalterability.
Theoretical Issues in Korean Linguistics ed. by
Young-Key Kim-Renaud, 45–60. Stanford: CSLI.

Chomsky, Noam & Morris Halle
1968 The Sound Pattern of English. New York: Harper and Row.

Clements, George N
1985 The Geometry of Phonological Features.
Phonology Yearbook 21: 225–252.


Clements, George N
1991 Vowel Height Assimilation in Bantu Languages.
Working Papers of the Cornell Phonetics Laboratory51, 37–76. Ithaca, N. Y: Cornell University.

Coetzee, Andries & Joe Pater
2011 The Place of Variation in Phonological Theory.
The Handbook of Phonological Theory, 2nd ed. ed. by
John Goldsmith,
Jason Riggle &
Alan Yu, 401–434. Oxford: Blackwell.


Davis, Stuart & Mi-Hui Cho
2006 Phonetics versus Phonology: English Word Final /s/ in Korean Loanword Phonology.
Lingua 1161: 1008–1023.


Dell, François
1973 Les règles et les sons. Paris: Hermann. [1980.
Generative Phonology and French Phonology Engl. trans. by Catherine Cullen. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.]

Dell, François
1995 Consonant Clusters and Phonological Syllables in French.
Lingua 951: 5–26.


Dupoux, Emmanuel, Kazuhiko Kazehi, Yuki Hirose, Christophe Pallier & Jacques Mehler
1999 Epenthetic vowels in Japanese: A Perceptual Illusion.
Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 25.61: 1568–1578.


Eulitz, Carsten & Aditi Lahiri
2004 Neurobiological Evidence for Abstract Phonological Representations in the Mental Lexicon during Speech Recognition.
Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 16.4: 577–583.


Fant, Gunnar
1973 Speech Sounds and Features. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Halle, Morris
1983 On Distinctive Features and their Articulatory Implementation.
Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 1.1: 91–105.


Halle, Morris & Kenneth N. Stevens
1971 A Note on Laryngeal Features.
Quarterly Progress Report 1011, 198–212. Cambridge, MA: Research Laboratory of Electronics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

Han, Jeong-Im
1996 The Phonetics and Phonology of Tense and Plain Consonants in Korean. Ph. D. dissertation, Cornell University.
Hirano, Hideyuki
1994 A Constraint-based Approach to Korean Loanwords.
Language Research 301: 707–739.

Honda, Kiyoshi
1995 Laryngeal and Extralaryngeal Mechanisms of F0 Control.
Producing Speech: Contemporary Issues ed. by
Fredericka Bell-Berti &
Lawrence J. Raphael, 215–232. New York: American Institute of Physics.

Honda, Kiyoshi
1999 Interactions between Vowel Articulation and F0 Control.
Proceedings of LP’98 ed. by
Osamu Fujimura,
Brian D. Joseph &
Bohumil Palek, 517–527. Prague: The Karolinum Press.

Honda, Kiyoshi, Hiroyuki Hirai, Shinobu Masaki & Yasuhiro Shimada
1999 Role of Vertical Larynx Movement and Cervical Lordosis in F0 Control.
Language and Speech 421: 401–411.


Hsieh, Feng-fan, Michael Kenstowicz & Xiaomin Mou
Hyman, Larry
1970 The Role of Borrowing in the Justification of Phonological Grammars.
Studies in African Linguistics 11: 1–48.

Iverson, Gregory K
1983 Korean s.
Journal of Phonetics 111: 191–200.


Iverson, Gregory K. & Ahrong Lee
Jakobson, Roman, Gunnar Fant & Morris Halle
1952 Preliminaries to Speech Analysis: The Distinctive Features and their Correlates. Acoustics Laboratory, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, (
Technical Report No. 13).

Jakobson, Roman & Linda R. Waugh
1987 The Sound Shape of Language. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter.

Jessen, Michael
1998 Phonetics and Phonology of Tense and Lax Obstruents in German. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Company.


Jun, Sun-Ah
1993 The Phonetics and Phonology of Korean Prosody. Ph. D. dissertation, The Ohio State University.
Jun, Sun-Ah
1994 The Status of the Lenis Stop Voicing Rule.
Theoretical Issues in Korean linguistics ed. by
Young-Key Kim-Renaud, 101–114. Stanford, CA: CSLI.

Kang, Eunji, Ho-Young Lee & Juwon Kim
2004 The Phonetic Realization of Syllable Codas in Korean.
Malsori [Journal of the Korean Society of Phonetic Science and Speech Technology] 491: 1–30.

Kang, Yoonjung
2003 Perceptual Similarity in Loanword Adaptation: English Postvocalic Word-final Stops in Korean.
Phonology 201: 219–273.


Kang, Yoonjung
2008a Tensification of Voiced Stops in English Loanwords in Korean.
Harvard Studies in Korean Linguistics XII1: 179–192.

Kang, Yoonjung
2008b The Adaptation of English /s/ in Korean.
Inquiries into Korean Linguistics III ed. by
John Whitman,
Ponghyung Lee,
Chang-Kook Suh,
Sungdai Cho,
Yeun-Jin Jung,
Jae-Young Chung &
Jeong-Im Han, 1–13. Seoul: Hankook Munhwasa.

Kang, Yoonjung
2009 English /z/ in 1930s Korean. Simon Fraser University Working Papers in Linguistics Vol. 2: Proceedings of the Second International Conference on East Asian Linguistics.
Kang, Yoonjung
2012 The Adaptation of English Liquids in Contemporary Korean: A Diachronic Study.
Catalan Journal of Linguistics 111: 41–63.


Kenstowicz, Michael
2003 The Role of Perception in Loanword Phonology.
Studies in African Linguistics 32.11: 95–112.

Kent, Ray D. & Charles Read
1992 The Acoustic Analysis of Speech. San Diego, CA: Singular Publishing Group.

Kewley-Port, Diane
2006 Topics in Speech Perception. Presentation at ISCA Tutorial and Research Workshop on Experimental Linguistics. University of Athens, Greece.
Keyser, Samuel Jay & Kenneth N. Stevens
2001 Enhancement Revisited.
Ken Hale: A Life in Language ed. by
Michael Kenstowicz, 271–291. Cambridge, MA: MIT press.

Keyser, Samuel J. & Kenneth N. Stevens
2006 Enhancement and Overlap in the Speech Chain.
Language 821: 33–64.


Kim, Chin-Wu
1965 On the Autonomy of the Tensity Feature in Stop Classification (with the Special Reference to Korean Stops).
Word 211: 339–359.


Kim, Hyunsoon
1999 The Place of Articulation of the Korean Affricates Revisited.
Journal of East Asian Linguistics 81: 313–347.


Kim, Hyunsoon
2001a A Phonetically-Based Account of Phonological Assibilation.
Phonology 181: 81–108.


Kim, Hyunsoon
2001b The Place of Articulation of the Korean Plain Affricate in Intervocalic Position: An Articulatory and Acoustic Study.
Journal of the International Phonetic Association 31.2: 229–257.


Kim, Hyunsoon
2002 Korean Tense Consonants as Singletons.
Proceedings of the Chicago Linguistic Society 381: 329–344. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Kim, Hyunsoon
2003 The Feature [tense] Revisited: The Case of Korean Consonants.
The Proceedings of the North East Linguistic Society 341: 319–332.

Kim, Hyunsoon
2004 Stroboscopic-cine MRI Data on Korean Coronal Plosives and Affricates: Implications for their Place of Articulation as Alveolar.
Phonetica 611: 234–251.


Kim, Hyunsoon
2005 The Representation of the Three-way Laryngeal Contrast in Korean Consonants.
The Internal Organization of Phonological Segments ed. by
Marc van Oostendorp &
Jeroen van de Weijer, 287–315. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter.


Kim, Hyunsoon
2008 Loanword Adaptation between Japanese and Korean: Evidence for L1 Feature Driven Perception.
Journal of East Asian Linguistics 171: 331–346.


Kim, Hyunsoon
2012 Gradual Tongue Movements in Korean Palatalization as Coarticulation: New Evidence from Stroboscopic cine-MRI and Acoustic Data.
Journal of Phonetics 40.11: 67–81.


Kim, Hyunsoon
2013a The role of F0 in Seoul and Kyungsang Korean Speakers’ Categorization of Japanese Plosives: Implications for the Laryngeal Feature Specification of Korean Consonants. Unpublished manuscript.

Kim, Hyunsoon
2013b Korean Speakers’ Perception of Japanese Geminates: Evidence for the Role of L1 Grammar in Loanword Adaptation. Presented at the 3rd International Conference of Phonetics and Phonology held at the National Institute for Japanese Language and Linguistics, Tokyo Japan. To appear in
Aspects of Geminate Consonants, Oxford University Press.
Kim, Hyunsoon
2014 A Two-Decade-Interval Variation in Vowel Insertion after Word-Final English and French Postvocalic Plosives in Korean Adaptation. Presented at the conference in the honor of Annie Rialland, the Sorbonne University, Paris.
Kim, Hyunsoon, Kiyoshi Honda & Shinji Maeda
2005 Stroboscopic-cine MRI Study of the Phasing between the Tongue and the Larynx in the Korean Three-Way Phonation Contrast.
Journal of Phonetics 33.1: 1–26.


Kim, Hyunsoon, Shinji Maeda & Kiyoshi Honda
2010a Invariant Articulatory Bases of the Features [tense] and [spread glottis] in Korean Plosives: New Stroboscopic cine-MRI Data.
Journal of Phonetics 38.1: 90–108.


Kim, Hyunsoon, Shinji Maeda, Kiyoshi Honda & Stephane Hans
2010b The Laryngeal Characterization of Korean Fricatives: Acoustic and Aerodynamic Data.
Turbulent Sounds: An Interdisciplinary Guide ed. by
Susanne Fuchs,
Martine Toda &
Marzena Zygis, 143–166. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter.


Kim, Hyunsoon. Shinji Maeda & Kiyoshi Honda
2011 The Laryngeal Characterization of Korean Fricatives: Stroboscopic cine-MRI Data.
Journal of Phonetics 39.41: 626–641.


Kim, Hyunsoon & Chae-Lim Park
2011 An Acoustic Study of the Korean Fricatives /s, s’/: Implications for the Features [spread glottis] and [tense].
Tones and Features ed. by
John Goldsmith,
Beth Hume &
W. Leo Wetzels, 176–194. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter.


Kim, Soohee
1999 Subphonemic Duration Difference in English /s/ and Few-to-many Borrowing from English to Korean. Ph. D. dissertation, University of Washington.
Kim, Soohee & Emily Curtis
2002 Phonetic Duration of English /s/ and its Borrowing into Korean.
Japanese/Korean Linguistics 101: 406–419.

Kingston, John & Randy L. Diehl
1994 Phonetic Knowledge.
Language 70.3: 419–454.


Kiparsky, Paul
1982 Lexical Morphology and Phonology.
Linguistics in the Morning Calm, vol. 21 ed. by
In-Seok Yang, 3–91. Seoul: Hanshin Publishing Company.

Klatt, Dennis
1974 The Duration of [s] in English Words.
Journal of Speech and Hearing Research 171: 51–63.


Klatt, Dennis
1976 The Linguistic uses of Segmental Duration in English: Acoustic and Perceptual Evidence.
Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 591: 1208–1221.


LaCharité, D Darlene & Carole Paradis
2005 Category Preservation and Proximity Versus Phonetic Approximation in Loanword Adaptation.
Linguistic Inquiry 36.21: 223–258.


Ladefoged, Peter
1999 American English.
Handbook of the International Phonetic Association: A Guide to the Use of the International Phonetic Alphabet ed. by International Phonetic Association, 41–44. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Ladefoged, Peter
2001 A Course in Phonetics. Fort Worth, TX: Hartcourt College Publishers.

Lahiri, Aditi & Henning Reetz
2002 Underspecified Recognition.
Laboratory Phonology 7 ed. by
Carlos Gussenhoven &
Natasha Warner, 637–676. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter.


Laver, John
1994 Principles of Phonetics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Lee, Ahrong & Gregory K. Iverson
2006 Variation in Korean Integration of English Word-Final /s/.
Euhakyenkwu [
Language Research] 421: 239–251.

Lisker, Leigh, Alvin M. Liberman, Donna M. Erickson, David Dechovitz & Roland Mandler
1977 On Pushing the Voice-Onset-Time (VOT) Boundary About.
Language and Speech 201: 209–216.


Martin, Samuel E
1982 Features, Markedness, and Order in Korean Phonology.
Linguistics in the Morning Calm, vol. 21 ed. by
In-Seok Yang, 601–618. Seoul: Hanshin Publishing Company.

McCarthy, John J
1988 Feature Geometry and Dependency: A Review.
Phonetica 451: 84–108.


Mohanan, Karuvannur P
1986 The Theory of Lexical Phonology. Dordrecht, Netherlands: D. Reidel Publishing Co.

NIKL (The National Academy Institute of the Korean Language)
2011 Woylayephyokipeyp [How to borrow foreign sounds]. Seoul.
Nam, Ji-Young & Bruce Southard
1994 Orthographic Representation and Resyllabification of English Loan words in Korean.
Language and Speech 37.3: 259–281.


Odden, David
2005 Introducing Phonology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Ohala, John J
1981a Speech Timing as a Tool in Phonology.
Phonetica 381: 204–212.


Ohala, John J
1981b Articulatory Constraints on the Cognitive Representation of Speech.
The Cognitive Representation of Speech ed. by
Terry Myers,
John Laver &
John Anderson, 111–122. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publishing Company.


O’Shaughnessy, Douglas
1981 A Study of French Vowel and Consonant Durations.
Journal of Phonetics 91: 385–406.


Paradis, Carole & Darlene LaCharité
1997 Preservation and Minimality in Loanword Adaptation.
Journal of Linguistics 331: 379–430.


Paradis, Carole & Antoine Tremblay
Peperkamp, Sharon
2005 A Psycholinguistic Theory of Loanword Adaptations.
BLS 301: 341–352.


Peperkamp, Sharon & Emmanuel Dupoux
2003 Reinterpreting Loanword Adaptations: The Role of Perception.
Proceedings of the 15th International Congress of Phonetic Sciences ed. by
Maria-Josep Solé,
Daniel Recasens &
Joaquin Romero, 367–370. Barcelona: Universitat Autónoma de Barcelona.

Peperkamp, Sharon, Inga Vendelin & Kimihiro Nakamura
2008 On the Perceptual Origin of Loanword Adaptations: Experimental Evidence from Japanese.
Phonology 25.1: 129–164.


Polivanov, Evgenij D
1931 La perception des sons d’une langue étrangère [The perception of non-native language sounds].
Travaux du Cercle Linguistique de Prague 41: 79–96.

Polivanov, Evgenij D
1974 The Subjective Nature of the Perceptions of Language Sounds.
Selected Works: Articles on General Linguistics ed. by
Evgenij D. Polivanov, 223–237. The Hague: Mouton.


Rhee, Seok-Chae & Yoo-Kyung Choi
2001 Yengechayongeuy moumsapipey tayhan thongkyeycek kwanchalkwa ku uyuy. [A statistical observation of vowel insertion in English loanwords in Korean and its significance.]
Studies in Phonetics, Phonology and Morphology 71: 153–176. Seoul: Hankwukmunhwasa.

Sagey, Elizabeth C
1986 The Representation of Features and Relations in Nonlinear Phonology. Ph. D. dissertation, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Shinohara, Shigeko, Seong-Rim Ji, Tomohiko Ooigawa & Takahito Shinya
2011 The Limited Role of Perception in Korean Loanword Adaptation: The Korean Three-Way Laryngeal Categorization of Japanese, French, English and Chinese Plosives.
Lingua 121.9: 1461–1484.


Silva, David J
1992 The Phonetics and Phonology of Stop Lenition in Korean. Ph. D. dissertation, Cornell University.
Silverman, Daniel
1992 Multiple Scansions in Loanword Phonology: Evidence from Cantonese.
Phonology 91: 289–328.


Skaličková, Alena
1960 The Korean Consonants. Prague: Rozpravy ČSAV.

Steriade, Donca
2001 Directional Asymmetries in Place Assimilation: A Perceptual Account.
The Role of Speech Perception in Phonology ed. by
Elizabeth Hume &
Keith Johnson, 219–250. San Diego: Academic Press.

Stevens, Kenneth N
1998 Acoustic Phonetics. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Stevens, Kenneth N
2005 Features in Speech Perception and Lexical Access.
The Handbook of Speech Perception ed. by
David B. Pisoni &
Robert E. Remez, 125–155. Oxford: Blackwell.


Stevens, Kenneth N., Samuel J. Keyser & Haruko Kawasaki
1986 Toward a Phonetic and Phonological Theory of Redundant Features.
Invariance and Variability in Speech Processes ed. by
Joseph S. Perkell &
Dennis H. Klatt, 426–449. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

Tranel, Bernard
1987 The Sounds of French: An Introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Trubetzkoy, Nikolai S
1939 Grundzüge der Phonologie. Goöttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht. (English edition: 1969.
Principles of Phonology Engl. trans. by Christiane A. M. Baltaxe. Berkeley/Los Angeles: University of California Press.)

Wells, John C
1982 Accents of English 2: The British Isles. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Wetzels, W. Leo & Joan Mascaró
2001 The Typology of Voicing and Devoicing.
Language 77.2: 207–244.


Yip, Moira
2006 The Symbiosis between Perception and Grammar in Loanword Phonology.
Lingua 116.7: 950–975.


Cited by
Cited by 4 other publications
Jacobs, Haike
Kim, Hyunsoon
2017.
A two-decade-interval variation in vowel insertion after word-final English and French postvocalic plosives in Korean adaptation: A sociolinguistic account.
Linguistics Vanguard 3:1

Kim, Hyunsoon, Shinji Maeda, Kiyoshi Honda & Lise Crevier-Buchman
2017.
The Mechanism and Representation of Korean Three-Way Phonation Contrast: External Photoglottography, Intra-Oral Air Pressure, Airflow, and Acoustic Data.
Phonetica 75:1
► pp. 57 ff.

2022.
External photoglottography, intra-oral air pressure, airflow and
acoustic data on the Korean fricatives /s’, s/.
Phonetics and Speech Sciences 14:3
► pp. 11 ff.

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 20 february 2023. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.