Chapter published in:Beyond Markedness in Formal Phonology
Edited by Bridget D. Samuels
[Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today 241] 2017
► pp. 153–190
Chapter 7. Markedness and formalising phonological representations
As a linguistic concept, markedness is in trouble (Hale & Reiss 2000, 2008; Blevins 2004; Haspelmath 2006; Samuels 2011; Reiss 2017). Accepting many of these criticisms and conclusions, this chapter, nevertheless, claims that there is space for markedness in formal phonology. By examining syllable structure from a highly representational viewpoint, I conclude that ‘markedness by complexity’ does have explanatory value and that markedness is explicable in terms of ‘structural complexity’ and ‘length of description’. The core demonstration is based on Charette’s (1990, 1991, 1992) formal typology of consonant clusters (CCs). These papers contain important implicational universals that Charette relates directly to her representations. My contribution will be to enrich the typology and reorganize those principles and parameters into a decision tree or parameter hierarchy that derives the implicational universals. Moreover, the number of parameter settings (the depth in the parameter hierarchy) increases the markedness of the resultant grammar. Crucially, each parametric ‘yes’ setting corresponds to an extra empty phonological category or extra ability to license, or reflects the distance between heads and dependents in the representation. For this reason, markedness is not merely a ‘metaphor’ ‘for a cognitive state’ (Haspelmath 2006), it is directly convertible into linguistic categories. This markedness is not part of the online computation of forms (contra Optimality Theory) and markedness statements cannot be re-ranked to obtain different grammars. However, markedness is one step in the chain of explanation for: (a) the apparent step-wise variation of complexity and implicational universals of consonant clusters, (b) the Trubetzkoy hypothesis.
Keywords: empty categories, markedness, parameter hierarchies, phonological complexity, strict CV phonology
Published online: 16 November 2017
Breen, Gavan & Pensalfini, Rob
Clements, George N.
Clements, George N. & Keyser, Samuel Jay
Cover, Thomas M., Gács, Peter & Grey, Robert M.
Cullicover, Peter W.
Cyran, Eugeniusz & Gussmann, Edmund
Gallon, Nicola, Harris, John & van der Lely, Heather K.
Gnanadesikan, Amalia E.
1983 Gemination as a Syllable Structure Process in Modern Sinhala. Ms, University of Victoria. www.mmduvic.ca/index.php/WPLC/article/download/5491/2099
Hale, Morris & Reiss, Charles
Hall, Daniel Currie
Harris, John, Gallon, Nicola & van der Lely, Heather K.
Kaye, Jonathan D.
Kaye, Jonathan, Lowenstamm, Jean & Vergnaud, Jean Roger
2013 On the empirical bases of phonological typology. Paper presented at the Workshop on Phonological Typology, Oxford.
Levelt, Clara C.
1995 Unfaithful Kids: Place of Articulation Patterns in Early Vocabularies. Colloquium presented at the University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland.
Levelt, Clara C., Schiller, Niels O. & Levelt, Willem
2013 Syllable Structure. In The World Atlas of Language Structures Online, Chapter 12, Matthew S. Dryer & Martin Haspelmath (eds). Leipzig: Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology. http://wals.info/chapter/12 (9 January 2016).
Marshall, Chloe R., Harris, John & van der Lely, Heather K.
2003 The nature of phonological representations in children with Grammatical-Specific Language Impairment (G-SLI). In The University of Cambridge First Postgraduate Conference in Language Research, Damien Hall, Theodore Markopoulos, Angeliki Salamoura & Sophia Skoufaki (eds), 511–517. Cambridge: Cambridge Institute of Language Research.
Niang, Mamadou Ousmane
Roberts, Ian & Holmberg, Anders
Romani, Cristina & Calabrese, Andrea
Tamburelli, Marco, Sanoudaki, Eirini, Jones, Gary & Sowinska, Michelle
Trubetzkoy, Nikolai Sergeyevich
1939 Principles of Phonology. The Center for Research in Languages and Linguistics. Berkeley CA: University of California Press. https://monoskop.org/images/7/73/Trubetzkoy_NS_Principles_of_Phonology.pdf
van der Lely, Heather K.
van Oostendorp, Marc