Cover not available
Article published In:
Language Problems and Language Planning
Vol. 48:1 (2024) ► pp.1–25

The role of identification criteria in language

The Croatian case

ORCID logo | University of Ljubljana

The article presents the criteria employed in distinguishing languages and, within the framework of structuralist and sociolinguistic perspectives, delves into the role of identification criteria in the context of the Croatian language. Through a critical analysis of the interpretation of various criteria in Croatian linguistics, the article uncovers the issue of arbitrariness in language differentiation. The author asserts that, as a product of society, language cannot exist without its specific cultural context and, therefore, concurs with the thesis that language is inevitably influenced by politics. Within the scope of the Croatian language, the article examines several differentiation criteria, including structural, genetic, standardization, mutual intelligibility, and, notably, the identification criterion. The latter appears to be the least ambiguous, aligning with the principle that a language belongs to the entire community of its speakers. However, practical application raises certain challenges.

Keywords: language, dialects, identification, differentiation, arbitrariness
Article outline
  • Introduction
  • Inconsistencies in Croatian applications of structuralism
  • Croatian perspectives on the relationship between language and dialect
  • Exploring ambiguities in language distinction criteria
  • The position of identification criteria
  • Legitimacy and implementation challenges of language rights
  • Conclusion
  • References
Published online: 29 March 2024
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/lplp.23028.iva
References (73)
Babić, Stjepan
(1997) O Guberininima pogledima na hrvatsko-srpske jezične razlike. Jezik 45 (5), 176–82.Google Scholar
(2007) Nagrada za novu riječ ime dr. Ivana Šretera. Jezik 54 (1), 32–33.Google Scholar
(2009) Hrvatski književni jezik, ponajprije njim samim. Jezik, 56 (5), 161–189.Google Scholar
Badurina, Lada
(2019) O strukturi Silićeva strukturalizma. Prikaz knjige Josipa Silića Dihotomije: izabrane rasprave. Priredio Ivan Marković Zagreb: Disput, 2019. Fluminensia 31 (1), 305–315.Google Scholar
Banac, Ivo
(1988) Nacionalno pitanje u Jugoslaviji: porijeklo, povijest, politika. Zagreb: Globus.Google Scholar
(1991) Hrvatsko jezično pitanje. Zagreb: Most.Google Scholar
Bašić, Nataša
(2000) Uvod u nastanak Guberina-Krstićevih Razlika. Jezik 47 (4), 121–60.Google Scholar
(2007) Ljudevit Jonke i jugoslavenski jezični unitarizam. Jezik 54 (5), 161–200.Google Scholar
Blommaert, Jan
(1996) Language Planning as a Discourse on Language and Society: The Linguistic Ideology of a Scholarly Tradition. Language Problems and Language Planning 20 (3), 199 – 222. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Brozović, Dalibor
(1970) Standardni jezik. Zagreb: Matica hrvatska.Google Scholar
(2002) Lingvistički nazivi na srednjojužnoslavenskom području. Jezik 49 (1), 1–9.Google Scholar
(2015) Rasprave i članci. Zagreb: Matica hrvatska.Google Scholar
Chen, Xiao, & Madiyeva, Gulmira
(2022) The Influence of Political Environment on Language and the Development of the Modern Russia. Journal of Ethnic and Cultural Studies 9 (3), 212–225. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Clyne, Michael G.
(1992) Pluricentric Languages – Introduction. In Michael G. Clyne (ed.), Pluricentric Languages: Differing Norms in Different Nations, 1–11. Berlin & New York: Mouton de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Coseriu, Eugenio
(2011) Teorija jezika i opća jezikoslovlje: pet studija. Zagreb: Disput.Google Scholar
de Saussure, Ferdinand
(2000) Tečaj opće lingvistike. Zagreb: ArTresor naklada.Google Scholar
(2018) Splošno jezikoslovje. Ljubljana: Studia humanitatis.Google Scholar
Esih, Ivan
(1999) Kultura književnog jezika (Deset jezičnih zapovijedi). In Marko Samardžija (ed.), Norme i normiranje hrvatskog književnog jezika, 42–49. Zagreb: Matica hrvatska.Google Scholar
Fasold, Ralph W.
(1984) The Sociolinguistics of Society. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Franolić, Branko
(1984) An Historical Survey of Literary Croatian. Paris: Nouvelles editions latines.Google Scholar
Grbić, Jadranka
(1994) Identitet, jezik i razvoj. Istraživanje o povezanosti etniciteta i jezika na primjeru hrvatske nacionalne manjine u mađarskoj – 1.dio. Narodna umjetnost 31 (1), 9–137.Google Scholar
Greenberg, Robert D.
(2000) Language Politics in the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia: The Crisis over the Future of Serbian. Slavic Review 59 (3), 625–40. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Guberina, Petar
(1940) Hrvatski jezični osjećaj i srpski jezični osjećaj. Obzor 80 (69), 5.Google Scholar
(1996) Zašto možemo govoriti o posebnom hrvatskom književnom jeziku. Jezik 44 (5), 162–191.Google Scholar
Guberina, Petar, & Krstić, Krunoslav
(1940) Razlike između hrvatskoga i srpskoga književnoga jezika. Zagreb: Matica hrvatska.Google Scholar
ISO 639–3
(2012) Change Request Documentation: 2012–068. [URL]
(2023) Scope of denotation for language identifiers. [URL]
Ivašković, Igor
(2022a) Pogledi na pojavu purizma u hrvatskom kontekstu. Jezik, 69 (4), 134–151. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
(2022b) Hrvatski kao strani jezik na području poslovanja i ekonomije u Sloveniji. Rasprave Instituta za hrvatski jezik i jezikoslovlje 48 (1), 45–63. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
(2023) Odnos prema novotvorenicama u hrvatskom jeziku u Sloveniji. In Sanda Ham (ed.), Međunarodni znanstveni skup Dani Stjepana Babića, 211. Zagreb: Hrvatsko filološko društvo.Google Scholar
Jonke, Ljudevit
(1971) Hrvatski književni jezik 19. i 20. stoljeća. Zagreb.Google Scholar
Kačić, Miro, & Šarić, Ljiljana
(1995) Hrvatski i srpski. Zablude i krivotvorine. Zagreb: Zavod za lingvistiku Filozofskog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Zagrebu.Google Scholar
Kapović, Mate
(2011) Čiji je jezik? Zagreb: Algoritam.Google Scholar
Katičić, Radoslav
(1971) Jezikoslovni ogledi. Zagreb: Školska knjiga.Google Scholar
(1992) Novi jezikoslovni ogledi. Zagreb: Školska knjiga.Google Scholar
(2013) Hrvatski jezik. Zagreb: Školska knjiga.Google Scholar
Katičić, Radoslav, & Kovačec, August
(2004) Hrvatski jezični standard. Izazovi globalizacije i hrvatski jezični standard. Zagreb: Hrvatska akademija znanosti i umjetnosti.Google Scholar
Katnić-Bakaršić, Marina
(2013) Bosanskohercegovačka sociolingvistička previranja. In Vesna Požgaj-Hadži (ed.), Jezik između lingvistike i politike, 113–133. Beograd: Biblioteka XX vek.Google Scholar
Kennedy, David W.
(1986) Critical Theory, Structuralism and Contemporary Legal Scholarship. New England Law Review 21 (2), 209–289.Google Scholar
Klein, Wolf Peter
(2014) Das Sprachgefühl zwischen methodologischem Instrument und antisemitischem Agitationsmuster. Zu einem schillernden Begriff der Sprachwissenschaft. In Lenca Vaňková (ed.), Emotionalität im Text, 19–33. Tübingen: Stauffenburg Verlag.Google Scholar
Kordić, Snježana
(2010) Jezik i nacionalizam. Zagreb: Durieux.Google Scholar
Kovačec, August
(2007) Ferdinand de Saussure i strukturalizam. In Zrinjka Glovacki-Bernardi (ed.), Uvod u lingvistiku, 99–178. Zagreb: Školska knjiga.Google Scholar
Kovačić, Marko
(2005) Serbian and Croatian: One language or languages? Jezikoslovlje 6 (1), 195–204.Google Scholar
Lakić, Igor
(2009) Crnogorski jezik: od negacije do standardizacije. In Vesna Požgaj-Hadži, Tatjana Balažic Bulc, & Vojko Gorjanc (eds.), Med politico in stvarnostjo: Jezikoslovna situacija v novonastalih državah bivše Jugoslavije, 85–97. Ljubljana: Znanstvena založba Filozofske fakultete.Google Scholar
Lasić, Igor
(2017) Snježana S. Kordić: Četiri naziva uzgajaju zabludu o četiri jezika. Novosti, 16. 1. 2017. [URL]
MacNamara, John
(1977) The Irish Language and Nationalism. The Crane Bag, 1 (2), 40–44.Google Scholar
Mandić, Davor
(2015) Najveći živući lingvist Josip Silić: Predložio sam uvođenje čakavskog u škole. Novi list, 11. 10. 2015. [URL]
Matasović, Ranko
(2001) Uvod u poredbenu lingvistiku. Zagreb: Matica hrvatska.Google Scholar
(2011) Što je srednjojužnoslavenski? Jezik 58 (3), 81–90.Google Scholar
Meyerhoff, Miriam
(2006) Introducing Sociolinguistics. London, New York: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Mićanović, Krešimir
(2006) Mjesto standardologije u jezikoslovnoj kroatistici. In Marko Samardžija & Ivo Pranjković (eds.), Hrvatski jezik u XX. stoljeću, 559–585. Zagreb: Matica hrvatska.Google Scholar
Mønnesland, Svein
(2005) Jezik u Bosni I Hercegovini. Sarajevo: Institut za jezik.Google Scholar
Murray, Robert W.
(2006) The place of historical linguistics in the age of structuralism. In Sylvain Auroux, E. F. K. Koerner, Hans-Josef Niederehe & Kees Versteegh (eds.), 3. Teilband: An International Handbook on the Evolution of the Study of Language from the Beginnings to the Present, 2430–2445. Berlin, New York: De Gruyter Mouton. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Norton, Bonny, & Toohey, Kelleen
(2011) Identity, language learning, and social change. Language Teaching, 44 (4), 412–446. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Paravina, Aleksandra
(2022) Croatian Serb Culture, Language, and Minority Education Rights. Social Sciences 11 (7), 275. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Pelinka, Anton
(2007) Language as a political category: The viewpoint of political science. Journal of Language and Politics 6 (1), 129–143. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Piller, Ingrid, & Bodis, Agnes
(2022) Marking and unmarking the (non)native speaker through English language proficiency requirements for university admission. Language in Society, 1–23.Google Scholar
Požgaj-Hadži, Vesna
(2014) Language policy and linguistic reality in former Yugoslavia and its successor states. Inter faculty – Journal of interdisciplinary research in human and social sciences University of Tsukuba 5 1, 49–91. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Pranjković, Ivo
(2007) Stogodišnjica Ljudevita Jonkea. Croatica et Slavica Iadertina 3 (1), 3–8. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Račić, Marta
(2020) Dobre prakse održivosti (identiteta) manjinske zajednice – primjer moliških Hrvata. Studia ethnologica Croatica, 32 (1), 209–232. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Rijeka danas
(2023) Čakavski službeno priznat kao jezik. 30. 1. 2023. [URL]
Ruhlen, Merrit
(1976) A guide to the languages of the world. Stanford: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Samardžija, Marko
(1997) Iz triju stoljeća hrvatskoga standardnog jezika. Zagreb: Matica hrvatska.Google Scholar
Silić, Josip
(2006) Funkcionalni stilovi hrvatskog jezika. Zagreb: Disput.Google Scholar
Škiljan, Dubravko
(1995) Nemoguće je dokazati da su hrvatski i srpski dva različita jezika. [URL]
(2002) Govor nacije. Jezik, nacija, Hrvati. Zagreb: Golden marketing.Google Scholar
Sućeska, Alen
(2017) Towards a Critique of the Dominant Philosophies of Language from a Historical-Materialist Standpoint. Synthesis philosophica 32 (1), 193–214. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Stedje, Astrid
(2001) Deutsche Sprache Gestern und Heute: Einführung in Sprachgeschichte und Sprachkunde. Munich: Fink.Google Scholar
Tafra, Branka
(2012) Prinosi povijesti hrvatskoga jezikoslovlja. Zagreb: Hrvatski studiji Sveučilišta u Zagrebu.Google Scholar
Trudgill, Peter
(1974) Sociolinguistics: An Introduction to Language and Society. Harmondsworth: Penguin.Google Scholar
Užarević, Josip
(2007) Jezik, stilovi, funkcije. Umjetnost riječi 1–2 1, 173–181.Google Scholar
Večernji list
(2017) Donosimo potpunu listu potpisnika Deklaracije: Evo za što se zalažu! Večernji list, 29 March 2017. [URL]
Vermeer, Willem
(1982) On the principal sources for the study of Čakavian dialects with neocircumflex in adjectives and e-presents. Studies in Slavic and General Linguistic 2 1, 279–340. DOI logoGoogle Scholar