Article published in:
Morphological MetatheoryEdited by Daniel Siddiqi and Heidi Harley
[Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today 229] 2016
► pp. 163–200
The costs of zero-derived causativity in English
Evidence from reading times and MEG
Lisa Levinson | Oakland University
Jonathan Brennan | University of Michigan
This paper investigates the processing of lexical causative verbs in English as a means to provide insight into long-standing debates in this domain and to explore methods for comparison of words which are phonologicallyidentical but vary at other levels of representation. Verbs such as melt can be used in both transitive and intransitive contexts, which have been argued to vary not only in the number of thematic arguments, but also in semantic, morphological, and syntactic representation. Hypothesizing that the transitive variants contain additional causativity, we predicted that they would induce greater processing cost that could be attributed to greater lexical semantic complexity. In order to test this prediction, we included in each study pairs of activity verbs which alternate in transitivity but not causativity. Two self-paced reading studies confirmed our prediction, demonstrating an interaction such that transitive verbs in the causative condition took significantly longer to process than intransitive verbs, a pattern that was not reflected in the activity condition. A further magnetoencephalography study tested for neural activity associated with different levels of linguistic processing and provides insight into the nature of the behavioral delay. The behavioral findings suggest that the transitive variants in the lexical causative alternation are more complex than the intransitives at some level of representation, despite their phonological identity. The MEG study provides a profile which is suggestive of a link with lexical or morphological complexity.
Published online: 29 June 2016
https://doi.org/10.1075/la.229.06lev
https://doi.org/10.1075/la.229.06lev
References
References
Adachi, Y., Shimogawara, M., Higuchi, M., Haruta, Y. & Ochiai, M.
Alexiadou, Artemis, Anagnostopoulou, Elena & Schäfer, Florian
Baayen, R. Harald
Baayen, R. Harald, Davidson, Douglas J. & Bates, Douglas M.
Baggio, Giosuè, Choma, Travis, van Lambalgen, Michiel & Hagoort, Peter
Bates, Douglas & Maechler, Martin
Bedny, Marina, Hulbert, Justin C. & Thompson-Schill, Sharon L.
Bemis, Douglas K. & Pylkkänen, Liina
Ben-Shachar, Michal, Palti, Dafna & Grodzinsky, Yosef
Bhatt, Rajesh & Embick, David
Bookheimer, S.
Bornkessel, Ina & Schlesewsky, Matthias
Bornkessel, Ina, Zysset, Stefan, Friederici, Angela D., von Cramon, D. Yves & Matthias Schlesewsky
Bornkessel-Schlesewsky, Ina & Schlesewsky, Matthias
Bozic, Mirjana, Marslen-Wilson, William D., Stamatakis, Emmanuel A., Davis, Matthew H. & Tyler, Lorraine K.
Brennan, Jonathan, Nir, Yuval, Hasson, Uri, Malach, Rafael, Heeger, David J. & Pylkkänen, Liina
Brennan, Jonathan & Pylkkänen, Liina
Carter, Cameron S., Braver, Todd S., Barch, Deanna M., Botvinick, Matthew M., Noll, Douglas & Cohen, Jonathan D.
Chiarelli, Valentina, El Yagoubi, Radouane, Mondini, Sara, Bisiacchi, Patrizia & Semenza, Carlo
Chierchia, Gennaro
Cohen, Jonathan D., MacWhinney, Brian, Flatt, Matthew & Provost, Jefferson
Crain, Stephen & Fodor, Jerry D.
Dale, Anders M., Liu, Arthur K., Fischl, Bruce R., Buckner, Randy L., Belliveau, John W., Lewine, Jeffrey D. & Halgren, Eric
Dale, Anders M. & Sereno, Martin I.
Desikan, Rahul S., Ségonne, Florent, Fischl, Bruce, Quinn, Brian T., Dickerson, Bradford C., Blacker, Deborah, Buckner, Randy L., Dale, Anders M., Maguire, R. Paul, Hyman, Bradley T., Albert, Marilyn S. & Killiany, Ronald J.
Devlin, Joseph T., Jamison, Helen L., Matthews, Paul M. & Gonnerman, Laura M.
Dowty, David
Ferreira, Fernanda
Ferstl, Evelyn C., Neumann, Jane, Bogler, Carsten & von Cramon, D. Yves
Fiorentino, Robert & Poeppel, David
Friederici, Angela D., Meyer, Martin & von Cramon, D. Yves
Gennari, Silvia & Poeppel, David
Gold, Brian T. & Rastle, Kathleen
Grewe, Tanja, Bornkessel, Ina, Zysset, Stefan, Wiese, Richard, von Cramon, D. Yves & Schlesewsky, Matthias
Grodzinsky, Yosef & Friederici, Angela D.
Hagoort, Peter, Hald, Lea, Bastiaansen, Marcel & Petersson, Karl Magnus
Hämäläinen, Matti S. & Sarvas, Jukka
Hämäläinen, Matti & Ilmoniemi, Risto J.
Harley, Heidi
1995 Subject, Events, and Licensing. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT.
Haspelmath, Martin
Hickok, Gregory & Poeppel, David
Humphries, Colin, Binder, Jeffrey R., Medler, David A. & Liebenthal, Einat
Husband, E. Matthew, Kelly, Lisa A. & Zhu, David C.
Kuperberg, Gina R., Choi, Arim, Cohn, Neil, Paczynski, Martin & Jackendoff, Ray
Kuroda, Sige-Yuki
1965 Generative grammatical studies in the Japanese language. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT.
Lakoff, George
1965 On the Nature of Syntactic Regularity. Ph.D. dissertation, Harvard University.
Lau, Ellen F., Phillips, Colin & Poeppel, David
Lehtonen, Minna, Vorobyev, Victor A., Hugdahl, Kenneth, Tuokkola, Terhi & Laine, Matti
Lehtonen, Minna, Monahan, Philip J. & Poeppel, David
Leminen, Alina, Leminen, Miika, Lehtonen, Minna, Nevalainen, Päivi, Ylinen, Sari, Kimppa, Lilli, Sannemann, Christian, Mäkelä, Jyrki P. & Kujala, Teija
Levin, Beth
Levin, Beth & Rappaport-Hovav, Malka
Levinson, Lisa
2012 The morphosemantics of (anti-)causative alternations. Talk presented at the
2012 Linguistic Society of American Annual Meeting
, January.
MacDonald, Maryellen C., Pearlmutter, Neal J. & Seidenberg, Mark S.
Malaia, Evguenia, Wilbur, Ronnie B. & Weber-Fox, Christine
Mazoyer, Bernard M., Tzourio, Nathalie, Frak, Victor, Syrota, André, Murayama, N., Levrier, Olivier, Salamon, George, Dehaene, Stanislas, Cohen, Laurent & Mehler, Jacques
McCandliss, Bruce D., Cohen, Laurent & Dehaene, Stanislas
McCawley, James D.
McKoon, Gail & MacFarland, Talke
Oldfield, R.C.
Pallier, Christophe, Devauchelle, Anne-Dominique & Dehaene, Stanislas
Piñón, Christopher
Pylkkänen, Liina, Brennan, Jonathan & Bemis. Douglas K.
Pylkkänen, Liina & Marantz, Alec
Pylkkänen, Liina, Martin, Andrea E., McElree, Brian & Smart, Andrew
Pylkkänen, Liina & McElree, Brian
Pylkkänen, Liina
2002 Introducing Arguments. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT.
R. Development Core Team
Rappaport Hovav, Malka & Levin, Beth
Rogalsky, Corianne & Hickok, Gregory
Sahin, Ned T., Pinker, Steven, Cash, Sydney S., Schomer, Donald & Halgren, Eric
Santi, Andrea & Grodzinsky, Yosef
Shapiro, Lewis P., Zurif, Edgar & Grimshaw, Jane
Shetreet, Einat & Friedmann, Naama
Shetreet, Einat, Friedmann, Naama & Hadar, Uri
Shetreet, Einat, Palti, Dafna, Friedmann, Naama & Hadar, Uri
Shibatani, Masayoshi
Steinhauer, Karsten, Pancheva, Roumyana, Newman, Aaron J., Gennari, Silvia & Ullman, Michael T.
Stowe, Laurie A., Broere, Cees A.J., Paans, Anne M.J., Wijers, Albertus A., Mulder, Gijsbertus, Vaalburg, Wim & Zwarts, Frans
Stowe, Laurie A.
Stowe, Laurie A., Haverkort, Marco & Zwarts, Frans
Vandenberghe, Rik, Nobre, Anna Christina & Price, Charis J.
Vartiainen, Johanna, Aggujaro, Silvia, Lehtonen, Minna, Hultén, Laine, Annika M. & Salmelin, Riita