Article published in:
Revisiting Linguistic Territoriality in Contemporary Europe
Edited by Till Burckhardt, John Coakley and László Marácz
[Language Problems and Language Planning 45:2] 2021
► pp. 187–217

Linguistic territoriality in Switzerland

Exploring the roots of a constitutional principle

| Université de Genève
This article argues that the linguistic territoriality principle cannot be considered as a general guideline for the design of language policy but rather as a tool to find the right balance between linguistic freedom and linguistic peace under given circumstances. The article traces the origin and evolution of language policy principles during the drafting process of the new constitutional article in its three official language versions. The Swiss language regime is embedded in an institutional system of executive federalism in which mostly monolingual cantons and municipalities are in charge of implementing nearly all public policy. This significantly reduces the relevance of the inconsistency between a formally personalistic multilingual federal language regime and linguistic territoriality deriving from cantonal language regimes. The point of the new federal regulation is to provide room for manoeuvre for cantonal policymakers to adopt legislation based on linguistic territoriality. The relevant constitutional article recognises that territorial language policies can be implemented to ensure linguistic peace. At the same time, the personality principle may be adopted to protect autochthonous linguistic minorities.
Keywords: territoriality principle, personality principle, linguistic freedom, state traditions, Switzerland
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
  • 2.The roots of linguistic territoriality
  • 3.The Swiss national languages and their challenges
    • 3.1The survival of Romansh
    • 3.2The ambiguous status of Italian
    • 3.3The threatened equality of French
    • 3.4German or Swiss-German?
    • 3.5Non-territorial national minorities
  • 4.The (non-)recognition of the territoriality principle
    • 4.1Recognition of Romansh
    • 4.2Language communities or language regions?
    • 4.3Minority rights at national level
    • 4.4Territoriality
  • 5.Conclusion
  • Notes
  • References
Published online: 24 November 2021
https://doi.org/10.1075/lplp.00077.bur
References
Acklin Mujin, D.
(2005) La première révision de l’article des langues. Vers la reconnaissance du romanche comme langue nationale (1935–1938). In: J. Widmer, R. Coray, D. Acklin Mujin, & É. Godel (Eds.), Die Schweizer Sprachenvielfalt im öffentlichen Diskurs. La diversité des langues en Suisse dans le débat public. (pp. 127–246). Berne: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Auer, A.
(2005) The constitutional scheme of federalism. Journal of European Public Policy, 12(3), 419–431. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Belser, E. M., & Waldmann, B.
(2015) Art. 70. In: B. Waldmann, E. M. Belser, & A. Epiney. Bundesverfassung. Basler Kommentar Basel: Helbing Lichtenhahn Verlag.Google Scholar
Berner, H.
(2010) Kirchgemeinde. In: Historisches Lexikon der Schweiz (HLS), Version vom 20.05.2010. Online: https://​hls​-dhs​-dss​.ch​/de​/articles​/010263​/2010​-05​-20/, accessed 2021-07-17.
Büchi, C.
(2001) Mariage de raison, Romands et Alémaniques : une histoire suisse. Carouge: Zoé.Google Scholar
Cardinal, L.
(Ed.) (2008) Le fédéralisme asymétrique et les minorités lingusitiques nationales. Ottawa: Prise de parole.Google Scholar
Cardinal, L., & Sonntag, S. K.
(2015) Introduction: State traditions and language regimes: Conceptualizing language policy choices. In: L. Cardinal & S. K. Sonntag (Eds.), State Traditions and Language Regimes (pp. 3–28). Montreal, QC/Kingston, ON: McGill-Queen’s University Press.Google Scholar
Cherix, F.
(2009) La question romande. Lausanne: Favre.Google Scholar
Christen, H., Glaser, E., & Friedli, M.
(2010) Kleiner Sprachatlas der deutschen Schweiz. 5. überarbeitete und erweiterte Ausgabe. Frauenfeld/Stuttgart/Wien: Huber.Google Scholar
Coray, R.
(2005) Minderheitenschutz und Beziehungspflege: die zweite Revision des Sprachenartikels (1985–1996). In: J. Widmer, R. Coray, D. Acklin Mujin, & É. Godel (Eds.), Die Schweizer Sprachenvielfalt im öffentlichen Diskurs. La diversité des langues en Suisse dans le débat public (pp. 247–428). Berne: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
(2008) Von der Mumma Romontscha zum Retortenbaby Rumantsch Grischun. Chur: Verlag Bündner Monatsblatt.Google Scholar
Dardanelli, P.
(2010) Federal democracy in Switzerland. In: M. Burgess & A.-G. Gagnon (Eds.), Federal democracies (pp. 142–159). Milton Park/New York, NY: Routledge.Google Scholar
Dardanelli, P., & Stojanović, N.
(2011) The acid test? Competing theses on the nationality–democracy nexus and the case of Switzerland. Nations and Nationalism, 17(2), 357–376. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
De Schutter, H.
(2008) The linguistic territoriality principle – A critique. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 25(2), 105–120. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Degen, B.
(2010) Arbeitsfrieden. In: Historisches Lexikon der Schweiz (HLS), Version vom 06.05.2010. Online: https://​hls​-dhs​-dss​.ch​/de​/articles​/016535​/2010​-05​-06/, accessed on 2021-07-16.
Erne, E.
(2007) Helvetische Gesellschaft. In: Historisches Lexikon der Schweiz (HLS), Version vom 05.12.2007. Online: https://​hls​-dhs​-dss​.ch​/de​/articles​/016429​/2007​-12​-05/, accessed on 2021-07-15.
FDHA
(1989) Le quadrilinguisme en Suisse – présent et futur. Analyse, propositions et recommandations d’un groupe de travail du Département fédéral de l’intérieur. Bern: Federal Chancellery.Google Scholar
Gagnon, A. G., Turgeon, L., & De Champlain, O.
(2006) Representative bureaucracy in multinational states. Revue francaise d’administration publique, (2), 291–306. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Gazzola, M.
(2016) Programmazione e controllo della ‘politica del plurilinguismo’nell’ amministrazione federale svizzera. Studi Italiani di Linguistica Teorica e Applicata, 45(3), 479–497.Google Scholar
Grin, F.
(2002) La Suisse comme non-multination. In: M. Seymour (Ed.), États-nations, multinations et organisations supranationales (pp. 265–282). Montréal, QC: Liber.Google Scholar
Grunder, H.-U.
(2015) Alphabetisierung. In Historisches Lexikon der Schweiz (HLS), Version 2015-01-21. Online: https://​hls​-dhs​-dss​.ch​/de​/articles​/010394​/2015​-01​-21/, accessed on 2021-10-12).Google Scholar
Haller, W., Kölz, A., & Gächter, T.
(2013) Allgemeines Staatsrecht. Eine juristische Einführung in die Allgemeine Staatslehre. Zurich: Schulthess Verlag.Google Scholar
Kägi-Diener, R.
(2015) Art. 70. In: B. Ehrenzeller, B. Schindler, R. J. Schweizer, & K. A. Vallender (Eds.), Schweizerische Bundesverfassung. Sankt Galler Kommentar. (3rd ed., Vol. 11, pp. 1442–1460). Zürich/St. Gallen: Dike.Google Scholar
Kaufmann, R. U.
2016 Judentum. In: Historisches Lexikon der Schweiz (HLS), Version vom 01.02.2016. Online: https://​hls​-dhs​-dss​.ch​/de​/articles​/011376​/2016​-02​-01/, accessed on 2021-07-16.
Kreis, G.
(2015) Schweiz. In: Historisches Lexikon der Schweiz (HLS), Version vom 19.06.2015. Online: https://​hls​-dhs​-dss​.ch​/de​/articles​/009825​/2015​-06​-19/, accessed on 2021-07-16.
Kübler, D., Kobelt, É., & Andrey, S.
(2013) Towards a representative bureaucracy: Promoting linguistic representation and diversity in the Swiss and Canadian federal public services. World political science, 8(1), 272–296. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Kübler, D., Kobelt, E., & Zwicky, R.
(2020) Les langues du pouvoir: le plurilinguisme dans l’administration fédérale. Lausanne: Presses polytechniques et universitaires romandes.Google Scholar
Kymlicka, W.
(1989) Liberalism, community and culture. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
(1995) Multicultural citizenship: a liberal theory of minority rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
(2001) Politics in the vernacular: Nationalism, multiculturalism, and citizenship. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Laitin, D. D.
(2000) What is a language community? American Journal of Political Science, 44(1), 142–155. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Laponce, J. A.
(2003) On Grin and Laitin. In: P. Van Parijs (Ed.), Cultural diversity versus economic solidarity. Proceedings of the Seventh Francqui Colloquium (pp. 203–209). Brussels: De Boeck.Google Scholar
(Ed.) (1984) Langue et territoire. Quebec City, QC: Les Presses de l’Université Laval.Google Scholar
Lijphart, Arend
(1977) Democracy in plural societies. New Haven/London: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Lüdi, G., & Werlen, I.
(2005) Sprachenlandschaft in der Schweiz. Neuchâtel: Federal Statistical Office.Google Scholar
Mader, L.
(2001) Der verfassungsrechtliche Rahmen des Sprachenrechts des Bundes. Babylonia 2001(4), 15–22.Google Scholar
May, S.
(2003) Misconceiving minority language rights: Implications for liberal political theory. In: W. Kymicka & A. Patten (Eds.), Language rights and political theory (pp. 123–152). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
(2013) Language and minority rights: Ethnicity, nationalism and the politics of language. Milton Park/New York, NY: Routledge. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
McRae, K. D.
(1975) The principle of territoriality and the principle of personality in multilingual states. International Journal of the Sociology of Language 1975(4), 33–54.Google Scholar
Müller, S., & Dardanelli, P.
(2014) Langue, culture politique et centralisation en Suisse. Revue internationale de politique comparée, 21(4), 83–104. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Papaux, A.
(2012) La langue de la justice civile et pénale en droit suisse et comparé. Basel: Helbing Lichtenhahn.Google Scholar
Petkova, M.
(2012) Die Deutschschweizer Diglossie: eine Kategorie mit fuzzy boundaries. Zeitschrift für Literaturwissenschaft und Linguistik, 1661, 61–87. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Pfister, U.
(2010) Konfessionelle Parität. In: Historisches Lexikon der Schweiz (HLS), Version vom 20.05.2010. Online: https://​hls​-dhs​-dss​.ch​/de​/articles​/030550​/2010​-05​-20/, accessed 2021-07-17
Rhinow, R.
(2002) Die neue Verfassung in der Schweiz. Der Staat, 411, 575–596.Google Scholar
Ribeaud, J.
(2010) La Suisse plurilingue se déglingue. Plédoyer pour les quatre langues nationales suisses. Neuchâtel: Delibreo/Alphil.Google Scholar
Richter, D.
(2005) Sprachenordnung und Mindrheitenschutz im schweizerischen Bundesstaat. Relativität des Sprachenrechts und Sicherung des Sprachenfriedens. Heidelberg: Springer.Google Scholar
Robichaud, D.
(2011) Justice et politiques linguistiques: pourquoi les laisser-fairistes devraient exiger des interventions de l’État. Philosophiques, 38(2), 419–438. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Schnyder, C.
(2013) Reformation. In: Historisches Lexikon der Schweiz (HLS), Online: https://​hls​-dhs​-dss​.ch​/de​/articles​/013328​/2013​-01​-29/, accessed on 2021-07-16.
Schweizer, R. J., Baumann, J., & Scheffler, J.
(2011) Grundlagen und Verfahren der mehrsprachigen Rechtsetzung im Bund. In: R. J. Schweizer & M. Borghi (Eds.), Mehrsprachige Gesetzgebung in der Schweiz. Légisaltion plurilingue en Suisse. Legislazione plurilingue in Svizzera. La legilazium plurilingua en Svizra (pp. 13–45). Zürich/St. Gallen: Dike.Google Scholar
Sciarini, P.
(2014) Processus législatif. In: P. Knoepfel, Y. Papadopoulos, P. Sciarini, A. Vatter, & S. Häusermann (Eds.), Handbuch der Schweizer Politik – Manuel de la politique suisse (5 ed.). Zurich: Verlag Neue Zürcher Zeitung.Google Scholar
Singy, P., & Bourquin, C.
(2012) Usages langagiers et jeunes générations: regards de périphérie. Langage et société, (3), 99–115. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Sonderegger, S.
(2018) Deutsch. In: Historisches Lexikon der Schweiz (HLS), Version vom 24.01.2018. Online: https://​hls​-dhs​-dss​.ch​/de​/articles​/011194​/2018​-01​-24/, accessed on 2021-07-16.
Stojanović, N.
(2000) The idea of a Swiss nation: A critique of Will Kymlicka’s account of multination states. (M.A.), McGill University, Montréal, QC.Google Scholar
(2009) Is democracy possible in a multilingual country? The Swiss experience and the paradox of direct democracy. In: M. Hooghe and D. Sinardet (Eds.), Is democracy possible without a unified public opinion? The Swiss experience and the Belgian case. (pp. 9–23). Brussels: Rethinking Belgium.Google Scholar
(2010) Une conception dynamique du principe de territorialité linguistique: La loi sur les langues du canton des Grisons. Politique et Sociétés, 29(1), 231–259. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Taylor, C.
(1994) The politics of recognition. In: A. Gutman (Ed.), Multiculturalism. Examining the Politics of Recognition (pp. 25–73). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Vaccaro, L.
(Ed.) (1996) Storia religiosa della Svizzera. Milan: Centro Ambrosiano.Google Scholar
Van Parijs, P.
(2000) The ground floor of the world. On the socioeconomic consequences of linguistic globalization. International Political Science Review, 21(2), 217–233. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
(2010) Linguistic justice and the territorial imperative, Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy, 13(1), 181–202. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Vatter, A.
(2016) Switzerland on the road from a consociational to a centrifugal democracy?. Swiss Political Science Review, 22(1), 59–74. CrossrefGoogle Scholar
Widmer, J.
(2005) Constitutions d’une Suisse plurilingue. Une introduction. In J. Widmer, R. Coray, D. Acklin Mujin, & É. Godel (Eds.), Die Schweizer Sprachenvielfalt im öffentlichen Diskurs. La diversité des langues en Suisse dans le débat public (pp. 127–246). Bern: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Würgler, A.
(2012) Eidgenossenschaft. In: Historisches Lexikon der Schweiz (HLS), Version vom 08.02.2012. Online: https://​hls​-dhs​-dss​.ch​/de​/articles​/026413​/2012​-02​-08/, accessed on 2021-07-16.
Zangger, A.
(2012) Dasselbe mit anderen Worten? Artikel 175 Absatz 4 der Bundesverfassung im Sprachenvergleich. Leges 2012(2), 205–210.Google Scholar