Methods for studying variation in partitives
In the last sixty years, starting with the method of introspection to judge the acceptability of linguistic data, research methods in linguistics have become more varied and more sophisticated. This also holds for studies on partitivity. In this paper various methods are presented that have recently been used in the literature to study variation in the linguistic expression and the use of partitive constructions and partitive elements in Romance, Germanic and some other languages, language varieties and dialects. It is argued that different types of research call for adapted methods. It is shown that the use of different methods may lead to different results, although this is not always the case. The overview presented in this paper reveals that in recent years much progress has been made in the study of variation in partitives.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Partitives and variation
- 3.Methods to detect variation in the linguistic expression or use of partitives
- 3.1Partitive constructions
- 3.2Partitive case
- 3.3Partitive determiners
- 3.4Partitive pronouns
- 4.Conclusion
- Acknowledgements
- List of glossing abbreviations
-
References
References (61)
References
Barbiers, Sjef. 2017. Kwantitatief er en ze
. Nederlandse Taalkunde
22
(2).163–187.
Berends, Sanne. 2019. Acquiring Dutch quantitative ER. Amsterdam: LOT Publications 547.
Brandner, Ellen. 2024. The indefinite article as an exponent for partition. In Elvira Glaser, Petra Sleeman, Thomas Strobel & Anne Tamm (eds.), Partitive constructions and partitive elements within and across language borders in Europe (Linguaggio e Variazione. Variation in Language), 19–54. Venice: Edizioni Ca’ Foscari. [URL]
Bricmont, Jean & Julie Franck. 2010. Chomsky, France, reason, power. In Julie Franck & Jean Bricmon (eds.). Chomsky notebook, 53–73. Columbia University Press.
Buchstaller, Isabelle & Karen P. Corrigan. 2011a. How to make intuitions succeed. In April McMahon & Warren Maguire (eds.), Analysing variation in English, 30–48. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cardinaletti, Anna & Giuliana Giusti. 2018. Indefinite determiners: Variation and optionality in italo-romance. In Roberta D’Alessandro & Diego Pescarini (eds.), Advances in dialectology. Sketches of Italo-Romance grammars, 135–161. Leiden: Brill.
Chaika, Lesia, Natalia Lehka, Anne Tamm & Natalia Vaiss. 2024. Ukrainian aspect and object case in ukTenTen. The partitive genitive of perfective verbs and mass nouns. In Elvira Glaser, Petra Sleeman, Thomas Strobel & Anne Tamm (eds.), Partitive constructions and partitive elements within and across language borders in Europe (
Linguaggio e Variazione. Variation in Language
), 173–223. Venice: Edizioni Ca’ Foscari. [URL]
Chomsky, Noam. 1965. Aspects of the theory of syntax. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Coppen, Peter-Arno, Walter Haeseryn & Folkert de Vriend. 2012. Electronic ANS (Algemene Nederlandse Spraakkunst, Dutch Reference Grammar). [URL]
Cornips, Leonie. 1994. Syntactische variatie in het algemeen Nederlands van Heerlen. [Syntactic variation in Heerlen Dutch]. Amsterdam: IFOTT, University of Amsterdam PhD dissertation.
Cornips, Leonie & Cecilia Poletto. 2005. On standardising syntactic elicitation techniques (part 1). Lingua
115
1, 939–957.
Corver, Norbert, Marjo van Koppen & Huib Kranendonk. 2013. De nominale woordgroep vanuit dialect-vergelijkend perspectief. Variaties en generalisaties [The noun phrase in Dutch dialects from a comparative perspective. Variations and generalisations]. Nederlandse Taalkunde
18
1, 107–137.
D’Arcy, Alexandra. 2011. Corpora: Capturing language in use. In Warren Maguire & April McMahon (eds.), Analysing variation in English, 49–71. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Etxeberria, Urtzi. 2021. The partitive marker in Basque and its relation to bare nouns and the definite article. In Petra Sleeman & Giuliana Giusti (eds.), Partitive determiners, partitive pronouns and partitive case (Linguistische Arbeiten 580), 319–355. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Falco, Michelangelo & Roberto Zamparelli. 2019. Partitives and partitivity. Glossa: A Journal of General Linguistics 4(1): 111.
Gerards, David Paul. 2020. Bare partitives in Old Spanish and Old Portuguese. Zurich: University of Zurich PhD dissertation.
Gerards, David Paul & Elisabeth Stark. 2020. Why “partitive articles” do not exist in Old Spanish. In Tabea Ihsane (ed.), Disentangling bare nouns and nominals introduced by a partitive article, 105–139. Leiden: Brill.
Gerards, David Paul & Elisabeth Stark. 2022. Non-maximal definites in Romance. In Marco Bril, Martine Coene, Tabea Ihsane & Petra Sleeman (eds.), RLLT
19
, special issue of Isogloss. Open Journal of Romance Linguistics
8
(5)/5, 1–35.
Giusti, Giuliana & Petra Sleeman. 2021. Partitive elements in the languages of Europe. An advancement in the understanding of a multifaceted phenomenon. In Petra Sleeman & Giuliana Giusti (eds.), Partitive determiners, partitive pronouns and partitive case (Linguistische Arbeiten 580), 1–30. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Graën, Johannes, Dolores Batinic & Martin Volk. 2014. Cleaning the Europarl corpus for linguistic applications. In Josef Ruppenhofer & Gertrud Faaß (eds.), Proceedings of the 12th edition of the KONVENS conference, 222–227, Hildesheim: Universitätsverlag Hildesheim.
Haeseryn, Walter, Kirsten Romijn, Guido Geerts, Jaap de Rooij, Maarten van den Toorn. 1997. Algemene Nederlandse spraakkunst. 2nd ed. Deurne: Wolters Plantyn.
Hoeksema, Jack. 1984. Partitives. Ms., University of Groningen.
Hoeksema, Jacob (ed.). 1996. Partitives: Studies on the syntax and semantics of partitive and related constructions. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Hoffmann, Thomas. 2013. Obtaining introspective acceptability judgements. In Manfred Krug & Julia Schlüter (eds.), Research methods in language variation and change, 99–118. Cambridge University Press.
Hoop, Helen de. 1992. Case configuration and Noun Phrase interpretation [PhD dissertation]. Groningen: University of Groningen.
Ihsane, Tabea, Winistörfer, Oliver & Elisabeth Stark. 2023. Francoprovençal: a spatial analysis of ‘partitive articles’ and potential correlates in Swiss and Italian varieties. Isogloss. Open Journal of Romance Linguistics
9
(1)/4, 1–30.
Jong, Francesca de. 1983. Sommige niet, andere wel: De verklaring van een raadselachtig verschil. GLOT
6
1, 229–246.
Kranendonk, Huib. 2010. Quantificational constructions in the nominal domain: Facets of Dutch microvariation. Utrecht: LOT.
Krifka, Manfred, Francis J. Pelletier, Greg Carlson, Alice ter Meulen, Gennaro Chierchia & Godehard Link. 1995. Genericity: An introduction. In Greg Carlson & Francis J. Pelletier (eds.), The generic book, 1–124. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kristol, Andres. 2014. Les grammaires du francoprovençal : l’expression de la partitivité. Quelques leçons du projet ALAVAL. In La Géolinguistique dans les Alpes au XXe siècle: méthodes, défis et perspectives. Actes de la Conférence annuelle sur l’activité scientifique du Centre d’études francoprovençales “René Willien”, 29–44. Saint Nicolas: Région autonome de la Vallée d’Aoste, Bureau régional pour l’ethnologie et la linguistique.
Kristol, Andres. 2016. Francoprovençal. In Adam Ledgeway & Martin Maiden (eds.), The Oxford guide to the Romance languages, 350–362. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Labov, William. 1972. Some principles of linguistic methodology. Language in Society
1
1. 99–120.
Lado, Robert. 1957. Linguistics across cultures: Applied linguistics for language teachers. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Newmeyer, Frederick J. 2020. The relevance of introspective data. In Samuel Schindler, Anna Drożdżowicz & Karen Brøcker (eds.), Linguistic intuitions: Evidence and method, 149–164. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pinzin, Francesco & Cecilia Poletto. 2022. An indefinite maze: on the distribution of partitives and bare nouns in the Northern Italian dialects. In Ora Matushansky, Laurent Roussarie, Michela Russo, Elena Soare & Sophie Wauquier (eds.). RLLT 17, Special issue of Isogloss Open Journal of Romance Linguistics
8
(2)/20, 1–23.
Pfaff, Alexander. 2015. Adjectival and genitival modification in definite noun phrases in Icelandic – A tale of outsiders and inside jobs [PhD dissertation]. Tromsø: University of Tromsø.
Pfaff, Alexander. 2017. Adjectival inflection as diagnostic for structural position – Inside and outside the Icelandic definiteness domain. Journal of Comparative Germanic Linguistics
20
(3). 283–322.
Schilling, Natalie. 2013. Surveys and interviews. In Robert J. Podesva & Devyani Sharma (eds.), Research methods in linguistics, 96–115. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Schütze, Carson T. 1996. The empirical base of linguistics: Grammaticality judgments and linguistic methodology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press
Schütze, Carson T. 2016. The empirical base of linguistics: Grammaticality judgments and linguistic methodology. (Classics in Linguistics 2). Berlin: Language Science Press.
Schütze, Carson T. & Jon Sprouse. 2013. Judgment data. In Robert J. Podesva & Devyani Sharma (eds.), Research methods in linguistics, 27–50. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Schwartz, Bonnie & Rex Sprouse. 1996. L2 cognitive states and the Full Transfer/Full Access model. Second Language Research
12
(1). 40–72.
Selkirk, Elisabeth O. 1977. Some remarks on noun phrase structure. In Peter W. Culicover, Thomas Wasow & Adrian Akmajian (eds.), Formal syntax, 285–316. New York: Academic Press.
Seržant, Ilja. 2021. Diachronic typology of partitives. In Petra Sleeman & Giuliana Giusti (eds.) Partitive determiners, Partitive pronouns and partitive case (Linguistische Arbeiten 580). Berlin: de Gruyter.
Sigurðsson, Halldor Armann. 1993. The structure of the Icelandic NP. Studia Linguistica
47
(2). 177–197.
Sigurðsson, Halldor Armann. 2006. The Icelandic noun phrase. Central traits. Arkiv för Nordisk Filologi
121
1. 193–236.
Sleeman, Petra. 2022a. Het woordje er: klein, maar niet fijn. In Alla Peeters & Petra Sleeman (eds.), Taalmysteries, 166–169. Amsterdam: Lias.
Sleeman, Petra. 2022b. Partitive pronouns and quantified adverbial NPs: A labeling account. In Gabriela Alboiu, Daniela Isac, Alexandru Nicolae, Mihaela Tănase-Dogaru & Alina Tigău (eds.), A life in linguistics: A festschrift for Alexandra Cornilescu on her 75th birthday, 513–525. Bucharest: Bucharest University Press.
Sleeman, Petra & Tabea Ihsane. 2016. Gender mismatches in partitive constructions with superlatives in French. Glossa: A Journal of General Linguistics,
1
(1): 35.
Sleeman, Petra & Silvia Luraghi. 2023. Crosslinguistic variation in partitives. In Silvia Luraghi & Petra Sleeman (eds.), Partitives cross-linguistically, special issue of Linguistic Variation
23
(1). 1–27.
Strobel, Thomas & Elvira Glaser. 2020. The rise and fall of partitive markers in some Germanic varieties. In Tabea Ihsane (ed.), Disentangling bare nouns and nominals introduced by a partitive article. Leiden: Brill, 17–53.
Westveer, Thom. 2021. Gender mismatches in partitive constructions in French and German: How society shapes language. Amsterdam: LOT.
Zanoli, Emma. 2022. A linguistic perspective on feminization and gender-inclusive language. How partitive constructions can be used to uncover implicit gender bias in Italian. Annali di Ca’ Foscari
56
1, 195–219.