Honorifics in the marketplace
A multimodal indexical analysis
Jiyoon Lee | Washington University in St. Louis
Lucien Brown | Monash University
This paper analyzes how vendors and customers in Korean marketplaces use three distinct levels of addressee
honorifics: the deferential ‑supnita
style, the polite ‑yo style and the so-called
panmal ‘half speech’ style. The frequencies of these forms to some extent pattern with the relative ages of
the participants; for example, vendors are more likely to use panmal towards customers who are relatively
younger. However, the majority of interactions feature dynamic variation between different styles, which cannot be adequately
explained by relative age. Rather, we see that participants use ‑supnita
style and ‑yo to index
that they are speaking in their prescribed roles as “vendors” or “customers”. Meanwhile, panmal was found to
index two main forms of social meaning. It was used to mark stages of the interaction that were conversational, playful, or
intimate, but also when speakers strategically indexed their authority or power as they tried to take the upper hand in price
negotiations. This authoritative use of panmal was accompanied by non-verbal behaviors such as large body
postures, high chin positions and the withholding of gaze and bodily orientation. The paper contributes towards a growing body of
research adopting an indexical approach to the use of honorifics, and demonstrates the importance of including analysis of
multimodal features alongside the honorific forms themselves.
Keywords: multimodality, indexicality, honorifics, marketplace, speech-styles, Panmal, Contaymal
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Indexical properties of Korean honorifics
- 2.1Overview
- 2.2The deferential style
- 2.3-yo
- 2.4 Panmal
- 2.5Other verbal and non-verbal features
- 3.Methodology
- 3.1Data
- 3.2Analysis
- 4.Data presentation
- 4.1Quantitative overview
- 4.2Qualitative analysis
- 4.2.1–supnita
- 4.2.2-yo
- 4.2.3 Panmal
- 5.Discussion
- 5.Conclusion
- Notes
-
References
Available under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial (CC BY-NC) 4.0 license.
For any use beyond this license, please contact the publisher at rights@benjamins.nl.
Published online: 28 March 2022
https://doi.org/10.1075/kl.20007.lee
https://doi.org/10.1075/kl.20007.lee
References
Barke, Andrew
Brown, Lucien
Brown, Lucien and Pilar Prieto
Brown, Lucien and Bodo Winter
Chang, Kyung-Hee
Cook, Haruko
Culpeper, Jonathan
Culpeper, Jonathan, Haugh, Michael & Kadar, Daniel
Dunn, Cynthia
Eun, Jong-oh and Susan Strauss
George, Johnny
2011 Politeness
in Japanese Sign Language (JSL): Polite JSL expression as evidence for intermodal language contact
influence. Berkeley, CA: University of California dissertation.
Geyer, Naomi
Haugh, Michael
Hwang, Juck-ryoon
Jo, Jaehyun
Kim, Minju
Kim, Hye Ri Stephanie
Kim, Soung-U.
2013 Language
attitudes on Jeju Island – an analysis of attitudes towards language choice from an ethnographic
perspective. London: SOAS (University of London) dissertation.
Kim, Eun Hye
2006 Hankwuke senemal
emi ‘-si-’uy samwul contay kinung: paykhwacem, tayhyengmathu, caylaysicang phanmaywen-uy palhwa-lul
cwungsim-ulo [The inanimate object function of Korean verb ending ‘-si-’:
focussing on the utterances of sales personnel in department store, supermarkets and markets]. Sahoyenehak [The Sociolinguistic Journal of
Korean] 24(1). 91–113.
2006 Hankwuke senemal
emi ‘-si-’uy samwul contay kinung: paykhwacem, tayhyengmathu, caylaysicang phanmaywen-uy palhwa-lul
cwungsim-ulo [The inanimate object function of Korean verb ending ‘-si-’:
focussing on the utterances of sales personnel in department store, supermarkets and markets]. Sahoyenehak [Sociolinguistics] 24(1). 91–113.
Kim, Young-Jin and Douglas Biber
Kim, Kyu-hyun and Kyung-Hee Suh
Lee, Hyo Sang
Lee, Chang Soo
Lee, Hyo Sang
1991 Tense, aspect and modality: A
discourse pragmatic analysis of verbal affixes in Korean from a typological
perspective. (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of California, Los Angeles.
Lee, Jungbok
Lee, Jung-bok
Lee, Keunyoung
2020 Impoliteness,
identity and power in Korean: Critical discourse analysis and perception study of
impoliteness. Eugene, OR: University of Oregon PhD dissertation.
Lee, Kiri and Young-mee Yu Cho
Martin, Samuel
Mason, Paul, Juan Domínguez, Bodo Winter and Andrea Grignolio
Ochs, Elinor
Okamoto, Shigeko
Park, Yong-Yae
Park, Mi Yung
Paxton, Alex, Lucien Brown and Bodo Winter
2018 Complex
coordination: How power dynamics and task demands shape interpersonal motor synchrony. Paper
presented at CogSci 2018, Madison,
WI.
Raymond, Chase Wesley
Sherr-Ziarko, Ethan
Silverstein, Michael
Strauss, Susan and Jong-oh Eun
Sung, Ky-chull
Winter, Bodo and Sven Grawunder
Winter, Bodo, Paula Pérez-Sobrino and Lucien Brown
Yoon, Kyung-joo
Yoon, Sangseok
2010 Situational
Meanings and Functions of Korean Speech Styles. Manoa, Hawaii: University of Hawaii dissertation.