Article published in:Differential objects and datives – a homogeneous class?
Edited by Monica Alexandrina Irimia and Anna Pineda
[Lingvisticæ Investigationes 42:1] 2019
► pp. 102–131
Prolegomena to the study of object relations
This paper argues that there is nothing “differential” in the licensing conditions of Differential Object Marking and outlines an analysis that unifies dom with dative object marking and with a broader set of “derived object”-marking configurations. We show that neither morphological nor syntactic distinctiveness can be the driving force for dom: accounts of dom as a morphological distinctiveness device are inadequate diachronically and very unefficient functionally. Syntactic analyses that postulate DP-internal differences or construction-specific double-licensing conditions fail to capture the basic fact that dom is a relation between the objects and the predicates selecting them. Precisely, the burden of our unified explanation falls on the checking requirements imposed to the DP complements by the structural heads selecting them.
- 1.Scales and other theoretical artifacts
- 2.Syntactic accounts
- 2.1Differential licensing
- 2.2The locus of parametric variation
- 3.The importance of being an object
- 3.1Direct objects
- 3.1.1The house of dom
- 3.1.2A note on specificity
- 3.1.3 dom and agreement are not two sides of the same coin
- 3.1.4Putting everything together. The derivation of Object dom
- 3.2Derived objects
- 3.1Direct objects
Published online: 10 July 2019
Baker, M. C.
Baker, M. C. & Vinokurova, N.
Béjar, S. & Rezac, M.
Belletti, A. & Menetti, C.
In press. Topics and passives in Italian-speaking children and adults. Language acquisition.
Bernstein, J., Ordóñez, F. & Roca, F.
2018 dom and DP layers in romance. Talk presented at Differential Object Marking in romance-towards microvariation , Inalco, Paris Nov. 10 2018.
Berro, A. & Fernández, B.
Croft, W. & Poole, K. T.
Fernández, B. & Rezac, M.
García García, M.
Harley, H. & Ritter, E.
2018 Are we making progress in understanding differential object marking? https://dlc.hypotheses.org/1119
Irimia, M. A.
Jones, M. A.
2018 Parametric variation in dom in the dialects of Southern Italy. Talk, International workshop Differential Object Marking in Romance. Towards Microvariation. INALCO, Paris 2018/11/9-10
Ormazabal, J. & Romero, J.
Paul, W. & Whitman, J.
2018 Differential object marking in Catalan varieties. Talk, International workshop Differential Object Marking in Romance. Towards Microvariation. INALCO, Paris 2018/11/9-10.
Rappaport-Hovav, M. & Levin, B.
Rodríguez Mondoñedo, M.
Sigurðsson, H. Á.
von Heusinger, K. & Kaiser, G. A.
2005 The evolution of differential object marking in Spanish. In K. von Heusinger, G. A. Kaiser & E. Stark (Eds.). Proceedings of the Workshop “Specificity and the Evolution / Emergence of Nominal Determination Systems in Romance”, 33–70. Arbeitspapier Nr. 119. Fachbereich Sprachwissenschaft, Universität Konstanz.