Article published in:Metaphor in Education: A multilingual perspective
Edited by Katrin Ahlgren, Anne Golden and Ulrika Magnusson
[Metaphor and the Social World 11:2] 2021
► pp. 302–328
Answering the charge?
Metaphors about and by Sami in Norwegian textbooks and in Sami witness testimonies
From 1850 to 1980 the Norwegian state pursued a policy of Norwegianization of the Sami, where schools played an important part in the attempt to turn Sami children into Norwegian citizens. Pupils lived in boarding schools where all teaching was in Norwegian and it was forbidden to speak Sami, both in and out of the classroom. This article examines metaphors in three types of material: Norwegian textbooks; Sami literature in these textbooks; and Sami testimony literature. The aim is to find out how the Norwegian state used its power to stigmatize Sami identity through metaphors in textbooks, and how Sami writers show their resistance to Norwegianization through metaphors in Sami literary texts and Sami testimony literature. The analysis also examines whether metaphors are signalled or not, in order to see if they are open to negotiation or taken as self-evident, and if signalling can be related to genre. One central finding is that the Norwegian texts contain more condescending and less signalled metaphors than the Sami ones. Another is that signalling might be related to genre: there are more signalled metaphors in the reflective narratives of witness testimonies than in the other genres that are examined. The theoretical foundations of the analyses are discourse-based metaphor analysis in a post-colonial perspective.
- 2.Background and earlier research
- 3.Theory and methods
- 5.1About the Sami (and other indigenous people) in Norwegian textbooks
- 5.2Sami voices in Norwegian textbooks
- 5.3Sami witness testimonies
Published online: 12 October 2021
Ashcroft, B., Griffits, G. & Tiffin, H.
Cameron, L. & Deignan, A.
(2011) Song, poetry and images in writing. Nordlit, 271, 33–54, https://septentrio.uit.no/index.php/nordlit/article/view/1804. Visited 26.4.20
Handlingsplan for samiske språk
Hansen, H. H.
Hellwald, F. V.
Johansen, S. B.
Knudsen, S. V.
(2011) FNs barnekonvensjon artikkel 29 (1) om formålet med opplæring: En rettssosiologisk studie om hva barn lærer om det samiske folk . [The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child Article 29 (1) on the Purpose of Education: Sociology of Law Study on What Children in Norway Learn About The Sámi People] Doktoravhandling [Ph.d.thesis] Juridisk fakultet, Universitetet i Oslo. [Faculty of Law, University of Oslo].
(2012) Barn av minoriteter og urfolk. [Children of minorities and indigenous people.] In: N. Høstmælingen, E. S. Kjørholt & K. Sandberg (2012) Barnekonvensjonen: Barns rettigheter i Norge, 3. Utgave. [The Convention of the Rights of the Child: Childrens’ rights in Norway, third edition.] (pp. 357–372). Oslo: Universitetsforlaget.
Lund, E. & Indresøvde, E.
(Ed.) (2003–2013) Sami school history. http://skuvla.info/index-n.htm
(1997) Kulturmøte, etnisitet og statlig intervensjon på Nordkalotten. [Cultural meetings, ethnicity and stately intervention on the North Calotte.]- In: Andersson, R. B. (Ed.) Den nordiska mosaiken: språk- och kulturmöten i gammal tid och i våra dagar: [The Nordic Mosaic: language – and cultural meetings in the foretime and today.] Humanistdagarna [15–16 mars] vid Uppsala universitet 1997. [Humanity Days (15 – 16 Marsh) at the University of Uppsala.] Uppsala: Uppsala Universitet.
Olsen, T. & Andreassen, B. O.
(2016) Ansvar, hensyn og forpliktelse. Urfolk og samiske forhold i barnehagens rammeplaner. [Responsibility, consideration and commitment. Indigenous people and Sami issues in framework plans in kindergarten,] In N. Askeland & B. Aamotsbakken (Eds.), Folk uten land? Å gi stemme og status til urfolk og nasjonale minoriteter [People with no Country? To Give Voice and Standing to Indigenous People and National Minorities.] (pp. 60–76). Oslo: Cappelen.
Selle, P., Semb, A.J., Strømsnes, K. & Nordø, Å. D.
Skjelbred, D., Askeland, N., Maagerø, E. & Aamotsbakken, B.
(1993) Utredning om tapt skolegang. Rapport fra et arbeidsutvalg vedrørende samer som har tapt skolegang under andre verdenskrig. [Investigation into lost schooling – report from a working committee concerning Sami who suffered a loss of schooling in WW2.] Oslo: Kommunaldepartementet [Oslo: Ministry of Municipal Affairs.]
[The Norwegian Language Council] (2019) Samisk. https://www.sprakradet.no/Spraka-vare/Spraka-i-Norden/Samisk/. December 3, 2019
Steen, Gerard. J., Dorst, Aletta, Hermann, J. Berenike, Kaal, Anna, Krennmayr, Tina og Pasma, Trijntje
The Truth and Reconciliation Commission
https://uit.no/kommisjonen_en. Visited 26.4.20