Theory Construction in Second Language Acquisition

Geoff Jordan | ESADE, Barcelona

Hardbound – Available

ISBN 9789027217059 (Eur) | EUR 98.00

ISBN 9781588114815 (USA) | USD 147.00

Paperback – Available

ISBN 9789027217066 (Eur) | EUR 36.00

ISBN 9781588114822 (USA) | USD 54.00

e-Book –

ISBN 9789027295767 | EUR 98.00/36.00*
| USD 147.00/54.00*

Recently, many SLA researchers have adopted a postmodernist approach which challenges the assumption that SLA research is a rationalist, scientific endeavour. The resulting epistemological arguments, plus problems of theory proliferation, contradicting theories, and theory domain, hinder progress towards a unified theory of SLA. Theory Construction in SLA addresses these problems by returning to first principles; it asks whether there is such a thing as reliable knowledge, what is special about scientific method, and how we can best explain SLA. It is the first book to use the philosophy of science in order to examine the epistemological underpinnings of SLA research and evaluate rival theories of SLA. Part One explores the central issues in the philosophy of science, defends rationality against relativists, and offers Guidelines for theory assessment. Part Two examines different theories of SLA and evaluates them in terms of how well they stand up to the Guidelines.

[Language Learning & Language Teaching, 8] 2004. xviii, 295 pp.

Publishing status: Available
Published online on 21 October 2008

https://doi.org/10.1075/lllt.8

Table of Contents

Acknowledgements | p. xiii

Abstract | p. xv

The Guidelines (Abridged) | p. xvii

Part 1. Some fundamental issues concerning the construction and assessment of theories of SLA

1. Key terms and current problems in SLA | p. 5

2. Research methodology: Rationalism and its critics | p. 19

3. Recent relativists | p. 51

4. In defence of rationalism | p. 69

5. The construction and assessment of theories of SLA | p. 87

Part 2. A critical rationalist review of some hypotheses, models and theories of SLA

6. Chomsky | p. 123

7. The role of UG in an explanation of SLA | p. 151

8. Approaches to SLA that offend the guidelines | p. 167

9. Signs of progress | p. 203

10. Explaining SLA | p. 251

Name index | p. 287

Subject index | p. 291

“Whereas SLA research has grown relatively sophisticated methodologically over the past 30 years, it has been a very different story where SLA theorizing and theory evaluation are concerned. SLA theories (using the term loosely) continue to proliferate, and most remain on the market well past their shelf-life. The existence of relationships between acquisition and use is taken by some to mean claims about either are one and the same. Worse, the rationalist enterprise and SLA's status as an emerging discipline within cognitive science and are currently challenged by a small but vocal assortment of relativists and 'critical' theorists (few of whom conduct research), creating confusion, impeding progress, and threatening the field's credibility. What has long been needed, and what this book provides, is an authoritative analysis of the epistemological issues by someone familiar with the debates in the SLA literature who also has serious academic credentials in the history and philosophy of science. A student of Popper's in LSE's prime, as well as of Lakatos, Feyerabend, and Laudan, Geoff Jordan has provided a scholarly, yet accessible, book that should be of great benefit to faculty and students alike, and having a lasting impact on the field.”

Mike Long, Professor of SLA and Director, School of Languages, Literatures, and Cultures, University of Maryland, College Park, USA

“For readers who, for whatever reason, have felt a sense of frustration with the way theory is heading in SLA, this is a book worth reading. It asks the applied linguist to go back to the philosophical roots of science, and proposes some guidelines for SLA research so that the field can proceed on common philosophical and methodological ground. The book is an ambitious undertaking and Jordan's degree of success varies with each chapter, but as a whole it is a very useful, thought-provoking addition to the SLA literature.”

Stephen A. Bird, University of Brunei Darussalam, in Language and Education Vol. 19(5), 2005

“This book first sets up a series of guidelines based on theories of science and then measures diverse theories of second language acquisition against them. It is fascinating to see Popper, Chomsky and Krashen mentioned in the same breath and the book provides a highly useful introduction to the philosophical bases of second language acquisition research. It is also interesting to see which theories survive the best, with rather surprising results. It is a sign of maturity that a field has a sufficient breadth and depth of work to be evaluated in this way and we are fortunate that the author has the background to make this bridge between the disciplines.”

Vivian Cook, University of Essex

“This is an important book. There are quite a few treatments of second language acquisition (SLA) research, but no other book captures theory construction the way Jordan does. Even though his conclusions may not be shared by everyone, his argumentation is straight and fair and his judgements are balanced. It is a rich source of information on the main theories and it aims to give as objective as possible an evaluation of these theories. Even though it is sometime dense and complex, it is a 'must-read' for researchers and graduate students in SLA and language development.”

Kees de Bot, University of Groningen, in Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development Vol. 27(6), 2006

“Overall, Jordan offers a very knowledgeable and well-written account of theory construction in general and theorising in the field of second language research in particular, which should be of interest to virtually everyone in the diverse SLA community, from postgraduate students to senior scholars. The broad scope of the book makes it a valuable source of information not only for researchers interested in the epistemology of their subject area, but also for students new to the field of SLA who seek an up-to-date outline of second language theories past and present. Unlike the volumes specifically devoted to providing such an overview (e.g. R. Ellis, 1994; Mitchell & Myles, 1998), Jordan's book is — intentionally — less exhaustive; however, it offers the added bonus of a critical appraisal against a fascinating historical backdrop. The epistemological chapters do not require any prior knowledge in the area of philosophy. Whether Darwin or Derrida, Pavlov or Popper — Jordan's treatment of what might appear to be daunting subject matter is always accessible and often highly entertaining. Jordan's lucid writing gives us a very useful insight into an essentially complex topic, allowing the reader to see the field of second language research within the bigger picture of philosophy and science, and to locate his/her own position, views, and beliefs in relation to the history of theory construction.”

Karen Roehr, Lancaster University on Linguist List 15.1864, 2004

“Jordan's lucid writing gives us a very useful insight into an essentially complex topic, allowing the reader to see the field of second language research within the bigger picture of philosophy and science”

Karen Roehr, Lancaster University on Linguist List 15.1864, 2004

“This volume is extremely valuable due its critical its critical approach and comparative evaluation of theories. Thus, it should be of great interest and benefit, not only to specialists and researchers, but also to newcomers to the field who need a comprehensive overview.”

Marcus Callies, Phillips University Marburg, on eLanguage, 2008-05-13 21:38:03

Cited by (59)

Cited by 59 other publications

Order by:

Kawaguchi, Satomi, Bruno Di Biase & Yumiko Yamaguchi

2023. Chapter 1. Processability Theory, second language learning and teaching in the Asia-Pacific region. In Processability and Language Acquisition in the Asia-Pacific Region [Processability Approaches to Language Acquisition Research & Teaching, 9], ► pp. 1 ff.

T. Rayes, Eman & Nuha K. Albelaihi

2023. Investigating Bandura’s Processes of Observational Learning Implementations from EFL Faculty Perspective at Umm Al-Qura University English Language Centre. SSRN Electronic Journal

Forsyth, Helen Victoria

2022. A Processability Approach to Instructed Language Learning in Multilingual Contexts Developmental Stages from a Receptive Competence Perspective. EL.LE :2

Rastelli, Stefano

2022. Chapter 5. The uncertainty principle in second language acquisition. In Second Language Acquisition Theory [Bilingual Processing and Acquisition, 14], ► pp. 101 ff.

Río, José Ignacio Aguilar & Cédric Brudermann

2022. Construit ou objet construit ? Questionner la valeur épistémologique de l’entrée « interculturel » dans des supports académiques du supérieur français. Contextes et didactiques :20

Wirag, Andreas, Yunong Li & Bin Zhang

2022. Applying cognitive linguistics to foreign language teaching and learning. Cognitive Linguistic Studies 9:2 ► pp. 185 ff.

Lichtman, Karen & Bill VanPatten

2021. Was Krashen right? Forty years later. Foreign Language Annals 54:2 ► pp. 283 ff.

Bardovi-Harlig, Kathleen & Llorenç Comajoan-Colomé

2020. THE ASPECT HYPOTHESIS AND THE ACQUISITION OF L2 PAST MORPHOLOGY IN THE LAST 20 YEARS. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 42:5 ► pp. 1137 ff.

Han, Weifeng

2020. Introduction. In Universal Grammar and the Initial State of Second Language Learning [SpringerBriefs in Education, ], ► pp. 1 ff.

Nicolas, Laura

2019. Bibliographie. In Dynamiques langagières et logiques professorales en classe de langue, ► pp. 201 ff.

Jakobson, Liivi

2018. Teacher written feedback on adult beginners’ writing in a second language. ITL - International Journal of Applied Linguistics 169:2 ► pp. 235 ff.

Bradley, Linda, Nataliya Berbyuk Lindström & Sylvana Sofkova Hashemi

2017. Integration and Language Learning of Newly Arrived Migrants Using Mobile Technology. Journal of Interactive Media in Education 2017:1 ► pp. 3 ff.

Al-Shalabi, Nazmi Tawfiq

2016. A Postmodernist Reading of Anne Tyler's Breathing Lessons, Jean Rhys's Wide Sargasso Sea and Kurt Vonnegut's Breakfast of Champions. SSRN Electronic Journal

Skehan, Peter

2016. Tasks Versus Conditions: Two Perspectives on Task Research and Their Implications for Pedagogy. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics 36 ► pp. 34 ff.

Walenta, Magdalena

2016. Reconciling SLA Theories with Classroom Practice: Designing a Principled Eclectic Bridge. In Classroom-Oriented Research [Second Language Learning and Teaching, ], ► pp. 243 ff.

Baten, Kristof, Aafke Buyl, Katja Lochtman & Mieke Van Herreweghe

2015. Chapter 1. Processability theory. In Theoretical and Methodological Developments in Processability Theory [Processability Approaches to Language Acquisition Research & Teaching, 4], ► pp. 1 ff.

Buyl, Aafke & Alex Housen

2015. Developmental stages in receptive grammar acquisition: A Processability Theory account. Second Language Research 31:4 ► pp. 523 ff.

Couper, Graeme

2015. Applying Theories of Language and Learning to Teaching Pronunciation. In The Handbook of English Pronunciation, ► pp. 413 ff.

Earp, Brian D. & David Trafimow

2015. Replication, falsification, and the crisis of confidence in social psychology. Frontiers in Psychology 6

Fahim, Mansoor & Hossein Parsazadeh

2015. The dilemma of the dilemma: Getting education issues out of their dilemmas. Policy Futures in Education 13:4 ► pp. 492 ff.

Sadeghi, Karim & Zainab Abolfazli Khonbi

2015. Language Learning Aptitude (LLA) and Language Learning Strategy (LLS) use among Iranian university EFL students: Patterns and relationships. Eurasian Journal of Applied Linguistics 1:1 ► pp. 77 ff.

Dakowska, Maria

2014. Are the Only Things That Count the Things That Can Be Counted? On Modeling as a Cognitive Tool in the Field of Foreign Language Learning and Teaching. In Studying Second Language Acquisition from a Qualitative Perspective [Second Language Learning and Teaching, 27], ► pp. 17 ff.

Dakowska, Maria

2014. O rozwoju dydaktyki języków obcych jako dyscypliny naukowej,

Dakowska, Maria

2018. How to Deal with Applications in Foreign Language Learning and Teaching (FLLT). In Challenges of Second and Foreign Language Education in a Globalized World [Second Language Learning and Teaching, ], ► pp. 17 ff.

Hulstijn, Jan H., Richard F. Young, Lourdes Ortega, Martha Bigelow, Robert DeKeyser, Nick C. Ellis, James P. Lantolf, Alison Mackey & Steven Talmy

2014. BRIDGING THE GAP. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 36:3 ► pp. 361 ff.

Macré, Nicola

2014. Les apprenants LANSAD de niveau A2/B1 en première année d’anglais en autonomie accompagnée médiatisée : quels besoins ?. Recherche et pratiques pédagogiques en langues de spécialité - Cahiers de l APLIUT Vol. XXXIII N° 2 ► pp. 118 ff.

Collentine, Joseph

2013. Subjunctive in Second Language Spanish. In The Handbook of Spanish Second Language Acquisition, ► pp. 270 ff.

Fulcher, Glenn

2013. Philosophy and Language Testing. In The Companion to Language Assessment, ► pp. 1431 ff.

Hulstijn, Jan H.

2013. Is the Second Language Acquisition discipline disintegrating?. Language Teaching 46:4 ► pp. 511 ff.

Khatib, Mohammad & Nima Shakouri

2013. On Situating the Stance of Socio-cognitive Approach to Language Acquisition. Theory and Practice in Language Studies 3:9

Whong, Melinda

2013. Applied Generative SLA: The Need for an Agenda and a Methodology. In Universal Grammar and the Second Language Classroom [Educational Linguistics, 16], ► pp. 231 ff.

Zhao, Wanzhe

2013. Intelligent Computer Aided Second Language Learning Based on Constitutive Principle. In Proceedings of the 2012 International Conference of Modern Computer Science and Applications [Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, 191], ► pp. 247 ff.

Butler, Yuko Goto

2012. Bilingualism/Multilingualism and Second‐Language Acquisition. In The Handbook of Bilingualism and Multilingualism, ► pp. 109 ff.

DAVYDOVA, JULIA

2012. Englishes in the Outer and Expanding Circles: A comparative study. World Englishes 31:3 ► pp. 366 ff.

Robinson, Peter

2012. Aptitude in Second Language Acquisition. In The Encyclopedia of Applied Linguistics,

CHAPELLE, CAROL A.

2009. The Relationship Between Second Language Acquisition Theory and Computer‐Assisted Language Learning. The Modern Language Journal 93:s1 ► pp. 741 ff.

Thomas, Margaret

2009. Review article: Ethical issues in the study of second language acquisition: resources for researchers. Second Language Research 25:4 ► pp. 493 ff.

DE BOT, KEES

2008. Introduction: Second Language Development as a Dynamic Process. The Modern Language Journal 92:2 ► pp. 166 ff.

Narcy-Combes, Marie-Françoise

2008. L’anglais de spécialité en LEA : entre proximité et distance, un nouvel équilibre à construire. ASp :53-54 ► pp. 129 ff.

Narcy-Combes, Marie-Françoise

2008. Conflits de représentations et adaptation des dispositifs d’enseignement/apprentissage. Les Cahiers de l'APLIUT :Vol. XXVII N° 1 ► pp. 32 ff.

GASS, SUSAN M., JUNKYU LEE & ROBIN ROOTS

2007. Firth and Wagner (1997): New Ideas or a New Articulation?. The Modern Language Journal 91:s1 ► pp. 788 ff.

GASS, SUSAN M., JUNKYU LEE & ROBIN ROOTS

2007. Firth and Wagner (1997): New Ideas or a New Articulation?. The Modern Language Journal 91:s1 ► pp. 788 ff.

Grosbois, Muriel

2007. Didactique des langues et recherche expérimentale. Recherches en didactique des langues et des cultures 4:4

Grosbois, Muriel

2009. TIC, tâches et nativisation : impact sur la production orale en L2. Alsic :Vol. 12

Grosbois, Muriel

2011. CMC-based projects and L2 learning: confirming the importance of nativisation. ReCALL 23:3 ► pp. 294 ff.

Grosbois, Muriel

2014. Mobilité internationale et production orale en anglais L2. Les dossiers des sciences de l'éducation :32 ► pp. 65 ff.

Pallotti, Gabriele

2007. An Operational Definition of the Emergence Criterion. Applied Linguistics 28:3 ► pp. 361 ff.

Pallotti, Gabriele

2022. Cratylus’ silence: On the philosophy and methodology of Complex Dynamic Systems Theory in SLA. Second Language Research 38:3 ► pp. 689 ff.

Pallotti, Gabriele

2023. Constructive dialogue, disruptive criticism and the complex dynamics of academic life. Instructed Second Language Acquisition 7:1 ► pp. 27 ff.

Steinbach, Markus, Ruth Albert, Heiko Girnth, Annette Hohenberger, Bettina Kümmerling-Meibauer, Jörg Meibauer, Monika Rothweiler & Monika Schwarz-Friesel

2007. Bilingualer Spracherwerb und Zweitspracherwerb. In Schnittstellen der germanistischen Linguistik, ► pp. 103 ff.

Narcy-Combes, Jean-Paul

2006. Deux modes de fonctionnement mémoriel en production langagière et tâches d’apprentissage des langues. Les Cahiers de l'APLIUT :Vol. XXV N° 2 ► pp. 77 ff.

Narcy-Combes, Jean-Paul

2008. LEA/LANSAD : Convergences/Divergences – Synthèse des travaux. Les Cahiers de l'APLIUT :Vol. XXVII N° 1 ► pp. 90 ff.

Narcy-Combes, Jean-Paul

2021. 2008 – « LEA/LANSAD : Convergences/Divergences – Synthèse des travaux ». Recherche et pratiques pédagogiques en langues de spécialité - Cahiers de l APLIUT :Vol. 40 N°2

Narcy‑Combes, Jean‑Paul

2006. La didactique de L2 à la croisée des chemins. Recherches en didactique des langues et des cultures :2

Demaizière, Françoise & Jean-Paul Narcy-Combes

2005. Méthodologie de la recherche didactique : nativisation, tâches et TIC. Alsic :Vol. 8, n° 1 ► pp. 45 ff.

Demaizière, Françoise & Jean-Paul Narcy-Combes

2007. Du positionnement épistémologique aux données de terrain. Recherches en didactique des langues et des cultures 4:4

[no author supplied]

2011. Bibliographie. In Interagir et apprendre en ligne, ► pp. 251 ff.

[no author supplied]

2015. Language Proficiency in Native and Non-native Speakers [Language Learning & Language Teaching, 41],

[no author supplied]

2020. Theory of Second and Foreign Language Learning. In Textbook Theory and Invariant Approaches to Language Learning [Advances in Educational Technologies and Instructional Design, ], ► pp. 1 ff.

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 24 october 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.

Subjects