Cover not available
Article published In:
Language and Linguistics
Vol. 21:1 (2020) ► pp.1–32

Left is right, right is not

On the constituency of the classifier phrase in Chinese

| National Chengchi University
| National Chengchi University

This paper argues for the left-branching constituency of the Chinese classifier phrase and demonstrates that the right-branching approach assumed by the majority of current syntactic works is not viable. The rejection of the right-branching approach entails the rejection of the “split” approach, where both left- and right-branching structures are required. In this debate, we offer a vital fresh perspective from the syntax and mathematics of complex numerals. We examine the right-branching argumentation in A. Li (2014), which, crucially, extends Ionin & Matushansky’s (2006) non-constituent account of complex numerals, e.g. two hundred, in non-classifier languages like English to Chinese and must rely on ellipsis and a silent element YIDIAR ‘a bit’. Yet, complex numerals in Chinese, e.g. liang bai ‘200’, are in fact constituents (He 2015), and the alleged YIDIAR ‘a bit’ does affect the semantics of the noun phrase and is thus by definition illicit (Her & Tsai 2014; 2015). Other evidence comes from Chinese synchronic and diachronic syntax as well as the typology of classifier word orders. While the overall argumentation centers on Chinese, it has significant cross-linguistic implications.

Keywords: numeral classifier, complex numerals, left-branching, right-branching
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.Two camps, four positions
  • 3.Constituency of complex numerals
    • 3.1A multiplicative theory of C/M and its implications on C/M constituency
    • 3.2 Ionin & Matushansky (2006): Non-constituent account of English numerals
    • 3.3 He’s (2015): Constituency account of Chinese numerals
    • 3.4Extending the constituency of complex numerals to [Num C/M] in Chinese
    • 3.5Complex numerals and C/M word order typology
  • 4.Revisiting A. Li (2014)
    • 4.1Evidence from ban/duo ‘half/more’
    • 4.2Property-denoting [Num C/M] phrases
    • 4.3Phonologically-inserted de in the C/M phrase
    • 4.4The discrepancy between Cs and Ms
  • 5.Conclusion
  • Acknowledgements
  • Notes
  • Abbreviations
  • References
Available under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) 4.0 license.

For any use beyond this license, please contact the publisher at [email protected].

Published online: 2 January 2020
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/lali.00046.her
References

References

Abels, Klaus & Neeleman, Ad
2012 Linear asymmetries and the LCA. Syntax 15(1). 25–74. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Aikhenvald, Alexandra Y.
2000 Classifiers: A typology of noun categorization devices. (Oxford Studies in Typology and Linguistic Theory). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Au Yeung, Wai Hoo Ben
2005 An interface program for parameterization of classifiers in Chinese. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University of Science and Technology. (Doctoral dissertation.) DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2007 Multiplication basis of emergence of classifiers. Language and Linguistics 8(4). 835–861.Google Scholar
Bhattacharya, Tanmoy
1999 The structure of the Bangla DP. London: University College London. (Doctoral dissertation.)Google Scholar
2001 Numeral/quantifier-classifier as a complex head. In van Riemsdijk, Henk & Corver, Norbert (eds.), Semi-lexical heads, 191–221. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Borer, Hagit
2005 Structuring sense, vol. 1: In name only. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Chan, Eugene S. L.
2016 Numeral systems of the world’s languages. ([URL]) (Accessed 2018-07-17).
Cheng, Lisa Lai-Shen & Sybesma, Rint
1998  Yi-wan tang, yi-ge tang: Classifiers and massifiers. Tsing Hua Journal of Chinese Studies (New Series) 28(3). 385–412.Google Scholar
1999 Bare and not-so-bare nouns and the structure of NP. Linguistic Inquiry 30(4). 509–542. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Cinque, Guglielmo
2005 Deriving Greenberg’s universal 20 and its exceptions. Linguistic Inquiry 36(3). 315–332. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Comrie, Bernard
2006 Numbers, language, and culture. (Paper presented at the 16th Jyväskylä Summer School, Jyväskylä, 24 July-11 August 2006.)
2016 Numeral bases. In Dryer, Mathew S. & Haspelmath, Martin (eds.), The world atlas of language structures online. ([URL]) (Accessed 2018-07-17).
Corver, Nobert & Zwarts, Joost
2006 Prepositional numerals. Lingua 116(6). 811–835. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Croft, William
1994 Semantic universals in classifier systems. Word 45(2). 145–171. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Fukui, Naoki & Takano, Yuji
2000 Nominal structure: An extension of the symmetry principle. In Svenonius, Peter (ed.), The derivation of VO and OV, 219–254. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Greenberg, Joseph H.
1990[1972] Numeral classifiers and substantival number: Problems in the genesis of a linguistic type. In Denning, K. & Kemmer, Suzanne (eds.), On language: Selected writings of Joseph H. Greenberg, 166–193. Stanford: Stanford University Press. (First published 1972 in Working Papers on Language Universals 91. 1–39.)Google Scholar
1990[1978] Generalizations about numeral systems. In Denning, K. & Kemmer, Suzanne (eds.), On language: Selected writings of Joseph H. Greenberg, 271–309. Stanford: Stanford University Press. (First published 1978 in Universals of human language, vol. 3: Word Structure, 249–295. Stanford: Stanford University Press.)Google Scholar
Grimshaw, Jane
2000 Locality and extended projection. In Coopmans, Peter & Everaert, Martin B. H. & Grimshaw, Jane (eds.), Lexical specification and insertion, 115–133. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
He, Chuansheng
2015 Complex numerals in Mandarin Chinese are constituents. Lingua 1641. 189–214. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2016 Lun hanyu shu-liang zuhe de chengfen wanzhengxing. [On the constituenthood of the numeral-classifier combinations in Chinese]. Dangdai Yuyanxue [Contemporary Linguistics] 18(1). 1–18.Google Scholar
He, Chuansheng & Her, One-Soon & Hu, Xiaoshi & Zhu, Weijing
2017 Overt coordination in additive numerals of minority languages in South China. Syntax 20(3). 292–316. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Her, One-Soon
2012a Distinguishing classifiers and measure words: A mathematical perspective and implications. Lingua 122(14). 1668–1691. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2012b Structure of classifiers and measure words: A lexical functional account. Language and Linguistics 13(6). 1211–1251.Google Scholar
2017a Deriving classifier word order typology, or Greenberg’s Universal 20A, and universal 20. Linguistics 55(2). 265–303. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Her, One-Soon & Hsieh, Chen-Tien
2010 On the semantic distinction between classifiers and measure words in Chinese. Language and Linguistics 11(3). 527–551.Google Scholar
Her, One-Soon & Tsai, Hui-Chin
2014  Color isn’t silent, shallow isn’t deep: Two case studies of evaluating silent elements. Language and Linguistics 15(6). 775–800. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2015 On silent elements: A case study of grand and its silent entourage. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 33(2). 575–605. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Her, One-Soon & Chen, Jing-Perng & Tsai, Hui-Chin
2015 Justifying silent elements in syntax: The case of a silent numeral, a silent classifier, and two silent nouns in Mandarin Chinese. International Journal of Chinese Linguistics 2(2). 193–226. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Her, One-Soon & Tsai, Hui-Chin & Lin, Kun-Han & Tang, Marc & Lee, Meng-Chang
2016 Numeral bases and numeral classifiers in SMATTI: Word order variation in Tibeto-Burman. (Paper presented at the conference of New Ways of Analyzing Variation–Asia Pacific 4 (NWAV AP4), Chiayi, 22–24 April 2016.)
Hsieh, Miao-Ling
2008 In Her, One-Soon & Chui, Kawai (eds.), The internal structure of noun phrases in Chinese (Taiwan Journal of Linguistics: Book Series in Chinese Linguistics 2). Taipei: Crane Publishing.Google Scholar
Huang, C.-T. James
1982 Logical relations in Chinese and the theory of grammar. Cambridge: MIT. (Doctoral dissertation.)Google Scholar
Huang, C.-T. James & Li, Yen-Hui Audrey & Li, Yafei
2009 The syntax of Chinese. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Huang, C.-T. James & Ochi, Masao
2011 Classifiers and nominal structure: A parametric approach and its consequences. In Gao, Ming-le (ed.), Universals and variation (Proceedings of GLOW in Asia VIII, 2010), 191–197. Beijing: Beijing Language and Culture University Press.Google Scholar
Hurford, James
1975 The linguistic theory of numerals. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
1987 Language and number: The emergence of a cognitive system. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
2001 Numeral systems. In Smelser, Neil J. & Baltes, Paul B. (eds.), International encyclopedia of the social and behavioral sciences, 10756–10761. Amsterdam: Elsevier. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ionin, Tania & Matushansky, Ora
2006 The composition of complex cardinals. Journal of Semantics 23(4). 315–360. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Jackendoff, Ray
1977 X-Bar syntax: A study of phrase structure. Cambridge: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
Jenks, Peter
2010 Evidence for the syntactic diversity of numeral classifiers. (Paper presented at the 84th Annual Meeting of the LSA, Baltimore, 7–10 January 2010.) DOI logo
Jiang, L. Julie
2008 Monotonicity and measure phrases in Chinese. (Paper presented at the 11th International Symposium on Chinese Languages and Linguistics (IsCLL-11), Hsinchu, 23–25 May 2008.)
Kayne, Richard S.
2006b On parameters and on principles of pronunciation. In Hans Broekhuis & Corver, Norbert & Huybregts, Riny & Kleinhenz, Ursula & Koster, Jan (eds.), Organizing grammar: Linguistic studies in honor of Henk van Riemsdijk, 289–299. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2006a A note on the syntax of numerical bases. In Suzuki, Yubun & Mizuno, Keizo & Takami, Ken-ichi (eds.), Gengo kagaku no shinzui o motomete: Nakajima Heizo Kyoju kanreki kinen ronbunshu [In search of the essence language science : Festschrift for professor Heizo Nakazima on the occasion of his sixtieth birthday], 21–41. Tokyo: Hituzi Syobo Publishing.Google Scholar
Li, Charles & Thompson, Sandra
1981 Mandarin Chinese: A functional reference grammar. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Li, Xu-Ping
2011 On the semantics of classifiers in Chinese. Israel: Bar-Ilan University. (Doctoral dissertation.)Google Scholar
Li, Xu-Ping & Rothstein, Susan
2012 Measure readings of Mandarin classifier phrases and the particle de. Language and Linguistics 13(4). 693–741.Google Scholar
Li, Yen-Hui Audrey
1999 Plurality in a classifier language. Journal of East Asian Linguistics 8(1). 75–99. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2014 Structure of noun phrases: Left or right? Taiwan Journal of Linguistics 12(2). 1–32.Google Scholar
Lin, Jo-Wang
1997 Chinese noun phrase structure: DP or NP? In Tsao, Feng-fu & Wang, H. Samuel (eds.), Chinese language and linguistics III: Morphology and lexicon, 31. 401–434. Taipei: Academia Sinica.Google Scholar
Liu, Yi-Hsien
2013 A unified syntactic account of Mandarin subject nominals. Los Angles: University of Southern California. (Doctoral Dissertation.)Google Scholar
Muromatsu, Keiko
1998 On the syntax of classifiers. Maryland: University of Maryland. (Doctoral dissertation.)Google Scholar
Peyraube, Alain
1998 On the history of classifiers in archaic and medieval Chinese. In T’sou, Benjamin K. (ed.), Studia linguistica serica, 39–68. Hong Kong: Language Information Sciences Research Centre, City University of Hong Kong.Google Scholar
Selkirk, Elisabeth
1977 Some remarks on noun phrase structure. In Culicover, Peter W. & Wasow, Thomas & Akmajian, Adrian (eds.), Formal syntax, 285–316. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Simpson, Andrew
2005 Classifiers and DP structure in Southeast Asia. In Cinque, Guglielmo & Kayne, Richard (eds.), The Oxford handbook of comparative syntax, 806–838. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Tang, Chih-Chen Jane
1996  Ta maile bi shizhi and Chinese phrase structure. Bulletin of the Institute of History and Philology 67(3). 445–502.Google Scholar
2005 Nouns or classifiers: A non-movement analysis of classifiers in Chinese. Language and Linguistics 6(3). 431–472.Google Scholar
Watanabe, Akira
2006 Functional projections of nominals in Japanese: Syntax of classifiers. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 24(1). 241–306. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Yang, Rong
2001 Common nouns, classifiers, and quantification in Chinese. New Jersey: The State University of New Jersey. (Doctoral dissertation.)Google Scholar
Zhang, Niina Ning
2011 The constituency of classifier constructions in Mandarin Chinese. Taiwan Journal of Linguistics 9(1). 1–50.Google Scholar
2013 Classifier structures in Mandarin Chinese. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar