A questionnaire-based study of impersonalization in Romanian and English
With special attention to passivization
Valentin Rădulescu | University of Cambridge , UK
Daniël Van Olmen | Lancaster University , UK
This paper is the first contrastive study of impersonalization in Romanian and English. Taking an acceptability
judgment approach, we describe the functional potential in all impersonal uses of not only the pronouns ‘one’, ‘you’ and ‘they’
but also the lesser studied passive. We find inter alia: a similar division of labor in the languages between ‘you’ and ‘they’ for
contexts paraphrasable as, respectively, ‘everyone’ and ‘someone/some people’; a wider range of uses for pro-dropped ‘they’ than
for its overt counterpart, as hypothesized in previous research; and a preference in English, but not Romanian, for passives to
‘they’ especially in contexts like ‘they’ve stolen my wallet!’, where the referent is entirely unidentifiable and likely to be
singular. Levels of identifiability and number, each of which has been suggested in a separate semantic map as necessary for
capturing impersonalization, are also shown to interact, supporting a proposal to combine them in one map.
Keywords: impersonal, pronoun, passive, semantic map, English/Romanian
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 1.1Impersonalization
- 1.2Impersonal constructions
- 1.3Languages
- 2.Methodology
- 2.1Acceptability judgment questionnaires
- 2.2Questionnaire design
- 2.3Implementation
- 2.4Statistics
- 3.Results
- 3.1Universal-internal uses
- 3.1.1In general
- 3.1.2‘You’ and ‘one’
- 3.1.3The passive, versus ‘you’
- 3.2Non-universal-internal uses
- 3.2.1In general
- 3.2.2‘They’
- 3.2.3The passive, versus ‘they’
- 3.3Summary
- 3.1Universal-internal uses
- 4.Conclusion
- Notes
- Abbreviations
-
References
Published online: 21 May 2021
https://doi.org/10.1075/lic.20004.rad
https://doi.org/10.1075/lic.20004.rad
References
Baayen, R. H.
Bard, E. G., Robertson, D. and Sorace, A.
Cabredo Hofherr, P.
Cojocaru, D.
Coussé, E. and van der Auwera, J.
Creissels, D.
D’Alessandro, R.
Data-Bukowska, E.
De Hoop, H. and Tarenskeen, S.
Dobrovie-Sorin, C.
Fenger, P.
Fernández, S. S.
Fonesca-Greber, B. and Waugh, L. R.
Gast, V.
Gast, V., Deringer, L., Haas, F. and Rudolf, O.
Gast, V. and van der Auwera, J.
Giacalone Ramat, A. and Sansò, A.
Haas, F.
2018b Changing
Human Impersonal Pronouns in English: A Corpus Study. Paper presented at
the Fifty-First Conference of the Societas Linguistica
Europaea. Tallinn, Estonia, 30 August
2018.
Hall, D.
Jensen, T. J. and Gregerson, F.
Kitagawa, C. and Lehrer, A.
Kluge, B.
Laberge, S. and Sankoff, G.
Malamud, S.
Manea, C.
Moltmann, F.
O’Connor, P. E.
Pană Dindelegan, G.
Posio, P. and Vilkuna, M.
Rudolf, O.
Sansò, A.
Shibatani, M.
Siewierska, A. and Papastathi, M.
Sprouse, J. and Almeida, D.
Stirling, L. and Manderson, L.
van der Auwera, J., Gast, V. and Vanderbiesen, J.
Van Olmen, D. and Breed, A.