(No) variation in the grammar of alternatives
Anna Howell | University of Tübingen
Vera Hohaus | The University of Manchester
Polina Berezovskaya | University of Tübingen
Konstantin Sachs | University of Tübingen
Julia Braun | University of Tübingen
Şehriban Durmaz | University of Tübingen
Sigrid Beck | University of Tübingen
The paper reports the results of an in-depth crosslinguistic study of intervention effects and the grammar of
alternatives in a typologically diverse sample of five languages: Palestinian Arabic (Afro-Asiatic, Semitic), Russian
(Indo-European, Slavic), Samoan (Austronesian, Oceanic), Turkish (Altaic, Turkic), and Yoruba (Niger-Congo, Defoid). In all of
these languages, we find an interesting asymmetry in that focus evaluation interrupts question evaluation and causes an
intervention effect, but not vice versa. We take our data to inform the crosslinguistic analysis of two alternative-evaluating
operators, the squiggle operator and the question operator. To capture the observed absence of variation, we propose two semantic
universals: The squiggle operator unselectively evaluates all alternatives in its scope. The question operator, on the other hand,
is selective.
Keywords: alternative semantics, focus, interrogatives, multiple questions, disjunctive questions, intervention effects, Baker ambiguities, crosslinguistic variation, fieldwork
Article outline
- Introduction
- 1.The grammar of alternatives – Informal version
- 1.1Association with alternatives
- 1.2Intervention effects
- 1.3Other associations with Q
- 1.4Crosslinguistic variation in the grammar of alternatives
- 2.The data from the crosslinguistic study
- 2.1Methodology
- 2.2The crosslinguistic data
- 2.2.1Palestinian Arabic
- Preliminaries and structural prerequisites
- Intervention data
- 2.2.2Russian
- Preliminaries and structural prerequisites
- Intervention data
- 2.2.3Samoan
- Preliminaries and structural prerequisites
- Intervention configurations
- 2.2.4Turkish
- Preliminaries and structural prerequisites
- Intervention configurations
- 2.2.5Yoruba
- Preliminaries and structural prerequisites
- Intervention configurations
- 2.2.1Palestinian Arabic
- 2.3Summary of results
- 3.Analysis
- 3.1Technical implementation using distinguished variables
- 3.2Applying the framework to the crosslinguistic data
- Example 1.Intervention effect in a wh-in-situ question in Turkish
- Example 2.Absence of intervention in focus association across a question in Russian
- 4.Connecting the analysis to literature on the grammar of alternatives
- 5.Discussion and conclusion
- Acknowledgments
- Notes
- Abbreviations
-
References
Available under the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) 4.0 license.
For any use beyond this license, please contact the publisher at rights@benjamins.nl.
Published online: 22 March 2021
https://doi.org/10.1075/lv.19010.how
https://doi.org/10.1075/lv.19010.how
References
Adesola, Oluseye
Alonso-Ovalle, Luis
Arslan, Zekiye C.
Bade, Nadine, & Konstantin Sachs
Baker, Carl L.
Baker, Mark C.
Bechhofer, Robin
Beaver, David & Brady Clark
Beaver, David I. & Brady Z. Clark
Beck, Sigrid
To
appear. Parameters of crosslinguistic variation in
semantics. In Daniel Gutzmann, Lisa Matthewson, Cecile Meier, Hotze Rullmann & Thomas Zimmermann eds. The
Blackwell companion to
semantics Oxford Wiley-Blackwell
Beck, Sigrid & Shin-Sook Kim
Beck, Sigrid; Svetlana Krasikova, Daniel Fleischer, Remus Gergel, Stefan Hofstetter, Christiane Savelsberg, John Vanderelst & Elisabeth Villalta
Beck, Sigrid; Toshiko Oda & Koji Sugisaki
Berezovskaya, Polina
Berezovskaya, Polina & Anna Howell
Berezovskaya, Polina & Vera Hohaus
Biezma, Maria & Kyle Rawlins
Bochnak, M. Ryan
Bochnak, M. Ryan; Vera Hohaus & Anne Mucha
Braun, Julia
Bruening, Benjamin & Vivan Lin
Büring, Daniel & Katharina Hartmann
Cable, Seth
Calhoun, Sasha
Chen, Sihwei; Vera Hohaus, Rebecca Laturnus, Meagan Louie, Lisa Matthewson, Hotze Rullmann, Ori Simchen, Claire K. Turner & Jozina Vander Klok
Dayal, Veneeta
Deal, Amy Rose & Vera Hohaus
Drubig, H. Bernhard
Durmaz, Şehriban
Durmaz, Şehriban
Eilam, Aviad
Erlewine, Michael Y. & Hadas Kotek
Erlewine, Michael. Y. & Hadas Kotek
Fox, Danny
Fox, Danny & Benjamin Spector
Göksel, Aslı & A. Sumru Özsoy
Gracanin-Yüksek, Martina
Haida, Andreas
Haida, Andreas & Sophie Repp
Hohaus, Vera
Hohaus, Vera & Anna Howell
Hohaus, Vera & M. Ryan Bochnak
Horn, Laurence R.
Howell, Anna
Huang, C. T. James
Isleem, Nasser M.
İşsever, Selçuk
Kamali, Beste & Lena Karvovskaya
Kelepir, Meltem
Kim, Shin-Sook
Kitagawa, Yoshihisa; Katsuo Tamaoka and Satoshi Tomioka
Kornfilt, Jaklin
Kornfilt, Jaklin; Susumu Kuno & Engin Sezer
Kotek, Hadas & Michael Y. Erlewine
Kratzer, Angelika
Krifka, Manfred
Kural, Murat
Lutz, Uli; Gereon Müller & Arnim von Stechow
Matthewson, Lisa
Matthewson, Lisa & Kai von Fintel
Mayr, Clemens
Özçelik, Öner & Miho Nagai
Ogihara, Toshiyuki & Yael Sharvit
Renans, Agata; Malte Zimmermann & Markus Greif
Ruangjaroon, Sugunya
2002 Thai
wh in-situ
. Paper presented at the 14th
Northwest Linguistics Conference, Simon Fraser
University, Burnaby.
Rudin, Catherine
Shlonsky, Ur
von Stechow, Arnim
Stepanov, Arthur
Sudhoff, Stefan
Tomioka, Satoshi
2017 Maximality
mimics exhaustivity: A case study of dake ‘only’ in Japanese. Poster
presented at
GLOW in Asia XI, University of
Singapore, Singapore.
Tonhauser, Judith
Uegaki, Wataru
Wagner, Michael
Winans, Lauren
Wold, Dag
Zifonun, Gisela; Ursula Brauße, Ludger Hoffmann, Bruno Strecker, & Joachim Ballweg