Cover not available
Article published In:
Language and Linguistics
Vol. 25:1 (2024) ► pp.28–55

Cleaving idioms with right-node-raising

An LF copying approach

| Korea University
| Korea University
| Korea University

This paper examines right-node-raising (RNR) with idiom chunks. RNR sentences allow idiomatic interpretation when they contain the whole idiom chunk within the pivot (i.e., the shared element) (e.g., Jessica believed, but Zac doubted, that Justin popped the question.), but those containing only a part of the idiom within the pivot do not (e.g., #John kicked, and Mary filled, the bucket.). Given this, Woo (2015) argues for a multidominance approach (cf. Wilder 1999) to RNR in that the multiply dominated pivot must not be partially shared for idiomatic interpretation. However, we report that even if the pivot contains the whole idiom part, the issue of missing idiomatic interpretation in RNR still lingers (e.g., #We played a party game, and they used an ice hammer, to break the ice.). In order to deal with this problem, multidominance, movement, or PF deletion analyses must resort to an extra interpretive parallelism according to which a pivot cannot be used in two different senses simultaneously. From this perspective, we argue that an LF copying approach can explain the idiomaticity in RNR without extra proviso since under this analysis, it is not necessary to postulate a separate LF constraint of interpretive symmetry. We extend our analysis to Korean (and Japanese) data pertaining to RNR with idiomatic or polysemous expressions. We thus conclude that lexical mismatches and interpretive mismatches in English and Korean RNR are solid evidence of interpretive identity in RNR.

Keywords: Anti-Pun Ordinance, idiom, interpretive identity, LF copying, right-node-raising (RNR)
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.Idiomatic interpretation in RNR
  • 3.Previous analyses of RNR phenomena
    • 3.1Movement-based analyses
    • 3.2Deletion-based analyses
    • 3.3Multidominance-based analyses
  • 4.Proposal
    • 4.1LF copying analysis
    • 4.2Korean RNR with idioms
    • 4.3Exploring identity conditions in RNR
  • 5.Conclusion
  • Acknowledgements
  • Notes
  • Abbreviations
  • References
Available under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) 4.0 license.

For any use beyond this license, please contact the publisher at [email protected].

Published online: 2 January 2024
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/lali.00148.kim
References (82)
Abbott, Barbara
1976 Right node raising as a test for constituenthood. Linguistic Inquiry 7(4). 639–642.Google Scholar
Abe, Jun & Hornstein, Nobert
2012 “Lasnik-effects” and string-vacuous ATB movement. In Uribe-Etxebarria, Myriam & Valmala, Vidal (eds.), Ways of structure building, 169–205. Oxford: Oxford University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Abe, Jun & Hoshi, Hiroto
1997 Gapping and P-stranding. Journal of East Asian Linguistics 6(1). 101–136. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Abels, Klaus
2004 Right node raising: Ellipsis or across the board movement? In Moulton, Keir & Wolf, Mathew (eds.), NELS 34: Proceedings of the 34th Annual Meeting of the North East Linguistic Society, 45–60. Amherst: GLSA Publications.Google Scholar
Ahn, Hee-Don & Cho, Yongjoon
2006 A dual analysis of verb-less coordination in Korean. Language Research 42(1). 47–68.Google Scholar
Bachrach, Asaf & Katzir, Roni
2017 Linearizing structures. Syntax 20(1). 1–40. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Barros, Matthew & Vicente, Luis
2011 Right node raising requires both ellipsis and multidomination. University of Pennsylvania Working Papers in Linguistics 17(1). 1–10.Google Scholar
Bošković, Željko
2004 Two notes on right node raising. University of Connecticut Working Papers in Linguistics 121. 13–24.Google Scholar
Bruening, Benjamin
2010 Ditransitive asymmetries and a theory of idiom formation. Linguistic Inquiry 41(4). 519–562. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Carlson, Greg N.
1987 Same and different: Some consequences for syntax and semantics. Linguistics and Philosophy 10(4). 531–565. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Chaves, Rui P.
2014 On the disunity of right-node raising phenomena: Extraposition, ellipsis, and deletion. Language 90(4). 834–886. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Chomsky, Noam
1995 The minimalist program. Cambridge: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
2000 Minimalist inquiries: The framework. In Martin, Roger & Michaels, David & Uriageraka, Juan (eds.), Step by step: Essays on minimalist syntax in honor of Howard Lasnik, 89–155. Cambridge: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
Chung, Daeho
2004 A multiple dominance analysis of right node sharing constructions. Language Research 40(4). 791–811.Google Scholar
Chung, Sandra & Ladusaw, William A. & McCloskey, James
1995 Sluicing and logical form. Natural Language Semantics 3(3). 239–282. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Citko, Barbara
2005 On the nature of merge: External merge, internal merge, and parallel merge. Linguistic Inquiry 36(4). 475–496. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2011 Symmetry in syntax: Merge, move, and labels. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Clapp, Jessica M.
2008 Right node raising: Evidence from ‘rule interaction.’ In Chang, Charles B. & Haynie, Hannah J. (eds.), WCCFL 26: Proceedings of the 26th West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, 129–137. Somerville: Cascadilla Proceedings Project.Google Scholar
de Vos, Mark & Vicente, Luis
2005 Coordination under right node raising. In Alderete, John & Han, Chung-hye & Kochetov, Alexei (eds.), WCCFL 24: Proceedings of the 24th West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, 97–104. Somerville: Cascadilla Proceedings Project.Google Scholar
de Vries, Mark
2009 On multidominance and linearization. Biolinguistics 3(4). 344–403. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Fiengo, Robert & May, Robert
1994 Indices and identity. Cambridge: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
Fraser, Bruce
1970 Idioms within a transformational grammar. Foundations of Language 6(1). 22–42.Google Scholar
Gibbs, Raymond W. Jr. & Nayak, Nandini P.
1989 Psycholinguistic studies on the syntactic behavior of idioms. Cognitive Psychology 21(1). 100–138. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Goldberg, Lotus Madelyn
2005 Verb-stranding VP ellipsis: A cross-linguistic study. Montreal: McGill University. (Doctoral dissertation.)
Goodall, Grant
1987 Parallel structures in syntax: Coordination, causatives and restructuring. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Grosz, Patrick George
2015 Movement and agreement in right-node raising constructions. Syntax 18(1). 1–38. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ha, Seungwan
2008 Ellipsis, right node raising, and across-the-board constructions. Boston: Boston University. (Doctoral dissertation.)
Hamblin, Jennifer L. & Gibbs, Raymond W. Jr.
1999 Why you can’t kick the bucket as you slowly die: Verbs in idiom comprehension. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 28(1). 25–39. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hartman, Jeremy
2009 When e-GIVENness over-predicts identity. (Paper presented at the Fourth Brussels Conference on Generative Linguistics (BCGL 4) Ellipsis Workshop, Brussel, 9–10 November 2009.)
Hartmann, Katharina
2000 Right node raising and gapping: Interface conditions on prosodic deletion. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hornstein, Norbert & Nunes, Jairo & Grohmann, Kleanthes K.
2005 Understanding minimalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ingria, Robert J. P.
1990 The limits of unification. In Berwick, Robert C. (ed.), ACL '90: Proceedings of the 28th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics, 194–204. Stroudsburg: Association for Computational Linguistics. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Jackendoff, Ray
1977 X’ syntax: A study of phrase structure. Cambridge: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
Jayaseelan, Karattuparambil A.
1990 Incomplete VP deletion and gapping. Linguistic Analysis 20(1–2). 64–81.Google Scholar
Johnson, Kyle
2007 LCA+alignment=RNR. (Paper presented at Workshop on Coordination, Subordination and Ellipsis, Tübingen, 6–7 June 2007.)
Kayne, Richard S.
1994 The antisymmetry of syntax. Cambridge: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
Kim, Jeong-Seok
1997 Syntactic focus movement and ellipsis: A minimalist approach. Storrs: University of Connecticut. (Doctoral dissertation.)
2019 Saynglyakkwa chocem: Swuyongseng phantanul cwungsimulo 생략과 초점: 수용성 판단을 중심으로. Seoul: Hankuk Publishing.Google Scholar
Kim, Soowon
1999 Sloppy/strict identity, empty objects, and NP ellipsis. Journal of East Asian Linguistics 8(4). 255–284. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kim, Yong-Ha
2007 Hankwukeuy mwutongsa cepsokmwun 한국어의 무동사 접속문. In Yim, Changguk (ed.), Saynglyakhyensangyenkwu: Pemenecek kwanchal 생략현상연구: 범언어적고찰, 84–122. Seoul: Hankuk Publishing.Google Scholar
Kim, Yong-Ha & Lee, Chung-Hoon
2014 Some semantic mismatches in Korean verb-less coordination. Studies in Modern Grammar 791. 37–50. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Koizumi, Masatoshi
1995 Phrase structure in minimalist syntax. Cambridge: MIT. (Doctoral dissertation.)
Kubota, Yusuke
2015 Nonconstituent coordination in Japanese as constituent coordination: An analysis in hybrid type-logical categorial grammar. Linguistic Inquiry 46(1). 1–42. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Larson, Bradley
2011 Problems with a movement analysis of right node raising in Tagalog. Linguistic Inquiry 42(1). 163–171. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Lasnik, Howard
1999 Chains of arguments. In Epstein, Samuel David & Hornstein, Norbert (eds.), Working minimalism, 189–215. Cambridge: The MIT Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Lee, Hyeran
2005 VP coordination analysis of gapping constructions in Korean. Studies in Generative Grammar 15(4). 533–562.Google Scholar
Lee, Juwon
2020 Semantic taxonomy and NP-coordination in Korean. The Linguistic Association of Korea Journal 28(4). 147–174.Google Scholar
Levine, Robert D. & Hukari, Thomas E.
2006 The unity of unbounded dependency constructions. Stanford: CSLI Publications.Google Scholar
Machonis, Peter A.
1985 Transformations of verb phrase idioms: Passivization, particle movement, dative shift. American Speech 60(4). 291–308. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
McCawley, James D.
1982 Parentheticals and discontinuous constituent structure. Linguistic Inquiry 13(1). 91–106.Google Scholar
Merchant, Jason
2001 The syntax of silence: Sluicing, islands, and the theory of ellipsis. Oxford: Oxford University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2004 Fragments and ellipsis. Linguistics and Philosophy 27(6). 661–738. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2008 Variable island repair under ellipsis. In Johnson, Kyle (ed.), Topics in ellipsis, 132–153. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
2013 Voice and ellipsis. Linguistic Inquiry 44(1). 77–108. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Milward, David
1994 Non-constituent coordination: Theory and practice. In Association for Computational Linguistics (ed.), COLING 94: The 15th International Conference on Computational Linguistics, 935–941. Stroudsburg: Association for Computational Linguistics. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Mukai, Emi
2003 On verbless conjunction in Japanese. In Kadowaki, Makoto & Kawahara, Shigeto (eds.), NELS 33: Proceedings of the Thirty-Third Annual Meeting of the North East Linguistic Society, 205–224. Amherst: GLSA Publications.Google Scholar
O’Grady, William
1998 The syntax of idioms. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 16(2). 279–312. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Oku, Satoshi
1998 A theory of selection and reconstruction in the minimalist perspective. Storrs: University of Connecticut. (Doctoral dissertation.)
Otani, Kazuyo & Whitman, John
1991 V-raising and VP-ellipsis. Linguistic Inquiry 22(2). 345–358.Google Scholar
Park, Myung-Kwan
2009 Right node raising as conjunction reduction fed by linearization. Language Research 45(2). 179–202.Google Scholar
Postal, Paul M.
1974 On raising: One rule of English grammar and its theoretical implications. Cambridge: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
1998 Three investigations of extraction. Cambridge: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
Pullum, Geoffrey K. & Zwicky, Arnold M.
1986 Phonological resolution of syntactic feature conflict. Language 62(4). 751–773. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ross, John R.
1967 Constraints on variables in syntax. Cambridge: MIT. (Doctoral dissertation.)
Sabbagh, Joseph A.
2007 Ordering and linearizing rightward movement. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 25(2). 349–401. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Saito, Mamoru
1987 Three notes on syntactic movement in Japanese. In Imai, Takashi & Saito, Mamoru (eds.), Issues in Japanese linguistics, 301–350. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2007 Notes on East Asian argument ellipsis. Language Research 43(2). 203–227.Google Scholar
2017 Ellipsis. In Shibatani, Masayoshi & Miyagawa, Shigeru & Noda, Hisashi (eds.), Handbook of Japanese syntax, 701–750. Boston: Mouton de Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Sakamoto, Yuta
2016 Phases and argument ellipsis in Japanese. Journal of East Asian Linguistics 25(3). 243–274. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2017 Escape from silent syntax. Storrs: University of Connecticut. (Doctoral dissertation.)
2019 Overtly empty but covertly complex. Linguistic Inquiry 50(1). 105–136. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Sato, Yosuke
2020 Idioms, argument ellipsis and LF-copy. Journal of East Asian Linguistics 29(3). 259–278. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Sohn, Keun-Won
1999 Deletion or copying? Right node raising in Korean and Japanese. In Editorial Committee of Nanzan GLOW (ed.), Proceedings of the Nanzan GLOW: The Second Glow Meeting in Asia September 19–22, 1999, 367–384. Nagoya: Nanzan University.Google Scholar
Stone, Megan Schildmier
2013 Can idioms be passivized? Evidence from online processing. Coyote Papers 211. ([URL]) (Accessed 2021-05-05).
Stowell, Tim
1991 The alignment of arguments in adjective phrases. In Rothstein, Susan D. (ed.), Perspectives on phrase structure: Heads and licensing (Syntax and Semantics 25), 105–135. San Diego: Academic Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Svenonius, Peter
2005 Extending the extension condition to discontinuous idioms. In Pica, Pierre & Rooryck, Johan & van Craenenbroeck, Jeroen (eds.), Linguistic variation yearbook, vol. 51, 227–263. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Wexler, Kenneth & Culicover, Peter W.
1980 Formal principles of language acquisition. Cambridge: The MIT Press.Google Scholar
Whitman, Philip Neal
2005 Category neutrality: A type-logical investigation. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Wilder, Chris
1999 Right node raising and the LCA. In Bird, Sonya & Carnie, Andrew & Haugen, Jason D. & Norquest, Peter (eds.), WCCFL 18: Proceedings of the 18th West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, 586–598. Somerville: Cascadilla Press.Google Scholar
Woo, Brent
2015 Breaking idioms with right node raising. (Paper presented at The Eighth Brussels Conference on Generative Linguistics (BCGL 8): The Grammar of Idioms, Brussels, 4–5 June 2015.)
Zaenen, Annie & Karttunen, Lauri
1984 Morphological non-distinctiveness and coordination. In Alvarez, Gloria & Brodie, Belinda & McCoy, Terry (eds.), Proceedings of the First Eastern States Conference on Linguistics (ESCOL ’84): The Ohio State University, 309–320. Columbus: ESCOL 84.Google Scholar
Zwicky, Arnold & Sadock, Jerrold M.
1975 Ambiguity tests and how to fail them. In Kimball, John F. (ed.), Syntax and Semantics 41, 1–36. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar